4 ms·
Why insurers worry the world could soon become uninsurable
- whatwrongwyou 1y agoThis seems based on outdated science to me. The world isn't just "getting hotter", the overall climate is changing due solely to human influence. The article makes it sound like insurers believe houses will start spontaneously combusting. What they should really worry about is desertification in populated areas and flooding along the coasts, and the inevitable humanitarian crisis and necessary social restructuring that those will require. We can't leave this to insurers - we need strong cooperation between governments and academia to plot a better course into our brave new world.
- whatwrongwyou 1y ago[flagged]
- cwmoore 1y ago“insurers believe houses will start spontaneously combusting”
- whatwrongwyou 1y ago"The article makes it sound like", which I used to emphasize the seeming misunderstanding that the author seems to have. Insurers aren't stupid. I don't think the author is stupid either; I think they're just not a SME. And unless you have credentials, neither are you or anyone else here. We have to be better at listening to the experts who dedicate their lives to this stuff, and we need to fund them whatever they need to do their work.
- cwmoore 1y ago>We have to be better at listening to experts From the article; “financial burden of these disasters often falls on individuals, businesses and governments, rather than insurance firms.” Considering the article, your post was simply off-topic and inaccurate. There are flooding issues far from the coasts, and desertification in farmland far from where most people live. “Houses spontaneously combusting” was just the most obvious fiction that would draw downvotes. This was not an article denying atmospheric carbon dioxide. Open your mind to awaken others. Respect the fact that some eyes are already open.
- anoxor 1y ago“the overall climate is changing due solely to human influence.” Way past anything scientific. Spend 2 minutes googling “anthrophemoric co2 percentage”
- oezi 1y agoWell solely is dramatizing but to a large extend it is true that the clima is changing because of human actions. Certainly the rise in Co2 from 280 ppm to 420 ppm since the onset of industrialization is rather very likely due to human actions.
- lazyasciiart 1y agoBecause they’re the ones who are supposed to pay money when shit blows up, and they are finally at the point where the giant flaming signs that it’s going to all blow up are within foreseeable shareholder ownership periods.
- Xylakant 1y agoInsurance is supposed to average out small probability high impact events across a large number of smaller payments from more people. It is entirely expected to loose money on insurance as a single customer - that's usually great. It means your house hasn't burned down, you're in good healt and you bike hasn't been stolen. If we're now moving towards a world where due to man-made climate change certain classes of risks are no longer insurable, everyone looses.
- esseph 1y agoI would think insurance would be among the least of worries?
- _carbyau_ 1y agoI think they are using Insurance as a predictive indicator of how terrible things are. So you are largely agreeing. IE: 1. insurance spreads a hurt across a society, using money as an instrument. 2. If insurance doesn't work anymore then the hurt is too large for society! This linking of 1 and 2 may not be entirely true due to insurance not necessarily being a perfectly efficient "spreader" across society. But I think in practical terms it is close enough.
- Xylakant 1y agoThe linking doesn’t need to be perfect to have real-world consequences: as the article explains, dues to increasing heavy weather events, home owner insurance is harder or even impossible to obtain. Without HOI, you won’t get a mortgage, because that would mean the bank partially enters into that risk. No mortgage means a lot of people cannnot afford to own a house or flat.
- RowanH 1y agoChunks of NZ are becoming very expensive to uninsurable, and extreme impact weather events are getting more frequent. It would be fair say a good portion of the population don't understand the maths of a weather event just how astronomically expensive a sudden flood is. In our small town in the last 5 years, we've had 2-3 different "1 in 100 year" floods within 30km of each other (highly localised dramatic flooding and slips). To the point "1 in 100 year" is now a standing joke.
- ViscountPenguin 1y agoWhen did the council last revise your flood models? Up here in Queensland, it caused a real stir when the council released updated flood models and lots of "1/1000" year flood houses turned into "1/10"
- RowanH 1y agoI don't know. Certainly the frequency and severity is just eye opening. We had 2 1 in 50's with 1 in 100 in 3 weeks (!!!). I know you guys have also had it bad over there. I expect the insurance companies will start removing flood cover soon. Which then becomes a bit of a shit show with mortgages. Or will raise the premiums so high that they're effectively uninsurable.
- _carbyau_ 1y agoBrisbane had cyclone Alfred that caused a major panic with ~100km-ish winds. A friend went to visit NZ and 100km/hr winds was just another day...
- Havoc 1y agoNot a big fan of "uninsurable". They'll happily insure high risk stuff, for an appropriate premium. It just becomes unaffordable to the average family. As a side note there is another insurance disaster in the making - shadow fleet carrying millions of barrels of oil in old ships with opaque ownership and even murkier maintenance history...they don't do the whole insurance thing. Only a matter of time before the world faces a very awkward "who's picking up the bill" discussion. Small one already happened in the Black sea.
- beej71 1y ago> They'll happily insure high risk stuff, for an appropriate premium. From what I've seen, this isn't always the case. My parents' insurer stopped offering fire coverage in their area with no option to buy at a higher price.
- DiggyJohnson 1y agoPresumably they could try and find a different insurance firm or a boutique.
- xoa 1y agoFWIW and depending on where you are this could be down to local regulations. A lot of (most?) polities do not allow insurance companies to simply set prices based on their assessment of risks and the market, but rather place extremely heavy restrictions on the process (which further inevitably get politicized). They may also have regulations around minimum numbers of people to offer coverage to in an area and endless other related issues. So an insurance company that does the math and thinks it has to raise premiums 200% or whatever to make it work, unless somebody meets specific XYZ criteria around fire resistance (which are expensive), it may find that it simply is not allowed to at all, or not without long delays and a burdensome legal/PR battles. They always have the right to leave though.
- avalys 1y agoThis is likely because the state they live in does not allow insurance companies to price their coverage according to risk, and applies political pressure when they try to do so. Insurance companies are demonized and characterized as heartless, rapacious and greedy, despite the fact that they’re probably losing money at current prices. So, many companies decide to exit the market rather than be forced to sell a service that they expect to lose money on.
- xnx 1y agoRisk feels like a pendulum that periodically needs to swing back to the individual property owners. We're probably entering a cycle where homes need to be built in less risky locations and built more durable to risk.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- aaron695 1y ago[dead]
- andy99 1y agoFirst, insurance companies should be the last thing we consider when setting policy, this is propaganda for them trying to protect their racket, not anything more telling. Second, governments and private companies should be looking at (socializing) mitigations that will keep risk within tolerable levels (without caring whether some legacy insurer continues to be able to gouge cusotmers). If there's a clear and identifiable threat, we can build dikes or sea walls or spillways or whatever it is that can alleviate the issue. "Think of the insurance implications" is a silly distraction.
- milesskorpen 1y agoAt least in the US, insurers have been losing money in recent years. Definitely not price gouging. Insurance is an amazing service.
- andy99 1y ago> Insurance is an amazing service I've noticed it's done wonders for your healthcare system
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- NegativeK 1y agoI agree with your disgust with our healthcare, but I downvoted you because your comment is more of a gotcha than fostering conversation.
- jlund-molfese 1y agoHealth insurance in the US, and other countries, is pretty far from traditional insurance markets where you pay a small amount of money to cover rare, catastrophic events (like your house burning down, or an earthquake). The name might be similar, but the products actually function very differently. Health insurance in many countries covers routine, predictable "losses" like primary care for strep throat as well as long-term "losses" like prescription medication. A lot of this is because a traditional insurance model isn't palatable when it comes to healthcare. You can't really employ price or service discrimination against high-risk people with preexisting conditions, like you can with auto insuring a Ferrari, or home insuring a coastal house in a hurricane zone. Not to mention life insurance! You can't just look assume things work the same way because they have similar names.
- charcircuit 1y agoI'm confused that this article made no mention of laws preventing insurance companies from accurately pricing insurance. Otherwise they can increase the price to match the risk. Even if the risk is unpredictable they could increase the price until they were comfortable with the risk, or themselves get insurances to cover the risk of providing insurance.
- vjvjvjvjghv 1y agoI think it also has to do with asset inflation. Housing prices constantly rising makes insuring them more expensive.
- ndsipa_pomu 1y agoThat shouldn't be a major factor as it's the repair/rebuild costs that insurance companies are interested in. If house prices increase, it doesn't mean that it would cost more to rebuild them.
- vjvjvjvjghv 1y agoFrom what I have seen, the cost of home building has gone up a lot.
- agentultra 1y agoThis doesn’t seem surprising and I hope it isn’t. David Suzuki and others have gone on record saying that we’ve lost the climate fight. Politics and economics are useless at preventing it. Oil and gas won. We’re locked in for a post 1.5 C world. You can’t insure against catastrophes that are basically guaranteed to happen. It’s too late to restructure to prevent catastrophic climate change. Seems like all we can do is restructure to survive and take care of one another for as long as we can.
- _carbyau_ 1y agoWho will have the most care taken of them? Maybe the people with the most money? I have hopes society will have done something to reduce wealth inequality by then - but right now they are distant hopes.
- MengerSponge 1y agoI recall the insurance industries lost so much in the 2008 financial crisis that it wiped out all their profitability over all of human history to that point. I imagine they haven't made enough in the last two decades to outweigh those losses, so they probably are a net-negative as an industry, which is very funny.