6 ms·
Study finds gaps in evidence for air-cleaning technologies to prevent infections
- aaron695 1y ago[dead]
- DANmode 1y agoUV-C / hydroxyl generators or bust
- monster_truck 1y agoWho in the world is installing UV in forced air systems without running an activated carbon filter to remove ozone? The guides I followed when I installed mine called this out multiple times.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- mensetmanusman 1y agoNot all UV wavelengths generate ozone.
- Bukhmanizer 1y agoI’ve just been pip installing my forced air systems and it’s been going ok
- nextcept 1y agoAll the tech in the world won't change anything if people don't focus on airflow and airchanges. Air needs to move and be replenished with air from the outside. Filters/UV/etc are just a bonus.
- ortusdux 1y agoI've been running an airgradient sensor for a year now and as a result I am seriously considering adding a MERV to my HVAC system. Ideally I'd like to get two more sensors (one outside, one in the HVAC ducts) and setup home assistant to govern air exchanges.
- schiffern 1y agoTip: avoid the cheap 1" filters that only have a few pleats. Fewer pleats = less surface area = more flow resistance. Many HVAC people will recommend thicker filters (3-6" thick) if using a higher MERV, but the 1" 3M 1900 often has more actual surface area if laid flat. Testing by Project Farm and others showed the 3M 1900 filter has the lowest airflow resistance of any 1" high-MERV filter. If your HVAC only accepts a 1" filter, that's the only brand I'd use. Change the filter ideally every 3 months, but to avoid costly HVAC repairs don't exceed 6 months maximum.
- turtlebits 1y agoYou can damage/destroy your furnace if you put in a too restrictive filter. Better to follow manufacturer recommendations and add circulating air filters in your house.
- schiffern 1y agoThe issue is, all too often the HVAC equivalent of "gym bro science" teaches young technicians that High MERV = Too Restrictive, which (to put it mildly) is a gross oversimplification. It's important to follow the manufacturers recommendations for the total pressure drop including the filter (this can be measured with a $10 radon manometer), but if the manufacture says something silly like "avoid high MERV filters" then you can safely ignore that claim provided you abide by the maximum pressure drop specced. This is just an issue with residential HVAC, but of course the residential side has always been messed up...
- quickthrowman 1y agoIf by ‘people’ you mean ‘mechanical engineers’, they already do, see ASHRAE 62.1 - Ventilation and Acceptable Indoor Air Quality https://static1.squarespace.com/static/6320b844c3820725e4d5688f/t/6372af076022e56f815dc7f5/1668460297956/ASHRAE+62.1-2022+%281%29.pdf https://static1.squarespace.com/static/6320b844c3820725e4d56...
- throw0101c 1y ago> * Air needs to move and be replenished with air from the outside. Filters/UV/etc are just a bonus.* Outside air needs to be filtered otherwise you can bring in pollen and other things (e.g., exhaust/brake dust from cars if near heavy arteries). Avoid UV for residences: * https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xLwHmfdwO9s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xLwHmfdwO9s
- lazide 1y agoOr for anyone on the west coast the last 5 years, nasty smoke.
- wahnfrieden 1y agoToronto also
- throw0101c 1y agoCarbon filters on your incoming air supply (e.g., ERV): * https://shop.aprilaire.com/search?q=Carbon+Air+Filter https://shop.aprilaire.com/search?q=Carbon+Air+Filter
- lazide 1y ago1) broken link 2) any (actual) HEPA filter works too. A lot of stuff sold as HEPA doesn’t meet the original HEPA standards though, so needs to be actually rated for the super small particles.
- jerlam 1y agoYes, there is a whole certification system for measuring how well an air purifier works (CADR - Clean Air Delivery Rate) but consumers are easily distracted and confused by flashy features that promise everything but usually don't do much.
- _carbyau_ 1y ago> if people don't focus on airflow and airchanges Even basic airflow understanding is surprisingly not common knowledge. IE for air to leave a room occupied by humans, then air needs a path into that room too. I commonly see ceiling exhaust fans in bathroom showers and toilets with windows sealed shut. The door is meant to be closed... so the only gap for air to come into the room is around the door somehow - while the exhaust fan struggles. I even visited one host who implemented a seal along the bottom of the door because: 1. Shower creates steam and with the above mentioned little airflow, that steam stayed around. 2. So the exhaust fan had to run while they dried themselves with a towel. 3. But they didn't like getting cold feet from the draft of air coming in under the door... I could not convince them they needed an air intake vent. :-( Similar but different, a couple of times now I've been in hotel rooms with a bar fridge buzzing away entirely enclosed in a cupboard. Extrapolate that to the hundred rooms or more of the hotel and it is a colossal waste thanks to a "simple" understanding of airflow.
- Aurornis 1y ago> I commonly see ceiling exhaust fans in bathroom showers and toilets with windows sealed shut. The door is meant to be closed... so the only gap for air to come into the room is around the door somehow If the building has central air heating or cooling, having a vent into the bathroom is standard. That’s more than enough for the exhaust fan to pull from. In areas where central air is uncommon, you need a decent door undercut. A surprising amount of air can flow around a door and modern exhaust fans can pull a relatively good vacuum.
- schiffern 1y agoYeah, the real pro tip here is sealing the bottom of your bathroom door to avoid cold feet. Genius!
- derefr 1y ago> be replenished with air from the outside I live in an apartment above a busy road, and my building has no central HVAC. Opening my windows makes the air (much, much) worse. It took a while to figure this out, so from the ~1.5 years I've lived here, I've accumulated huge, thick coats of brake dust on my windowsills, in my carpets, on the blades of my air-circulation floor... and so on. Probably am half-way to developing COPD. I do still "replenish air from outside", though! ...through a three-stage filter. (I put an industrial air scrubber on my balcony, and fed the exhaust from it inside through the same kind of doorjam seal you'd use for a portable AC unit.) I still get noxious fumes coming in sometimes, though. I had to set the thing up on a timer so it wouldn't pull air in during rush hour.
- lisbbb 1y ago[flagged]
- ungreased0675 1y agoFair argument, but let’s not forget that indoor air quality, HEPA filters, and upper air UV systems weren’t even allowed to be discussed as solutions to airborne transmission of viruses not that long ago. It was all about masks/no masks, remember? It’s a little unfair to say that things haven’t been studied, when it would have been career damaging to do so until very recently.
- jeffbee 1y agoNo, I do not remember that. I'm pretty sure you just made it up. Air filtering is obviously long-studied, and if you are alluding to COVID-era events I seem to recall that one of the first large-scale responses that happened in my region was the subway operator installed up-rated HEPA+UV air cleaners on every car. If you want to sustain this claim, show us the process by which someone's career was truncated by researching air filtration.
- valbaca 1y ago> It was all about masks/no masks, remember? You're clearly pushing an agenda. The problem is that these kind of filtration systems couldn't be rolled out en-masse across the world. During COVID hospitals absolutely were using air filtration systems and places where it made sense (I remember COVID doctor's conferences had advanced filters for each room).
- craftkiller 1y agoGot a source? I don't remember anyone objecting to studying HEPA filters' impact on airborne viruses. In fact, I've found studies on that exact topic from that time period. The CDC was saying that HEPA combined with masks was more effective than masking alone back in 2021 (but masking alone was better than HEPA alone) > Without the HEPA air cleaners, universal masking reduced the combined mean aerosol concentration by 72%. The combination of the two HEPA air cleaners and universal masking reduced overall exposure by up to 90%. The HEPA air cleaners were most effective when they were close to the aerosol source 2022: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/35947419/ 2022: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/34098798/ 2021: https://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/volumes/70/wr/mm7027e1.htm
- bluGill 1y agothis is similar to anti-vax propoganda - setting an ever higher bar and saying we need that first there is no particular reason to think lab tests are not most of what we need.
- searine 1y agoFunded by National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health at the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention aka NIOSH / CDC
- jerlam 1y agoWhich has been completely gutted by the current administration.
- jld 1y agoDouble blind studies are helpful when we do not understand they underlying dynamics of a complicated system (like a body) but we want to learn what effect a change has on that system (like a medicine). If we know pathogens cause disease, and we know filtering removes pathogens from the air (and we can test and verify that) we don't need to run a double blind study to verify they work. It's the same reason you don't need to run a double blind study on whether seat belts work. We understand the cause and effect of car ejections and windshield/steering wheel impacts on human bodies. Seat belts are designed to mitigate these incidents and are tested and validated in the lab using formal science and engineering.
- valbaca 1y ago> It's the same reason you don't need to run a double blind study on whether seat belts work. We might need some historical investigation into the road that was travelled to get seatbelts to where they are now (physically, legally, and socially). I'm a millennial and I remember growing up where similar arguments were made: - "If it's my time to go, then it's God's will" - "It's uncomfortable" - zero/inconsistent law enforcement - "If the car rolls over than it can trap you" To now, where it's entirely automatic and incredibly wild to even suggest being without a seatbelt.
- astura 1y agoIts crazy, I was born in the early 80s and I never wore a seatbelt until I started driving. As a kid I would ride in a van that didn't even have seats and think absolutely nothing of it.
- rootusrootus 1y agoI was born in the early 70s and we always wore seatbelts, for as long as I can remember. Though we did routinely ride in the back of the pickup, which isn't something I see happening much today.
- c0nsumer 1y agoDon't forget the one about how it's safer to be thrown free of a wreck (which will happen if you don't wear your seatbelt) than remain in the car. <sigh>
- HocusLocus 1y agoBreathing and sleeping in negative ionized air for 40 years. Just high voltage potential -7 to -10kVDC and spread carbon hairs (better than metal spikes) to launch it. Walls and floors always have positive charge conducted from the ground outside relative to the air, no sparks means ozone in too small concentrations to worry about. Dust, smoke, bacteria and viruses stick to walls not the inside of lungs and the air is clean and odorless. You can shine a very bright flashlight through it in a dark room and see absolutely no beam. Every so often you sponge off the walls with strong cleaning solution. Latex paint stains easily near the device which is a subtle way of reminding you how germy it really would have been. Use plastic over walls near the device to save yourself some color matching and painting. Over all these years, the most annoying thing has been other people trying to sell me HEPA filter solutions with screaming fans that need accessory replacement often. They insist I'm killing myself with ozone as a fear tactic. Few people sell just ionizers or sabotage the concept by selling weak/ineffective ones... because HEPA is big money. Ionizers use tiny energy and no recurring supplies. Just make sure your electronics are grounded well.
- pinoy420 1y agoAre you allergic to going outside? I watched a grand designs episode where the parents (well, inflicted by the wife) Munchausen by proxied these allergies onto their kids. They were obsessive about having an allergy free house and spent hundreds of thousands building one with, basically a lesser version of what you explained up there. Revisiting several years later, the children had integrated with society (amazing that they weren’t homeschooled) and lo and behold - allergy free. The provocative host coaxed out of the parents that they believed that the house did bugger all in terms of helping their children. I wonder how the kids are doing now without their namby mother
- 0b110907 1y agoDo you have a more detailed writeup about how you've set this up?
- HocusLocus 1y agoMy primary device is a 2010 Comtech (good luck finding one). It's just a voltage multiplier off of 110VAC( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Voltage_multiplier https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Voltage_multiplier ). I bought 8 $5/ea Chinese 'neg ion modules' and tied then to the back of the fan... they are parts to build into a much weaker device for cars. They will last longer (because they're resin sealed) and safer (12VDC supply) but by comparative output measurement I will need an array of 36 to match the output of the 2010 device. At $5 ea, this is doable. There are single power supply units more capable but I like the idea of 36 separate waterproof replaceable 12VDC things.
- don-bright 1y agoI support more research but anecdotally HEPA air filters changed my life. I used to get pretty bad respiratory infections every winter but after getting these that went away. I’m talking the simple kind with basic charcoal prefilter and fiber HEPA filter which are about $150 at most home stores or big box stores. Never used any ionization or ozone. The interesting bit is the newer ones even measure air particulates and have a variable speed option where they will speed up when they detect high pollution… Which turns out is mostly from me cooking.
- gerdesj 1y agoWell you will need a particulate detector to determine the problem and then that will inform your solution.
- vosper 1y agoYour HEPA filters must be real ones. HEPA is just an acronym anyone can slap on anything, there's no accreditation. Recent testing on the Vacuum Wars channel showed big differences between filters from the vacuum manufacturer and off-brand "HEPA" filters. Probably the same applies everywhere. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eAIYRykQkMk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eAIYRykQkMk
- throw0101c 1y ago> HEPA is just an acronym anyone can slap on anything, there's no accreditation. There are standards: > Filters meeting the HEPA standard must satisfy certain levels of efficiency. Common standards require that a HEPA air filter must remove—from the air that passes through—at least 99.95% (ISO, European Standard)[4][5] or 99.97% (ASME, U.S. DOE)[6][7] of particles whose diameter is equal to 0.3 μm, with the filtration efficiency increasing for particle diameters both less than and greater than 0.3 μm.[8] * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HEPA https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HEPA * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HEPA#Specifications https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HEPA#Specifications
- sirtaj 1y agoHere in India you can usually tell them apart by whether they are advertised as HEPA vs "HEPA-type".
- throw0101c 1y agoIn 2023 there was a conference about Chemistry of Indoor Environments (CIE) that looked at the research that was done over a ten-year period; opening presentation: * https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vt0GLbi20Q4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vt0GLbi20Q4 * https://indoorchem.org/publications/ https://indoorchem.org/publications/ Playlist of the various presentations from the conference: * https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=J2iHOCI2hz4&list=PLsc2-5fAgMq4bj2P8fMgQjzJmx8p1mCMd https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=J2iHOCI2hz4&list=PLsc2-5fAgM... Generally: avoid any use of electronics to 'do stuff' to the air or pathogens (e.g. UV) and just use high-MERV / HEPA filters, and use an ERV to vent stale air and bring in (filtered, conditioned) outside air.
- thepaulmcbride 1y agoEven HEPA isn’t a requirement, you just need a high CADR. Doesn’t matter if the filter doesn’t catch a particle on the first pass as long as it does one a subsequent one and the flow rate is high!
- rogerkirkness 1y agoYeah the whole 'just use HEPA' has been what's worked for us after about a half dozen different air purifiers of experimentation. I noticed the positive ionization things changed my heart rate variability which was spooky.
- o11c 1y agoEmpirically, the ionizer is good for wildfire season, but the rest of the year HEPA is good.
- throw0101c 1y ago> Empirically, the ionizer is good for wildfire season, but the rest of the year HEPA is good. Smoke can be dealt with via a carbon filter and you don't have to do a chemistry experiment in your house. * https://shop.aprilaire.com/search?q=Carbon+Air+Filter https://shop.aprilaire.com/search?q=Carbon+Air+Filter
- Havoc 1y ago>analyzed nearly 700 studies Really feels like they went so meta here they lost the plot. Complaints about fails to catch covid. People are buying air filters to fish out particulate matter not fix a 2022 pandemic. To say they failed to see the forest for all the trees would be a kindness
- duffpkg 1y agoThis is a "metastudy".
- Night_Thastus 1y agoI think it's worth mentioning to people that for non-infection purposes, HEPA is honestly not a great idea. The problem is that such low-porosity filters struggle to even let air move through them. And if you don't move a lot of air, you aren't cleaning a lot of air. At low fan speeds they're effectively placebo for how little they do. You can get around this by adding yet more powerful fans and cranking up their speed, but then it sounds like a jet engine. Everyone just ends up turning them off (or way down) because they're too noisy - defeating the purpose. If you just want non-virus stuff (pollen, smoke, dust) then don't go HEPA. Go with something like MERV-13. They come in standard off the shelf furnace style filters. They're way cheaper than HEPA and way better for most use cases. HEPA only makes sense for something as fine as viruses, or if you only get a single pass to do the filtering. For anything that circulates (like in a house) it makes 0 sense.
- PaulKeeble 1y agoThere doesn't need to be tests on humans. We have plenty of research showing that viruses harm humans as do small particles in the air this isn't in question at all. These devices have been shown to remove these items from the air using engineering testing based on physics like the electrostatic force and the laws of motion. That they work is not in question, they do filter the air. The only remaining aspect is how well do they clear air that is constantly getting dirty that has been tested as well, for the most part 6 air changes an hour seems to drastically reduce the particle count. The problem with medical research "questions" on filtration currently is it thinks random control trials are the gold standard of proof. They aren't physics and engineering tests are a much higher quality of science and evidence. Filters work, respirators do work to remove viruses because we know the size of aerosol they tend to live in (1-5 microns mostly for something like Covid) and how effective the filters are at those particle sizes.
- buckle8017 1y agoThis is just "we have no evidence that masks prevent spread of disease" all over again. Yes that's technically true, but this is just a grant money grab. It's not a serious attempt to study these things.
- user568439 1y agoI have 3 oversized air purifiers in my home. I don't really know if they help to prevent infections but my wife has Long Covid and every time there is too much dust, pollen or smoke around us she gets pretty bad. So we decided to buy them with little proof after she noticed she feels somewhat better when staying in a room with one. It could even be partially placebo but for the days with too much particles from outside I think it really helps. Maybe we should rather have a full control of air flows in our home but that would be a huge investment for a very old house, also having air flowing with windows partially open on dry days also seems to help. Humidity ( and certainly mold) also has a clear negative effect so I had to buy a dehumidifier too