5 ms·
> what the hell is happening. How do we "get back to normal"? To a certain degree, that is what’s happening. Denmark should bolster its military presence on Gr
by JumpCrisscross 1y ago
> what the hell is happening. How do we "get back to normal"?
To a certain degree, that is what’s happening. Denmark should bolster its military presence on Greenland, potentially up to and including by putting it under a nuclear umbrella. (Ideally European. Pragmatically, homegrown.)
- docdeek 1y agoHow would that work? The options for a European nuclear umbrella would be a choice between Russia (practically impossible), the UK (unlikely to be outside of US influence) or France (only EU nuclear power). A homegrown nuclear weapon would mean pulling out of the NPT and quite possibly giving a state like the US pretext to annex Greenland in the face of Denmark seeking nucear weapons.
- rsynnott 1y agoFrance has previously indicated that it's willing to make its nuclear umbrella available to other EU countries, though precisely under what terms is unclear.
- jmclnx 1y agoCanada ? Canada could allow France and maybe the UK to put sites on their soil. That would piss of Trump, always a good thing and will give Canada some security. Also, Denmark should now kick the US Military Sites off Greenland until the US climbs out if its psychotic break.
- aurareturn 1y agonuclear umbrella would be a choice between Russia (practically impossible) Would be one of the bigger plot twists in history. I wouldn't rule it out. I think it has a decent chance of happening. Maybe 10%? Let's say the Russia/Ukraine war is over. Russia mends its ties with Europe and says it will be good from now on. The US is ready to annex Greenland. Denmark is powerless and will lose Greenland. Russia calls Denmark and says it can help. If you're Denmark, what would you do?
- rsynnott 1y agoI mean, France would still be a far more obvious partner under those circumstances.
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago> France would still be a far more obvious partner under those circumstances Unless the weapons are under Copenhagen’s control, they’re Potemkin protection. Paris won’t risk its economy being destroyed by sanctions, much less its military destroyed by the American war machine, to protect Danish interests in Greenland.
- docdeek 1y agoI think that the chance of an EU and NATO member aligning themselves with Russia would be a lot lower than a 1 in 10.
- aurareturn 1y agoWhat if a NATO member is suddenly hostile to you and Russia says it can help you? Russia probably does not want the US to have Greenland. It would certainly trigger a collapse of NATO. But if the US is serious about taking Greenland, that automatically starts the collapse anyway, right? Anyway, just all hypotheticals. Interesting to think about. I don't think chances are 0. History has shown us that countries make surprising decisions, including allying with historic enemies, when pushed against the wall.
- polotics 1y agoWell eventualy one would hope the Putin Mafia dies out and the Russian Diaspora manages to turn that country back to a happier place than its current child-abducting state. There are many good russians, there is an actual society under the madness, look: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9_0E9IzXT34 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9_0E9IzXT34
- egman_ekki 1y agoYou're giving a 10% chance to Denmark allying with Russia over a threat from US? Even right-wing parties in Dk aren't really pro-Russian, so I'd say the chance is closer to 0 than 10%.
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago> homegrown nuclear weapon would mean pulling out of the NPT Build then pull. Or don’t. It’s a treaty from a falling world order. > quite possibly giving a state like the US pretext to annex Greenland If you believe America would wait for pretext, you don’t need the umbrella.
- jacquesm 1y agoSeeing the USA as a potential enemy in a shooting war is not 'normal'. It may be what it comes down to but as descendant of people who would not have been alive if not for the liberation of Western Europe and who was steeped in WWII lore this is not normal by any stretch of the imagination.
- shepherdjerred 1y agoit's pretty sad
- bryanrasmussen 1y agoin a view of world history it is totally normal that benevolent countries turn antagonistic over several generations, although very seldom such an abrupt turn where allies are concerned as this one has been. Mad rulers are also quite normal for much of human history, the theory was that Democracy would relieve us of that particular problem.
- wuschel 1y agoThat - and there is the perspective of WW2 as change of guard of dominating world power. The Empire bit the dust, Europe ruined - and the US and CSSR divided the world upon themselves. It is not narrative for us to hear, as there have been many sacrifice that came to liberation of Europe. It is much easier to see them trough less less of the good guys, the liberators. But there are many sides to history: it also was a change of guard in the strategic geopolitical sense… and even after WW2, the US did a lot to accelerate the Empire’s demise …
- jacquesm 1y ago> the theory was that Democracy would relieve us of that particular problem I don't think that was the theory. I think the theory was something in the middle of the wisdom of the crowds and the fact that non-violent hand overs of power are less bad than violent ones. The main flaw is that democracy can be undone by democracy whereas autocracy in principle can be made to last forever. Of course autocrats eventually kill the host organism so there too there is a built in fuse but it can take a long time (centuries?) to burn.
- westpfelia 1y agolegally Denmark can't have its own nukes. They can only borrow in a sense, nukes as a member of NATO. The US who is a main contributor towards that. I agree something needs to be done but as it stands its not a easy solution. And I would assume if Denmark through nato put nukes on Greenland the US (and I would assume Canada) would treat it as some level of Cuban Missle Crisis.
- Swenrekcah 1y agoThis is rationalising of insane and dangerous behaviour. Who is it that Denmark should consider their enemy in this situation? Is it normal in your mind that the US should be considered the enemy?
- SanjayMehta 1y agoI’m curious to know your views on The Ukraine.
- SanjayMehta 1y agoDoes article 5 apply if a NATO member attacks another NATO member?
- yencabulator 1y agoThe EU defense pact will apply on attacks against Denmark.