9 ms·
Personal aviation is about to get interesting (2023)
- mordechai9000 1y agoSmall personal aircraft are great, but subject to weather and visibility. Although some of that could probably be mitigated through automation technology. I doubt we'll see Jetsons style cars replacing the American auto anytime soon, but more competition in the world of light sport aircraft would be nice.
- wingspar 1y agoMOSAIC is Done! >> Ninety days from now, about three-quarters of the general aviation fleet will be accessible to sport pilots and those exercising sport pilot privileges. One year from now, new and modern aircraft will begin entering the fleet with minimal certification costs. https://www.eaa.org/eaa/news-and-publications/eaa-news-and-aviation-news/workingnewsarticles/2025-07-22-mosaic-is-done https://www.eaa.org/eaa/news-and-publications/eaa-news-and-a...
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- oceanplexian 1y agoCan’t support MOSAIC enough. I’ve owned a composite LSA called a Flight Design for about 5 years, been in arguments with a lot of old timers about the safety aspects but I consider revolutionary and far safer than a certified aircraft than the statistics will tell you. For example it has a ballistic parachute that will bring the entire aircraft to the ground. Unlike the Lycomings and Continentals the engine wasn’t designed in the 1950s. It’s equipped with real time satellite weather, GPS autopilot, Avionics that would cost you $15-20k to put in a Cessna due to all the red tape. I will get a lot of heat for this but I think the FAA has killed a lot of people. If pilots had low cost access to things like glass cockpits, satellite weather, inexpensive autopilot, and a healthy ecosystem of cheap, modern aircraft with modern engines (Basic things like fuel injection) a lot of pilots might still be alive right now.
- SR2Z 1y ago> I will get a lot of heat for this but I think the FAA has killed a lot of people. On the balance, the FAA has saved more lives than it's cost just because big jetliners hold SO MANY PEOPLE. But otherwise I fully agree with you. It's deranged that students these days are taught to manually lean the mixture until the engine sputters (i.e. the engine begins to DIE), then bump it back up. It's incredibly stupid that an aircraft flying in 2025 has multiple solid state accelerometers and gyroscopes on board as part of people's phones - but the only certified one is a vacuum-powered analog instrument from 1981. And why the hell do we still fuel GA aircraft with a gasoline that's literally ILLEGAL to use anywhere else? Don't even get me started on the DPE or medical systems. These changes cannot come soon enough, because the entire GA world has slipped through the cracks as the FAA has become a disaster.
- dreamcompiler 1y ago> And why the hell do we still fuel GA aircraft with a gasoline that's literally ILLEGAL to use anywhere else? Unleaded avgas is a thing now. But it won't work with many legacy aviation engines. I hope this new rule will finally enable some engine (and thus fuel) innovation.
- andrepd 1y agoThe massive effects of lead poisoning are still seen on a large scale near airports and in areas with lots of avgas powered traffic. That most of it is for essentially recreational purposes makes it even more infuriating.
- rightbyte 1y ago> It's deranged that students these days are taught to manually lean the mixture until the engine sputters (i.e. the engine begins to DIE), then bump it back up. Why? That is essentially an engine check. I think you want pilots to understand their machines and to do that you need to operate the engines.
- SR2Z 1y agoI'm not sure I see the value of doing an engine check while flying the plane, or flying carbureted engines without automatic mixture control in general. Pilots will understand their engines' quirks better, but those quirks are stupid and obviated by newer technology.
- giantg2 1y ago"Let’s start with the obvious one. If the compliance costs of safety regulation get too high, it will shut down iteration and innovation in the industry. These innovations include safety enhancements." An interesting point here is that you can sometimes get safety improvements in an experimental aircraft that you can't get in the same airframe under Part 23 because the manufacturers don't want to go through the certification process for upgraded parts and newer technology.
- rgmerk 1y agoHmmm. I have a couple of concerns about a large expansion of personal aircraft of the type the original author is advocating. For one, even certified GA aircraft have a fatality rate far in excess of automobiles, let alone public transport or airliners. Yes, some of that is pilot error which can be mitigated to a substantial extent by computer controls, but it’s also a result of the lack of redundancy and hard failure modes of a light aircraft compared to a car. I’d also note that the flight controls don’t do the maintenance that is required to keep a light aircraft safe. Yes, the more libertarian amongst you won’t have a problem with this, but I’d also observe that the proposal is to make these regulations applicable to four-seater aircraft, so plenty of spouses and especially kids will be affected by this risk. Secondly, expanding a class of vehicle that chews a lot of fossil fuel is going to worsen the already serious effects of climate change; and while short-range aircraft might well electrify you’re not going to fly at 250 knots for 1000 nautical miles on batteries any time soon.
- SR2Z 1y ago> Secondly, expanding a class of vehicle that chews a lot of fossil fuel is going to worsen the already serious effects of climate change; and while short-range aircraft might well electrify you’re not going to fly at 250 knots for 1000 nautical miles on batteries any time soon. Your average single-engine piston gets ~22mpg with a single passenger. It's not terrible at all.
- rgmerk 1y agoIgnoring EVs for a moment, a Toyota Camry hybrid, which can carry five people in more comfort and carrying more luggage than a light aircraft, gets 50mpg on the highway. 22 mpg is not terrible only if your frame of reference is pickup trucks, whose load-carrying capabilities can only be matched by far larger aircraft with far higher fuel usage. Furthermore, aircraft that cruise at 250 knots are not going to get anywhere near 22mpg. A Lancair Evolution, a reasonably modern four-seater turboprop that cruises at around that speed gets something approximating 7 mpg.
- sokoloff 1y ago
- pbhjpbhj 1y agoDid someone wanting to sell flying cars bribe Trump, or is this from before the current administration? Didn't they cut loads of FAA inspectors and such? >Without the need for type certification, manufacturers can iterate on their designs more rapidly without going through the costly supplemental type certification process. They can include cheaper uncertified avionics. They can do over-the-air software updates. Being completely out of the loop and nothing more than a moderately interested member of the public (outside USA) -- isn't lack of type certification one of the causes of recent major aviation calamities. Looks like they're saying loads of EABs crash but well just call them LSAs because those don't crash as much, problem solved! Oh, and software is totally reliable so well have that control the aircraft. And we'll make them go faster.
- jauntywundrkind 1y agoMOSAIC has seemingly been approved, just last week I guess. A bunch of the coverage has a nice table showing the new spec. https://www.flyingmag.com/faa-finalizes-major-overhaul-of-light-sport-aircraft-rules/ https://www.flyingmag.com/faa-finalizes-major-overhaul-of-li...
- parsimo2010 1y agoFor those not tracking: this article is about the MOSAIC rules, which the FAA announced this week is now approved (Final Rule). In 90 days the new Sport Pilot rules will go into effect and allow Sport Pilots (a certification less stringent than Private Pilot) the ability to fly aircraft of much higher performance. Over the next year, new certification rules will go into effect allowing manufacturers to manufacture much more high performance aircraft under the Light Sport rules. There are some details, but the big picture is that the allowable performance for these “entry level” classes just got a lot higher. Is it good? Well, a lot of people are cheering the change. The FAA doesn’t normally make things easier for the average Joe. This will make it easier for an inexperienced (but still fairly wealthy) pilot to get their hands on a real hot rod of a plane. There’s probably some additional risk, but the FAA has clearly recognized that one of the biggest dangers too flying a high performance aircraft is having to land fast. 200 kts vs 100 kts doesn’t make a big difference in risk in straight and level flight, but landing at 80 kts vs 55 kts does make a difference. I don’t know where I stand exactly. It’s a big jump. Surely this is going to cause some old geezer to be screaming through a congested area and not be able to keep up with the ATC traffic calls because he’s never gone this fast before, and he’ll have a midair collision. Surely this is going to cause someone to buy a “light sport” aircraft with 280 hp and a huge prop and they’re going to crash taking off. But I think that overall I’m just being overly cautious, and most Sport Pilots are too poor to afford a plane that burns 15 gallons of avgas an hour, so most of the new planes under MOSAIC won’t be that powerful. I am curious to see what kind of new aircraft become available, and what the long term safety impacts will be. Edit: for about five minutes my post said “not approved” when I meant to type that MOSAIC is “now approved”
- MichaelZuo 1y agoWouldn’t this problem be obviated by simply mandating sufficiently high third party liability insurance? Then it will be the much less likely to be gamed insurance market effectively deciding who gets to fly the higher performance aircraft.
- willis936 1y agoThe goal of regulation should not be "make reckless endangerment expensive enough that only the plutocrats can afford to do it".
- dostick 1y agoIs this like Ultralight license? Making it more accessible only created more new deaths.
- bluGill 1y agoThis is a step higher. Ultralight requires no training at all, this license has same training requirements but not as much.
- fnord77 1y agoThis article is outdated. FAA split the concept of "sport pilot" from LSA Now Sport Pilots can fly just about anything with VS1 of 59 knots or less (clean stall speed) (up from 45kts) Meanwhile, new plane designs can go through a less rigorous certification as LSA if they have a VS1 of 61kts or less.
- GianFabien 1y agoThe big question: How is pilot training and certification going to ensure that accident rates are further reduced? Will also need huge changes to training and certification of aircraft mechanics. Existing air traffic controller shortages, under-staffing, equipment deficiencies are going to have trouble coping with the increased workload posed more and faster planes.
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago> Will also need huge changes to training and certification of aircraft mechanics Why? These aren’t novel power plants. > Existing air traffic controller shortages, under-staffing, equipment deficiencies are going to have trouble coping with the increased workload posed more and faster planes Sport pilots aren’t landing at La Guardia.
- sparrish 1y ago> Will also need huge changes to training and certification of aircraft mechanics There's already a shortage of certified mechanics. Adding thousands of more pilots and presumably aircraft will make already long wait times for annuals even longer.
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago> Adding thousands of more pilots and presumably aircraft will make already long wait times for annuals even longer The article specifically calls out bringing simpler power plants and engines to general aviation.
- sparrish 1y agoSimpler power plants and engines will still require at least annual inspections... who's going to certify all those aircraft?
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- rkagerer 1y agoover-the-air avionics updates I was on board up until this phrase. I don't want my plane behaving as flakey as my Tesla, and my gauges shifting their location around every update at the whim of some junior designer. Not saying there couldn't be a manufacturer that does OTA properly, I just haven't seen that as the trend in any other space (cars, smartphones, etc). The OTA part always seems to benefit the manufacturer, not the user. ("Watch this ad to take off....")
- JCBird1012 1y agoDon't picture them as OTA firmware updates. Picture them as OTA navigation data updates (i.e. maps, charts, waypoints, airport info, etc...) - that's much easier to pull off. The process right now is pulling out an SD card from your Garmin/Avidyne/BendixKing whatever every 28-days or so (that's how often the FAA updates the navigation database backing these avionics), popping it into your PC, using software/webistes that could be... much better designed (to put it lightly) and then going back again. It's not exactly the hardest thing in the world, but it's not exactly a walk in the park either (especially for less-technically inclined pilots, who just let it lapse, and click out of the big expiration warnings every time they start up their planes).
- piperswe 1y agoOTA map updates on my other Garmin devices have always been unobtrusive, I expect their avionics updates to be similar.
- hoekit 1y agoThis idea of a continuum as a tool to allow experimentation and gradual evolution of a critical infrastructure is an interesting one. Wonder if there's something similar in other domains.
- dang 1y agoDiscussed at the time: Personal aviation is about to get interesting - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37988638 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37988638 - Oct 2023 (137 comments)
- daft_pink 1y agoThe reality is that personal aviation doesn’t make sense because the range of an cheap aircraft just isn’t very high so you’re not gonna fly from New York to California on an aircraft under $1 million dollars brand new and you’re certainly not gonna fly internationally. How can you spend so much money and so much time getting your pilots license for a plane that only will get you 500 or 600 miles effectively. Most people who can afford a six figure aircraft wanna fly much longer distances than they are able to fly.
- hollerith 1y agoThe main way that personal aviation contributes to the economy is by giving inexperienced pilots the experience they need to qualify to work for the airlines.
- ufmace 1y agoWouldn't they just land, refuel, and take off again a few times if they wanted to fly cross-country, similar to what they'd do in a car?
- andoando 1y agoYou can but its very slow and very expensive. Even at full speed in a straight line, 2000 mile trip in a C172 would take 14.5 hours, and that's without refueling. Fuel would cost you ~$920. In a twin prop like a Piper Seneca it would take about 9 hours, and ~$1700 of fuel. There's also the issue of weather which small aircraft are much more subject to.
- dontTREATonme 1y agoWow, private flying really is for the rich. $1700 to fly cross country and it’s still 3 hours longer than flying commercial.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- 1y ago
- FabHK 1y agoAviation moves more slowly than IT: > the category could include planes like the forthcoming Pipistrel Panthera. The "forthcoming" (2023) Panthera has been worked on since 2011, had its first flight in 2013, and is still in development (2025).
- brikym 1y agoIt'd be good if small time pilots could fly quieter aircraft. There is an A380 that regularly takes off near me and it's quieter than most small planes. The engines on smaller planes drone loudly and it goes on and on as the planes are slow. Just another externalized cost of aviation.
- nosefrog 1y agoOn the flip side, my baby likes the small loud airplanes. He points at them and says "oooh!"
- smeeger 1y agoflying is dumb. in a small aircraft your fuel efficiency can be vaporized by a simple head wind. owning an operating any kind of aircraft is insanely expensive. for years i looked into finding some way of justifying the expense of a private aircraft. the only way it can be worth it is if you need to hop between distant cities as a part of your business. flying cars will never happen
- sheepscreek 1y agoAll I want is an electric or hybrid autogyro equipped with cutting-edge technology and sensors. Once airborne, autogyro planes can safely descend without relying on power or even a functioning engine. They possess remarkable hover-like capabilities without stalling, unlike fixed-wing aircraft, and can achieve impressive distances at commendable speeds, unlike helicopters. In other words, it’s the best of both worlds and very beginner friendly IMO.