5 ms·
Researchers map where solar energy delivers the biggest climate payoff
- metonymy 1y agoexcept there's no map!
- jtbaker 1y agoyou had one job!
- dmead 1y agoIt's like reading an article about a painting. I think this might be the worst experience.
- s1mon 1y agoAnd "California" is a huge area. I doubt that the entire state is ideal for solar. I was hoping to see an actual map and zoom in on my neighborhood. I want to know if it makes sense to install on my house. This is zero help.
- maigret 1y agoYou need to ask a contractor to check your roof orientation and potential shade sources (trees, big mountain? You should be aware about those already). Other factors are pretty much not relevant. Also remember that light, not sun shine, matters. Light clouds might still allow the panels to work very efficiently.
- olddustytrail 1y agoSolar doesn't have to be "ideal" to be practical. The whole of the UK is north of California and solar is certainly deployed here.
- andsoitis 1y agoVerb vs noun
- liquidise 1y agoDirect study link (with associated diagrams): https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/sciadv.adq5660 https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/sciadv.adq5660
- csense 1y agoThe study compares a percentage increase of solar power against an absolute decrease of CO2 emissions. This seems like questionable reasoning to me. If California has 100 MW of solar power for every 10 MW in Indiana, a 10% increase in solar will show up as 10x more CO2 savings for California just because it has a larger installed base. To me the relevant question is the relative dirtiness of the nonrenewables being replaced, and the relative cost and effectiveness of solar. IMHO the data ought to be normalized to a per-MW-installed-rating basis. I wish the study went like this (all the following numbers are completely made up, based on nothing more than the fertile imagination of an HN commentator mildly annoyed by the study's questionable numeracy): - In California, clouds / latitude / etc. mean a panel's only usable 10/24 hours on average per day - In Indiana, the geography's less ideal, so clouds / latitude / etc. make it usable 8/24 hours on an average day - In California, it would be replacing a super-clean natural gas plant installed in 2008 that has expensive high-tech emissions control devices required by the super-strict California environmental regulations and emits 0.4 tons of CO2 per MWH. - In Indiana, there was no money or political will for modern power plants or strict environmental regulations, so the solar panel would be replacing a smoke belching coal plant from the previous millenium that emits 1.2 tons of CO2 per MWH. - In California, labor for >1 MW solar installations costs $0.20 / W, costs are inflated by high CoL / taxes and business unfriendly regulations but there are lots of firms with experience who can install quickly. - In Indiana, labor for >1 MW solar installations is $0.15 / W, they pay a lot less and don't have as much red tape, which slightly outweighs the fact installers don't have much experience and bumble around being slow and making expensive mistakes. - Your per-watt cost is $0.20 / (10/24) = $0.48 in California but $0.15 / (8/24) = $0.45 in Indiana (which is also your per-MW cost in millions). - Your daily emissions reduction is 0.4 x 10 = 4.0 tons for California and 1.2 x 8 = 9.6 tons emissions reduction for Indiana. - Therefore every $1M spent in California buys 4.0 / $0.48 = 8.3 tons / day of emissions reduction and every $1M spent in Indiana buys 9.6 / .45 = 21.3 tons / day of emissions reduction. If you care about efficiently spending money to reduce emissions, in this example (using made-up numbers) Indiana is the low-hanging fruit, investments there are better by a factor of 21.3 / 8.3 ~ 2.6. But the way the study's written, if we assume solar is currently 2000 MW for California and 200 MW for Indiana, its calculations would suggest a 10% increase in California (200 MW) would save 200 x 4.0 = 800 tons and a 10% increase in Indiana would save 20 x 9.6 = 192 tons. This is very misleading. If you don't think about the units and just look at the numbers, you might be tempted to conclude the study's telling you that California's emissions reduction rating is 800 and Indiana's rating is 192, so if you care about CO2 reduction every dollar of investment is a factor of 4 as effective in California -- when in reality, with these numbers every dollar is actually a factor of 2.6 more effective in Indiana.
- rdtsc 1y agoGH project with a link to the data and the instructions how to process it https://github.com/NSAPH-Projects/green-energy-optimization https://github.com/NSAPH-Projects/green-energy-optimization
- gsf_emergency_2 1y ago"raw data" is from EIA (a veritable rabbit hole!) >EIA publishes hourly operational data across the United States electricity grid, including demand, net generation of electricity from various sources (such as coal, natural gas, solar), CO2 emissions, import/export to other regions, and many more. The complete details of the EIA-930 data is available here: https://www.eia.gov/electricity/gridmonitor/about https://www.eia.gov/electricity/gridmonitor/about. Furthermore, we obtained the solar capacities of each year and each region from EIA (https://www.eia.gov/electricity/data/state/ https://www.eia.gov/electricity/data/state/) and had stored the information in the file solar_capacity_factor.csv. (2023-07-01)
- smadge 1y agoCalifornia has the opportunity to be a beacon in North America for environmental and climate action e.g. by expanding solar production, finishing the CAHSR, and other projects like expanding and electrifying mass transit and commuter rail networks, but they are their own worst enemy.
- oceanplexian 1y agoCalifornia has already fallen behind both Texas and Florida in new utility grade solar. As for CA-HSR, no comment. But if you don't want to wait, you can buy a ticket today and ride Florida's new high speed rail between Orlando and Miami.
- drtz 1y agoThe fact that Brightline can take you from Miami to Orlando is wonderful, and I'm really happy Florida is embracing more efficient, less dangerous, and less stressful forms of transportation. But using it to make a subtle jab agains CAHSR isn't really fair -- they're two very different projects (for one of them, it's genuinely a stretch to call it "HSR") in two very different regions. Yes, it's harder to get big projects through the red tape in California than it is in West / Panhandle Texas or Central Florida. Go take a drive through those regions and you'll quickly see some reasons why, besides just NIMBYism, Californians are a bit more protective of their landscapes. If a massive wind project were proposed across large swaths of the Texas Hillcountry, you'd see a lot more push-back.
- drtz 1y agoAlso, fwiw, we've had an HSR project in the works in Texas for a couple decades now and have yet to even make a solid plan, much less break ground.
- renewiltord 1y ago> But using it to make a subtle jab agains CAHSR isn't really fair -- they're two very different projects (for one of them, it's genuinely a stretch to call it "HSR") in two very different regions. Well, CA HSR doesn't exist. It's missing the R part of the HSR. So that must be the one it's a stretch to call "HSR".
- sophia01 1y agoWhen I read "map", I think "map"...
- searine 1y agoFunded by US taxpayers via 11 grants, predominantly from NIH with additional institutional support from Harvard University.
- m0llusk 1y agoThis kind of reasoning and technology would never have predicted the surge in popularity of patio solar in Germany.
- nandomrumber 1y agoGermany electricity: €0.3943 / kWh That's about US$0.46 or AU$0.71 per kWh That largely explains the surge in popularity of patio solar in Germany.
- adrianN 1y agoThe important part of making it popular was changing laws to make it dead simple to install.
- nandomrumber 1y agoThe important part is cheap abundant energy obviates the need for the average person to have to worry about being their own electricity generator.
- arlcode 1y agoJust a small correction but 39cts is a pretty bad price even for Germany. You'll typically get ~30 these days with minimal comparison. Still expensive but a full quarter less.
- nandomrumber 1y agoGood to know
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- ViewTrick1002 1y agoAnd mostly coming from taxes. The wholesale price and plus covering the subsidies would lead to a much lower cost.
- sabaimran 1y ago> The central finding is that a 15% increase in solar generation across the U.S. is associated with an annual reduction of 8.54 million metric tons (MMT) of CO2, a significant step toward national climate goals. Whoa, that's really cool. You can see the paper along with figures & regional breakdowns here: https://openpaper.ai/paper/share/1d0c6956-4820-4ee2-ac1e-12c86d550ab2 https://openpaper.ai/paper/share/1d0c6956-4820-4ee2-ac1e-12c...
- spwa4 1y ago[flagged]
- colechristensen 1y agoThe reason this is a stupid argument is that solar power is significantly cheaper than fossil fuel power almost everywhere. And not in a "calculating all of the global impacts" way, in the very direct, greedy, "I want the cheapest electricity possible" way. "Whatabout"s with storage and time of day, etc. aren't necessary, battery tech is cheap and solar production is so cheap you can do inefficient things with it (panels at non-ideal angles to get more power at off peak hours) and still come out ahead. I really doubt China is installing solar at insane rates to be nice to the world.
- putinapologist 1y ago[dead]
- squigz 1y agoI don't think Jevon's Paradox is applicable here? This is about solar becoming more efficient. In any case, if the argument is that oil is going to be pumped regardless of how much it's actually used, can we not just save it for a rainy day, so to speak?
- spwa4 1y agoNo because we cannot store large amounts of oil. We can store a few weeks of oil, and that's it. That's why, for example, Putin burned it off: if he doesn't cut supply, he can't store it. But that isn't a Russian problem, that's a global problem. Losses through burnoff are typical in the industry, which is why equipment for large scale burnoff even exists: for various logistical problems. If oil can't be taken out of pumps or refineries, and it's not worth it to take production offline due to restart costs, they just burn it right there. For no useful work.
- lorenzohess 1y agoOn Mercury
- rbanffy 1y agoMercury's climate wouldn't benefit much.
- pards 1y ago> In some areas, such as California, Florida, the mid-Atlantic, the Midwest, Texas and the Southwest, small increases in solar were estimated to deliver large CO2 reductions, while in others, such as New England, the central U.S., and Tennessee, impacts were found to be minimal
- m101 1y agoThis sort of study is dumb as it misses the bigger picture. The focus on CO2 is for climate purposes. If one is genuinely concerned about the environment then one would look at all power generation technologies, not only solar. If one did this then solar would not be a focus of concern for power generation. Articles like this one suggest that solar is an answer to climate change, when, at best, it is a distraction.
- boringg 1y agoI agree that this kind of exercise is only academic in nature and mostly useless pragmatically once you layer in the complexities of energy markets. I actually would say the solutions to climate change from a grid perspective are pretty straightforward but tough to implement. New generation: Large nuclear hubs, smrs, solar and battery. hydro and wind as is.