5 ms·
I feel like there was a fast slide to content-free echo chamberism a while ago. HN was starting to become painfully predictable if it didn't talk about: - Appl
by bane 14y ago
I feel like there was a fast slide to content-free echo chamberism a while ago. HN was starting to become painfully predictable if it didn't talk about:
- Apple in glowing terms
- a LISP
- how massive overvaluations were not a bad sign
Certain HN rockstars would receive hundreds of upvotes for the most minor of comments and the fanboyism towards a few specific companies, products and people was so thick you could cut it with a knife. Anything that even smelled like dissent was downvoted until you couldn't even see the comment with a flashlight and a 100' rope.
Then a few things happened and it seemed to slowly wind down and I think even reverse. The quality and content of HN seems remarkably improved in the last year:
- Karma became invisible
- Steve Jobs passed away
- Gruber posts started getting flagged
- Android came neck and neck with iOS then surpassed it, then Apple started suing
- a few overhyped, overvalued, overinvested-in companies popped in very public ways
In fact the discussions about the above things have been some of the most spirited, invigorating discussions on HN in a long while. But the other posts and discussions on other topics started getting better as well. Sure the focus of HN has somewhat changed a bit since the old, small community, days. But a few internal and external factors seems to have kept the ship upright.
- tomrod 14y ago> Certain HN rockstars would receive hundreds of upvotes for the most minor of comments Oh! To be one of the principate! What networking that would lead to ;-)
- debacle 14y agoI think Karma being invisible is a huge factor. While I understand the idea behind the decision, I think it prevents the community from really seeing what its broader sentiments are.
- sin7 14y agoMore than that, I don't want to read all the comments. I just want to read the good ones. Without knowing which comments are good, I read the first set and move on to the next story.
- tripzilch 14y agoI agree, I could easier skim through the comments by first reading the higher-voted ones.
- Nick_C 14y agoAgree completely. I skim the threads in each post now, which is a shame because I'm sure I miss some good points. To fix this, I would like to see threads bubble up to the top based on total karma score for the thread. Read the top half-dozen threads and you have a pretty good synopsis of both sides of the topic.
- epo 14y agoSo, you don't seem to like posts about Apple but you do seem to like posts about Android. Isn't this the whole 'problem'? People only object to posts they don't want to see, so to a fandroid any post about Apple proves that HN is full Apple fanboys.
- DanBC 14y agoAn elegant demonstration of the problem.
- jlgreco 14y agoIt seems to me his problem is was not so much with the Apple posts (except Gruber's which he calls out specifically), but rather the quality of the comments in Apple related discussion. (I cannot say that I have noticed an increase in the number of Android posts here, but there does seem to have been a change in the tone of discussion.)
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- bane 14y agoIt's not posts about Apple per se. Apple makes fantastic stuff. It was the out of control community fawning and over reactionary responses to the slightest critical comment that was the problem. A year ago even commenting that anything was wrong with any Apple product was met with derison, scorn and a flock of downvotes. For whatever reason, the tone here has changed tremendously for the better so that this community can actually have serious, educational and productive discussions, and even present respectful competing opinions here. It was frustrating, but frankly it was boring as hell also. I really think the turning point was the moment that pg turned off the points.
- cooldeal 14y agoI find it extremely funny how any small of hint of criticism of Groklaw's 'analysis' or the sacred PJ was met with instant whiting out of the comment, but now that Groklaw took Google's side against Apple, comments, critical of Groklaw comments get a bunch of upvotes or at least are not flagged to death. General rules I have noticed even after points stopped being show are (mostly regardless of the actual facts): Take Apple's side(except if it's against Google) = upvotes Take Google's side(except if it's against Apple) = upvotes Take an anti-MS stance = upvotes Take a non anti-MS stance: downvotes or no upvotes I bet you can literally farm karma by following the above rules, based on seeing some posters' karma.
- larrys 14y ago"HN rockstars would receive hundreds of upvotes for the most minor of comments" It would be interesting to test the same thesis that I have which indicates there is a halo effect on anyone considered a rockstar which allows them to get more upvotes than they would w/o the rockstar status. This is of course the way life operates. The only question is to what extent it happens. People tend to pay more attention to someone who has the trappings of success and/or has had their ticket punched. My guess is that a long thoughtful comment by a new user or non rock star would gain almost the same upvotes as the same long thoughtful comment by a HN rockstar. However a short comment, I'm fairly certain, (and once again this would have to be tested) would generate more upvotes from the rockstar then it would by a new user or non-rockstar. The gap would be much wider.
- neilk 14y agoMaybe there should be an "anonymous week" where usernames are hidden. Just to see if there are any different patterns.
- Karunamon 14y agoThis is one of the few things that 4chan has right - by removing names, you take ego entirely out of the question. Then, to avoid turning into 4chan, you can have posts be anonymous on the front end, but accountable to a user id on the back end only visible to the user themselves and the site staff. It would be an interesting experiment.
- kaybe 14y agoBut then it's nice to know you're at least talking to the same person over several comments. In 4chan you never really know, because anyone can claim to be op or to have written any other comment.
- Karunamon 14y agoPoster ID's. A hash that's created based on your IP address and a seed that changes daily and per thread. It stops people from claiming to be someone they're not, but I see your point about knowing who you're talking to.
- option_greek 14y ago"Certain HN rockstars would receive hundreds of upvotes for the most minor of comments" Except this, I agree with most of your comment. Most of the time I just up vote a good comment with out my eyes sliding to the poster's name (it provides me no meaningful information in most scenarios). Still, the comments I do up vote end being from the rock stars you are referring to. It's possible that they are able to put their thoughts into comments better than others. Since most of the names don't trigger a face to most people I don't see how this could be due to bias.
- bane 14y agoMost of the time I just up vote a good comment with out my eyes sliding to the poster's name (it provides me no meaningful information in most scenarios). I do as well. I rarely pay attention to the handles on the site. There's probably less than a dozen I can remember on sight. The reason I do remember the names I recognize is because they used to consistently and always be at the top of the discussion. Still, the comments I do up vote end being from the rock stars you are referring to. I'm certainly not saying the folks on http://news.ycombinator.com/leaders http://news.ycombinator.com/leaders don't deserve to be there. By and large, I think most of the folks there provide tremendous value to this community (even the ones I vigourously disagree with on a routine basis). But I've also noticed that it seems since pg turned off the points, the names I see at the top of a discussion are more and more ones I don't recognize, and more and more ones that aren't on the leaderboard (and even if the leaderboard members aren't the topmost comment, they usually show up near the top because they provide good comments). I like the new frothiness of HN.
- shinratdr 14y agoSo people talked about Apple positively in the past. Now they don't. That somehow reflects on HN... why?
- zem 14y agoi still feel the hn engine is optimised for expounding rather than discussion. the threading is nice, but in the absence of a reply notification, and with the nesting depth capped, having an actual discussion tends to be difficult.
- tripzilch 14y agoIt's true. There's no use replying to a comment that's a few days old, because I won't expect even the commenter to page that far back on their comments page, so likely nobody will even read it (given that it's far enough down the page).
- tripzilch 14y ago> - Apple in glowing terms Not really. People on both sides are just repeating the same discussion over and over again. Somewhat guilty of that myself, too. (disclaimer: generally not on Apple's side) (also, maybe I'm reading it wrong but is the Steve Jobs remark not a little bit in bad taste? no matter your thoughts of him or Apple... )