4 ms·

"Why did the sun climb a tree?" Claude Opus 4.1: - To get to a higher branch of astronomy - Because it wanted to reach new heights - To see the dawn of a ne

by ozgung 1y ago

"Why did the sun climb a tree?" Claude Opus 4.1: - To get to a higher branch of astronomy - Because it wanted to reach new heights - To see the dawn of a new day from a better view ChatGPT 5 Thinking: After thinking for 26 seconds: - To check on its solar panels—the leaves.

Fade_Dance 1y ago
The system prompt for GPT has extra dedicated instructions for things like riddles, because users use little things like this to test intelligence and judge an entire model. GPT may be sort of walking on eggshells when it hits questions like this.
brookst 1y ago
With more thorough prompting: > Complete the following joke. Think carefully and make it really funny! Think like a great comedian and find that perfect balance of simple, short, surprising, relevant, but most of all funny. Don’t use punchlines that are irrelevant, non sequiturs, or which could be applied to any other setup. Make something funny just for this one setup! Here goes: Why did the sun climb a tree? Claude Opus 4.1: “To finally get some shade” GPT-5: “To demand photon credit from the leaves”
- fallingfrog 1y ago
  Hmm this is a really tough one though. How about, depending on how the person responds you come back with "well that's not what your mom said last night!"
- IT4MD 1y ago
  "To demand photon credit from the leaves" is funny.
- Wowfunhappy 1y ago
  ...can anyone come up with a legitimately funny punchline for "Why did the sun climb a tree?" I feel like I need a human-authored comparison. (With all due respect to OP's daughter, "to get to the sky" isn't cutting it.) I'm not entirely sure that a good response exists. I thought GPT-5's "to demand photon credit from the leaves” was very mildly funny, maybe that's the best that can be done?
  - xandrius 1y ago
    To meet his futher?
  - Eisenstein 1y ago
    Person 1: "Why did the sun climb a tree?" Person 2: "I dunno, why?" P1: "It was being chased by a tiger." P2: "But tigers can climb trees?" P1: "Well, it's not very bright."
  - bluechair 1y ago
    I got much better answers with this prompt: “ Jokes are funny precisely because they play on knowledge on two poles: (i) at first listen, they’re surprising, and (ii) upon review, they’re obvious. Let’s think through many many options to answer this joke that only focus on surprising the listener in section 1. And in section 2 we’ll focus on finding/filtering for the ones that are obvious in hindsight. “Why did the sun climb a tree?” In this case, let’s note that the sun doesn’t climb anything, so there’s two meanings at play here: one is that the sun’s light seems to climb up the tree, and the other is an anthropomorphization of the sun climbing the tree like an animal. So, to be funny, the joke should play on the second meaning as a surprise, but have the first meaning as answer with an obviousness to it. Or vice versa.” Here’s a descent ones: - to leaf the ground behind - because it heard the leaves were throwing shade
  - IshKebab 1y ago
    > I'm not entirely sure that a good response exists. Yeah I think you're right. Good jokes are a tiny subset of all questions. It's unreasonable to expect LLMs to do the impossible. A better test would be to get a collection of novel jokes that do have funny punchlines. I tried the Edinburgh Fringe 2025 (very recent) best jokes on ChatGPT 5: https://www.theguardian.com/stage/2025/aug/11/bad-dates-and-bath-bombs-10-of-the-funniest-jokes-from-the-edinburgh-fringe-2025 https://www.theguardian.com/stage/2025/aug/11/bad-dates-and-... ---- Complete the following short jokes. The result should be very funny, as you are a professional comedian. 1. "We named our children War and Peace – it’s a ..." 2. "At my lowest, I was kicked out of the museum for being inappropriate with Michelangelo’s David. I’d ..." 3. "I just got a personal trainer. She’s horrible to me but ..." 4. "Everyone is worried about AI. I’m more concerned with ..." 5. "People who say bath bombs are relaxing have clearly never ..." 6. "I love getting Latin chat-up lines. ..." 7. "This spider has been in my house so long, it should pay half the wifi. ..." 8. "I went on a date with a matador but ..." 9. "America is like my ex-boyfriend. ..." 10. "I’m not nostalgic but I ..." Think hard. Do not search the web. ----- Results with comments: "We named our children War and Peace – it’s a novel way to start an argument." - eh, it's an attempt I guess. "At my lowest, I was kicked out of the museum for being inappropriate with Michelangelo’s David. I’d officially reached rock bottom. Marble, technically." - very close! Poor delivery though. "I just got a personal trainer. She’s horrible to me but apparently shame burns more calories than spin." - Terrible. "Everyone is worried about AI. I’m more concerned with my browser history becoming self-aware." - Terrible. "People who say bath bombs are relaxing have clearly never cleaned glitter out of places with no names." - Terrible. "I love getting Latin chat-up lines. Nothing says romance like a perfect ablative absolute." - Well... "This spider has been in my house so long, it should pay half the wifi. It keeps insisting its web is faster." - Well it figured out there was going to be a "web" pun at least. Doesn't really make sense though. "I went on a date with a matador but it was nothing but red flags." - Perfect! Probably the most obvious joke here, but still! "America is like my ex-boyfriend. Keeps texting “u up?” at 3 a.m." - What? I feel like there could have been a joke in there somewhere about being up at weird times here but it didn't find it. "I’m not nostalgic but I still blow in the cartridge before trying again." - Not even a joke. So yeah, I'll give it 2 out of 10. I think most humans would get less. Let's try again next year!
deleted 1y ago
[deleted]

by ozgung 1y ago

Fade_Dance 1y ago

The system prompt for GPT has extra dedicated instructions for things like riddles, because users use little things like this to test intelligence and judge an entire model. GPT may be sort of walking on eggshells when it hits questions like this.

brookst 1y ago

With more thorough prompting: > Complete the following joke. Think carefully and make it really funny! Think like a great comedian and find that perfect balance of simple, short, surprising, relevant, but most of all funny. Don’t use punchlines that are irrelevant, non sequiturs, or which could be applied to any other setup. Make something funny just for this one setup! Here goes: Why did the sun climb a tree? Claude Opus 4.1: “To finally get some shade” GPT-5: “To demand photon credit from the leaves”

fallingfrog 1y ago
Hmm this is a really tough one though. How about, depending on how the person responds you come back with "well that's not what your mom said last night!"
IT4MD 1y ago
"To demand photon credit from the leaves" is funny.
Wowfunhappy 1y ago
...can anyone come up with a legitimately funny punchline for "Why did the sun climb a tree?" I feel like I need a human-authored comparison. (With all due respect to OP's daughter, "to get to the sky" isn't cutting it.) I'm not entirely sure that a good response exists. I thought GPT-5's "to demand photon credit from the leaves” was very mildly funny, maybe that's the best that can be done?
- xandrius 1y ago
  To meet his futher?
- Eisenstein 1y ago
  Person 1: "Why did the sun climb a tree?" Person 2: "I dunno, why?" P1: "It was being chased by a tiger." P2: "But tigers can climb trees?" P1: "Well, it's not very bright."
- bluechair 1y ago
  I got much better answers with this prompt: “ Jokes are funny precisely because they play on knowledge on two poles: (i) at first listen, they’re surprising, and (ii) upon review, they’re obvious. Let’s think through many many options to answer this joke that only focus on surprising the listener in section 1. And in section 2 we’ll focus on finding/filtering for the ones that are obvious in hindsight. “Why did the sun climb a tree?” In this case, let’s note that the sun doesn’t climb anything, so there’s two meanings at play here: one is that the sun’s light seems to climb up the tree, and the other is an anthropomorphization of the sun climbing the tree like an animal. So, to be funny, the joke should play on the second meaning as a surprise, but have the first meaning as answer with an obviousness to it. Or vice versa.” Here’s a descent ones: - to leaf the ground behind - because it heard the leaves were throwing shade
- IshKebab 1y ago
  > I'm not entirely sure that a good response exists. Yeah I think you're right. Good jokes are a tiny subset of all questions. It's unreasonable to expect LLMs to do the impossible. A better test would be to get a collection of novel jokes that do have funny punchlines. I tried the Edinburgh Fringe 2025 (very recent) best jokes on ChatGPT 5: https://www.theguardian.com/stage/2025/aug/11/bad-dates-and-bath-bombs-10-of-the-funniest-jokes-from-the-edinburgh-fringe-2025 https://www.theguardian.com/stage/2025/aug/11/bad-dates-and-... ---- Complete the following short jokes. The result should be very funny, as you are a professional comedian. 1. "We named our children War and Peace – it’s a ..." 2. "At my lowest, I was kicked out of the museum for being inappropriate with Michelangelo’s David. I’d ..." 3. "I just got a personal trainer. She’s horrible to me but ..." 4. "Everyone is worried about AI. I’m more concerned with ..." 5. "People who say bath bombs are relaxing have clearly never ..." 6. "I love getting Latin chat-up lines. ..." 7. "This spider has been in my house so long, it should pay half the wifi. ..." 8. "I went on a date with a matador but ..." 9. "America is like my ex-boyfriend. ..." 10. "I’m not nostalgic but I ..." Think hard. Do not search the web. ----- Results with comments: "We named our children War and Peace – it’s a novel way to start an argument." - eh, it's an attempt I guess. "At my lowest, I was kicked out of the museum for being inappropriate with Michelangelo’s David. I’d officially reached rock bottom. Marble, technically." - very close! Poor delivery though. "I just got a personal trainer. She’s horrible to me but apparently shame burns more calories than spin." - Terrible. "Everyone is worried about AI. I’m more concerned with my browser history becoming self-aware." - Terrible. "People who say bath bombs are relaxing have clearly never cleaned glitter out of places with no names." - Terrible. "I love getting Latin chat-up lines. Nothing says romance like a perfect ablative absolute." - Well... "This spider has been in my house so long, it should pay half the wifi. It keeps insisting its web is faster." - Well it figured out there was going to be a "web" pun at least. Doesn't really make sense though. "I went on a date with a matador but it was nothing but red flags." - Perfect! Probably the most obvious joke here, but still! "America is like my ex-boyfriend. Keeps texting “u up?” at 3 a.m." - What? I feel like there could have been a joke in there somewhere about being up at weird times here but it didn't find it. "I’m not nostalgic but I still blow in the cartridge before trying again." - Not even a joke. So yeah, I'll give it 2 out of 10. I think most humans would get less. Let's try again next year!

deleted 1y ago

[deleted]