4 ms·
Fairness is what the powerful 'can get away with' study shows
- tyleo 1y agoI feel like fairness is what anyone can get away with and powerful people just tend to get away with more. Even the article seems to land on this conclusion.
- potato3732842 1y ago>Even the article seems to land on this conclusion. But the title landed in the next county because that's what the editor's job is in the modern era of clicks and eyeballs.
- tyleo 1y agoYeah, that’s what I was alluding to. There had to be a slight, “you’re getting screwed,” angle to it.
- FrustratedMonky 1y agoI'd like to see add on study on 'Banality of Evil'. Here "The willingness of those in power to act fairly depends on how easily others can collectively push back against unfair treatment, psychologists have found." What about all the the middle managers that enable the powerful. The more the middle layer of population supports the powerful, the less the 'masses' can revolt to enforce fairness. All revolutions are actually started by the middle class which gets upset. The true lower class masses never have the resources to get off the ground.
- pessimizer 1y agoA buffer class of courtiers. If you got rid of every powerful dictatorial elite with one magical bolt of lightning, the upper-middle class would have new ones chosen by the end of the day.
- kelseyfrog 1y agoYes, this is a trivial consequence of social reproduction theory. It's one of the reasons why change is so difficult. Changing one portion of society creates an impedance mismatch between it and the rest. The changed part eventually gets realigned to the whole once again.
- getnormality 1y agoI almost ignored this due to the sloganized, hard-to-understand title and the unreliability of the site. But the study actually seems pretty good, and the paper is well-written and open-access [1]. [1] https://spb.psychopen.eu/index.php/spb/article/view/11607 https://spb.psychopen.eu/index.php/spb/article/view/11607
- PaulHoule 1y agoWhenever my RSS reader shows me an article from phys.org and the article is open access I decide if I want to post the phys.org article or the paper, this was a toughie. A common situation is that the phys.org headline is "Scientists come to some conclusion" and the title of the paper was "We measured something"; this one was a tough call, I bet it would have gotten <5 upvotes had I posted a link right to the paper. Sometimes phys.org articles are absolutely great, sometimes they suck, sometimes they run articles off the AP wire or from a university press release. Their advertising is reprehensible, but I've looked at the alternatives and most of them are much worse, it's one reason why phys.org and related sites are on the list of top sites submitted to HN by people other than myself, not just the list of top sites I submit to HN. (I post enough that I really have to take stats ex-myself because for some sites, like coindesk, I post most of them)
- getnormality 1y agoI ended up clicking through because I saw your name!
- TacticalCoder 1y ago[dead]
- FergusArgyll 1y agoSurely this will replicate...
- mrala 1y ago> He added, however, that it is important to remember the limitations of such studies: "We used point/money to represent the real-life costs associated with actions like campaigning or going on a protest march. Experiments like these are only meant to simulate aspects of the real world, not perfectly represent its complexity." > Behavior may be different if participants had earned their points rather than simply received them, or both Proposers and Responder shared a common identity or wider goal. > "Still," Dr. Gordon continues, "it is a reminder that we should be mindful of attempts to limit the ability to hold power to account. For example, through anti-protest, anti-strike, and voter suppression laws. In an era marked by growing global inequality, this study offers critical insights into the psychology of power, and the mechanisms that can promote more equitable societies."
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- jvanderbot 1y agoIsn't the flip-side of this "The powerful do not do what they will be held accountable for"? Yes, everyone does what they can get away with in a mixed-incentive game.
- thucydides 1y agon=256 undergraduates playing “The Ultimatum Game.” The headline (“fairness is what the powerful can get away with”) is a tad lofty given the methodology of the study.
- FollowingTheDao 1y ago"Results suggest that the ease of collective action induces more egalitarian behavior by individuals in a position of power and makes those without power less willing to accept unfairness." This is why capitalists dislike unions so much, becasue they know this. Together we are stronger.
- aleph_minus_one 1y ago> This is why capitalists dislike unions so much, beca[us]e they know this. No, the reason why capitalists hate unions so much is that it is another layer of incredibly annoying bureaucrats that you have to get along with. What you describe might rather be the reason why people who have dark triad traits don't like unions; these people often are not "convinced capitalists", but rather people who use capitalism (or whatever the current system is) to their advantage.
- FollowingTheDao 1y ago> No, the reason why capitalists hate unions so much is that it is another layer of incredibly annoying bureaucrats that you have to get along with. I will never understand this perception. You think there is no bureaucracy in businesses? They want to be the sole bureaucrat is all, so getting rid of all other bureaucrats makes them more profit. Bureaucracy is the administrative system governing any large institution, whether publicly owned or privately owned. Capitalism favors dark triad traits. What capitalist doe snot use capitalism for their own advantage? Corporate Psychopathy: The Dark Triad Traits in Business Leaders https://scribe.rip/psychologs-magazine/corporate-psychopathy-the-dark-triad-traits-in-business-leaders-07925ac526d8 https://scribe.rip/psychologs-magazine/corporate-psychopathy...
- hobs 1y agoA distinction without a difference to anyone observing a "convinced capitalist" from the outside.
- PaulHoule 1y agoI'd argue that unions can help an area be more competitive. Any carpenter or handyman could nail together a stage for a movie, but members of the Carpenters Local 213 in LA are experts at efficiently building that kind of temporary structure and they do it efficiently. What would be a difficult HR problem in most places is just "call the union hall" in Hollywood; it has some costs, but it has some benefits.
- eachro 1y agoI'm reminded of the nixon quote: "When the president does it, that means it's not illegal."
- thrance 1y ago[flagged]
- schmidtleonard 1y agoIt was aspirational then, but after 50 years of working to create the Unitary Executive it is now fact.
- more_corn 1y agoOnly if we let it be fact. Surely there’s a line.
- ujkhsjkdhf234 1y agoThere isn't.
- p_j_w 1y agoThat line was crossed when we re-elected Mr. January 6th.
- 542354234235 1y agoWill no one rid me of this meddlesome priest!
- xaoz 1y agoAt least he seemingly pretended afterwards not to have meant to order "go kill him". The knights who murdered the archbishop weren't so lucky... my direct ancestor fled to Ireland afterwards (as family legend has it).
- 1y ago
- yassqn 1y ago[dead]
- PaulHoule 1y agoThinking about it now I'm surprised that Mancur Olsen doesn't get mentioned https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Logic_of_Collective_Action https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Logic_of_Collective_Action as his theory is precisely about how when collective action is difficult people don't do it.
- leobg 1y agoThis is an incredibly sad read.
- PaulHoule 1y agoYeah, one corollary is that membership-oriented groups like Greenpeace, the NRA, PIRG and such are not effective at representing member’s interests because they have no way of communicating displeasure other than leaving whereas the sponsor of something like https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Koch_network https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Koch_network Has a meaningful voice. See another book from about the same time https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Exit,_Voice,_and_Loyalty https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Exit,_Voice,_and_Loyalty
- bsenftner 1y agoIt's almost as if one could point at the failure of progressive liberalism to be due to these placeholder organizations that collect membership, member time, member dues, and then perhaps produce some showy PR, seed the press with some outrage media, and then they go home. They are worse than nothing, because they occupy the place of something better than their "in statement only" existence.
- ccorcos 1y agoVery insightful. 1965 was an interesting time to write this book too with welfare being passed around then.
- w10-1 1y agoRight effect, wrong mechanism. It's not free rider but coordination costs -- the same reason democracies are at a disadvantage relative to authoritarian regimes. Transaction cost ecomomics has been studying this and other transactions features since before 1965. Key to their methodology and success is comparing actual to actual alternatives, instead of actual to imagined.
- thevillagechief 1y agoSo this is just Thrasymachus - "Justice is nothing other than the advantage of the stronger"?
- lordleft 1y agoWe have not evolved far beyond the same problems that bedeviled Socrates and his interlocutors, have we?
- 0xbadcafebee 1y ago> We have not evolved We're still just apes with hats. Very complicated hats, but it's still an ape wearing it. You can teach a few apes a whole lot of tricks, but it takes a lot. Most of the apes won't learn much. The few smart apes will learn tricks and incentives, which when properly applied, allow those few smart apes to control the rest of the apes. That control is called society.
- bsenftner 1y agoUntil we graduate past our innate predator prey dynamic, this unsavory civilization is the best it gets. Consider yourself lucky to be capable of reading this at all.
- AndrewKemendo 1y agoThere’s no graduation, Humans will go extinct The only option is to build something that doesn’t act like this before that happens, but most likely we will just make a less accountable less empathetic version of humanity
- micromacrofoot 1y agoour memory truly only lasts a generation or two
- gryfft 1y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Might_makes_right https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Might_makes_right
- webdoodle 1y agoJust in time for the Epstein Kompromat op to go full Streisand Effect. https://edition.cnn.com/2025/08/12/politics/trump-epstein-relationship-timeline-invs-vis https://edition.cnn.com/2025/08/12/politics/trump-epstein-re...
- ihsw 1y ago[dead]
- thesuperbigfrog 1y ago"All animals are equal, but some animals are more equal than others." -- George Orwell, Animal Farm
- vivzkestrel 1y agoyou are also powerful compared to the homeless guy on the street, does this study also evaluate this?
- kjkjadksj 1y agoThey are also powerful compared to you in other ways. Homeless person can get away with being intoxicated in public for example or various other technical crimes that come hand in hand with sleeping rough.
- smitty1e 1y ago"Fa(ir|re) is what you pay to ride a bus"--LT Nicholson.
- m0llusk 1y agoInteresting crossover in how Jonathan Haidt in his book The Righteous Mind highlighted fairness as being the primary moral axis for conservatives, as opposed to caring and harm reduction for liberals. If that fairness is ultimately defined and measured in terms of raw social power then, well ... hmm.
- charlescearl 1y ago“The ease with which people can challenge authority significantly shapes how those in power behave” known in 19th century as “dictatorship of the proletariat”. The speed at which the so-called “authoritarian regime” ended lockdown the moment significant protests began.
- metalman 1y agofairness does not exist and is impossible to describe or define, and so it needs a decider, every time, and that is just power over others. fairness is the nastyest dirty trick ever invented