5 ms·
Note that CNN isn’t in trouble for reporting this, the person who exfiltrated the footage is. Stealing security camera footage and giving (or possibly selling)
by Aurornis 1y ago
Note that CNN isn’t in trouble for reporting this, the person who exfiltrated the footage is.
Stealing security camera footage and giving (or possibly selling) it is a problem. This article tries to make a case that the law applied wasn’t correct on somewhat pedantic terms, but I don’t know enough about the law to know if they have a point or not.
I do know, however, that if you take private data from your employer and leak it (or sell it) you’re not going to be on the right side of the law. I have a hard time buying this article’s point that it was just “violating company policy”
- johnhess 1y ago"the law" is the fulcrum this turns on. if you wrong your employer, for example by failing to do your job well, you are not a criminal to be prosecuted by the state. you may well deserve to lose that job though. here, wronging your employer is considered a criminal act.
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago> if you wrong your employer, for example by failing to do your job well, you are not a criminal to be prosecuted by the state This is going out of one’s way to abuse the employer’s trust. Moreover, it’s stealing their stuff. If I take cash out of a till, my employer should have the option of pressing charges. Where I agree with you is that this isn’t computer fraud and abuse. It’s closer to theft. The law used to prosecute should be more banal.
- uoaei 1y ago"stuff" being technically, legally, IP
- hluska 1y agoThat’s unclear. Mr. Mbengue plead no contest to a trespass charge. He was represented by an attorney with some prosecutorial experience so I think we can assume he received qualified legal advice based upon the facts of the matter. Under terms of his no contest plea, if he stays out of trouble for a year he can have his record expunged. It sure looks like a plea bargain, in which case we’ll likely never know the actual charges the prosecution was prepared to proceed with. But there’s a clue in the article - when the report was provided to the Intercept, the locations of the security cameras were redacted. When CNN aired the clip, they apparently aired information that identified where that camera was located. We’ll most likely never know the original charge the prosecution was prepared to proceed with, but the US takes airport security very seriously (as every country should). If taking a no contest on a trespass was considered an out, I wonder if the other charge started with a vowel like ‘e’.
- uoaei 1y agoWhat's unclear, exactly? Whether video documentation obtained privately belongs to the person who owns the camera and storage media? Because I think it's about as clear as it gets.
- hluska 1y agoI’m Canadian so I’m trying really hard to avoid saying anything that could be perceived as anti-American. I like Americans a lot as half my family hid out in the United States after getting kicked out of Canada, so I’ve struggled with a reply to this for a few days. The part that is unclear is that this is a Black man named Mohamed who exfiltrated footage that could be used to plan an attack against an airplane. I trust you can draw that out on your own.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- burnished 1y agoIt is in no way close to theft because theft involves depriving the victim of some good or asset.
- gameman144 1y agoDoes it? There are loads of types of theft that don't remove the good or asset from the owner: Identity theft, IP theft, theft of private digital assets (e.g. photos, writings, music)
- ipaddr 1y agoThose are labels. Identity theft is more identity fraud. Theft of digital assets is copyright infringement.
- margalabargala 1y agoIdentity theft is someone else stealing money from the bank, and the bank telling you that's your problem now.
- gameman144 1y agoThis is interesting, I definitely use "theft" colloquially for all these things. For the digital assets, I mentally bucket copyright infringement and theft differently. For instance, if I copy someone's photography and sell it, that's copyright infringement (not theft). However, if I hacked into someones Google photos and sold the contents, I'd consider that theft (since there was no intent for the material to be available) Granted, it's fair to disagree here, so I'm not adamantly against the definition that requires removing access or anything.
- ghurtado 1y ago"lots of theft is not theft. Like for instance, all these things that are not theft" ... Lots of murder doesn't have a victim... .... Lots of arson doesn't involve a fire... ... Lots of trespass involves not taking a single step from your work desk .. ... War is peace, peace is war...
- ghurtado 1y ago> it’s stealing their stuff. Then I'm sure your have a great explanation as to why they were charged with trespass and not theft.
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago> I'm sure your have a great explanation as to why they were charged with trespass and not theft Literally said I think they’re charging this wrong.
- metalman 1y agocant be theft, as it he copyed from one format to another...different video standards/resolutions...and if he gave a copy, of the copy away and the third party(cnn) has not been charged, even though they published the footage, and profited by that, then yes him getting criminaly charged for what is an indiscression at best is unusual. what would be of interest is if the same organisation that "owned" the cameras and footage has ever demanded that employies share footage taken on there phones, or requires employies to carry a personal phone for work, as that would further muddy any notion of personal/private ....all to cover up what is egregious behavior on the part of military pilots in civilian airspace....but realy part of an attempt to intimidate the public into not documenting military and police crime.
- Daviey 1y agoDifferent but comparable example. Some jobs, if you mess up you just get fired. Other jobs you could end up in prison, for doing the same/similar thing. A prison officer has a sexual relationship with a prisoner, should they simply be fired or also have a jury heard criminal court process then a record? .. Not that it should be relevant, but now factor in the prison officer is female, newly qualified and the training college wrote to the prison to warn that the prison officer is not suitable to be a prison officer because they are not robust enough. The prisoner is also highly manipulative and has a documented history of romance with vulnerable females.
- ndriscoll 1y agoWhy would it lead to more than them getting fired? What would be the crime? If the idea is that they've coerced/raped a prisoner, presumably that prisoner is making that allegation, and it's the rape allegation that gets investigated/tried, as with any other serious allegation of a crime. If it's consensual, that sounds like they're just not trustworthy to do their job and should be let go.
- Daviey 1y agoNo, the prisoner did not make an allegation. But this is the point I am making, if I have a relationship with someone at work, particularly when one person is subordinate or position of authority, then we'd simply be fired... but a prison officer will face a criminal prosecution of Misconduct in Public Office, and possibly face prison time themselves. Seems somewhat unfair for a low paying job.
- soraminazuki 1y agoStealing? Theft? Is there a god-given right for corporate or government interests to withhold lethal air crash footage from the public?
- opello 1y agoAnd it seems like that law requires malicious intent. I wonder how that would be proven here?
- hluska 1y agoSection A of 18.2-152.4 reads: “A. It is unlawful for any person, with malicious intent, or through intentionally deceptive means and without authority, to:” And Mr. Mbengue plead no contest to this charge, so he did not admit guilt but agreed to be punished as if he was guilty. He had an attorney with prosecutorial experience retained for his criminal proceeding so we can assume he entered that plea upon receiving qualified legal advice. Under terms of his plea, if he keeps his nose clean for a year, he can apply to have the charge expunged from his record. So, this looks like a plea bargain. But since he plead no contest, the prosecution doesn’t have to prove anything.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- kurikuri 1y ago> I do know, however, that if you take private data from your employer and leak it (or sell it) you’re not going to be on the right side of the law. I have a hard time buying this article’s point that it was just “violating company policy” If I were to copy the files on my work device and distribute them, I would be in violation of NDAs which could be pursued as civil offenses. If I didn’t have those NDAs, my employer could try and pursue something in court, along with firing me, but it wouldn’t be a straightforward suit. None of these are (or at least, should be) criminal situations.
- noitpmeder 1y agoI mean in the first case you're literally stealing from your employer. If that doesn't make you a criminal for theft I don't know what does
- opello 1y agoBut the footage isn't "real property" as I understand it. The only thing the theft does is deprive the company from the opportunity to sell the footage themselves, and it's not exactly like selling security camera footage is the business model of many/any(?) company. If the harm is that the company couldn't sell the footage itself, the remedy should be giving the company the money from the sale.
- otterley 1y agoIt’s a common misconception that “property” relates to physical objects (chattel) or land (real property). But that’s an incorrect and limited understanding. More generally, it’s about the right to control something and exclude others from using it. Copyright, for example, is what’s known as “intellectual property.” Its rights protect intangible things, namely, artistic expressions.
- opello 1y agoI think I did understand that, specifically contrasting real property and intellectual property, but maybe wrongfully implied that theft could only apply to real property. However, is there any argument for security camera footage like this instance to be considered a trade secret? Isn't that the only type of intellectual property it might be? It seems like if the business wasn't planning to derive economic value from the sale of the security camera footage (which seems like a generally safe assumption) it would fail to acquire trade secret protections.
- ghurtado 1y ago[flagged]
- tomhow 1y agoBe kind. Don't be snarky. Edit out swipes. Please don't fulminate. Please don't sneer, including at the rest of the community. Please respond to the strongest plausible interpretation of what someone says, not a weaker one that's easier to criticize. Assume good faith. Please don't post shallow dismissals, especially of other people's work. A good critical comment teaches us something. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html