10 ms·
Ubiquiti launches UniFi OS Server for self-hosting
- prrar 1y agoI have a full Ubiquiti stack at home (router, switches, cameras and APs) and they are great products. The UI keeps getting better and that’s a plus!
- carimura 1y agoAfter many (many!) years I finally got around to my childhood dreams of building a home network rack, centered around the Unifi stack. I've got the new 10 gig switch, the dream machine SE, a bunch of cameras, and I've been very impressed with their stuff. The experience "just works" and feels like they take inspiration from Apple. The whole camera setup can be "closed" by shutting off outside access, this self-hosting option takes it all a step further for those who care deeply about privacy!
- whalesalad 1y ago> feels like they take inspiration from Apple the founders are ex-Apple
- AlexandrB 1y agoThere's one big gotcha with Unifi cameras, where you have to cloud-connect your Unifi system if you want "AI" detections[1] (anything other than simple motion detection). I'm hoping they fix it some day[2], but for now I just have motion detection on my Unifi hardware. If this is a problem for you, make sure you understand the tradeoffs here before you commit to a Unifi system. [1] https://old.reddit.com/r/Ubiquiti/comments/1cifnut/unifi_protect_now_requires_cloudremote_access_for/ https://old.reddit.com/r/Ubiquiti/comments/1cifnut/unifi_pro... [2] https://old.reddit.com/r/Ubiquiti/comments/1dbyvan/home_assistant_users_with_unifi_protect/l7yq5qx/?context=3 https://old.reddit.com/r/Ubiquiti/comments/1dbyvan/home_assi...
- alt227 1y agoStill dont understand why this is such a big issue, and I have been reading threads about it for a year now. Just turn on cloud access, accept the t&cs and then turn it off again. If you are really scared then you can isolate that device in a vlan or DMZ temporarily. I run many commercial and residential networks, and this is definitely a non issue for me.
- paulryanrogers 1y agoWill it still get automatic updates in case of security issues?
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- oceanplexian 1y agoI stopped buying Ubiquiti when I reset my UDM Pro and took it to another house without internet access, and it refused to "activate" without an Internet Connection or a phone app connection. Seems they are more interested in selling a lifestyle rather than actual production network equipment.
- jeremywho 1y agoWhat are you using instead?
- ThePowerOfFuet 1y agoOPNsense.
- ungreased0675 1y agoI’m also curious what other prosumer network hardware companies have good products?
- thebruce87m 1y agoIf only the system would cope with power outages I would agree. My viewports refuse to reconnect to the cameras and need multiple forgets/adoptions to come back to life. The (wired) cameras themselves take hours before they show up again, except for the (WiFi) doorbell. During this period I can see the all online via the managed ubiquiti switches.
- Ultimatt 1y agoSurely the expected solution for that is a UPS on the POE switch?
- alt227 1y agoI agree, not sure why you are being downvoted.
- vel0city 1y agoIt's not a solution, its kicking the can down the road. What happens with the UPS battery dies and the power comes back on? The cameras are still down for an unacceptable amount of time because of poor software. The cameras should reassociate almost immediately after regaining a connection. It shouldn't take hours for them to try and connect again. I won't fault the camera for going down when the power dies, I will fault it for not coming back immediately after the power comes back though!
- subscribed 1y agoUmmm..... So the solution to cameras taking several hours to take back to life is to.... just to make sure the will never go offline? The UPS remark is such an non sequitur. Sure, it's prudent to have one but this doesn't make the bug go away.
- thebruce87m 1y agoA UPS is not a solution for all power outages, just ones short enough to last the UPS uptime. The brains of the system is supposed to be the Cloud Key anyway which has its own built in “UPS” and seems to shut down gracefully if you kill power. The cameras and viewports should not be writing data at all after an initial configuration if designed properly and killing power should present no problems to any system with a read-only filesystem. As someone who designs systems like these it absolutely baffles me.
- amluto 1y agoMy general impression is that it “Just Works” if you don’t do anything remotely interesting with it. Want to create a VLAN with no Internet connectivity? Better test that it actually has no Internet connectivity because the setting doesn’t actually work. Want to use the firewall? Better test all the rules — it’s amazingly buggy. Want to change a WiFi setting without WiFi going down for a minute or two? Good luck — UniFi doesn’t seem to care about making it work. Want to find information (MAC, switch port, DHCP reservation, etc) about a device that uses the same MAC address on multiple VLANs? Good luck — it looks like UniFi utterly flubbed either their database schema or whatever interface their front end uses to talk to their backend about it, and it’s very, very broken. Want to find basically any setting based on online docs? Too bad — they keep moving the settings and not updating the docs.
- stirlo 1y agoThis. They make excellent access points and their lite beam/air fibre products are great. But UniFi has serious limitations when it comes to anything beyond the basics. An off the self Asus all in one home router actually has more features and capabilities.
- alt227 1y ago> An off the self Asus all in one home router actually has more features and capabilities. This is just not true at all. I agree unifi can be buggy at times, and their super clean interface means they need to hide stuff all over the place, but I havent found any network configuration I couldnt do on Unifi yet. Care to elaborate on exactly which functions standard asus routers have over Ubiquiti gear?
- petepete 1y agoI did this in 2023 and my experience has been the same. Had 0 problems other than Sonos being, well, Sonos. Recently set up CCTV at my parents’ with a Cloud Gateway Max, set up a site to site VPN in 3 clicks and now I can support remotely and their Sony smart TV can see my Jellyfin server.
- donmcronald 1y agoIIRC some Sonos issues are related to STP. AFAIK it's, like you said, Sonos being Sonos. Lol.
- bc569a80a344f9c 1y agoHow could a Sonos device possibly interact with spanning tree? Are there Sonos devices that act as bridges?
- Polizeiposaune 1y agoMost of their devices act as bridges; some of the newer ones don't. Some have multiple ethernet ports, and anything that has both an ethernet port and is part of their "sonosnet" mutant-wifi will bridge between sonosnet and their ethernet port(s) with spanning tree using classic (pre-RSTP) link costs. If you're not careful you can end up with the "best" path between two switches going over the sonos-to-sonos wifi.
- justusthane 1y agoThat’s nutty!
- petepete 1y agoYeah, that was exactly it. Unifi have a special page in their docs for dealing with Sonos. https://help.ui.com/hc/en-us/articles/18930473041047-Best-Practices-for-Sonos-Devices https://help.ui.com/hc/en-us/articles/18930473041047-Best-Pr... I ended up connecting everything with a wired connection and disabling WiFi. Thankfully I have cat6 to every room so it wasn't an inconvenience. It's worked perfectly since.
- anotherhue 1y agoI am more interested in your childhood than your network at this point.
- kwanbix 1y agoI really love my Dream Machine. Super reliable. What I don't like that much is their UI. It is super weirdly done. It is not natural to use, at least if like me, you use it once every 6 months or more.
- donmcronald 1y agoI like the way they do VLANs. It's easy enough that it can be managed by people that don't understand all the low level terminology.
- esseph 1y agoThat's because Robert Pera, CEO/founder used to work for Apple for a few years when he was very young.
- shermantanktop 1y agoHas he said that? I did a lot of jobs when I was very young. I wouldn't want someone to draw conclusions about me today based on my failed stint at Burger King, for example.
- esseph 1y agoGoogle it. But yes. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robert_Pera#Apple https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robert_Pera#Apple
- 1a527dd5 1y ago> I finally got around to my childhood dreams of building a home network rack My childhood dream was to build crazy buildings, before that it was a space explorer. Not sure a home network rack ever made the list!
- carimura 1y agook well technically my original network dream was rows and rows of 14.4k baud modems, so we've come a ways since then.
- millzlane 1y agoIt would be cool if they brought back the self-hosted security camera solution UniFi Protect.
- alt227 1y agoIm pretty sure it never went away?
- ThatPlayer 1y agoI think he means self-hosted on your own hardware, rather than requiring their Unifi Protect appliances. You used to be able to with their old Unifi Video . Unofficially (and therefore not supported), you can just take their binaries and run it on your own hardware. But since they only support their own hardware and it's arm64 hardware, you only get arm64 binaries: https://github.com/dciancu/unifi-protect-unvr-docker-arm64 https://github.com/dciancu/unifi-protect-unvr-docker-arm64 With them adding generic onvif camera support, I might try it again because the other options aren't amazing either.
- SamuelAdams 1y agoWhat is the advantage of using this over existing OSS solutions?
- w0m 1y agoare there OSS solutions for controlling/configuring unify hardware?
- outworlder 1y agoThere are not.
- Saris 1y agoThis looks to be an executable that deploys podman containers for you, that is bizarre, and makes me question why it's called Unifi 'OS'?
- mwpmaybe 1y agoYes, a virtual appliance or system image a la Home Assistant OS would seem like a better fit...
- Saris 1y agoOr just a docker-compose file, since it's already in container format.
- izacus 1y agoThat would make it impossible to deploy it next to other services on an existing machine... why would you want less flexibility?
- dns_snek 1y agoWhen did it become impossible to run a VM next to other services on an existing machine? As they said, Home Assistant OS works great with that setup and it's rock solid in my experience.
- izacus 1y agoRunning a full resource hungry VM when a container is enough is downright silly. And the HassOS you mention had to go through a lot of work from HASS team to allow for full container runtime so it gets the functionality UniFi's approach has out of the box.
- dns_snek 1y agoI don't think running a VM (at least) for a core piece of network infrastructure is silly at all, in fact I think it would be silly not to. That is something that should never - ever - break because it would be a very bad day if it did. The only way to approach certain stability is by removing variables and making the environment as predictable as you possibly can. Containers partially address this issue by shipping a predictable user-space environment, but that still leaves the kernel. Other examples would include OpenMediaVault, TrueNAS, Mikrotik CHR, VyOS which are all distributed as VM appliances (or host system installs) even though technically, I'm sure all of them could be distributed as containers (and I think VyOS can be used this way, but I don't believe it's meant for production usage). And personally I want a much thicker security boundary that VMs provide when it comes to critical services like network controllers. Of course that would require a slightly different setup to begin with, i.e. having UniFi in one VM, and having random containers in another VM which is how I prefer to run things at home (in general, I don't use UniFi products).
- mtillman 1y agoRecently switched from a UDM Pro Max to a Firewalla Gold Pro and couldn't be happier about the move. Software that works > software that has everything but requires magic to get checkboxes to adhere to a save state-this is a common issue with UniFi Network options. They need far better QA before I recommend anyone use them as an OS. 1 of numerous examples: https://community.ui.com/questions/Device-Static-IP-Not-Saving/00a21041-d275-4544-9d42-3f0b0445d2a5 https://community.ui.com/questions/Device-Static-IP-Not-Savi...
- tiffanyh 1y agoWhat issues did you encounter when using Unifi? From what I’ve seen, Unifi seems like the closest to an "Apple-like" experience - especially given how much more robust their capabilities are compared to most other providers.
- j45 1y agoThat was definitely the case. It's not always the case anymore.
- covercash 1y agoThe idea that Ubiquiti pushes out buggy software as production-ready and that we're all their beta testers is a pretty common meme on their subreddit.
- e40 1y agoYou can easily turn off automatic updates. I check the forum before I update. Haven’t had any issues for 10+ years.
- elteto 1y agoSame, never had an issue. And I also skip the latest couple of minor versions most of the time unless there’s a security bugfix. Gives the updates time to bake.
- 1y ago
- mmastrac 1y agoThis is full circle. You used to be able to host the unifi stack on anything that would run Java. Glad to see them returning to their roots!
- bobbob1921 1y agoI may be misunderstanding this, but as I recall originally the only way to run unifi was to have self hosted it through an app on a Windows machine on your network, then it went to the cloud, then cloud only, and now it seems to be coming back to self hosted? Good if so. (UniFi is their app/system to configure your ubiquiti network devices and to gather stats from them, it really did change the networking industry for such a low cost product at the time)
- natebc 1y agoThere was the little cloud key thing that they had for a while and then there's a version 2 of that. There's also been a container version for quite a while too. Gen 1 cloud key: https://dl.ubnt.com/qsg/UC-CK/UC-CK_EN.html https://dl.ubnt.com/qsg/UC-CK/UC-CK_EN.html Gen 2 cloud key https://store.ui.com/us/en/products/uck-g2 https://store.ui.com/us/en/products/uck-g2 Container from linuxserver.io https://github.com/linuxserver/docker-unifi-network-application https://github.com/linuxserver/docker-unifi-network-applicat...
- taubek 1y agoLast time I used it (some 8 months ago) there was Windows app and mobile app. In order to configure, check what was going on I needed to run app on my Windows computer. I was looking into using docker or something like that, but I switched to another vendor.
- buran77 1y agoUniFi OS Server is similar to the old self hosted solution (the controller) except it can run more of the applications. I used to self host some years ago and only the Network was available. Now the OS supports InnerSpace and Identity too.
- myelin 1y agoThe self-hosted app never went away; I've been running it for the last 8 years or so, first on a MacBook Pro, then a Raspberry Pi, and now a repurposed HP T620 thin client. They promote their cloud controller pretty strongly, followed by the Cloud Key, which is their own preinstalled self hosting setup, but the self-hosted UniFi Network server has stuck around. (It changed names a couple of times; it was the "UniFi Controller", then "UniFi Network Application", and now "UniFi Network Server".)
- JonChesterfield 1y agoThere was a lot of drama around Ubiquity a few years back. Happy to see the company is still alive and the indicator that they're coming back around to self hosting. All the hardware I bought a decade ago is still running fine (without any of the cloud software) and it looks like their newer stuff would be worth the upgrade (10gb everywhere, easily, at last).
- s0ss 1y agoAs far as I can see, they still flirt with vendor lock in. None of their cameras supported ONVIF when I researched this previously. Nice hardware, lame software choices, IMO.
- Catbert59 1y agoThey support ONVIF now in their backend.
- baby_souffle 1y ago> They support ONVIF now in their backend. Got a link? I'm curious about which profile(s) and does this mean that it's still proprietary between the NVR and camera but from the NVR I can get an onvif profile compatible feed?
- sashk 1y agoYou can bring ONVIF compatible camera into NVR, but you won't get any detections unless you use AI Key...
- varenc 1y agoThe "UniFi Protect" NVR server can ingest a feed from a 3rd party ONVIF camera, but I don't believe Ubiquiti's own cameras can expose themselves over ONVIF. Their camera's still seemed locked to their NVR software. (Though they do have a very basic managment interface hosted on themselves, and you can ssh into them)
- nkotov 1y agoLove Ubiquiti devices. Easy to manage in environments who don't have strict requirements.
- Aurornis 1y agoYou could always self-host UniFi Network. https://help.ui.com/hc/en-us/articles/360012282453-Self-Hosting-a-UniFi-Network-Server https://help.ui.com/hc/en-us/articles/360012282453-Self-Host... This launches with UniFi Network and UniFi InnerSpace, which is a deployment visualization tool. I assume they'll add more of the applications to UniFi OS in the future
- j45 1y agoThis reminds me of the types of applications that are installed on the Ubquiti Dream Machine Pro. Ubiquiti has a pretty smooth setup that works well together, the recent years of reliability issues, updates, and data security issues however has been enough to stop buying Ubiquiti and protect it with other gear such as NetGate firewalls. The Dream Machine Pro had lost some critical advanced configurability from the ui and command line compared to it's predecessor, leaving a lot of users in no man's land. Some of it has been resolved from what I can tell. I own one and had to supplement it with another device in front of it temporarily. Once things are in production, we usually don't look for reasons to touch it. If your internet is 1 gig or less, I'll still vouch for the trusty littel EdgeRouter X, there's a great guide on setting up a nice little home network on it to learn which direction your next steps will be like. Hopefully this proves itself in a year and it's an easy decision.
- xyzzy123 1y agoIt turned out to be surprisingly annoying to do this on Debian due to the MongoDB requirement. I forget the exact difficulties but I ended up having to punt and run the container from linuxserver.io.
- beembeem 1y agoWhat hardware were you using to host it?
- xyzzy123 1y agoAhhh that's it, I think. It was on ODROID H3+, these run on pentium silver N6005 which don't support AVX, which means that "newer" MongoDB won't work without jumping through hoops to compile from source. I just ssh'd into the vm where I run it and it seems like I DID eventually get it working - with mongodb 4.4.x but it's not supported anymore :(
- johann8384 1y agoHow is this different than the docker container I am running now? I must be missing a detail or two.
- bri3d 1y agoYou're probably running what's currently called, I think, UniFi Network Server (at one point it was UniFi Controller?). That lets you configure networking devices but it isn't the "full" Ubiquiti ecosystem (Identity, Site Manager/SD-WAN/Teleport). Basically before you could run one "app" (the network management one) locally, but Unifi ship a grid of cloud "apps" that you see when you log into unifi.ui.com . Now they're shipping the thing that hosts the grid itself (enabling multi-site stuff like SD-WAN and the firmware update server), some more of the apps (Identity) and presumably they'll roll out more apps in the future.
- JCBird1012 1y ago1. This is an official Docker image/container from Ubiquiti themselves - no more relying on LinuxServer.io/jacobalberty, etc... 2. With the "UniFI OS" branding, the door is open to the possibility of being able to run Talk, Protect, Access, etc... on your own hardware in the future.
- jp191919 1y agoI'm not seeing an official docker image...
- JCBird1012 1y agoIt’s there - just built into the binary. ;) but yeah that was upsetting - I was hoping they’d push them to a registry and make them… more available.
- MobileVet 1y agoI toast jacobalberty once or twice a year when I login to my Synology / Docker / UniFi Controller app and gaze upon the pretty graphs and throughput visualizer. Love it. Thank you kind sir for your work! As others have said, UniFi had some tough years but that early stuff just works and my uptime is in years.
- dan_pixelflow 1y agoI've been self-hosting a Unifi controller (now called 'Unifi Network') for years in a Docker container, and before that I'd run it on a Windows machine whenever I needed to make changes to the configuration - I assume this pivot to call the self-hosted version 'UniFi OS' implies a future where more than just the Network application can be self-hosted.
- accrual 1y agoWhat do you like to use the UniFi controller container for? I've tried hosting the same container before but it never seemed to properly "marry" to my UniFi AP, or it would forget the AP the next day, etc. For now I just use the iOS app which is sufficient to update the AP firmware occasionally, but I wish I could get all the insights of the controller.
- nirav72 1y agoI had that problem before. You can fix that by SSH'ing into your AP and setting the inform IP to point to your controller. Just make sure the IP address of the host that's running the controller container is static. https://www.unihosted.com/blog/how-to-set-inform-in-unifi-a-guide https://www.unihosted.com/blog/how-to-set-inform-in-unifi-a-...
- accrual 1y agoThanks! I'll give it a try!
- jiri 1y agoI used to run in on raspberry pi, it worked flawlessly. Its like a hardware container ;-)
- irusensei 1y agoI'm curious how is this different from the controller software.
- bri3d 1y agoIt's the level above; it's the thing that hosts the "grid of apps" you see on unifi.ui.com or on a Dream Machine, for example. The Network / Controller app is just one "app" in the "grid of apps." (I get the feeling that the current Controller app was also forked at some point and this might clean that up too, but I haven't looked into the software to see if that's the case yet). To start, it seems to allow for the multi-site coordinated tools like MD-WAN to work with self-hosted OS installation, and they added Innerspace and Identity (which I suppose is necessary since I think that's how the login works) as "launch" apps. Presumably they'll roll more out in the future - ideally you could fully self-host stuff like Protect.
- lapetitejort 1y agoI set up a small Ubiquiti setup with Pi-hole, then moved into a home serviced by AT&T Fiber, which comes with an all in one fiber modem and WiFi hub. I started using it before I could unpack, then did a little research on how I could disable WiFi, DHCP, and/or DNS in order to use my own equipment. The WiFi isn't great in all parts of the house so I planned on setting up APs at strategic points. But of course laziness, fear of stuff breaking and my family getting mad at me, and WiFi entrenchment has stopped me from using any of the equipment I bought. I would one day love to switch back over, but I just don't see it happening soon.
- NoMoreNicksLeft 1y agoThere was a guy on dslreports selling certificates for $10 each, and you could just load it up into one of the cheap sfp modules off of aliexpress. Plug it straight into the router of your choice. No reason to use their junk. I've done the same with a different provider.
- a2tech 1y agoThis is interesting--do you have a link to the sale or instructions as to how that was working?
- NoMoreNicksLeft 1y agohttp://dslreports.com/ http://dslreports.com/ You'd have to poke around in the forums. I'm not sure what the best keywords to search with would be. The gist of it is only AT&T ONTs can connect, because it's using certificate fuckery, but there was a guy buying those up for $1 or $5 or something on ebay, jtag-ing the certs off of those, and selling them for $10 each. There were instructions for how to program the sfp module to use those, and when I got mine those modules were only about $50 each (no idea what they're now with the tariff nonsense). You'd need a router that can accept those, I've got a Mikrotik. I think Ubiquiti has a prosumer router with one too that's not too crazy. At the time (3 years ago-ish), no one had figured out a way to do it with AT&T 5gig service. But for that you'd need something with SFP+ slots, and those are seriously pricey.
- tcdent 1y agoOriginal announcement from UniFI: https://blog.ui.com/article/introducing-unifi-os-server https://blog.ui.com/article/introducing-unifi-os-server
- Arrowmaster 1y ago># src: Mirano Verhoef ># Go into root >su - > ># Install all required dependencies apt update ; apt upgrade ; apt install podman -y ; cd ~ ; mkdir 4.2.23 ; cd 4.2.23 ; wget https://fw-download.ubnt.com/data/unifi-os-server/8b93-linux-x64-4.2.23-158fa00b-6b2c-4cd8-94ea-e92bc4a81369.23-x64 https://fw-download.ubnt.com/data/unifi-os-server/8b93-linux... ; chmod +x 8b93-linux-x64-4.2.23-158fa00b-6b2c-4cd8-94ea-e92bc4a81369.23-x64 ; ./8b93-linux-x64-4.2.23-158fa00b-6b2c-4cd8-94ea-e92bc4a81369.23-x64 install This is some of the jankiest install installations I've seen in a long time. Not even using && to stop on an error, just plowing ahead for more errors to stack up.
- arm32 1y agoTheir code must be perfect and thus no need to worry about pesky errors.
- verandaguy 1y agoMy issue with this comment is my issue with the original article -- what's the actual source for this information? As far as I can tell, this article has no actual link back to any Unifi press release, git repo, or other project page about this, the closest the author does is link the downloads from Ubiquiti's site (as in, literally, links to the files, and nothing else). This is janky, yes, and I'm not gonna shill for Ubiquiti, but for lack of a legitimate source, I don't think this is a fair representation of the actual install steps.
- moontear 1y agoThe actual source is this: https://community.ui.com/releases/UniFi-OS-Server-4-2-23/21df94e9-55d6-4298-b849-fbef3e3b1dd6 https://community.ui.com/releases/UniFi-OS-Server-4-2-23/21d... but only accessible if you opt-in to the Unifi Early Access program. We are talking beta software / first release here, so any criticism needs to be looked at through that lens. Also there is the official announcement now: https://blog.ui.com/article/introducing-unifi-os-server https://blog.ui.com/article/introducing-unifi-os-server
- 1y ago
- InTheArena 1y agoThis is awesome because of how un-Apple-like it is. With Apple, they leverage the ecosystem and force you to buy everything to make a cohesive experience. Want to have cellular on your Mac? We expect you to buy an iPhone and a laptop and tether. If you want to have unifi WAPS without the UCG - this enables that. It's awesome that they do that, even though right now, it's the cohesiveness of the Unifi ecosystem that is a big driver in their success.
- Aurornis 1y ago> If you want to have unifi WAPS without the UCG - this enables that. You could always do this. UniFi Network always had a self-install option.
- JCBird1012 1y agoEven better - you don't even have to run Network - UniFi APs have standalone mode - https://help.ui.com/hc/en-us/articles/12594679474071-Standalone-Access-Points-without-UniFi https://help.ui.com/hc/en-us/articles/12594679474071-Standal...
- victor_vhv 1y agoI love the idea of centrally managing network infrastructure that can be ‘self-contained’ in a local service (whether a device, VM, or container). TP-Link offers a similar solution via their ‘Omada’-enabled devices. Unfortunately, mixing different brands can feel counterproductive, so there’s significant vendor lock-in. Does anyone know of a similar solution for OpenWrt devices?
- victor_vhv 1y agoSelf answering here: Seems like OpenWisp[1] is what I was looking for. I haven't used it yet, but I'm adding it to my bucketlist (currently using Omada, but a bit dissapointed with the sluginess) [1] https://openwisp.org/ https://openwisp.org/
- baby_souffle 1y ago> Seems like OpenWisp[1] is what I was looking for. When I last looked into openWISP, it was a pretty good effort but has a very hard dependency on openWRT. If your entire network is not made up of hardware that has "good/stable" openWRT support then you're going to have a bad time. I don't think there are any 10g switches that run openWRT well yet, for example. [0] [0]: Yes, I know openWRT runs on amd/intel but those devices have a few NICs at most. There are no 48 port 1/10gig switches that run openWRT as far as I know...
- random3 1y agoSo UniFi stack is the better alternative to Ring (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44620002 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44620002)? Is UniFi the sweetspot for prosumer networking if one wants switches, APs, cameras, etc. without a CCNP?
- atomicnumber3 1y agoI've been a unifi user for quite a few years, enthusiastically at first and with somewhat more trepidation as of late. They seemed to have some kind of hardware talent exodus a couple years ago, and also when they stopped having self-hostable unifi video and network. I ended up capitulating and just bought a cloud-key but wasn't thrilled. But yes, they still seem to be the best for small business / homelab type people who want something more than "the AT&T guy put a box behind the couch in 1998 and i don't know where it went after that" but also doesn't want to have to do opnsense or a bunch of that stuff. And they've managed to regain my enthusiasm a bit by adding plain-ole wireguard (not even teleport, though i do like teleport for my phone) to their managed VPN options, and now by bringing back self-hosting. My main gripe about lack of self-hosting is, I have a bunch of terabytes just sitting around i could put my video footage of my front lawn on, and it's free real estate. but since i can't (couldn't) self-host video on it, I would've had to pay like hundreds of bucks (or is it thousands?) to get the rackmount video server from them. But now that this is back, hopefully I can switch back to self hosting if my cloudkey ever dies. So that's nice.
- exabrial 1y agoIf I were a hospital, financial brokerage, etc, I would use Cisco. But since we're a small business < 50 employees, with 4 sites (office, call center, colocation, cloud) Ubiquiti makes it unbelievably easy to administer, even though I know I'm leaving plenty of performance on the table in terms of switching performance, latency, QoS, and throughput. Surprised at S2S VPN performance at these price points as well! More than adequate!
- jauntywundrkind 1y agoI really wish PC with some good m.2 wifi cards in it were more of an option for wireless. PC based routers are awesome, there's great software. It's just the wifi situation keeping us tethered to very special boxes. Even openwrt has severe limits. It's up to you to flap on all manners of optimizations and tweaks to what is basically a hostapd.cond file. Hostapd.conf is the gatekeeper of one of the most important connective channels on the planet, and we collectively know so so so little of it. At least the m.2 & m-pcie cards have finally started getting somewhat better availability. It's still 90% Compex reference designs, but they're somewhat purchaseable, after years of this stuff being super hard to get ahold of. Seems usually to be ~$200, for a card that'll do wifi-7 2x2 5+5GHz (ex: Compex WLTE7002E55, using Qualcomm's QCN6274).
- seany 1y agoThat market is pretty small I think, and it's split with the people that jump right to used enterprise aps for their radios (I'm using 3 rukus 850s for instance)
- ThePowerOfFuet 1y agoI use OPNsense with a Ruckus standalone AP. It has been bulletproof.
- JonChesterfield 1y agoGiven the context, Unifi access points work rather well for that. Wired router.
- zamalek 1y agoGet some access points. Something like the TP-Link EAP610[1] (I have not used one of these, yet). [1]: https://git.openwrt.org/?p=openwrt/openwrt.git;a=commit;h=11588c52b47c2c3b2cdc7849ce9e4804bfdb8bb5 https://git.openwrt.org/?p=openwrt/openwrt.git;a=commit;h=11...
- redleader55 1y agoThis is great and I hope they release all the other apps that right now can only be added on a Dream Router/Dream machine, etc. What I would like to see: 1. IPv6. I tried for several days to patch various warts in the Unifi Network Server (the unofficial docker container), to make it run on IPv6 only. Everytime I managed yet another horrible hack in some library they are using, I discovered 4 other bugs that prevent IPv6 only operation. There's always stuff that expects an IPv4 address in Unifi. 2. Managing my own hardware gateway from Unifi UI. I get it that Unifi doesn't make money from supporting this, but it would be very cool. Their gateway is not super complicated, and there are materials explaining how to "adopt" some random device, in the end you still need a cert from the company to make it work.
- nottorp 1y ago> Next, we need to log in with our Ubiquiti account. Right. They don't learn. > You can also proceed without an Ubiquiti account Can you? Or you have to make one and only then maybe possibly to some extent run the thing without one?
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- varenc 1y agoYou really don't need a Ubiquiti account. They of course make it the default, but you can check a "local user only" box and then just create a local user with a username and password. I really appreciate this about them. You don't need internet to set it up.
- nottorp 1y agoGood. Did they fix their APs too or those can't be initialized without an account still?
- varenc 1y agoYou can setup and initialize an AP with a controller, and that controller doesn't require a cloud account or internet access.
- nottorp 1y agoSorry to be paranoid, but is this current info from your personal experience? Because that's how it was years ago, and then they tried to make the cloud account compulsory, and the last time I asked around it was sort of not compulsory but you still needed to create one for the initial setup and only then put your AP somehow in standalone mode.
- ectospheno 1y ago> is this current info from your personal experience? I am not GP but I can provide my perspective. I currently use 5 of their switches and 2 of their APs in my house. You do not need a UI account to use the network server locally to manage the devices. I run my server on a debian 12 box. I locally return nxdomain for several domains they try to lookup. I setup a firewall rule to log any packets from their macs trying to send anything outbound. Apart from my test packets they haven't done so. If you don't nxdomain the domains they lookup then you will see that traffic. I have not tried the new Unifi OS Server this post is about.
- psyclobe 1y agoI have nothing but good things to say about ubiquiti. I run their cameras door bell and network switches at my house and have had nearly 100% uptime for years. Their ui constantly improves and it’s very well integrated into home assistant. Lotta haters out there but this is just advanced as I want to get in my home lab; and the racks are just so cool even with their gimmicky front touch panel, it’s just so sexy when all the displays in the rack sync up on their animations. Whoever designed these things really had an eye for design.
- Already__Taken 1y agoI just think £360 for an IP camera is too steep, half would be a no brainier over ring. Their new Lite switches replace stuff that was rack-mountable, not there's no ears are far as I can tell. The gateways are awesome value.
- Macha 1y agoThey have a lot of camera models, including a lot of cheaper models, starting at €180 for the G6 turret/bullet if you want 4k or €80 for the G5 turret if you want 1080p.
- philjohn 1y agoLooking at the various options, £360 is on the upper end (until you get into the insane DSLR lens one)
- sieabahlpark 1y ago[dead]
- stirbot 1y agoEspecially when they die after 2 years. Bought 3 G4 Pros direct from Ubiquiti and two are dead. Apparently it's just the POE daughterboard but my RMA requests were rejected due to being out of warranty. My cheap Lorex cameras have been running for 8 years now.
- BLKNSLVR 1y ago
- oseqr 1y ago[dead]
- Twey 1y ago(As non-curmudgeonly as possible, this is a genuine question I promise!) I see a bunch of projects and companies these days calling their product an ‘OS’. I'm not too much of a stick-in-the-mud to not see parallels between traditional OSes and things like Kubernetes (which actually doesn't brand itself as an OS, confusingly enough), but I'm genuinely very confused as to what it's supposed to signify in the branding of projects like these — e.g. this seems to just be a server that runs on Windows or Linux and provides a control panel for your UniFi devices and account. Could someone explain to me what the ‘OS’ is supposed to mean here? (Even if it's something very vague like ‘a sense of being a complete solution’!)
- aetherspawn 1y agoSo I’m confused, this is just the network management appliance right, you can’t use this to make a switch or firewall? Seems like a strange sink of capex because the pocket sized network appliance is cheep.
- esseph 1y agoCameras, networking, door controls, etc. Yes it has the whole UniFi Network piece, which is various unifi routers, switches, wireless access points, wireless mesh units, etc.
- mrbluecoat 1y agoDoes it support UniFi Deep Packet Inspection (DPI)? https://www.unihosted.com/blog/understanding-unifi-deep-packet-inspection https://www.unihosted.com/blog/understanding-unifi-deep-pack...
- wolttam 1y agoI will always moan about Ubiquiti's odd software distribution choices. Just publish an OCI image, for goodness sake. "Installer" executables on Linux.. shudders
- hbarka 1y agoI have always viewed Ubiquiti and UniFi as serving only the business and enterprise market, not consumer grade individuals like me. I have gotten frustrated with the Netgear and TP-Link grade of WiFi equipment available to the consumer customer and have now ventured into UniFi. My main challenge was just getting a single SSID to work around a large home. Mesh WiFi held a promise until I found out that they really aren’t that good unless you are using backhaul wiring. Companies have been using single SSIDs for decades and that’s where the solution was.
- EvanAnderson 1y ago> I have always viewed Ubiquiti and UniFi as serving only the business and enterprise market... I've gotten a lot of mileage out of Ubiquiti gear in SMB space, but enterprise it is not. Ruckus, Aruba, and to a lesser extent Cisco (Meraki) own that space. I wouldn't trust Ubiquiti gear to handle the densities that Ruckus gear can, for example. For your home frustrations some cheap Ubiquiti gear and spending the money to cable all your APs will do what you need.
- syntaxing 1y agoI used to do a wireless mesh with U6 (wifi 6) and I 100% agree with you. But with WiFi 7, everything changes. WiFi 7 wireless mesh is actually faster than hardwiring (mainly because my second AP is connected to a 1G flex mini). A WiFi 7 mesh can actually exceed 1G (using Wifiman, I get about 1.5G). Meshing with a WiFi 7 AP works great for me too since all my devices are only WiFi 6 compatible (for now). Highly recommend replacing your APs with a U7-<whatever you want>
- hbarka 1y agoInteresting. That’s sounds really promising. Please tell me more. Are there any YouTube videos or resources you can point to?
- syntaxing 1y agoNot much to it! Buy any Wifi 7 Pro stuff. Don't get the lite, its just not worth it. Especially confusing with Lite because Wifi 7 still works on Wifi 6 stuff but they call it Wifi 7? Hardwire the one closest to your gateway, remotely adopt the others, and youre good to go. Also, double check your frequencies. 1, 6, 11 for 2.4 Ghz. No DFS for 5 Ghz. Scan the environment and try your best. Wifi 7/ 6 Ghz must be same frequency though which is another plus since no ones really has it yet.
- syntaxing 1y agoWhoa this is pretty cool. I’m pretty into homelab stuff but self hosting your own gateway/firewall/router can get pretty tiring. I tried OPNSense and it worked great for a while. I tried self hosting unifiOS (I actually don’t get what’s different from the docker one from back then compared to this one) but it gets annoying. Was easier just to buy a cloud ultra for $130.
- mberning 1y agoWhat is the use case for this? Their cloud gateways are very affordable. Aside from the academic aspects of it I don’t see why I would want to run a home brew version of their cloud gateway.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- kalleboo 1y agoThe only Ubiquiti gear I use are their APs, and have cheaper solutions for routing/switching, so being able to run the controller for the APs as a container on an existing machine is a nice.
- sgjohnson 1y agoMulti-site centralized management if you don't want to use Ubiquiti's cloud. UI has an entire lineup of non-Cloud gateways. This is also for setups without an Ubiquiti gateway. Like a setup with just UI switches or APs.
- Nursie 1y agoIf they add 'Protect' to this, it would make it much easier to start building a unifi network piecemeal. I already have a debian-running storage server, that would be a good fit for running this, and it would enable me to start adding their cameras without going all-in in and grabbing a new router and access points at the same time.
- WesolyKubeczek 1y agoPepperidge Farm remembers that Unifi Protect used to be self-hostable up to version 3.11. I wish it still was so I could have it on my NAS.
- aplummer 1y agoJust bought a dream 7 and so far it’s the best router I’ve owned. The software portal is a cut above
- kassner 1y agoWhat does “OS” in the name stands for? My first thought was “Operating System”, but that doesn’t make sense when what they are providing is a server via a docker container. No one says they installed the Elastic OS… Ubiquiti themselves call it “software package”: > Self‑hosted software package that delivers UniFi Network [1] My second thought was “Open Source”, but the absence of comments complaining about the license make me believe it isn’t this. Any guesses? 1: https://blog.ui.com/article/introducing-unifi-os-server https://blog.ui.com/article/introducing-unifi-os-server
- chrisandchris 1y agoMy guess actually is "Operating System", because this piece of software is required* for operating all your UniFi devices (central management). * Required if not each should be a standalone, some devices won't work without UniFi OS AFAIK.
- chedabob 1y agoThey've borrowed the name from the CloudKey/Dream Machine to make it clear that this will have parity, instead of what we had previously where you could only run some of the apps in isolation that would normally be bundled in the full system image for the CloudKey.
- defraudbah 1y agoAny hardware recommendation to run unifi on? Curious what people recommend for that kind of staff
- ethan_smith 1y agoA small NUC or similar SFF PC with 4GB+ RAM and an SSD works perfectly - I run mine on a Raspberry Pi 4 (8GB) with minimal resource usage.
- defraudbah 1y agothank you kind stranger! Raspberry is godsent
- tobyhinloopen 1y agoThe OS being proprietary was the ONLY reason I doubted to commit to the platform, but this is amazing. If this actually works, I'm comfortable to 100% commit into their stuff.
- mancerayder 1y agoThe common sentiment is that Mikrotik is the gold standard for reliability and, not talking about the terrible UI, you're considered an Adult in networking if you choose to manually configure individual interfaces to do basic things, and it 'just works' Except when it doesn't, and you have to stop your day job to troubleshoot your home network because an interface literally vanishes overnight, when you hadn't touched the router in months. Then there's the wifi radio settings and the terrible CAPman, where I had to Google radio frequency settings and channel configuration (why?). In any case what's this power good for? what's a use case that you want to give up ease of use and central management for configuration power? I'm moving to all Ubiquiti stuff, and so far I love the management tooling that already alerts me and shows me latency stats and packet drops on my network in a status page, including a log. I love that I can use the app to connect my phone to an IPSEC tunnel at home, that I can quickly connect sites. Mikrotik's winbox and web configuration UI seem like they were written by lone developers in basements who never interacted with humans.
- alex-korr 1y agoI own a host of Unifi hardware, but some of it is ridiculously vulnerable to power outages. UDM SE got bricked when I was moving and absentmindedly unplugged it without shutting it down first. Ubiquiti replaced it but cmon...
- beala 1y agoI was just about to shell out $2k on unifi equipment for my home but after reading this discussion it's sounding like a much worse proposition. Sadly, it doesn't seem like there's a solid competitor either. Mikrotik seems like more complication than I want or need. I'm now looking into TP-Link Omada, but the entire point was to move away from consumer gear. Sigh. I guess I'll just keep making do with my old Orbi Netgear setup for now.
- smartbit 1y agoSame here. Unify at least is a US based company, less spying than Chinese TP-link. Would prefer the solid quality, absolute privacy and long term support of AVM Fritzboxes but they don’t have the form factors nor ease of management that Unify (or TP-Link?) offers.