4 ms·
Sunlight-activated material turns PFAS in water into harmless fluoride
- nick238 1y agoThe Materials Science Gameplay Loop: 1. Invent fantastic new material that does a heretofore novel reaction or one with improved performance (chemical, photovoltaic, etc.) 2. Do #1 without lead, cadmium, mercury, or arsenic. SociallyAwesomeAwkwardPenguinMeme("Turns PFAS to fluoride", "Contains Cadmium")
- momoschili 1y ago3. Do #2 without platinum, palladium, rhodium, ruthenium to make it economically viable
- 3eb7988a1663 1y agoIs that much of a problem for a catalyst? Presumably you do not need many of these: at water treatment plants and at the waste-stream for manufacturing processes which emit PFAS. You might not be able to justify the expense inside your home water purification system, but it could still be cost effective for large scale installations.
- momoschili 1y agoit depends on the scale and the required amounts. If having a limited amount of catalyst wasn't such a big problem I suspect hydrogen power would have been much more economically viable.
- ambicapter 1y agoI thought the point of catalysts was that they don't get used up in the reaction they promote.
- djtango 1y agoThe real world is messy - catalysts gradually need replacement over time in non lab conditions https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Catalyst_poisoning https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Catalyst_poisoning
- lazide 1y agoThe issue with hydrogen is the source of hydrogen.
- throwup238 1y agoYou would need a lot of catalyst because the water infrastructure to supply several hundred million people in the US is massive, let alone the rest of the world. The problem with those catalysts is that the latter two are minor components of platinum and copper/nickel ores and despite how expensive they are, the extraction is only economically viable as part of other mining. Their supply can only grow as much as platinum extraction allows and demand is already pretty significant with environmental regulations often necessitating their use. Any more demand for them will cause their prices to rise dramatically and its a long way before they become profitable enough to mine on their own (flooding the platinum market in the process which has much higher yields from the ores).
- SoftTalker 1y agoActivated carbon filtering removes up to about 75% of PFAS. Reverse-osmosis removes almost all. Doesn't get rid of them, to be clear. It would still be better if a way could be found to chemically (and cheaply) convert them to something less harmful.
- N2yhWNXQN3k9 1y ago> Activated carbon filtering removes up to about 75% Seems like the limitation must be more than reducing concentrations in fluid? Otherwise you'd just do multiple passes?
- BugsJustFindMe 1y ago> Activated carbon filtering removes up to about 75% of PFAS Common inexpensive non-RO filter systems come with independent test results showing 99% removal of PFOA/PFOS (see e.g https://www.brondell.com/content/UC300_Coral_PDS.pdf https://www.brondell.com/content/UC300_Coral_PDS.pdf). Do we have reason to believe that other PFAS don't filter as easily?
- SoftTalker 1y agoAIHI the shorter PFAS molecules are not captured as effectively by activated carbon.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- momoschili 1y agoYes, the key here is the degradation of the forever chemical, not the removal. Removal itself doesn't really change the environmental scale of it
- KennyBlanken 1y agoAlternative path, like with General Electric: Invent seemingly fantastic new material. Discover it is harmful to humans and wildlife, accumulates in groundwater, etc. Bury that discovery. Get caught after decades of wild profits, the occasional secret settlement, and spend a decade more fighting legal action before finally running out of appeals or the writing is on the wall, and accept it and pay out. Start selling water filtration systems, thus profiting off people dealing with your pollution. This is what I find so frustrating about "the fight against cancer." I'm convinced cancer is so prevalent because corporations are poisoning the shit out of our environment, and thus our water supply, our food, our air. Because we're not equipped with timestamping chemical detection systems, it's difficult to identify the exposure that caused it or increased the person's risk, so industry gets a "freebie" death nobody can pin to them. As long as the chemical isn't toxic enough to be obvious - the companies get away scott free, despite an extensive history of the chemical industry time and time again coming up with some major novel chemical that comes to be used all over society and turns out to be toxic. Bill Moyers once submitted his blood to a lab and asked them to test for everything they could identify in terms of industrial chemicals, pesticides, etc. The blood was a veritable toxic soup (and some of the control sample containers were contaminated from the supplier, showing how pervasive the toxins are): https://www.pbs.org/tradesecrets/problem/popup_bb_02.html https://www.pbs.org/tradesecrets/problem/popup_bb_02.html You don't "fight cancer" doing walks and charity balls and cute-kid-starts-fundraiser-because-friend-dies-from-leukemia. You fight cancer by addressing the toxins being pumped into us in the name of profit and "bettering society", allowed to get away with it because of how difficult it is to show any particular chemical directly caused the cancer.
- anonymars 1y agoIf only the vaccine-autism energy could be directed in the right place PS not to diminish GE's game but they certainly weren't the only player. This one always stuck with me: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Minamata_disease#Wastewater_treatment https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Minamata_disease#Wastewater_tr...
- exogenousdata 1y agoSadly the goal of vaccine-autism energy has largely become to destabilize western nation states. But I share the sentiment!
- tstrimple 1y ago[flagged]
- baby_souffle 1y ago[flagged]
- nraynaud 1y agoI'm a bit confused, are they suggesting that a cadnium coumpound to treat PFAS is a done deal?
- pxeger1 1y agoIgnoring the cadmium problem, is fluoride really harmless? I don't know what concentration of fluoride you'd end up with from converting typical PFAS pollution, but if you get enough fluoride it is acutely poisonous, which might be worse than the carcinogenic PFAS. (Likewise, it might be worse for the environment)
- nick238 1y agoFluoride doesn't bio-accumulate like PFAS do, which has a strong affinity for proteins and fats in organisms. Constantly drinking water with 0.5-1 ppm fluoride may cause minor side effects like mild dental fluorosis, but you'll excrete almost all the excess as it's very water soluble. Drink water with any PFAS, and your body will strongly hold on to it all.
- formerly_proven 1y ago"0.5-1 ppm" covers what's considered the optimum level of fluoride in drinking water, so I doubt you'd get dental fluorosis from that. Coincidentally, if you calculate the equivalent dose that you'd give babies (via dissolved vitamin D + fluoride tablets), you also end up at about 0.3-0.5ppm.
- marbro 1y ago[dead]
- bawolff 1y agoEverything is toxic at a certain conentration, but as far as i know PFAS is a million times more toxic than flouride. According to the EPA safe level for flouride for drinking water is up to 4 mg/L. The epa level for PFOS is 0.000004 mg/L, literally a million times lower.
- sitkack 1y agoI thought the EPA was deregulating everything except flouride which it was going to deem a poison.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- ChrisMarshallNY 1y agoFluoride?!! Isn't that supposed to be some kind of demonic juice? Why else is the government so intent on making sure that there's none in our water? I'm sure that they would much rather have the PFAS, produced by their nice, generous, industrialist bros.
- sitkack 1y agoAnd PFAS are used heavily in the manufacturing of microchips (photoresist and etching).
- ChrisMarshallNY 1y agoThe PFAS are the mellowest chemicals they use. I think they use this stuff: https://www.science.org/content/blog-post/sand-won-t-save-you-time https://www.science.org/content/blog-post/sand-won-t-save-yo...
- f_devd 1y agoAt least that will self-decompose, reactive chemicals aren't usually a problem