9 ms·
Trees on city streets cope with drought by drinking from leaky pipes
https://archive.ph/5gJNi https://archive.ph/5gJNi
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- abstractspoon 1y agoThis is not news. Having to rebore pipes due to tree roots has been around for decades
- alehlopeh 1y agoDecades? Try millennia.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- metalman 1y agothere is a new to me datum in that trees along residential streets are experiencing less water stress than trees in parks, due to city water leakage that was demonstrated by doing core samples on the trees to show how lead isotopes differed in the two populations of trees. it highlights a growing concern with water in general and how carefull water monitering and management is becoming, and how what was primarily interesting to civil engineering types, has a wider audience
- KritVutGu 1y ago[dead]
- pessimizer 1y agohttps://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/rebore#English https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/rebore#English They mean clearing tree roots out of the pipes, and patching them.
- bombcar 1y agoOr the modern method of inflating a new pipe inside the old pipe, bursting the old pipe
- abhiyerra 1y agoHeh. Yesterday, we had a plumber over who told us we have to rebore our sewage pipes because roots got in. It is an old house with cast iron pipes and they still got in.
- bombcar 1y agoCast Iron’s worse than plastic because they always leak a tiny bit and that means that the roots can “smell” the water and go for it. Plastic either is impervious or completely fucked.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 1y agoI get tree root intrusion where my newish plastic sewer main joins the street sewer.
- bombcar 1y agoYeah joints are always the problem. Which is why you want the joints to be someone else’s problem.
- HarHarVeryFunny 1y agoI've never heard it called "reboring" - wonder if there is a different procedure for when it gets really bad, but I'd have thought problems (backup) would happen pretty quickly, so wouldn't be too bad as long as you take care of it. They basically use something like a weed whacker fed down the pipe, except it uses a short bit of chain instead of trimmer line, and will pulverise any intruding roots.
- peterbecich 1y agoThere are at least two techniques: sewer rooting (low velocity and high torque) and sewer de-scaling (opposite).
- xenotux 1y ago> While the park trees contained lead isotopes normally associated with air pollution, the street trees had isotopes found in lead water pipes, which were made with metal from geologically old deposits in nearby mines. I don't understand this part. We didn't use different sources of lead to make leaded gas and lead pipes, no?
- striking 1y agoWhen you need a lot of lead (enough to build plumbing for a neighborhood), you probably want to source it locally. When "1 part TEL to 1300 parts gasoline by weight is sufficient to suppress detonation",[1] you can source the lead from just about anywhere and ship it with the fuel. 1: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tetraethyllead https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tetraethyllead
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- metalman 1y agolead from pipes was mined localy, but the lead in parks soil is from airborn pollution and so the isotope signature will be quite different
- throwup238 1y agoTetraethyllead production was very centralized by Ethyl corp/DuPont and required a higher purity lead ore so their isotope ratios are very well known based on the deposits that they mined. More locally sourced lead used for construction will have different isotope ratios.
- estimator7292 1y agoWe didn't put elemental lead in gasoline, it was a very different molecule with a single lead atom. Given how dense lead is, you want to source it from as physically close as you can. A foundry making pipes in a city with a lead mine nearby will obviously use the local lead. For gasoline, all production had to be centralized in a few refineries. The lead would have been shipped in, and would have been largely the same quality and age, likely coming from the same mine, or geographically close mines. Plus the absolute quantity of lead added to gasoline is relatively small. In the 60 years the US used TEL, we processed about 8 million tons of lead. Averaged out, it's 133 thousand tons a year. It would only take a few mines to provide that much. Probably not more than five or ten, but I can't immediately find good data on this. One would expect that the lead used in gasoline is pretty homogeneous across time, and that intensive lead use (as in casting into solid metal object like pipes) would use the nearest available source, and use that source for as long as possible.
- panarchy 1y agoOr if you're a willow tree you make a leaky pipe.
- buildsjets 1y agoSome genius planted a curly willow right in the middle of my house’s septic drain field. That tree cost me $20,000.
- hinkley 1y agoYou’re not supposed to plane ANY trees in the middle of the septic system.
- ghaff 1y agoYou're not. But people often don't even fully know exactly where the limits of their septic system (including leach fields) are. SUPPOSEDLY they know where their septic tank is but tree roots grow, records are lost, etc.
- dingnuts 1y agoSame happened to me with a hackberry I didn't know was wild. Some genius added landscaping to make it look like a choice. You got off easy, I think after all was said and done I paid about the same out of pocket, but also was displaced for a long time due to the damages, and it cost insurance another $80+ grand that I'm sure I'll pay back over time in raised premiums. Fun!
- AngryData 1y agoReminds me when I installed a drain field for a guy that had to have trees in the woods cleared and dug up for space and everything pumped 100 feet up a hill to it due to the terrain. Just as I was finishing up he asked when he could park his 40 foot boat on top of it and was outraged when I said he can't/shouldn't do that, he then declined the offer to have us clear more area before we loaded up all the equipment. All I could imagine as I drove away was the river of shit flowing back down the hill to his house in a few years.
- Rygian 1y agoSidetracked by the nominative determinism in the article (researcher André Poirier's surname means "pear tree").
- londons_explore 1y agoI wonder how much human health is impacted by these leaky pipes. I would like to see a city where pipes are guaranteed leak free, for example by making them double walled with high pressure air in the outer layer, and then seeing if disease levels in the city are lower.
- Aromasin 1y agoWe already have this data in a way, from cities where there is no running water and people rely on bottled water for drinking and washing.
- cluckindan 1y agoThat’s not biased at all.
- cyanydeez 1y agoThose leaks are 99.9% one way.
- londons_explore 1y agoThat way being 'sewage leaking into the ecosystem '? Followed by ecosystem being collected and put back into drinking water, most of which only has pretty lightweight treatment which doesn't even involve testing for any viruses which have snuck through.
- bluGill 1y agoMost of the time the local soil is well able to purify the small amount that leaks. Most is key, see and expert on your local conditions for details.
- likpok 1y agoThe pipes are pressurized, so I would expect there to be limited avenue for infiltration. (Also, for sewage exposure, you’d need two leaks close together. Not impossible or anything, but much less likely.
- _qua 1y ago500 million liters of water a day lost to leaks!
- dataflow 1y agoFor those wondering how big this is, that's about (80 meters)^3.
- x775 1y ago> Maple trees need to consume around 50 litres of water per day. Since street trees can’t get much of this from rainwater, which falls on concrete and drains into the city’s sewers, Poirier says the most likely explanation is that it is coming from Montreal’s leaky pipes, which lose 500 million litres of water per day. I feel like this is burying the lede. What can be done to reduce leakage?
- CalRobert 1y agoHopefully the lede, lead would be an even bigger concern.
- 1over137 1y agoMontreal has plenty of lead pipes too. ;(
- x775 1y agoHah, that was an unfortunate auto-correct. Fixed!
- bluebarbet 1y agoThe lede rendering is optional: >The spelling lede (/ˈliːd/, from Early Modern English) is also used in American English, originally to avoid confusion with the printing press type formerly made from the metal lead or the related typographical term "leading". https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/News_style#Lead https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/News_style#Lead
- lupusreal 1y agoWhy should anything be done to reduce leakage? They take water out of the St Lawrence and, as much isn't diverted by trees, it goes back in (cleaner then when it came out.)
- bluGill 1y agoBecause trees will clog those pipes eventualay and then we must dig them up. Pipes that don't leak don't attract roots and so last longer
- btbuildem 1y agoThe city where I live estimates that we lose somewhere between 25% and 30% of drinkable water to leaky infrastructure. We've had something close to a drought this summer -- unseasonally long periods without rain. You can see the young trees on the streets and trees in the middle of large parks suffer from it - wilted leaves and leaves dropping earlier than usual. BUT, large old trees seem to be thriving - full canopies, lush, firm leaves. I've been suspecting the big street trees do so well because they benefit from the dilapidated state of our water delivery infra. It's nice to read of a study that confirms my amateur observations and musings.
- devnullbrain 1y agoOlder, bigger plants have roots that go deeper and have access to more water. You can see the same effect in gardens, where new plants wilt sooner than established plants (and the care instructions advise frequent watering for the first couple of weeks).
- reactordev 1y agoBoth are facts and both are true. Big trees, with their deeper, longer roots - have access to more leaky infrastructure. Or are the cause of it.
- kulahan 1y agoTree roots stay surprisingly shallow for the most part. Generally, 90% of the roots are in the top 2' of soil.
- Spooky23 1y agoThat’s really high. There’s either a big problem in your city, or they are making generous estimates to justify asking for more capital. 10-15% is more typical. In my region, the street trees are usually getting sewer water. Residential service in older houses are usually clay pipes with lead solder that the tree infiltrates. It’s not a problem until the clay pops and roots clog it. It varies a lot by region and jurisdiction. One of the cities near me made the mistake of using riveted pipe from rolled steel to save money 75 years ago, and regularly has catastrophic main breaks as the rivets aren’t as robust as a regular pipe.
- vaughnegut 1y agoI wonder how many of the pipes are made of wood. I forget the source, but I heard a decent number of pipes in Montreal are very old and made of wood (which is better than the proliferation of lead pipes that are still being removed)
- andix 1y agoNot only trees in cities do that. A lot of clogged home sewers are caused by trees that wanted more to drink. Once the sewer line is fully blocked, they've arrived in paradise. Now there is a constant supply in the permanently filled sewer line.
- bigstrat2003 1y agoOr at least, constant supply for the several hours it will take to call a rooter company and clear the drain line. Ironically, the tree would have better results if it only partly blocked the drain. I wonder if trees might ever evolve to strike that kind of balance, or if there's not enough selection pressure for that to happen.
- lelandbatey 1y agoWatch out, some tree roots may be stronger than the rooter used to clear them, in which case the rooter company may end up with a rooter trapped in your pipe, as happened to my parents. Ultimately they had to get the sewer line excavated and replaced where it met the city sewer, 15 feet down in the middle of the road. Cost like $30k. Maybe ask the rooter company what happens if they end up with equipment trapped jammed down your pipe is all I'm saying.
- FireBeyond 1y agoThat to me seems like something that should be covered by the company's insurance. Any services company that comes out, ens up with breaking their tools because they used inadequate tooling, and causing more damage? I don't know how they managed to foist that on to your parents. The issue wasn't the tree roots, it was the rooter company's poor investigation. Video scoping a sewer line is trivial these days.
- lelandbatey 1y agoOh, they video scoped the sewer, and my parents (father is a lawyer) went after them. Ultimately, the rooter company decided they'd rather go for the full legal battle and my parents decided "eh, we know how awful a legal battle is, we'll back down and not sue."
- pastureofplenty 1y agoOne of the houses across the street from me had its driveway dug up, all the way from the street to inside the garage, for what I first thought was for putting a bathroom or something in the downstairs level. When I walked past the old pipes they took out they were full of roots.
- agnosticmantis 1y agoOr as Anthropic's Safety team would write: "Trees conspire to take down human race by sabotaging the underground water network."
- Lalabadie 1y agoWith a Botany of Desire angle: Trees have led the humans to channel water and irrigate them so they survive even in dry and isolated soil, and provide shade for urban areas in exchange.
- back2dafucha 1y ago[flagged]
- accoil 1y agoCope? Won't they be drinking from leaky pipes regardless of a drought?
- dhosek 1y agoNot really mentioned, but I suspect that at least part of the time, the leaky pipes are caused by the trees. I used to own a house in southern California with a sprinkler system and a couple Chinese elms. Trying to track down why some sprinkler heads weren’t sprinkling, I discovered that the trees had sent roots into some of the (PVC) piping, going as far as six feet of the pipe. I ended up digging up and replacing a lot of piping on that project, although I wouldn’t be surprised if the Chinese elms (which are nasty nasty trees that I will hate until I die) didn’t pull the same stunt on subsequent owners of the house.
- sinoue 1y agoNot just leaky fresh water pipes, but also sewer.
- _ache_ 1y agoLeaky pipe ? It's not a bug, it's a feature!