5 ms·
Astronomy Photographer of the Year 2025 shortlist
- aredox 1y agoI can't look at this without asking myself "how many of these are completely generated"? Thanks for destroying trust, AI researchers and companies. On top of everything else.
- vjvjvjvjghv 1y agoThey are highly processed and often stacked but I see nothing there that looks fake.
- olddustytrail 1y agoI'm not aware of any photograph of this sort that would fool an astronomer. The times and dates wouldn't work if it was faked.
- ethan_smith 1y agoThe competition requires submission of raw files and detailed processing information, making it one of the more rigorous contests for verifying authentic astrophotography.
- foxglacier 1y agoIf you were trusting photos to be pictures of the real world before AI then you should never have had that trust in the first place. You should thank AI companies for opening your eyes to what was already fooling you. Even if they are real, does it really matter when the camera is doing superhuman work with things like a 27 km zoomed in picture of a building or composite of 300 separate exposures. If you get to combine exposures, why not just expose a moon separately from a building and combine them in the computer?
- pploug 1y agoOh its not coldplay concert photos
- hodgehog11 1y agoThis is the kind of discovery that I love to see on HN. Regardless of who wins the competition, we all win by getting to see all of the entries. Absolutely gorgeous shots. Made my day.
- creativenolo 1y agoIt’s also lovely to see the exhibition IRL when it comes, if you’re lucky enough. When I saw it, there were narratives about the people behind the shots which made it extra special.
- sal_welissen 1y ago> Absolutely gorgeous shots Yes, but these days I have to wonder whether AI was involved, and I hate having that thought because of the massive time, expertise, equipment, and luck that it takes for the real photos to be created.
- Nvorzula 1y agoHello, astrophotographer here. The unique thing about astrophotography is that the subject that we are imaging is (relatively speaking) static. Any slight deviation, even the smallest detail, that is not structurally accurate is PAINFULLY obvious. As an aside, we do use traditional neural networks for certain processing steps. Deconvolution and noise reduction are very common. However, these are only helping in correcting errors caused by viewing conditions. They are not the "imaginative" AI that you are dreading.
- hodgehog11 1y agoI had a feeling something like this was true, thank you for confirming it! I would actually be more worried about a knowledgeable human engaging in clever Photoshop alterations, or pasting different images together. Is this an issue in astrophotography? Are there ways to easily detect this?
- alexchamberlain 1y agoThere is a category called "Annie Maunder Open Category", which allows for creative use of generative AI, as long as it is declared, otherwise it is banned. You have to take that slightly with a pinch of salt though, as many of the images don't represent what could be seen with the naked eye. It could be as simple as a wide spectrum sensor (which I don't think anyone could claim is AI) through to alignment of many 100s of images (for which the algorithms in use may have been considered AI a decade or 2 ago).
- ucarion 1y ago> Into the Past by Jim Hildreth The area in this photo -- the Caineville Mesa, Factory Butte, "Long Dong Silver" (I'm not aware of a more polite name) -- is some of the strangest land in America. It really is that lunar blue gray. The Temples of the Sun and Moon (enormous natural sandcastles) are also nearby, and are similarly eerie in the evening. The closest I've ever felt to being in space. Recommend!
- dfee 1y agoAgree. Found his site, but that shot’s not listed: https://www.hildreth-photographer.com/portfolio.html?folio=Fine%20Art https://www.hildreth-photographer.com/portfolio.html?folio=F...
- ucarion 1y agoSeems their IG has some of these, including the shot from the article: https://www.instagram.com/tripodtales/p/C8hRS0ctzCp/ https://www.instagram.com/tripodtales/p/C8hRS0ctzCp/ Factory Butte: https://www.instagram.com/tripodtales/p/C6gg-wpS-tr/ https://www.instagram.com/tripodtales/p/C6gg-wpS-tr/ "Long Dong Silver": https://www.instagram.com/tripodtales/p/C-yLCskOGiC/ https://www.instagram.com/tripodtales/p/C-yLCskOGiC/
- S0y 1y agoThe amount of compression that was applied to these photo is downright criminal.
- dylan604 1y agoYou are free to visit the actual exhibition to see the images without compression. https://www.rmg.co.uk/whats-on/astronomy-photographer-year/exhibition https://www.rmg.co.uk/whats-on/astronomy-photographer-year/e...
- xd1936 1y agoIs there any place for me to pay to download one of these for personal use as a desktop wallpaper?
- roldie 1y agoWow, these are gorgeous. Thanks for sharing!
- finnjohnsen2 1y agoNorwegian here. Not a young one. Ive seen my share of the northern lights and Ive also seen a lot of photos of it. The photos are attractive, but they are never like seen by the photographer with the naked eye. I blame that dark/night photography is an impossible task. The tricks like long exposure, ISO boost and noise cleanup, saturation, hdr or whatever you throw at it, just wont be like your eyes. Photographers gets carried away in post and boost too much, and I understand why. Northern lights - are awesome. I encourage you to see it if you havent. Go this winter! And take photos and you’ll know what I meen. The colors wont pop like these popular photos, but standing outside on a freezing winter night holding back your frost breath from blocking the view of the green lights moving like firely beams of across the sky. Hopefully you’re somewhere quiet with no light pollution. There is nothing like it - watching the reflections of the armor of the valkyrene as they march on valhal
- dylan604 1y agoI'm all for managing people's expectations, but I'm just not agreeing with your conclusion. Human vision is only capable of registering such a small piece of the spectrum that is there. Just because human eyeballs cannot perceive the information does not mean it is not there. This is true of pretty much any astronomy photographs, and that is why people do it. When you look at the milky way, you don't see all of the colors with your naked eye. It doesn't mean they are not there though. Looking at Pleiades, you just see a group of stars, but long exposures reveal all of the incredible nebulosity around them. Looking at the Andromeda galaxy with the naked eye is meh at best, and only truly becomes awe inspiring with long exposure to start to reveal the detail in the spiral arms. Looking at any deep sky object even with a telescope with naked eye is just never going to allow us to see what is truly there. Boosting colors/saturation that is already there is no different from what most people do with images on their phones. I also have no issues when people use a SII or H-alpha filters and give them a false color.
- jamestimmins 1y agoI like this interpretation, because my experience seeing the northern lights was similar to OC's. I had such high expectations from photos, and then I saw them and was somewhat underwhelmed. My friends are photographers and they took vibrant photos, but since then it has felt 'fake' somehow. But your framing it as what is actually going on, just with better sensors than our eyes have, makes me appreciate the art more.
- srean 1y agoShanghai blood moon reminded me of Blade Runner. Who knew that a 1982 imagination of LA Chinatown would look so similar to Shanghai in fool Moon. I know it's partly because of the color pallette, but still
- temp0826 1y agoThe one of M33 (Triangulum Galaxy) really blew me away, so many nebulae!
- Noumenon72 1y ago> Gateway to the Galaxy by Yujie Zhang Are the "geometric buildings" real or just something she put up for the picture?
- dcre 1y agoI pasted the image into ChatGPT and while I can't find the place described on Google Maps, the picture is clearly of the same place. They're more of a sculpture than a set of buildings. https://subsites.chinadaily.com.cn/ezhejiang/lishui/2025-01/08/c_1063076.htm https://subsites.chinadaily.com.cn/ezhejiang/lishui/2025-01/...
- Mars008 1y agoNice images. I personally prefer more of Space and less of Earth in astro. How did they do solar eruption? Must be some filters as Sun doesn't look like this to naked eye. I mean this image: https://www.rmg.co.uk/sites/default/files/styles/large/public/2025-06/OS-255963-2025-1_500%2C000_km_Solar_Prominence_Eruption_Captured_in_Full.jpg.webp?itok=TBjaG3-w https://www.rmg.co.uk/sites/default/files/styles/large/publi...
- dekhn 1y agoI believe it's an H-alpha filter. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hydrogen-alpha https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hydrogen-alpha
- ratmeadow 1y agoSome absolutely stunning shots here, wow! Photos like this inspire me. The compositions with the huge moon rising behind the landscape are particularly impressive. You need a huge lens to get that kind of perspective, and atmospheric effects and camera shake become more pronounced. The other photos of the night sky impress me less honestly because they are almost always composited (i.e. the Milky Way doesn't actually look like that).
- skybrian 1y agoI’d like to see a nice photo of M31 with something in the foreground. It would have to be a composite image, but getting the relative sizes and positions right.
- yla92 1y agoAmazing shots. 500,000-km Solar Prominence Eruption, in particular, was amazing!
- dyauspitr 1y agoAren’t images like the one with Saturn basically just different pictures photoshopped together?
- anthk 1y agoNASA guide to astro photography with smartphones: https://spacemath.gsfc.nasa.gov/SMBooks/AstrophotographyV1.pdf https://spacemath.gsfc.nasa.gov/SMBooks/AstrophotographyV1.p...
- rdrd 1y agoI get an immense amount of pride when I see anything that the Royal Museum Greenwich do because not only is it very local to me but they have such a great way of balancing the history of maritime/meridian with modern services and facilities. If you’re coming to London please spend a day in Greenwich, you won’t regret it, take in the museums, the small markets, the observatory, stroll round the park, grab a photo of the best view in London (imo) https://www.rmg.co.uk/royal-observatory/attractions/enjoy-best-view-london https://www.rmg.co.uk/royal-observatory/attractions/enjoy-be... - then take a walk along the Thames, once you’re done you can hop on an Uber boat and head into central London.