4 ms·

I'm on the image and video side of AI. I see the claims being levied against LLMs, but in the generative media world these models are nothing short of revoluti

I'm on the image and video side of AI. I see the claims being levied against LLMs, but in the generative media world these models are nothing short of revolutionary. In addition to being an engineer, I'm also a filmmaker. This tech has so many orders of magnitude changes to the production cycle: - Films can be made 5,000x cheaper (a $100M Disney film will be matched by small studios on budgets of $20,000.) - Films can be made 5x faster (end-to-end, not accounting for human labor hour savings. A 15 month production could feasibly be done in 3 months.) - Films can be made with 100x fewer people. (Studios of the future will be 1-20 people.) Disney and Netflix are going to be facing a ton of disruptive pressure. It'll be interesting to see how they navigate. Advertising and marketing? We've already seen ads on TV that were made over a weekend [1] for a few thousand dollars. I've talked to customers that are bidding $30k for pharmaceutical ad spots they used to bid $300k for. And the cost reductions are just beginning. [1] https://www.npr.org/2025/06/23/nx-s1-5432712/ai-video-ad-kalshi-advertising-nba-finals https://www.npr.org/2025/06/23/nx-s1-5432712/ai-video-ad-kal...

Palomides 1y ago
there is a very strong implicit claim in what you're saying: that AI video output is usefully comparable to human output
kaonwarb 1y ago
I agree the impact on generative media is huge. But I also do not think anyone is making a $100m-equivalent film for $20k anytime soon. Disprove me by doing it!
- queenkjuul 1y ago
  Don't hold your breath
suddenlybananas 1y ago
>a $100M Disney film will be matched by small studios on budgets of $20,000 I do not believe this is true.
tovej 1y ago
5000x is hilarious (as is 5x and 100x). When you make outlandish claims, at least provide a reference or analysis.
- amelius 1y ago
  5000x if you ignore the electricity bill ;)
- CyberDildonics 1y ago
  This person predicted two years ago that by now teenagers would be creating star wars quality movies in their bedrooms with AI.
viraptor 1y ago
> customers that are bidding $30k for pharmaceutical ad spots they used to bid $300k for How does this work? If the quality ads are easier to produce, wouldn't there be more competition for the same spot with more leftover money for bidding? Why would this situation reduce the cost of a spot?
maxbond 1y ago
Can you point to a film that has used this technology? Can you point to anything that substantiates those numbers? Genuinely asking, my mind is open to the possibility but I don't want to take it on faith. (I watched that Kalshi ad to be clear.)
- JimDabell 1y ago
  Not those numbers, but you might be interested in Netflix using generative AI: > Using AI-powered tools, they were able to achieve an amazing result with remarkable speed and, in fact, that VFX sequence was completed 10 times faster than it could have been completed with traditional VFX tools and workflows > The cost of [the special effects without AI] just wouldn’t have been feasible for a show in that budget — https://www.theguardian.com/media/2025/jul/18/netflix-uses-generative-ai-in-show-for-first-time-el-eternauta https://www.theguardian.com/media/2025/jul/18/netflix-uses-g... Discussed on Hacker News here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44602779 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44602779
- Karawebnetwork 1y ago
  The best example I've seen so far is this one: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gx8rMzlG29Q https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gx8rMzlG29Q Personally, I'm not particularly impressed. Yes, I'm impressed by the technology and the fact that we've reached a point where something like this is even possible, but in my opinion, it's soulless and suffers from the same problems as other AI videos. More emphasis was placed on length than quality, and I've seen shorter, traditionally produced videos that had more heart. That's probably because these videos were created by amateurs who thought the AI would fill in all the gaps, but that only underscores the need for human artists with a keen eye.
Cthulhu_ 1y ago
While in theory you're right - AI tools can "democratize" filmmaking - what will make them unique? There was another anecdote, someone saying "this AI can generate 30.000 screenplays in a day!". Which is cool but... who is going to read them? In theory (idk it probably exists already) you can generate a script and feed it into an AI that generates a film. Novelty aside, who is going to watch it? And what if you generate a hundred films a day? A thousand? This probably isn't a hypothetical scenario, as low-effort / generated content is already a thing, both writing, video and music. It's an enormous long tail on e.g. youtube, amazon, etc, relying on people passively consuming content without paying too much attention to it. The background muzak of everything. As someone smarter than me summarized, AI generated stuff is content, not art. AI generated films will be content, not art. There may be something compelling in there, but ultimately, it'll flood the market, become ubiquitous, and disappear into the background as AI generated background noise that only few people will seek out or watch intentionally.
- echelon 1y ago
  Hollywood is nepo land. That's not fair. Do you know how many dreamers and artists and great ideas wither away on the vine? It's tragic. Movies are going to be like books today. And that's not a bad thing. Distribution is always the hard part. Indie games, indie music. You've still got to market yourself and find your audience. But the difference is that now it's possible. And you don't have to obey some large capital distributor and mind their oversight and meddling.
  - CyberDildonics 1y ago
    Hollywood is nepo land. Says who? Do you know how many dreamers and artists and great ideas wither away on the vine? How many? Movies are going to be like books today. People are already creating movies with $1k cameras that look good enough to distribute. A lot of them are horror movies because of the budget and most of them are terrible with huge glaring mistakes in editing, pacing, framing, etc. but they can still make money. And you don't have to obey some large capital distributor and mind their oversight and meddling. How many movies have you worked on? Most experienced executives can help guide priorities and make sure there aren't any big overlooked problems.
UncleMeat 1y ago
$20,000 is a budget for what, one animator for three months? What does "a small studio with a budget of $20,000" even look like?
ygritte 1y ago
Why would I prefer a film that was generated by you pressing a button over a film that was generated by me pressing the same button?
- echelon 1y ago
  Gen AI tools are being used by teams of writers, directors, editors, and VFX artists. These aren't prompted end-to-end. There's a tremendous amount of work being done. For end-to-end, go to Show Runner AI. Or look up SpongeBob AI on YouTube.

Palomides 1y ago

there is a very strong implicit claim in what you're saying: that AI video output is usefully comparable to human output

kaonwarb 1y ago

I agree the impact on generative media is huge. But I also do not think anyone is making a $100m-equivalent film for $20k anytime soon. Disprove me by doing it!

queenkjuul 1y ago
Don't hold your breath

suddenlybananas 1y ago

>a $100M Disney film will be matched by small studios on budgets of $20,000 I do not believe this is true.

tovej 1y ago

5000x is hilarious (as is 5x and 100x). When you make outlandish claims, at least provide a reference or analysis.

amelius 1y ago
5000x if you ignore the electricity bill ;)
CyberDildonics 1y ago
This person predicted two years ago that by now teenagers would be creating star wars quality movies in their bedrooms with AI.

viraptor 1y ago

> customers that are bidding $30k for pharmaceutical ad spots they used to bid $300k for How does this work? If the quality ads are easier to produce, wouldn't there be more competition for the same spot with more leftover money for bidding? Why would this situation reduce the cost of a spot?

maxbond 1y ago

Can you point to a film that has used this technology? Can you point to anything that substantiates those numbers? Genuinely asking, my mind is open to the possibility but I don't want to take it on faith. (I watched that Kalshi ad to be clear.)

JimDabell 1y ago
Not those numbers, but you might be interested in Netflix using generative AI: > Using AI-powered tools, they were able to achieve an amazing result with remarkable speed and, in fact, that VFX sequence was completed 10 times faster than it could have been completed with traditional VFX tools and workflows > The cost of [the special effects without AI] just wouldn’t have been feasible for a show in that budget — https://www.theguardian.com/media/2025/jul/18/netflix-uses-generative-ai-in-show-for-first-time-el-eternauta https://www.theguardian.com/media/2025/jul/18/netflix-uses-g... Discussed on Hacker News here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44602779 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44602779
Karawebnetwork 1y ago
The best example I've seen so far is this one: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gx8rMzlG29Q https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gx8rMzlG29Q Personally, I'm not particularly impressed. Yes, I'm impressed by the technology and the fact that we've reached a point where something like this is even possible, but in my opinion, it's soulless and suffers from the same problems as other AI videos. More emphasis was placed on length than quality, and I've seen shorter, traditionally produced videos that had more heart. That's probably because these videos were created by amateurs who thought the AI would fill in all the gaps, but that only underscores the need for human artists with a keen eye.

Cthulhu_ 1y ago

While in theory you're right - AI tools can "democratize" filmmaking - what will make them unique? There was another anecdote, someone saying "this AI can generate 30.000 screenplays in a day!". Which is cool but... who is going to read them? In theory (idk it probably exists already) you can generate a script and feed it into an AI that generates a film. Novelty aside, who is going to watch it? And what if you generate a hundred films a day? A thousand? This probably isn't a hypothetical scenario, as low-effort / generated content is already a thing, both writing, video and music. It's an enormous long tail on e.g. youtube, amazon, etc, relying on people passively consuming content without paying too much attention to it. The background muzak of everything. As someone smarter than me summarized, AI generated stuff is content, not art. AI generated films will be content, not art. There may be something compelling in there, but ultimately, it'll flood the market, become ubiquitous, and disappear into the background as AI generated background noise that only few people will seek out or watch intentionally.

echelon 1y ago
Hollywood is nepo land. That's not fair. Do you know how many dreamers and artists and great ideas wither away on the vine? It's tragic. Movies are going to be like books today. And that's not a bad thing. Distribution is always the hard part. Indie games, indie music. You've still got to market yourself and find your audience. But the difference is that now it's possible. And you don't have to obey some large capital distributor and mind their oversight and meddling.
- CyberDildonics 1y ago
  Hollywood is nepo land. Says who? Do you know how many dreamers and artists and great ideas wither away on the vine? How many? Movies are going to be like books today. People are already creating movies with $1k cameras that look good enough to distribute. A lot of them are horror movies because of the budget and most of them are terrible with huge glaring mistakes in editing, pacing, framing, etc. but they can still make money. And you don't have to obey some large capital distributor and mind their oversight and meddling. How many movies have you worked on? Most experienced executives can help guide priorities and make sure there aren't any big overlooked problems.

UncleMeat 1y ago

$20,000 is a budget for what, one animator for three months? What does "a small studio with a budget of $20,000" even look like?

ygritte 1y ago

Why would I prefer a film that was generated by you pressing a button over a film that was generated by me pressing the same button?

echelon 1y ago
Gen AI tools are being used by teams of writers, directors, editors, and VFX artists. These aren't prompted end-to-end. There's a tremendous amount of work being done. For end-to-end, go to Show Runner AI. Or look up SpongeBob AI on YouTube.