5 ms·
The choice to use charity is a nice move here, but I still think it's kind of a poor choice. The indie games community in particular is an example where lots o
by kevingadd 14y ago
The choice to use charity is a nice move here, but I still think it's kind of a poor choice.
The indie games community in particular is an example where lots of 'outsiders' with very limited access to resources are able to build interesting games that speak loudly and provide experiences people have never seen before. Many of those people cannot afford even an extra $100 to submit a game to a service like Greenlight just for a chance to share it with people (the same complaint has often been lodged against competitions like the IGF), and end up having to beg fans to help them handle it.
For someone earning minimum wage, a $100 donation - which seems tiny to me, used to Silicon Valley salaries - is over a day's worth of take-home pay.
A fee this large skews the effort involved in a Greenlight submission such that it is dramatically in favor of people for whom money does not mean much, and has the unfortunate effect of excluding developers who are perfectly willing to invest TIME into their games but do not have extra money to give away just to get into a public voting competition. The games are not worse just because the authors are poor.
Note that services like Apple and Microsoft's marketplaces at least provide some value for your $99: They host your game, they perform basic quality certification, etc. In this case you aren't getting as much for the expense.
EDIT: Some additional thoughts:
Offloading the fees directly onto charity means that the impact of a potential chargeback (most likely to come from a jerk who is looking to put fake entries up for laughs) is more dramatic than it would be otherwise. Now the bill for a chargeback is potentially being sent to the charity (though I'm sure in this case Valve would choose to eat the fees.)
If the goal is merely to filter out joke submissions, the fee does not need to be remotely as high as $100. SomethingAwful uses a much lower cost for forum registrations which does help to filter out noise.
On the other hand, SomethingAwful is proof that a fee is not sufficient to keep trolls, unkind individuals, stupid people and all-around jerks away from your community. Valve can set the fee as high as they want and bad things will still happen.
The problems that currently afflict Greenlight require a serious approach to moderation and a serious approach to content discovery. Right now their approach to both is lackluster at best: The only way to discourage poor behavior on the part of a game creator is the Report button, while poor behavior on the part of commenters generates zero retribution (the most a creator can do is ban them from their game page). Game discovery is nonexistent as there is a single randomly-sorted list of games that reshuffles itself as you page through, making it impossible to simply browse. Even something as simple as 'people who upvoted this game also liked' is not present here.
At present Greenlight is basically a popularity contest, with a group of around ~15 games currently boasting visitor counts in the hundreds of thousands with the rest of the games on the service sitting around 5 to 10 thousand. If Valve's goal was a popularity contest, it makes the idea of paying money to participate all the more ridiculous.
- Dylan16807 14y agoI think the fee does need to be higher than a somethingawful-level price. Ten dollars is not going to be a significant barrier to casual trolling. One hundred is. If you have a solid game, you should be able to sell enough copies off of greenlight to pay for the fee. I don't think there will be much issue with chargebacks. People might make them, but unless the credit card companies are completely off-the-ball they will treat a donation to charity as a donation to charity. But maybe I'm too optimistic there. Greenlight is supposed to be a popularity contest. All the games get thousands of views which means good games are not easily missed. Then people take the good ones and share them to friends and friends of friends and blogs and news sites etc.
- kevingadd 14y agoThe issue with the fee is not whether you will make the money back. The issue is that it's $100 being spent for literally nothing unless you get lucky enough to get a Steam contract, and if you get that contract, it will be months (or years) before your game actually goes up and sells copies. Then, finally, you can sell the few hundred copies it will take to earn $100 after valve takes their (reportedly as high as 40%) cut of the revenue (after they discount your prices during the Steam Sale). Again, for someone like you or me, that money probably doesn't matter, but I know a few devs who have spent time homeless. It's not exactly a profitable line of work to be in. Re: Chargebacks: For Valve to know that you donated, the payment will probably have to be processed by Valve. This makes it more likely that CC companies will honor a chargeback, because Valve has an abysmal customer service record that includes explicitly telling customers that chargebacks are illegal (when they're not only legal, but appropriate in cases where Valve refuses to refund customers for nonfunctional products). I do agree that it is unlikely to be a big issue.
- Dylan16807 14y agoThe wait sounds like a far worse problem than the payment in that case. Steam is flat-out not a good distribution platform for people that are really struggling, and greenlight isn't changing that.
- 14y ago