5 ms·
Pirate library operator arrested, study canceled for 330k members
- ronsor 1y ago> Copyright Crime Special Unit It's amazing that people have somehow been convinced that it's sane not only to throw others in prison for copying files but also to have special police for it.
- amarcheschi 1y agoUnless big tech does it I guess
- gosub100 1y ago"It's not copyright infringement! I'm just using it to train my neural networks with the information!"
- slg 1y agoThis quote is perfectly constructed to underline the hypocrisy considering this case is about pirating educational material. If pirating information is allowed when that neural network you are training is some LLM, why shouldn't it be allowed when that neural network is a human brain?
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- BriggyDwiggs42 1y agoHuman brains are not created and owned solely by companies
- timeon 1y ago"fair use" for corporations.
- komali2 1y agoThat's easy: government should serve the needs of people, not companies. It's not hypocritical to want a different set of rules for companies.
- whoopdedo 1y ago> a different set of rules for companies That is sort of the problem we find ourselves in.
- kelnos 1y agoI had the same thought. Those people could be put to so much better use, solving real problems that everyday people have.
- lostlogin 1y ago> Those people could be put to so much better use, solving real problems that everyday people have. You can apply that logic to large swathe of well paid jobs.
- h2zizzle 1y agoThis is why an economic crash is not necessarily a bad thing in the long run. It shatters calcified assumptions about what labor is valuable and presents an opportunity to redefine them. We keep putting the next one off, and the people working jobs that "should" have gone away keep moving forward in their careers, gaining seniority and higher salaries doing varyingly terrible and unnecessary work.
- charlieyu1 1y agoYou would think we as a society should crack down harder on theft and robbery but here we are subsiding the rich on copyright laws
- whycome 1y agoDrug and Copyright Enforcement Agency? I always thought that one reason to go after marijuana was that it was something that one could easily "grow at home" -- eg, make a copy. Alcohol and hard drugs typically required a lot of equipment or expertise. ..and in a dystopian future there will be an agency to remove any unauthorized knowledge (gained from pirated sources) from ones' brain.
- trhway 1y ago>..and in a dystopian future there will be an agency to remove any unauthorized knowledge (gained from pirated sources) from ones' brain. as a preview - the similar is going to happen to the LLMs soon. Actually with growth of LLMs it may become unimportant what is in the actual biological brain of its user.
- lisbbb 1y agoThe cyberpunk dystopia that 80s fiction authors prepared [some of] us for.
- autoexec 1y agoThey've been getting away with it for ages. The RIAA even hired a bunch of ex-cops to act as goons, impersonate the FBI, and go on raids https://web.archive.org/web/20040209170528/http://www.laweekly.com/ink/04/07/news-sullivan.php https://web.archive.org/web/20040209170528/http://www.laweek... I swear I've seen photos of them in their RIAA jackets too, but I can't seem to find any at the moment
- wrp 1y agoIn South Korea, educational inequality due to inability to afford educational materials has been an issue for many years. The argument against piracy is that people have the right to be compensated for their work. Consider this argument in the context of medical services. The extreme pirate position is equivalent to expecting doctors to provide cosmetic surgery for free. The extreme industry position is equivalent to saying doctors should let patients die on the sidewalk if they can't pay. I'm torn on the issue of sharing files, because I've watched its rise over the past 25 years and seen how tremendously it has improved educational opportunities for poorer peoples.
- atom_arranger 1y agoThe anti piracy stance would be making it illegal for a surgeon/person to copy the procedure another surgeon invented without payment. Copying does not require additional labor from the inventor. Obviously we would like the inventor of the procedure to be compensated, but is it worth depriving other people, or potentially them dying, to protect "intellectual property"?
- tux3 1y agoIt is important to note that authors are not compensated when you buy access to an academic article in a journal. In fact, since the authors both do the work of creating the content and peer-reviewing submissions, they must also pay the journal in exchange for doing this work. Think of it like the patient paying the hospital, the doctor paying the hospital, and in exchange the doctor can do their work at a prestigious hospital, which is all very lucrative (for the hospital)
- wrp 1y agoJournal articles represent an extreme where sharing is most ethical. An opposite extreme would be something like AAA games. In the range between are things like monographs, textbooks, literature, etc.
- xnyan 1y ago> textbooks Textbooks are not that distant from academic publishing in terms of the rent seeking that goes on. Textbook publishers essentially bribe academia for the right to rip off their students by providing courses with testing and academic services that are tied to a license in a new textbook that the student is required to buy.
- cmsefton 1y agoAnd next week, "Meta argues new Law AI tool trained on books from Pirate Library is fair use."
- squigz 1y agoAccess to education and information should be free - or at the very least a lot less broken than it is today. https://annas-archive.org/torrents https://annas-archive.org/torrents
- cyberpunk 1y agoI really would love to help out, but I don't have 650TB of storage laying around :( The logistics of this archive are quite crazy; most 2-4U JBODs I worked with hold like 24 or 45 SFF SAS disks. Standard size (unless things have changed) for 10k sff sas disks seems to be about 1.2TB, so you'd need 544 of these to build a raidz big enough. So we're talking 12 4U jbods, well over a full rack. I guess I can just hope some rich techie with a volcano lair / private datacenter somewhere is keeping a copy..
- squigz 1y agoWell I don't think you have to dedicate 650TB or nothing :P A full rack or more sounds like a lot, but I don't know much about hardware, so I'll take your word for it.
- Symbiote 1y agoAt work I have about 1PB per full rack, and that's with plain HP/Dell servers with 12 3.5" hard disks in each. Maximising storage isn't the purpose of this setup, much denser configurations are possible as others have commented.
- 0cf8612b2e1e 1y agoWhy limit yourself to the SFF? 45 Drives is the company that builds the hard drive pods used by Backblaze and they offer a 4U, 60x3.5 inch drive array. Has an advertised capacity of 1.44 PB, which would be 24TB drives configured without redundancy. https://www.45drives.com/products/storage-server-storinator-xl60/ https://www.45drives.com/products/storage-server-storinator-...
- Xymist 1y agoSeagate have an Exos M in 36TB for about £450, so 24 of those could do it. Three vdevs with one parity drive each? Call the project £13k? Not exactly a production grade setup, but it'd do the job and you'll see fewer failures each year than in 544 10k SAS drives.
- perelin 1y agobut how was he found out? did telegram cooperate with korean law enforcement?
- bestouff 1y agoTelegram forcefully "cooperated" with French law enforcement. Maybe the French police shared intel with Korean
- charcircuit 1y ago>The Ministry of Culture and Sport says others involved will be tracked down and given lessons in copyright law. This is way too soft of a punishment. If people can get away with attending a lesson there will not be enough risk in the risk reward analysis people do before violating people's copyrights.
- kps 1y agoWait until you see the price of the textbook.
- BriggyDwiggs42 1y agoWon’t someone think of the textbook publishers. They are but paupers.
- JoeDohn 1y agoSo 'pirating' stuff for personal use is bad, but if it's for corp use and benefits than it's good.
- edoceo 1y agoIn USA? Correct (unfortunately)
- JoeDohn 1y agoI guess US, but not only. I am eluding to the whole AI thing, instead of using it as a platform to improve human condition and not only profit financially, we do have 'Step mom' and 'Russian girl' bots built on top of 'pirated' content. We are fucked.
- WhyOhWhyQ 1y agoIn America, I see the main argument in support of the destruction of norms for AI corporations and copyright theft is as follows. "If we adhere to standard views of copyright, then we will be disadvantaged in the race to super-intelligence against China." I really think this argument is baseless, however, because there's absolutely no reason to think if Chinese corporations make some paradigm shifting advancement in AI then American corporations won't quickly copy it, just as Chinese corporations VERY quickly caught up to GPT 3. Is less than 1 year of economic advantage really worth the permanent erasure of norms like copyright and privacy?
- aussieguy1234 1y agoObviously book authors need to be paid, but those at the bottom of the ladder seeking to climb it through education can't afford the books. Perhaps some kind of program run by the publishers could give free books to these people, to reduce the motivation for piracy of the books? Those that can afford it would still pay, of course. That said, the current system is broken, so while this particular site is gone, z-library and anna's archive live on and won't be getting taken down any time zoon.
- lostlogin 1y ago> Obviously book authors need to be paid Do they? When the required reading is this years's version of the course professor's book, you are drowning in the BS.
- neya 1y agoThe real issue is modern day purchasing is not ownership. It's not even leasing. It's you pay the full list price for a PDF or music file that can disappear anytime from your library if the corpo-rats decide it shouldn't be available to you anymore. If purchasing isn't ownership, then piracy shouldn't be theft.
- pbronez 1y agoI would like to have a trustworthy, privacy-respecting digital asset licensing service. Ideally free from profit motives, maybe run my a government, maybe a non profit. Regardless, i want my right to engage with a work separated from the manifestation of that work. Movies Anywhere kinda does this, but I want it to go way, way further. Buy a book? You now own a the right to read that book from whatever file. Subscribe to Disney+? You have the right to watch all the marvel movies. Even when those movies are chopped and re-edited into a massive full chronology. If a digital store ceases operations, you retain the rights to the bits. Maybe you have to do some work to get access to them, but you’re perfectly within your rights to torrent those bits. Heck, maybe you could like the rights management to distribution. Have a right to the bits? Please seed.
- K0balt 1y agoI think that especially for educational, engineering, and scientific research, these kinds of “libraries” cross over firmly into the public good. Making money on textbooks by selling them to students at premium prices is despicable and is a poverty of mind for the future. Course tuition should include necessary book access. We gain so much more as a civilisation by sharing within academia that there needs to be a change in the way that the publishing industry treats these kinds of “violations “.
- zugi 1y agoI recall attending a talk by Richard Stallman where he critiqued the use of the word "piracy" for file sharing. "Pirates" attack and destroy ships, kill innocents, and generally rape and plunder. How does that word fit what's basically sharing and trying to help your neighbor?
- TylerE 1y agoUtterly losing the plot while playing dumb word games is so typical Stallman.
- squigz 1y agoThe words we use to describe and talk about things and people is actually very important and very much helps shape our impressions, so I can't really see how he's lost the plot.
- asacrowflies 1y agoSeems dead on in this case.
- tpoacher 1y agoAlso generally typical of Stallman
- tiahura 1y agoIt seems like the passing of linger should get more notice.
- move-on-by 1y agoNo doubt many LLMs have trained on the same content, with no complaints.