3 ms·
The Chrome experience is actually part of a new standard, Federated Credential Management (or FedCM for short). The idea is to create a browser mediated login
by mooreds 1y ago
The Chrome experience is actually part of a new standard, Federated Credential Management (or FedCM for short).
The idea is to create a browser mediated login experience that gives the identity provider and web app what they need without being able to correlate requests across the Internet.
I am working on an article on this topic. If you are interested in learning more, here's a video from a recent auth focused conference (full disclosure: my company put it on and I emceed): https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=FBAD4x7MWdI https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=FBAD4x7MWdI
They are actively working on the standard and Firefox has committed to it. Edge already supports it. They are looking for identity provider feedback.
More here: https://github.com/w3c-fedid/FedCM https://github.com/w3c-fedid/FedCM (we meet weekly on Tuesdays).
- michaelt 1y agoI'm curious - how does the standard make "to continue, google.com will share your name, e-mail address and profile picture" compatible with "a modern, privacy-preserving standard for federated identity on the web" ?? I mean, that doesn't sound privacy-preserving at all?
- benlivengood 1y agoWhy would you share your real name with Google when making a gmail account, or use your real picture? It's fine to be pseudonymous on the Internet if you are in control of your pseudonyms, which Google accounts actually does allow with some extra work (don't mix your chrome profiles and Google accounts, etc.) Or, like me, you can roll the dice on real names on the Internet (for professional things mostly)
- oefrha 1y ago> Why would you share your real name with Google when making a gmail account, or use your real picture? Google made a big push in that direction starting in the Google+ era. IIRC at some point my fake names were rejected by Google and I had to change to more plausible fake names. You can't fault regular people for falling into Big Tech's traps.
- mooreds 1y agoI don't think they are trying to preserve privacy between you and the identity provider you are logging in with and the website you are logging into. (At least not now. There's talk about some of this with IDP delegation, I think. Here's more on that: https://github.com/w3c-fedid/delegation https://github.com/w3c-fedid/delegation ) The first goal is to prevent data brokers from correlating data about users across the Internet using cookies and redirects. You can read more about the privacy focus here: https://www.w3.org/TR/fedcm/#privacy https://www.w3.org/TR/fedcm/#privacy
- aaronpk 1y agoIt refers to the property of FedCM that means nothing about your account is revealed to the website until you click the "Continue As" button. In other words, alternatives to this that use third-party cookies enable tracking you between websites without any user interaction.
- jazzyjackson 1y agoThat sounds really interesting, but is there any hope chrome would allow use of an identity provider other than google?
- sgoto 1y agoYeah, websites can choose any other identity provider, and in fact, do.
- gwbas1c 1y agoCan we block sharing email addresses by default? It seems every time I sign in with Google the site / app starts SPAMming me without my consent. It's pretty much why I don't use it: The SPAM.
- whynotmaybe 1y agoAnd we should also do something about website that consider you a "customer" when you've only started an order and entered your email but you've never pressed submit to complete the order.
- dotancohen 1y agoDoes that happen to you often?
- whynotmaybe 1y agoNot often, but recently. And after giving it some thought, I guess that I'm also in the wrong to believe that I have to press submit somewhere to agree to their policies. This is a "nice" reminder that just entering my email in a text input is enough to send it to any website.
- dotancohen 1y agoI love how the word submit takes on a second meaning in this context.
- mkipper 1y agoI guess "often" is relative, but this happens to me pretty regularly. I live in Canada, and it's not always obvious if an American company ships here or not. If the answer isn't trivial to find, I'll do this: 1. Add something to the cart 2. Start the checkout process as a guest 3. Fill in the boxes that pop up during the checkout process 4. Close the tab when I see that the country dropdown only has USA available On most websites these days, you're asked for your email before your mailing address. And after I abort the checkout, I'll get an annoying "Psst...you forgot something in your cart" email a few hours later even though I never made an account or placed an order with my email. Stores built with Shopify do this so consistently that I have to assume it's an out-of-the-box feature you need to opt out of.
- BobbyTables2 1y agoSounds great in theory, but how does this square with Google/Facebook tracking pixels and such. Seems like either way, they’re in control of a massive amount of tracking data…
- KwanEsq 1y agoIs this a successor to Mozilla's old Persona project, or similar in anyway?
- mook 1y agoIf it's a new standard, it must have… some kind of cross-industry support right? I ask because it looks like https://github.com/w3c-fedid/FedCM/graphs/contributors https://github.com/w3c-fedid/FedCM/graphs/contributors is mostly people who work at Google (I gave up once I hit people with ten or fewer commits)…
- alternatex 1y agoIsn't that the case for half of modern browsers APIs? Google develops whatever it needs for its own products into Chrome and then pushes it to W3C. Other browsers perpetually behind. They've gotten quite good at this strategy.
- pyrale 1y agoAs usual, the feature is being railroaded by google and other implementers are given the choice between following Chrome's de-facto choices or not implementing it, and breaking websites that will use it anyway.
- mooreds 1y agoWhile most of the contributions I have seen are from Google on the browser side, they are trying to work through the standards process. Here's the first draft of the w3c standard: https://www.w3.org/TR/fedcm/ https://www.w3.org/TR/fedcm/ I know there's a later draft but can't find it right now. Will share when I do. As mentioned in sibling comments I have seen are least on Firefox contributor and they are actively seeking input from identity providers.
- JimDabell 1y ago> They are actively working on the standard and Firefox has committed to it. Mozilla standards position says neutral: https://mozilla.github.io/standards-positions/#fedcm https://mozilla.github.io/standards-positions/#fedcm Their issue tracker on the subject shows they are interested but have a lot of reservations about the details: > However, some of our reservations on the initial positive position have not been addressed and some new issues have arisen. — https://github.com/mozilla/standards-positions/issues/618 https://github.com/mozilla/standards-positions/issues/618 Apple had a vague “interested” position over three years ago, with no further detail: https://github.com/WebKit/standards-positions/issues/309 https://github.com/WebKit/standards-positions/issues/309 Have these positions changed?
- mooreds 1y agoI don't speak for Mozilla, but I did see a bug in bugzilla which showed the blocking bugs for FedCM. I don't have the link now, but can share it later. That's what I thought of when I stated Firefox has committed to it. But I could be wrong. I do see a Mozilla employee engaging regularly. You can see some of the issues he has filed here: https://github.com/w3c-fedid/FedCM/issues?q=is%3Aissue%20state%3Aclosed%20author%3Abvandersloot-mozilla https://github.com/w3c-fedid/FedCM/issues?q=is%3Aissue%20sta...
- mooreds 1y ago> I did see a bug in bugzilla which showed the blocking bugs for FedCM. I don't have the link now, but can share it later. Here's the tracking bug for FedCM support: https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=1959702 https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=1959702
- otabdeveloper4 1y ago> The Chrome experience is actually part of a new Google non-standard Fixed it for you.
- WhyNotHugo 1y agoVaguely reminds me of the now defunct OpenID. But with browser-native integration.
- mooreds 1y agoOpenID lives on for real in Steam ( https://partner.steamgames.com/doc/features/auth#website https://partner.steamgames.com/doc/features/auth#website) and in the principles behind OpenID Connect! :)