3 ms·
> You are approaching this from a uniquely U.S. perspective. It’s not uniquely U.S. at all What other countries require ID checks for services like Discord?
by Aurornis 1y ago
> You are approaching this from a uniquely U.S. perspective.
It’s not uniquely U.S. at all
What other countries require ID checks for services like Discord?
The U.K.’s implementation of this law is much more unique than you’re claiming.
- foldr 1y agoYou don’t need age verification to access all of Discord, just NSFW servers. You can certainly argue that that’s an unjustifiable interference in people’s freedom to access the internet services that they want to access. But please don’t exaggerate.
- Aurornis 1y ago> You don’t need age verification to access all of Discord, just NSFW servers. That’s not correct. The Discord support explains that it’s required to change automatic content filtering or unblur any content that gets caught by the automatic filters.
- foldr 1y agoYes, that’s what I meant. You can still access Discord, just not any content that’s detected as NSFW. Generally speaking that content will be on NSFW servers (the kind that e.g. the iPhone app would block you from accessing by default). Obviously there is not going to be a “nah I really want to see this tho” button, or the age check would be completely pointless.
- johnisgood 1y agoThat is not true. Try going to a server that asks for your age and then go ahead to choose "2020". > Obviously there is not going to be a “nah I really want to see this tho” button, or the age check would be completely pointless. That is exactly how "ignoring" an user on Discord works. Their messages are still there and you have to click on it to have it uncollapsed, so that is kind of ironic of you to say, lmao. So yeah, there actually is a "nah I really want to see this tho" button.
- foldr 1y agoThere must be a misunderstanding here. I said in my post that some servers are indeed gated on age verification. Just not all of Discord.
- johnisgood 1y agoLook, create an account and when you join a server that asks for your age, make sure you set the birth year to one that makes you less than 13 years old. For what it is worth, it has to do with Discord ToS (per / by country). In some countries you must be over 13 to use Discord, other countries 14, but if you are below, you MUST verify yourself to be able to access your Discord account after you set it to below 13. This verification process is done through sending Discord an e-mail requesting them to restore your account, with a video of yourself holding your ID card as an attachment. The list per country can be found on Discord's website. What I am talking about is separate from the server settings (require phone verification and/or age verification).
- abxyz 1y agoDiscord’s own articles about this change explain that the fundamentals (content filtering) are applied to all accounts owned by teenagers worldwide. The only U.K. specific aspect of all of this is that if you tell Discord you are over 18 you must prove it. That’s a very small difference and not something most people in most countries care about. I’d go as far as to say, I think the majority of people in the majority of the world would be in favour of requiring people to prove they’re over 18 online if they want to claim to be over 18 online. https://support.discord.com/hc/en-us/articles/33362401287959-What-s-Changing-for-UK-Users-Due-to-the-UK-Online-Safety-Act https://support.discord.com/hc/en-us/articles/33362401287959...
- Aurornis 1y ago> The only U.K. specific aspect of all of this is that if you tell Discord you are over 18 you must prove it. That’s a very small difference Requiring ID verification in one country is not a small difference. The rest of the world checks a box. People in the U.K. must submit to ID verification. It’s so strange to see things like this claimed to be small differences.
- abxyz 1y agoAgain, this is a radical internet-libertarian-freedom-at-all-costs view. Normal people do not think that proving you are 18 is notable. We’ve been doing it for decades with credit cards. The system is more mature now but it is not fundamentally different.
- Aurornis 1y ago> Again, this is a radical internet-libertarian-freedom-at-all-costs view The current global status quo is “radical” and the U.K. is the only country doing it right? You were accusing others of being U.S. centric a few posts back, but now you’re pushing the U.K.’s unique laws as the only valid solution. > We’ve been doing it for decades with credit cards Age checks for credit cards are required because minors legally couldn’t be forced to pay their debts. If companies issued credit cards to minors then the minors could spend as much as they want and the bank would have no recourse to collect. I don’t think you understand these issues if you’re using this as a comparison. Either that or you’re not even trying to have an honest conversation.