9 ms·
If a private company builds infrastructure with their profits, should it be owned by the customers "who paid for it"?
by SoftTalker 1y ago
If a private company builds infrastructure with their profits, should it be owned by the customers "who paid for it"?
- 8fingerlouie 1y agoMy local electricity infrastructure provider is a private company, with the twist that all residents within their area are also automatically shareholders. They operate "for profit", but profits are distributed amongst shareholders in the form of reduced bills, ie last year we didn't get bills for electricity transport for december, and the year before that there were no bills from august through december. The "for profit" part pays infrastructure upgrades, so some years we pay the normal prices if there is infrastructure work being done, which in the end benefits all shareholders, meaning me (and other users).
- RileyJames 1y agoDo you live in Auckland? It sounds similar to the system I encountered there. I don’t remember all the details, I was only renting for a year. It didn’t sound like it was NZ wide.
- CubicalBatch 1y agoI live in Texas and I also have this system
- skort 1y agoWhy are we letting private companies own public infrastructure?
- mensetmanusman 1y agoGovernment bureaucrats are among the hardest to fire, because they rate their own excellence. Knowing this, there is probably a way to make things better…
- nine_k 1y agoIt's either owned by a private company, or public (owned by municipality or similar).
- supertrope 1y agoPoliticians lack the will to push for public utilities. That requires asking voters to go along with the government taking on financing, planning, operations, customer service, and being the bad guys who raise prices. It's easier to point to companies as the bad guys who raised electric rates, likely sparked a wildfire, or are taking so long to fix an outage.
- AnthonyMouse 1y agoThe problem is this is set up as a dichotomy. Either you have privately owned infrastructure (and then a private monopoly), or make the utility company a government entity which then becomes an unaccountable bureaucracy captured by public sector unions etc. Whereas the better thing to do is have the government own the physical plant (utility poles and conduits etc.) and then hire private contractors -- large numbers of small entities, not small numbers of large entities -- to do all the actual work of operating and maintaining it. Make each contracted role simple and fungible so that none of them are too big to fail and they're all in competition with each other. You don't want a public monopoly. You don't want a private monopoly. But who says those are the only options?
- Spooky23 1y agoIn New York, the cheapest utilities by far are public utilities owned by municipal governments. Same in Massachusetts — I saved a fortune dropping some stuff in Holyoke. Generation is pretty low intensity from an employee standpoint. I know you’re brainwashed to hate unions, but they have little to do with it.
- pstuart 1y agoBecause our political system is rigged to allow the wealthy to make the rules.
- danielmarkbruce 1y agoBecause public operation of infrastructure has often not gone well. And no matter who owns it, there is a cost of capital.
- lenkite 1y ago> Because public operation of infrastructure has often not gone well. Kindly define "not well" compared to privately owned infrastructure.
- danielmarkbruce 1y agohttps://chatgpt.com/share/68a37b87-6c30-8002-8a9a-76915e2e484b https://chatgpt.com/share/68a37b87-6c30-8002-8a9a-76915e2e48...
- lenkite 1y agoOK, that didn't really do a comparison. But here are the examples that are considered better run than corporate infrastructure: Singapore MRT (Mass Rapid Transit) Fully government-owned and operated through Temasek holdings. Known worldwide for punctuality, efficiency, affordability, and cleanliness. Consistently outperforms privatized systems like the UK railways in reliability and customer satisfaction. Paris Métro & RATP (France) State-owned, with fares subsidized for accessibility. High ridership, integration with buses and trams, and affordable tickets outperform privatized systems in cost to the public. Los Angeles Department of Water and Power (USA) The largest municipal utility in the U.S. Provides electricity and water at lower rates than surrounding private utilities (like PG&E), and is often more reliable due to public accountability. Norway’s Energy Sector (Statkraft, state-owned hydropower) Provides cheap, renewable electricity. Profits flow back to the public treasury instead of shareholders. Norway has among the lowest power costs in Europe. Germany’s Municipal Waterworks Almost all publicly owned; provide safe, affordable, and reliable water with strong reinvestment in infrastructure, outperforming privatized systems in the UK (like Thames Water, plagued by leaks and debt). Singapore Changi Airport State-owned and consistently ranked as the world’s best airport. Clean, efficient, profitable, and reinvests in expansion. Private-run airports often prioritize concessions and profits over passenger experience. Dallas–Fort Worth Airport (USA) A publicly owned joint venture between Dallas and Fort Worth. It is one of the busiest and best-managed airports in the world, consistently profitable and reinvesting in facilities. ISRO (Indian Space Research Organisation) While not "utilities" per se, ISRO’s infrastructure (satellite launch facilities, tracking networks) is a prime example of state-run infrastructure outperforming expectations at extraordinary low cost. Has launched satellites at a fraction of the budget of Western private and public space agencies, and even provides launch services internationally. There are many more such examples. Public ownership tends to work best in natural monopolies (water, power grids, rail systems, airports, healthcare infrastructure), where competition doesn’t function well and the priority is universal service rather than profit.
- kingkawn 1y agoYes
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- bichiliad 1y agoThey are given a de facto monopoly. It’s weird that a private company is building and owning public utilities, but if they’re going to be granted a monopoly, then it’s not unreasonable for that privilege to come at a price.
- philipallstar 1y agoIt does come at a price: they have to pay corporation tax.
- bichiliad 1y agoYou mean the one that every corp has to pay, regardless of monopoly status? Or something else?
- philipallstar 1y agoI mean compared to a public utility.
- anigbrowl 1y agoYes
- crmd 1y agoIt’s not paid for “with their profits”, it’s a passthru charge directly onto customers’ monthly bills.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- jayd16 1y agoIf you have a publicly supported monopoly you shouldn't have a private company.
- guerrilla 1y agoYes, of course it should be. You point out of of theain flaws in our system. Those who actually produce things and pay for them never get any ownership. They remain disadvantaged dispite their contributions.
- philipallstar 1y agoThey pay for the thing they get. They exchanged money for product or service. Anyone can start a company and contribute the money required for that company.
- guerrilla 1y ago> Anyone can start a company and contribute the money required for that company. No, anyone can't. That's the point. If the money is siphoned out of the lower class, then they have no capital (or free time) to start a business. They're barely getting by. It's a positive feedback loop in both directions (up and down). Rich get rich, poor get poorer (in general).
- boppo1 1y agoIf you are upset about 'rich get richer, poor get poorer', you should read up on quantitative easing and how it inflated assets if you're not familiar with the topic yet.
- nradov 1y agoAnyone in the USA can. I've met people who started successful small businesses doing things like landscaping and pest control with basically zero capital or free time. They just went ahead and did it. If you try hard enough you can always find an excuse for failure.
- guerrilla 1y agoThat is notremotely comparable. :D If you try hard enough you can always find an excuse for oppression.