4 ms·
YouTube's sneaky AI 'experiment'
- tomhow 1y agoYouTube made AI enhancements to videos without warning or permission - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45003073 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45003073 - Aug 2025 (267 comments)
- rhdunn 1y agoThey've also introduced automatic dubbing for foreign language videos. While this can be useful, I'd prefer it to be opt-in like how you can select the language for subtitles.
- lm28469 1y agoThe best part is that the TTS is somehow worse than what elevenlab had 3 years ago
- torben-friis 1y agoLanguage is one of the silliest things in modern tech. I speak fluent English, but my native language is Spanish. I should be the most basic case of bilingualism for an app to handle - my native language is popular, English is the poster child of second language you learn for global communication, the combination itself is common as well... The amount of stupid assumptions apps and sites make about me is mindboggling. "Your app and OS is set to English, you watch mostly English content, you use no subtitles and your subscriptions are mostly US-based. let's give you an extremely fake dub over the content you usually watch." Reddit also auto translate the links I enter and makes them gibberish if I'm not logged in, chagpt switches languages halfway through a message regardless of what I use...It's becoming borderline hostile.
- anal_reactor 1y agoI've been downvoted for this and I'll be downvoted again, but average user is monolingual and for them, shitty automatic translation is better than no translation. Nobody cares about the fact that a small percentage of users speak more than one language. It's mind-boggling that HN users don't understand that they're not the target audience of most major platforms. Anyway, I recommend Revanced. It has an option to turn off both subtitles and dubbing. This makes YouTube usable again.
- amanaplanacanal 1y agoAverage American is monolingual, anyway.
- johannes1234321 1y agoWhile even in America (as in USA) there is a large community of people speaking English and Spanish. And tech companies (including Google) have a lot of immigrants, who should be aware of the existance of bilinguals. For broader America, including Canda there is Quebec with French+English. etc
- jcranmer 1y agoApparently about 20% of the US is multilingual (per census data). So while the median might be monolingual, it is still so large of the US as to be a market segment worth catering to.
- Wowfunhappy 1y ago> but [the] average user is monolingual That's certainly true in America, but my understanding (as an American myself) is that it's not true in much of the world! In Romania for example people speak Romanian and English; in Ukraine they speak Ukrainian and Russian. I'm not sure how this nets out in terms of the overall population of technology users, but it's a large chunk of people! P.S. For what it's worth, I downvoted you because you said "I'll be downvoted for this", not because I thought the rest of your comment was bad. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- anal_reactor 1y agoIt's just frustrating to see how clueless people here are on the topic of multilingualism, despite being otherwise well-rounded. They genuinely think that the reason why platforms support multilingualism so poorly is different from "market forces proved that multilingual support is not an important feature".
- 1y ago
- tavavex 1y agoIt's mind-boggling and insane how hostile YT became to multilingualism. You'd think that out of the hundreds of people involved in this project, at least one would've been bilingual and experienced this hostility firsthand. I can't even come up with any explanations for how this happened, except for no one important being bilingual (or even having thought of bilingual people), and/or some kind of systemic flaw that lets these breaking changes slip into the final product. YouTube doesn't care about the languages listed in your Google account, as everything else does. It doesn't care what content you watch. The algorithm seemingly takes your display language and forces poorly AI-translated content down your throat, more often than not completely obliterating any coherence the original video had. And this change is forced upon you, you must watch it in the language YouTube decides you have to watch it in. There is a browser extension that reverts this behavior to how it used to be and makes YouTube load the proper audio track. What happens when that stops working?
- Tostino 1y agoThese companies are not actually diverse, even if they attempt(ed in the past) to hire diverse ethnicities.
- tavavex 1y agoBut the strangest thing is that you don't need to be of a certain ethnicity to speak multiple languages. Sure, I think it's less likely for some average US-born employee, but I would still guess that probably >10% have got to speak a foreign language, especially since they're all highly educated people who had more exposure to other languages and cultures than the average American.
- happysadpanda2 1y agoAha! I too have seen thumbnails of videos with context clues (product brands in the thumbnail which doesn't exist under that brand in my country) yet with a video title in my native tongue, which a clear "machine translation"-feel to it. Until I read this thread I assumed that it was the content creator doing shenanigans (low quality AI slop video mass-produced in many languages and targeting my locale with videos for my locale), but it does make so much more "sense" that it would be YT doing this. And my reaction to those thumbnails, thinking it was the creator doing low quality AI slop, was to "reward" them with "Don't recommend this channel". So I have been punishing innocent channels for crap that YT is doing...
- glitchc 1y agoI'm certain it boils down to money. Someone like you (fluently bilingual) would provide the best translation but also the costliest. Every other option is cheaper, and Youtube will strive for the cheapest available. Google Translate and Gemini are essentially free to Youtube, so why not?
- tavavex 1y agoThe crazy part isn't that the feature exists - I'm sure YouTube wants to make foreign content available to people who don't speak that language, and of course they can't manually translate every video in the world - it's that it's mandatory.
- torben-friis 1y agoI would buy this argument, except the cheapest thing for them would be to offer me the regular original experience in English, which is always my preferred option (maybe with some optional subs once in a blue moon, for thick accents and the like). It’s pretty much impossible to set this preference the moment you have _something_ (a location, a keyboard, whatever) not set to the American default. And even if you do, it would then mangle Spanish content (or whatever your other language is)
- aredox 1y agoThose AI translations fail all the time - I am looking at woodworking, and a "plane" gets translated variously as an "avion", a "surface", etc... and never as a "rabot". It is "English to French" translation. Two close langs, with a humongous corpus to train on.
- mountainb 1y agoTry to drop a foreign phrase into MS Word to add a little color and watch it go completely berserk.
- thrance 1y agoOr at the very least, allow us to opt-out. This automatic enabling of AI dubbing for videos in a language I can understand is maddening.
- stephen_g 1y agoAbsolutely, I really wish you could opt-out of the auto-dubbing instead of having to select the audio manually. I'd take poorly translated auto-transcribed subtitles with the original audio basically every time over the badly auto-dubbed audio.
- JohnTHaller 1y agoI started watching a video that was using this on desktop. I down-voted it immediately because I figured it was AI slop, as so much of YouTube is today.
- fho 1y agoYouTube's automatic title translation (English to German in my case) is surprisingly bad. I often stumble over translations that are technically correct, but plain wrong in the context of the video. (Just tried to find some examples, but could not find any. Maybe Google does not force autotranslated titles on me anymore?)
- anticensor 1y agoIt's opt-out.
- explodes 1y agoHmm. I've been watching some old shows taken from VHS and some of them look like cursed AI upscale. One series was titled as AI upscale, and another wasn't. Both looked a bit rough. Wonder if this is why.
- karmakaze 1y agoI hate it. Similar to "Remastered" on Spotify that makes everything sound the same, which I hate far more.
- a57721 1y agoI think remasters are uploaded by the record labels, it's not some kind of algorithm run by Spotify. It has loudness normalization, which can be turned off in the settings.
- SoftTalker 1y ago"Remastered" = "Set loudness to 11."
- schiffern 1y ago"The same pixel-filled rectangle could contain the work of someone who spent time and energy and had the courage to perform publicly, or of someone who sits in bed typing prompts and splicing clips in order to make a few bucks." One can imagine much the same sentence being written 100+ years ago, about the honest hard-working landscape painters we all know and love, vs the newfangled corner-cutting opportunists with their (questionably moral) "photography." Fraud is bad, and people should know what they're consuming. Artists should control what they're producing, as in this case with Youtube. That said, the underlying moral panic betrayed by the quoted sentence is completely over-the-top. Full disclosure: I don't create AI art, and I don't know anyone who does.
- burnt-resistor 1y agoIf YT ads were honest: Corporate technofeudalism: now with 30% less consent and only 10% more suck.
- mitchbob 1y agohttps://archive.ph/2025.08.23-004440/https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2025/08/youtube-shorts-ai-upscaling/683946/ https://archive.ph/2025.08.23-004440/https://www.theatlantic...
- neonate 1y agohttps://archive.ph/VGfr0 https://archive.ph/VGfr0
- Workaccount2 1y agoWhat would be the goal here? Technical? Some kind of super compression-decompression scheme? Model tuning to see how people react? Is there a stupid "Upscale with AI" slider that is new and default turned on?
- anal_reactor 1y agoThey just throw shit at everything and see what sticks. Truth is, AI does and will revolutionalize some aspects of our lives, it's just not clear what specifically. It's like we're in this weird phase when during dotcom bubble everyone tried to make everything online. Most ideas are pure unadulterated poop, but someone will indeed hit the jackpot.
- OptionKitchen 1y agoI suspect they want to make natural videos look slightly more artificial so that AI generated content will look less unnatural. "close the uncanny valley" so to speak
- zb3 1y agoOr to get promoted :)
- atrettel 1y agoI think the compression idea is the most plausible, but it still doesn't make complete sense. Unless the compression scheme significantly reduced the size, I don't see why YouTube would implement something so lossy, especially without warning people beforehand.
- Gigachad 1y agoRemoving noise and smoothing the video would reduce the size. While also giving it that AI dream look.
- anal_reactor 1y agoAs much as HN hates AI, most users are happy with this change because for most videos, it works correctly.
- htrp 1y agoGoogle is behind on getting human feedback data and is incorporating this anywhere they can (SGE, Gemini in Gmail, Video in Youtube).
- gdbsjjdn 1y agoThere's a paywall, but does TFA actually confirm if this is done for "image quality" or if it's used to improve compression ratios? I've seen both theories - that YouTube is deliberately applying an AI aesthetic to non-AI videos, or that this is a side-effect of aggressive attempts to reduce bandwidth.
- olyjohn 1y agoWho knows. I just know that I have uploaded high quality video to YouTube, and they compress the living shit out of it so badly that it looked blurry and faded. Now they gotta use AI to upscale shitty looking videos? Dumb as fuck.
- userbinator 1y agoThat description sounds like what happens when the compression level of H.265 is turned up all the way. It's great for certain types of content (anime...) but not others.
- atleastoptimal 1y agoFor every erudite AI-skeptic who decries the overuse of AI and the muddy, oversaturated style AI image and upscaling models propagate, there are 10 reliable ad-watching product-purchasing users who love that aesthetic and their consumer behavior will drive towards that aesthetic being used more (for good reason, that look was fine tuned to match their preferences).
- add-sub-mul-div 1y agoThe tyranny of the majority and the plight of the discerning.
- NoPicklez 1y agoThis has happened with articles circulating about Will Smith and his recent concert video looking AI generated. Supposedly his video uploaded to Youtube shorts looked heavily AI generated compared to the same video uploaded to Instagram, despite the crowds and couples in the shorts being real people that were also photographed.
- jgalt212 1y agoThis must be great for Google's Cloud business.
- vivzkestrel 1y agomaybe they should also give some thought on how to fix their broken search since they are in the mood to fix things
- kurito 1y ago"Experiment" is such an understatement to the treachery happening here