4 ms·
One person was able to claim 20M IPs
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- g-mork 1y agoOne person was able to claim 9% of all HN clickthroughs
- thrance 1y agoSo, everyone just ignored that one guy that suggested simply... asking them by email?
- nilsherzig 1y agoSeeing everyone trying to come up with an idea and participating is way more fun
- Aurornis 1y agoThey could also just log some of the HTTP headers and check directly. They’re avoiding the easy answers because they want people talking about it and I think they’re afraid of the real answer. Contests like this attract a lot of bad behavior.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- ludwik 1y agoTurns out what constitutes "claiming" an IP on the site is nothing like you’d expect. You don’t need to prove you control the IP. All it takes is embedding a transparent 1x1 tracking pixel on a website, and every IP that loads the page gets counted as “claimed” by you. In other words, it’s just a tally of visitors (or even ad impressions), not actual control of the IPs. So there’s really nothing meaningful here.
- motbus3 1y agoIt could be just reverse engineer how it works for one or few IPs and send all requests in the correct order mimicking what the server expects to see from a real claim. For this test to be valid it would need to do much more than just that I think
- treve 1y agoIt's still an interesting post, because if true I'd still be curious how you'd get 20 million people to load anything. But the title here is totally misleading because it sure sounds like someone took control of 9% of the ipv4 address space but the actual post starts with context.
- chmod775 1y agoIf you run some random mid-sized web page with ~2 million monthly "unique" (by IP) visitors you'll get there very quickly.
- karel-3d 1y agoI would guess a WordPress plugin or something. 20 million is a lot, but if you look at geoip, they are around the whole world; I took 3 random latest IPs and I saw Vietnam, Brazil and Angola. So it's not that much when it's worldwide. But it suggests it's not a geographically limited website. If it's through a website. It's probably not a ad buy. (Who would burn money on that...) However the requests are literally every second. So it's something very popular. (Or a bot and they are somehow faking the source address...)
- bakugo 1y ago> Vietnam, Brazil and Angola Curiously, these are some of the top countries I see when analyzing traffic from malicious scraping bots that disguise themselves as old Chrome versions on my websites. So it's possible that one of those botnet-ish residential proxy services is being used here. The ones that use things like compromised browser extensions to turn unknowing users into exit nodes. Edit: Yep, it's residential proxies, someone on the linked page mentioned a website where you can look up the IPs and all of them come up as proxies.
- progbits 1y agoBuying ads or embedding on some popular sites seems like best theory. @jart: You could log referer header maybe, or user agent?
- jart 1y agoIt's Go-http-client/1.1 https://x.com/JustineTunney/status/1957130925013442876 https://x.com/JustineTunney/status/1957130925013442876 https://seclists.org/nanog/2025/Aug/260 https://seclists.org/nanog/2025/Aug/260
- progbits 1y agoWait how would they observe this? If not owner of the domain, and likely not owner of the client (random residential proxy)? Unless this is HTTP+MITM.
- jart 1y agoNANOG is the North American Network Operators Group. femboy.cat is sending HTTP requests from nearly every corner of the Earth.
- autoexec 1y agoMan, I really hate NANOG's new site. I've been using https://seclists.org/nanog/ https://seclists.org/nanog/ since the switch and it's so much better. On the new site I see that the post has a link at the bottom which claims to take you to non-JS version of the site and that gave me hope, but following it and clicking on the "list overview" button takes you to a page that doesn't work without JS, and clicking on the "all threads" page just gives you links to posts that also need JS.
- flerchin 1y agoHow is 20M IPs 9% of all IPv4 hosts? That works out to something like 220M IPv4 hosts, when I'd naively think there should be more like 4B or so.
- Hikikomori 1y agoMany are reserved, not in use or even advertised.
- wutwutwat 1y agoYet they are still part of the “all ipv4” address space, so either the percentage is wrong or the use of “all” is a lie here.
- Hikikomori 1y agoNo, it's hosts, something different from just all IPv4.
- flerchin 1y agoYou're really confident about this, but I just can't find where hosts is different than addresses when we're talking about IPv4.
- Hikikomori 1y agoYou see how you can have an IP address that is not assigned or used on something? So amount of IPv4 addresses > IPv4 hosts.
- jart 1y agoSee https://search.censys.io/ https://search.censys.io/
- mzajc 1y ago> There are currently 13'797 Tor exit nodes <https://www.dan.me.uk/tornodes https://www.dan.me.uk/tornodes> As far as I'm aware, this is off by a magnitude, and I'm not sure where the number comes from because the linked website lists much fewer (but ratelimits to 1/30m for some reason?). The official list at https://check.torproject.org/torbulkexitlist https://check.torproject.org/torbulkexitlist lists just over 1k exits, so I really doubt these made much of a difference.
- miyuru 1y agoCurrently top player no 2 "jackson" uses JS to send a request from his websites and anyone who clones his code. https://github.com/search?q=https%3A%2F%2Fipv4.games%2Fclaim%3Fname%3Djackson&type=code https://github.com/search?q=https%3A%2F%2Fipv4.games%2Fclaim... NO 1 must be doing a similar thing. Other attempts: https://github.com/search?q=ipv4.games%2Fclaim&type=code https://github.com/search?q=ipv4.games%2Fclaim&type=code
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- mijoharas 1y agoI'm trying to understand. If 9% is 20 million then the total is ~220 million. That doesn't seem right to me. So this isn't talking about the ipv4 address space is it? (Ignoring reserved blocks that's 4 billion). What exactly is it talking about?
- jart 1y agoSee https://search.censys.io/ https://search.censys.io/
- nilsherzig 1y agoCouple ideas (can’t test them now): They list guns.lol as one of their projects. Looks like a linktree type of personal website hosting service. Some traffic might come from that network of pages, but if that would be the case I would expect google to have indexed their claim links by now. Same thing goes for the captcha service they are running. They also have a cracked version of a Minecraft cheat client on GitHub. It’s very common to use residential proxies while cheating (or cracking Minecraft accounts), so that might be another option (obviously not for all of the IPs). Someone should scan the IPs claimed by them for common proxy ports. Might be a good idea to run their claims through a geoip db, even tho they are pretty spread out over different subnets, there still might be a correlation there (like mostly Spanish speaking countries or something like that). Looks like the gameserver provides some more insights at /statusz, notably there a basically no „image claims“. So it would have to be iframes or script src requests (?). Might also be fun to monitor your local network for requests to ipv4.games, I will set a notification with my firewall and report back :).
- Aurornis 1y agoSo to “claim” an IP address you only need to send a GET request to the server with your tag as a param? What am I missing? It seems like sampling the headers for the incoming requests would reveal the answer quickly if it’s a 1x1 tracking pixel. There’s a good chance that they wouldn’t really like the answer: It could have been slipped into a WordPress plugin or added as a call from an npm package, generating millions of unintended requests from other people’s computers to win an internet game.
- globular-toast 1y agoI think that might be the point. If you can get someone to load a 1x1 pixel image for you then you in some small way "own" their computer.
- throwmeaway222 1y agoYeah that's what I suspect as well - any website where you can put HTML on the domain in some way - there have to be many software packages out there that have this problem. It could also be as simple as an ad network femboy works at.
- Thaxll 1y agoWould be interesting to log the referer.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- jsnell 1y agoThe 9% number comes from dividing by the number of IPv4 hosts reported by Censys, who do a portscan of the entire IPv4 space. But obviously most clients will not have any ports open, and wouldn't be visible to the scan. It's not at all correct to treat that as the number of actively used IPv4 addresses.
- dilyevsky 1y agohttps://ipv4.games/user.html?name=femboy.cat https://ipv4.games/user.html?name=femboy.cat - looking at claimed networks they go in order. Some kind of spoofing attack either on TCP layer (less likely) or maybe server is consuming X-Real-IP or X-Forwarded-For without verification
- charcircuit 1y agoThe website sorts them.
- dilyevsky 1y agooh yeah i didn't pay attention it's only small number of IPs and basically covers entire space because it's not grouped by actual BGP routes. Must be public proxies then
- TZubiri 1y agoIf the shared proxy addresses hypothesis is correct, this would single handedly make for a great ip blacklist
- jpdye 1y agoNot much value here to be honest... these lists already exist and for a couple quid you can get enough data on a residential proxy provider to scan their entire list of available IPs yourself.
- TZubiri 1y agothat'd be the ips of 1 provider... For 20M IPs we are talking about most providers (including non residential)
- luckystarr 1y agoMy hunch: it's not a real captcha on their page femboy.cat, but actually a script which "claims" the address in the ipv4.games game. Nothing to see here, move along.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- sltkr 1y agoNothing so complicated. The HTML source of femboy.ca/ literally contains: <img src="https:////ipv4.games/claim?name=femboy.cat" hidden> However, the question is why would this domain get 20 million distinct visitors (before being posted on Hacker News)?
- netrap 1y agoInteresting. I looked up top 10 domains. I wonder if you could have it occur on wikipedia.org? Other random thoughts after looking at https://radar.cloudflare.com/domains https://radar.cloudflare.com/domains... Maybe tiktok somehow? Or a bug in NTP? :D
- zocco 1y agoAn analysis of the source IP address networks might reveal more about the technique he's using. For example if they are all from one cloud provider, he could be rapidly allocating and deallocating IPv4 addresses from their pool, to attach to a VM to make the requests. That said, probably it's multiple different techniques being used to make these requests, considering they are from such a huge number of different IP addresses. There's probably not one simple answer to this puzzle.
- cedws 1y agoI doubt a cloud provider would allow that, at some point you’d surely hit a rate limit or quota.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- JdeBP 1y agoThe idea that this is just exploitation of open proxy HTTP servers has been doing the rounds for a year, now. * https://isc.sans.edu/diary/31136 https://isc.sans.edu/diary/31136 However, at least one person thinks that it is a bug in the X-Forwarded-For handling code, * https://biggo.com/news/202508070812_IPv4_Games_Header_Exploitation https://biggo.com/news/202508070812_IPv4_Games_Header_Exploi... which, contrary to the headlined NANOG mailing list thread, is being parsed, as we can see: * https://github.com/jart/cosmopolitan/blob/master/net/turfwar/turfwar.c#L994 https://github.com/jart/cosmopolitan/blob/master/net/turfwar... * https://justine.lol/threads/ https://justine.lol/threads/ I think that the person who thinks that X-Forwarded-For: cannot be manipulated here needs to be put in the same room with the person who thinks that there's an endless variety of ways in which "desync" attacks can forge such headers when one uses HTTP/1.1. * https://portswigger.net/research/http1-must-die https://portswigger.net/research/http1-must-die * https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44915090 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44915090
- VoidWhisperer 1y agoCan someone help me understand why that 'turfwar game' is in what otherwise seems to be what is meant to be a C library that people include in their projects? It doesnt seem to be automatically built as part of the project, but it still seems very odd to place it in a repo of a library that you want other people using instead of splitting it out to its own repo
- mzajc 1y agoConsidering femboy.cat is still making thousands of claims per minute, shouldn't the header spoofing theory be easy to check? Just run tcpdump on the server, get a few claimed IPs, and see if they made any TCP handshakes in the packet dump.
- jart 1y agoIf it's so easy to fool the web server with a header, then why don't you try it. curl -H 'X-Forwarded-For: 6.0.0.1' http://ipv4.games/claim/lool Congratulations! You're the first person to claim the DoD's 6.x.x.x class a subnet.
- mdemare 1y agoI once thought of creating a cryptocoin where 1 initial coin would be handed out to whoever would be the first to claim each ip4 address. I think IP is too easy to spoof for that to work, but I still like the idea.
- topak3000 1y agoSubscribed to several residential proxies and claimed all IPs.
- sim7c00 1y agothere are many ways to pretend to be an IP. that being said, things like 911S5 can show people can actually control that many machines, even though i suspect others comments about tracking pixels and such methods are likely more plausible. you could also do like a resources lookup maybe in some games if you host the server (resources then being looked up on the client). games are full of weird design choices for performance, some can be abused. .another avenue is ads linking to different resources via scripts, maybe some smaller players still allows it. also there are (gray are) businesses who offer residential proxies for things like scraping (sales lead generation companies oftenuse such services for example). so you could likely pay your way to millions of ips, relatively cheap if ud do only 1 request over each