3 ms·
> a few dozen people's weird ideas about what shouldn't be allowed I want to underline the absurdity of a foreign feminist organisation [1], in this political
by JumpCrisscross 1y ago
> a few dozen people's weird ideas about what shouldn't be allowed
I want to underline the absurdity of a foreign feminist organisation [1], in this political environment, dictating what Americans can and cannot see.
[1] https://www.collectiveshout.org https://www.collectiveshout.org
- rodgerd 1y agoNo more absurd than US card schemes dictating what I can and can't buy in another country.
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago> No more absurd than US card schemes dictating what I can and can't buy in another country Philosophically, sure. Practically, no. America is an economic and military superpower. Washington having influence over its trading partners and military allies isn't unusual. To the extent I can think of something that mirrors the absurdity of this situation, it's American evangelicals running off to Uganda to stone gays.
- fivestones 1y ago> it’s American evangelicals running off to Uganda to stone gays. Is that something that happened? That sounds horrible. Do you have any more info?
- camtarn 1y agohttps://globalaffairs.org/commentary-and-analysis/blogs/unholy-relationship-between-ugandas-anti-lgbtq-law-and-us https://globalaffairs.org/commentary-and-analysis/blogs/unho... "...many extreme evangelical groups started to recognize that the fight against LGBTQ+ rights in the United States was a losing battle. These groups then shifted focus to Uganda, which was seen as fertile ground for this anti-gay ideology..."
- sombragris 1y agoNo mention on stoning, though...
- camtarn 1y agoYes, I think GGP was being hyperbolic. Still a shameful state of affairs.
- pjc50 1y agoNot literally, but they did manage to get homosexuality re-criminalized in Uganda.
- averageRoyalty 1y agoGood. The rest of the world is used to rolling our eyes at Americans who can't handle the word cunt or show a dick on TV and the impact it has on us. It's not a bad thing to get a reality check for you.
- shagie 1y agoThe group that did this is Australian based on Australian laws on illegal pornography.
- averageRoyalty 1y agoYes, and the things I described are based on American decision makers with American sensibilities. What is the point you're making?
- whatwrongwyou 1y agoI'm not sure what you call this fallacy. It's not really whataboutism because you're not equivocating against another argument, but instead you just discard it and push forward on the path that you've chosen for this interaction. I guess it's begging the question. I can see that this would be a powerful technique in a more open forum, or against an uninformed audience, because by pushing like this you imply that you are so correct that no other argument need even be heard. What is the "win condition" here for you? Do you have any other examples of your work, or do you cycle out soon?
- lcnPylGDnU4H9OF 1y agoThey made their point poorly but their argument is not fallacious. They are saying that the Americans who make the relevant decisions at Visa/Mastercard have their own reasons for making this decision and are probably not simply capitulating to a foreign special-interest group. (Of course, they could have more effectively gotten their point across by actually describing it.) The point is that leaders at Visa/Mastercard probably think it's very convenient that Collective Shout exists because it lets them blame that group for their decisions. And it seems to have worked given how so many members of this not-uninformed audience refuse to look past Collective Shout to see that Visa/Mastercard made a decision to change their policy.
- ethbr1 1y agoI was under the impression that Australia was more America than America in a lot of ways. Supposedly you can still hear the last of the V8 interceptors roar in the wild there...