4 ms·
Ultra-processed foods make up more than 60% of us kids' diets
- xandrius 1y agoOnly surprised it is not higher to be honest.
- v5v3 1y agoIs it because its an average and the Gwyneth Paltrows have 0%. If they broke it down to demographics then would show a divide depending on income/education levels, area and so on.
- xandrius 1y agoThe math doesn't add up: even if the top 10% of US kids ate 0% of ultra-processed foods and the rest have 80+% in their diet, it would still be a larger average than the one reported.
- sokoloff 1y agohttps://archive.is/8IavU https://archive.is/8IavU
- sokoloff 1y ago> highly processed foods like burgers, pastries, snacks and pizza Is a burger highly processed? Home-made burgers seem not to fall into that bucket. (Hot dogs, I can buy as being it, but burgers not.)
- garbawarb 1y agoIs pizza? Basic pizza is just wheat, mozzarella, and tomato sauce. It's cooked, but I guess cooking is a process.
- owebmaster 1y agoPizza is processed. Frozen pizza is ultra proccessed
- vjvjvjvjghv 1y agoHome made pizza is fine. The frozen stuff is mostly terrible with too much salt, sugar and god knows what else.
- cpursley 1y agoCheck what's in the tomato sauce and dough (hint: sugar)
- Aurornis 1y ago> Basic pizza is just wheat, No, it’s flour, which is a heavily processed wheat product. > mozzarella Which is a heavily processed food that differs greatly from the input products. > tomato sauce Also processed. Likely has added sugar. It’s interested to read these conversations and see that the frame of reference has shifted so much that obviously highly processed ingredients aren’t tripping people’s processed food detectors. Then the language used isn’t picking up on the processing (calling it wheat instead of flour).
- dinfinity 1y agoJust like the term "ultraprocessed foods" the term "sandwich" is very badly defined. I can't determine whether the study differentiates between healthy home made sandwiches and junk food that contains some kind of "bread".
- Milpotel 1y ago> healthy home made sandwiches That would include baking your own bread which is not common in the US afaik.
- jltsiren 1y agoOr just buying decent bread. The selection of breads in the average American supermarket seems pretty bad compared to what I was used to in Finland.
- Milpotel 1y agoUnfortunately, getting "decent bread" is not as easy as it has been years ago even in countries having the best bread and largest variety in the world such as Germany, Switzerland, Austria, ... Many small bakeries started adding artificial ingredients to extend shelf life, shorten production time or replace expensive ingredients.
- arp242 1y agoPretty much anything you get in mainland Europe is still tons better than the vague bread-shaped organic matter they sell at supermarkets in Ireland or the UK. Seems to be an Anglo thing because my experience in New Zealand was similar (can't speak to the US though). That doesn't mean you can't find decent bread even at supermarkets, but it's not the default and quite a lot more expensive. The main exception in Ireland is Lidl, which sells decent bread for a decent price.
- Milpotel 1y ago> exception in Ireland is Lidl Sorry but this is UPF bread and their rolls are sometimes made in China. > sell at supermarkets in Ireland or the UK At least in London there are many shops now that sell bread that at least looks like bread (Ole & Steen, Gail's, ...). I can't remember any ingredient lists, so likely UPF as well...
- oblio 1y agoI imagine low quality burger meat contains a lot of stuff, not just lean muscle.
- AJ007 1y agoOr even horse https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2013_horse_meat_scandal https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2013_horse_meat_scandal
- senko 1y agoFrom the article: > If the ingredients include artificial colors and chemicals that aren’t normally found in the kitchen, the item is likely ultra-processed. Curious to see sandwiches included in the list (and the top "offender", no less). Home-made ones can be pretty healthy! Edit to add: the study says: > "Ultra-processed foods tend to be hyperpalatable, energy-dense, low in dietary fiber, and contain little or no whole foods, while having high amounts of salt, sweeteners, and unhealthy fats". The study page also contains a more precise definition (using something called Nova classification).
- Aurornis 1y agoHighly processed flour bun. Slice of highly processed cheese. Highly processed ketchup sauce on top. An unprocessed slice of tomato and lettuce if you’re lucky. Conversations about processed foods reveal a lot about how our perspectives have shifted so much. Something like a burger is stacked with highly processed items.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- amelius 1y agoWhy are we calling it processed foods when it is not necessarily the processing of the foods that makes it bad?
- kristjank 1y agoBecause a big majority of bad food is extensively processed.
- AJ007 1y agoCorn syrup is just a vegetable?
- amelius 1y agoYeah, so don't call it a vegetable either if you want to focus on its nutritional defects.
- buran77 1y agoPart of the processing is to add something harmful or remove something useful either as the target of the process, or as a byproduct. I give you a tomato, that's unprocessed. I squash it a bit and maybe add some salt? That's processed. I boil the hell out of it and mix it with 30 other ingredients (like salt, sugar, flavoring, preservatives, other additives, etc.), especially in large quantities? That's heavily processed or above. As you can see, the processing is what made a tomato worse for the health. The term is perfectly apt.
- amelius 1y agoBut there is a widely supported hypothesis that humans evolved bigger brains because they started to cook their food. Hence "processed" is not necessarily bad. And thus the term, imho, is not suitable.
- buran77 1y agoNot "necessarily", but "realistically". I think we need to start by clarifying what "processed" means from a practical (legal/commercial) perspective rather than common sense. What you call "processing" as a normal person, like boiling, frying, smoking, canning, fermenting, baking aren't necessarily even considered "processed" in the commercial sense. They're considered "preservation" (e.g. smoked fish) or "cookery" (e.g. bread). So almost every process that humans applied to food until the 19th-20th century was basic cooking and preservation, with a few exceptions of convoluted foods. The modern interpretation of "processing" only begins at the next level. When the process has a lot more added steps and ingredients which in practice are almost guaranteed to be less healthy. But when we say "ultra-processed" it's guaranteed that it has significant health downsides. Ultra processed food has decreased nutritional content due to the processing, and high levels of unhealthy ingredients or components (like sugar, salt, trans fats, preservatives, and all kinds of other additives). Many ultra processed foods have more sugar, salt, or trans fats than they have the purported main ingredient. I'm just looking at a jar of "pistachio cream" that has 50% more sugar than pistachio. So for all intents and purposes, in practice, processed food makes it less healthy and ultra-processed is synonymous with very unhealthy.
- cpursley 1y agoWhat really amazes me is seeing little kids at the playground etc, walking around and eating things like Cheetos. Not only is this ultra-processed junk terrible for them, it's programming them bad habits (and manners) to just free feed and roam around like that. Is it any wonder why America is so fat and unhealthy and so many struggle with eating issues? You don't see this behavior nearly as often in Europe, Asia, etc and it should come at no surprise that those kids are more mature and have better self control over American kids.
- vjvjvjvjghv 1y agoMy casual observation is that a lot of Americans are obsessed with snacking. They can’t imagine going without food for a few hours.
- Xenoamorphous 1y agoHonest question (and I’m not from the US), do you have kids?
- Milpotel 1y agoQuestion as a parent: kids do need constant snacking now? I know some kids who do but they are overweight.
- cpursley 1y agoSnacking is an American/Anglo world thing. As are terrible manners in general. Civilized people sit down and eat at the table, and that includes having their children do the same - even for snacks (there are some exceptions, of course). That also goes for devices at the table, either at home or restaurants (truly incredible that people abuse their children this way). Yes, I have very strong opinions on this as a father who's seen that there's another way called "being a parent".
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago> Snacking is an American/Anglo world thing It’s spreading. The notion that if a child is hungry the only solution is to feed them immediately.
- lemoncookiechip 1y agoUltra-processed doesn't automatically mean unhealthy. It's what it's made of and how it's processed, and the quantities you ingest that can make it unhealthy, just like some unprocessed foods can still be unhealthy depending on what they are. Whole grain cereal with low sugar contents fall under ultra-processed, and it could still be more nutritious and less sugary than freshly squeezed OJ.
- vjvjvjvjghv 1y agoIt doesn’t necessarily mean unhealthy but in reality there is a very strong correlation between food being processed and having too much sugar, salt , fat or other stuff. A lot of these foods are designed for addictiveness .
- lemoncookiechip 1y agoIt depends on the classification system, but yes, whole grain cereal with added sugar and preservatives for shelf-life is often classified as ultra-processed. That said, I think framing all UPFs or processed foods as "bad" misses the point. What really matters is the nutritional value of the food itself. A food being ultra-processed doesn’t automatically make it less healthy than a minimally processed one. We should focus more on what’s actually in the food: the sugar content, fiber, protein, fat, micro-nutrients, rather than just whether it’s been processed or not. TLDR: It's the label telling what is in the food that matters, not the processes it underwent, although that can be VERY helpful for certain people who value how their food is made for moral/ethical/health reasons.
- vjvjvjvjghv 1y ago"That said, I think framing all UPFs or processed foods as "bad" misses the point. What really matters is the nutritional value of the food itself. A food being ultra-processed doesn’t automatically make it less healthy than a minimally processed one." Figuring out which ultra processed foods are ok and which ones aren't is very difficult and can be manipulated. I think it's much easier to avoid that stuff and cook from scratch.
- Aurornis 1y agoConversations about processed, heavily processed, and ultra-processed foods always trigger people who recognize that it’s an imperfect measure. It should be interpreted as a heuristic, not a perfect 1D measure of a food’s healthiness. As a heuristic it correlates quite well to many measures. The more someone’s diet falls on the ultra-processed end of the spectrum and the less they eat of unprocessed foods, the higher the rate of health problems. A simple example of the effects of processing would be considering an apple: Eating a whole apple is the healthiest because you consume all of the fiber and the digestion process is slowed because you have to break it down. Crushing it into something like apple sauce preserves much of the structure but now it absorbs faster and it’s easier to overeat it before your body can recognize it’s full. Processing it further to apple juice removes the fiber and now makes it spike your blood sugar and it’s easy to consume a lot of sugar. Ultra processed would take this even further, packaging it in a container with added sugar and some preservatives for shelf life. This is where it enters kids (and adults) diets, where it is far removed from the unprocessed Apple it started as.
- jimlawruk 1y agoFiber is also beneficial for the "good" gut bacteria, as it feeds on fiber. Fiber also binds to your LDL "bad" cholesterol in the digestive system and helps to eliminate it.
- kingstnap 1y agoIt triggers people because it's dumbing down something to the point of near uselessness. It's very much similar to the nonsense that is telling people not to eat "chemicals." Congrats, you found an example involving a basic item that works. I suppose that means something, and now people should go drink unpasteurized milk and RFK Jr. was right all along. The reason telling people not to eat chemicals is dumb is precisely because you lose the richness of the structure of the argument by taking the category of chemicals and casting them all in the same 1 dimension. Like saying, "Pharmaceuticals are dangerous." Proponents of the dumbing down basically suggest just memorizing all the counter examples. Congratulations, you successfully reduced the problem of recognizing junk food down the problem of recognizing junk food. I'll avoid processed food except the processes that are good, like baking bread instead of eating raw flour, and it's good when it is bread but bad when it's cookies. In reality, the measures that people need to legitimately follow aren't actually all that complex. You don't need to reduce it down to one dimension. You would be much better off if you just kept track of these 3 or 4 dimensions. 1. How many calories do you eat in a typical day. 2. How satiated they are after a reasonable number of calories. 3. If they aren't pooping well, eat more fibre. 4. If you really want to get nerdy about it, track macros. Doing so isn't actually all that complicated. In fact, I don't think a lack of knowledge or recognition of the issues in their diets is the issue. It's really the harsh reality that people struggle to manage the vices they already are fully aware of, and telling them about the dangerous of "processed" foods doesn't meet this issue in any way.
- mc32 1y agoHere is where Robert can come in and do something good by disincentivizing ultra-processed foods with the tools he has available at the FDA. Sure, getting bad color ingredients out is good --now go for the gusto and disincentivize ultra-processed foods.
- shigawire 1y agoHe could, but he's more focused on decreasing vaccine usage.
- evaXhill 1y agoThe quantity & quality of a child's diet determines how fast they age & their health later in life, its just crazy that US children now get 2/3rds of their energy from ultra-processed foods that are designed to be hyper-palatable & maintain hunger. Unfortunately, there’s just a lot of misinformation out there as it relates to diet (food pyramid being one of the most egregious examples). For one, although most ultra processed foods are bad, some can be actually beneficial for those with medical issues.
- a_shovel 1y ago"Ultra-processed food" is the new term for "junk food" for people who thought it needed three more syllables. They're both vague you-know-what-I-mean terms, and don't have any place in research papers, which really ought to be asking more specific questions. Are ultra-processed foods bad for you? You might as well ask whether "yucky foods" are good for you, or what the health effects of "appetizers" are. If you want to know if white bread or artificial colors or emulsifiers are unhealthy, ask that question directly instead of using this vague proxy category.
- Aurornis 1y ago> They're both vague you-know-what-I-mean terms, and don't have any place in research papers This is false. There are specific criteria for these categories in the research papers. It’s also acknowledge that it’s not a 100% perfect objective all-encompassing measure, but it is a very good heuristic. I don’t know why some people read a headline and think they know more about the topic than the research papers (which they clearly also have not read)
- atombender 1y agoThis is false. Research papers use formal definitions of what ultraprocessed means. The most common classification criteria are called Nova [1]. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nova_classification https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nova_classification
- a_shovel 1y agoI am aware of the Nova classification. "Vague" was the wrong word for me to use. "Overly broad" is probably closer to what I mean. Just read Group 4's definition. If "ultra-processed" can mean a million different things, then it doesn't matter that you've precisely defined all the things it can mean, your study will still be conflating a million independent variables. If you think emulsifiers are unhealthy, conduct a study on emulsifiers. If you think the absence of Nova group 1 foods is unhealthy, study that. I am questioning the value of studying foods with emulsifiers OR no group 1 ingredients OR added sugar OR were extruded OR were moulded OR which have "sophisticated packaging" OR have fruit juice concentrates OR hydrogenated oils OR etc. etc. etc., as if they formed a single scientifically meaningful group.