6 ms·
Ex-Google Exec Says "The Idea That AI Will Create New Jobs Is 100% Crap"
- jqpabc123 1y ago“The Idea That AI Will Create New Jobs Is 100% Crap” Seems like a current trend. The idea that a massive tax increase (aka "tariffs") will create jobs is also 100% crap.
- taylodl 1y agoThere are two sure-fire ways to peddle bad policy: 1. Say it will protect children 2. Say it will create jobs
- ben_w 1y agoMm, "more safety" and "more wealth" are two of the strongest drivers of human nature. But now I put it like that, it's a little strange I've not heard of any politicians even implying that their policies will get people more sex…
- add-sub-mul-div 1y agohttps://abcnews.go.com/Politics/trump-administration-5000-baby-bonus-incentivize-public-children/story?id=121094707 https://abcnews.go.com/Politics/trump-administration-5000-ba...
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- ben_w 1y agoMm, perhaps. (Especially as I did say "even implying")
- TimedToasts 1y agoThat's covered in "more wealth", fyi.
- fred_is_fred 1y agoDon't forget "building up fear of the unknown or the other" which the linked Youtube video seems to do.
- hooverd 1y agoDoes this Ex Google Exec have an interest in an AI company of his own?
- thatguy0900 1y agoI'm not sure he would say this if he did
- hooverd 1y agohe does, emma dot love, I swear some of this is FOMO marketing. get on the AI train now!!!
- somepleb 1y agoYes, Emma.love, I think I will stick to traditional love potions.
- morkalork 1y agoOh dear that's a sad premise of a website
- janitor77swe 1y agoI don't understand such statement. Automation has already created more job opportunities, why should this be any different? Jobs don't go away, they just transform. And since this AI (whatever that means, nobody really knows) isn't a human-like AGI, it will most certainly not replace humans, but it will automate processes and speed things up. If you're a business that offers 3 services to the public and "AI" could automate one person's salary out of your payroll, why would do that as opposed to keeping your headcount and instead offer 9 services to the public generating more streams of revenue?
- hearsathought 1y agoMuch of what was automated is physical labor which allowed workers to move into "service/intellectual" jobs. When tractors and dump trucks removed the need for masses of people to move dirt, it didn't create more jobs of moving dirt around since those jobs could also be tackled by more tractors and dump trucks. If AI is what all these "AI evangelicals" claim, then most intellectual jobs would be gone. And it won't create more service/intellectual jobs for humans because whatever new jobs are created would be tackled by AI. > If you're a business that offers 3 services to the public and "AI" could automate one person's salary out of your payroll, why would do that as opposed to keeping your headcount and instead offer 9 services to the public generating more streams of revenue? If AI could automate one person's job, why would you keep him? You can offer 9 services with one less person.
- robertlagrant 1y ago> When tractors and dump trucks removed the need for masses of people to move dirt, it didn't create more jobs of moving dirt around since those jobs could also be tackled by more tractors and dump trucks It created dump truck driver / maintenance / engineer / safety / fuel supply / parts factoring / etc jobs. I wouldn't say that's an example of creating zero jobs.
- hearsathought 1y ago> It created dump truck driver / maintenance / engineer / safety / fuel supply / parts factoring / etc jobs. Those are primarily intellectual/service jobs. > I wouldn't say that's an example of creating zero jobs. I never said it didn't create zero jobs. Reread my comment. I said it created more intellectual/service jobs. It's the first line of my comment.
- throwaway29303 1y agoCan someone, more informed than me, about the job landscape, name these jobs people keep claiming AI is creating? Thank you in advance.
- esarbe 1y agoMy guess? Basically even more bullshit jobs in advertising.
- throwawayoldie 1y ago_tumbleweeds roll past_
- gonzo41 1y agoSeriously, carpenters and plumbers and maybe more electricians. All those copy writers, graphic designers and junior coders are going to have to do something else. I'm joking, but not. I think a lot of fat is going to get trimmed of the bone of most industries. That may include myself which is a worry.
- dragontamer 1y agoThat's not job creation. That's job destruction. With this much shoddy code out there, I'm expecting a LOT more testers are going to be needed. This is job creation but not the good kind. Think Tesla Optimus robot grabbing popcorn. Instead of one cashier filling bags of popcorn, you now have a dedicated teleoperator + sweeper to pickup all the popcorn that's spilled. One job turned into two jobs.
- gonzo41 1y agoIn the macro sense, jobs are jobs, we're just going to see labor move to different places. And AI will hit a limit for usefulness. We're still early in this adventure. guard rails are coming, but we're going to see some big crashes yet.
- 5350-uiop-1130 1y agouber eats delivery drivers
- throwawayoldie 1y agoCool. Now do the idea that says AI will somehow fix the climate, while simultaneously doubling or tripling humanity's energy use.
- schnable 1y ago> He used his AI startup, Emma.love, to further drive the point home. He indicated that he was able to build the app with the help of two other software developers, a task that would have otherwise required the manpower of "over 350 developers in the past." Looking at the product, the idea that this would take 350 developers is likely complete nonsense. It also indicates that the recent big tech layoffs and hiring reductions are simply removing bloat, not AI driven.
- andoando 1y agoYeah this app seems like a simple wrapper around an LLM. Seems like something a senior could build a prototype in a week and a product in a month. Perhaps the "AI matchmaking" feature would take a lot of resources not done with AI, but that goes toward the point of AI creating things not possible before, not replacing existing development
- stego-tech 1y agoIt’s what us doomers have been saying all along: Even if we’re wrong and these LLMs can replace all or most professional jobs, it won’t create new jobs to replace the lost ones because the AI can replace most labor. For a global economy built on consumers spending money on goods and services, this is a death spiral where fewer jobs mean fewer consumers, which weakens demand, which lowers revenues (corporate and tax alike), which inflates asset prices (the sole things appreciating in value that can’t be fabricated by AI), which displaces more workers, which further decreases revenues… You get the idea. This is bad, it’s always going to be bad, and the only fix is a fundamental reorientation of global civilization away from “profit at all costs” and towards better metrics that reflect the health and wealth of a populace than GDP. Doing that would require existing power barons cede their control and cooperate on building such a new system, which they emphatically do not want to do. We’re fucked, basically, has been our position all along. Either AI via LLMs is the real deal and the economy collapses because corporate and political leaders are too stupid to understand macroeconomics and labor issues, or AI via LLMs is bullshit and the economy collapses because we let the rich and powerful light money on fire for years in pursuit of a boondoggle. There is no good ending here under current incentives and motives, and not one AI company has actually bothered to challenge or change those so that AI becomes a positive force.
- dev_l1x_be 1y agoLuckily replacement is not happening in real life scenarios. AI makes us faster, sure, replaces us? I don't see that happening any time soon. This is a pipe dream for Silicon Valley.
- stego-tech 1y agoI mean, I agree with you 100%, but we should still consider the consequences if we’re wrong. That’s something I don’t see from most folks (the concept they might be wrong, and what that looks like if they are). That’s what I was mainly getting at: whether we’re right or wrong, the outcome is still bad because the problem lies with the current systems (motivations, incentives, etc) and not technology itself.
- drdec 1y agoThink about what happened when we got advances in agriculture. We have gone from something like 90% of people employed growing food to something in the single digits (I'm too lazy at the moment to get exact figures, but this is close enough for my point). Did all those advances in agriculture create jobs? I would say yes and no. For the specific industry the advances happened in? No, definitely not. There are way fewer jobs in agriculture now. But what did happen is that people were freed up to do different things. Those jobs were indirectly created by the fact that people did not need to spend so much time growing food. That allowed people to do other things to create value and improve our lives. Without those agriculture advances, we wouldn't have AI right now. I suspect AI will be similar. We aren't going to have more jobs in the technology section because of AI. But that guy who hears "Code Monkey" for the first time and marvels that someone wrote a song about his life? He won't be a code monkey anymore he will be doing something else. If he's lucky something more personally fulfilling.
- tcfhgj 1y agowhat is this "something else" in this case?
- morkalork 1y agoI keep thinking of that investment disclaimer whenever people cite the - 100 year old - example of mechanization of agriculture: "Past performance is no guarantee of future results" Anyways, if I put my cynnical hat on after looking at this: https://blog.waldrn.com/p/american-boys-have-become-less-supportive https://blog.waldrn.com/p/american-boys-have-become-less-sup... The next generation of children is already being conditioned for women leaving the workplace and society reverting to a pre-WW2 social structure. That's a solution. Jobs are lost forever, women are out of the workforce and the number of workers is halved. We all live in a trad-conservative paradise.
- BurningFrog 1y agoYou never know beforehand. Before they existed, few would have believed the disappearing jobs would be replaced by web designers, uber drivers, youtubers, drone pilots etc.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- BurningFrog 1y agoAs a Software Engineer, Gawdat has no expertise in job creation. If an Economist said the same, I'd pay more attention. It's very counterintuitive, but for 250 years tech has constantly eliminated jobs, while unemployment rates have stayed the same. People have always predicted this would lead to mass unemployment, they've always been wrong, and yet they've kept predicting it. One way to explain it is that unemployed people are an unused resource, and free market economies are very good at finding uses for those.
- pjmlp 1y agoLike in Detroit, and Germany's Ruhrgebiet? Two examples out of plenty others, where people had to move out as means of survival.
- glimshe 1y agoAre you saying that we can't tell people whose jobs were created by technology (cars destroying the jobs of carriage makers elsewhere) that they jobs were affected by technology?
- pjmlp 1y agoI am saying people often overlook the destiny of those affected by technology changes, in name of capitalism.
- tim333 1y agoDetroit's decline wasn't really caused by tech. More that unions jacked the wages and other costs for car production there so the production moved elsewhere.
- pjmlp 1y agoAh the unions, thankfully a problem that US software engineers do not have to worry about, between offshoring and AI based automations.
- 1y ago
- gkoos 1y agoI see. And when everybody's fired, what will people be doing then?
- tcfhgj 1y agosocial slaves of the rich
- bluefirebrand 1y agoHistory suggests that when this happens, people will be building guillotines That's why I'm thinking about my new SAAS, revolution as a service! (Because this is HN I have to shill a product)
- Havoc 1y agoOf course it’ll create new jobs. Already has - see teams of people doing training runs and a whole bunch of AI SaaS and consulting services etc The risk is more that the quantity is less than what is removed. And that the people losing jobs aren’t suitable to retrain. Retraining say truck drivers as data scientists is an uphill battle. ie substantial risk of specific people getting left behind
- ivape 1y agoSoftware industry needs a healthy shake out anyway. Too many people came in for the money. The current shake out involves either stunting people inside vibe coding such that they are functionally retarded, or straight up leave them long-term unemployed. Honestly, the only reason anyone would stick around is because this is all they know or like. I would not fuck around with this career if you ain’t about that life. But this goes for all, so all the project managers, and basically anyone that acted as middle-men between text editor and production, they all need to go. It’s going to be a nice trim job, better for everyone.
- hooverd 1y agodevelopers hate project managers because they force them to deliver instead of forever being nerd sniped
- throwawayoldie 1y agoWell yes, because getting nerd sniped is fun, and 99.99% of ideas for software are boring bullshit.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- iambateman 1y agoIt's important to note that the lens for a silicon valley ex-google exec is whether AI will create new jobs which remind him of Google. There's almost no question that tech giants will have negative headcount over the next 15 years but the changes coming from AI haven't even really started to percolate into the broader economy.
- nerevarthelame 1y agoThe full interview this comes from is off the rails. Gawdat says we'll have AGI by 2026 at the absolute latest, and that we will have artificial super intelligence in the immediate future. He guarantees that after destroying jobs, within 15 years we will be in a "utopia" controlled by AI. It's an absurd level of confidence for an extremely bold prediction. In his last interview from this series in 2023, Gawdat said that LLMs are "alive in every possible way," have a "very deep consciousness," are "definitely aware," and "feel emotions." His current endeavors involve an unlaunched combination LLM relationship coach and dating site (matchmaking humans with humans, not with LLMs, as far as I can tell).
- xnx 1y agoThank you for saving me from even the slightest temptation to read anything from this guy.
- throwawayoldie 1y ago> Gawdat says we'll have AGI by 2026 at the absolute latest ...has he looked at a calendar lately? I just did, and it turns out that 2026 is less than five months away. I'm not even going to touch the "alive in every possible way" bullshit.
- ponector 1y agoDid he specify the calendar? It's now a year of 1447 according to one.
- throwawayoldie 1y agoHe did not, and for that matter, he never said if he was counting in base 10.
- anotheruser13 1y agoReminds me of someone else promising "full self driving" any day now.
- 1y ago
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- arctics 1y agoI think he is wrong, in a short run AI will create more jobs. We need more things to run AI and to make more things like power generation, connectivity, sensors, silicone, datacenters, monitoring, security, construction and so on. All of these things and more require massive workforce skilled or not skilled.
- mockingloris 1y agoWell I came here to say "...We'll need a universal basic income (UBI) in an AI-driven world". Eventually, at some point. Most industry would have been disrupted. There should be a working group of the major players/stake holders in the space to figure out how this is implemented. I work in tech and I don't see that happening for another decade and half or so. Where is this discussion thread? └── Dey well
- xnx 1y agoHistorically, jobs lost to technology are eventually replaced with other jobs, though not necessarily for the displaced workers. There's always the chance that "this time it's different". What's left after machines can think better than people? Dexterous manual work that mechanical arms can't perform? The ideal situation would be that we reap the benefits of technological abundance and work less.
- _DeadFred_ 1y agoBy historically you mean the one time. We went from a world where nearly everything was made by hand to one built on efficiency of scale, which turbocharged growth across the board. Moving from home made clothes to mass produced, etc. There isn't a new next level to take making clothes, nor everything else. There was a lot of low hanging fruit between 1880-today. What happened in the past wasn't magic. It was logical progression from a very basic civilization to an optimized one. But AI advocates push the past as 'everything changed but magic made it work out so that will happen again'. The past’s transformation was a one-off fueled by obvious, unexploited gains. There is no “next level” waiting in clothes, shipping, energy, or most other mature systems.
- root_axis 1y agoThe idea that LLMs will replace us all just seems untethered from reality. Yes, they are extremely powerful and useful, with incredible potential, but I am not convinced that the cost/benefit ratio scales to the size of the entire economy. As amazing as LLMs are, the statistical unreliability of the SOTA models means human intervention is always necessary. That's based on today's SOTA models which are already so absurdly gigantic that the DCs are disrupting civic infrastructure due to their water and power demands, and these companies still have to rate limit aggressively just to keep the service up. Everyone knows quadratic growth doesn't scale, so I don't see how these models continue to grow in capability, while also growing in capacity to meet the demand of an "agentic economy", while still ultimately needing to pay human SMEs to verify correctness and fix mistakes. It doesn't add up. My prediction is that we'll see increased efficiency in knowledge workers and reshaping/consolidation of certain job functions, but the structure of the economy over the next two decades won't be upended due to LLMs.
- jeffbee 1y agoThere are thousands of former Google execs and their mean intelligence is only slightly different than the population, with plenty of tail morons. There isn't any credibility innate to being an Ex-Google exec.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- xaxaxb 1y agoSolve for Crap :)
- noichnoich 1y ago[dead]