3 ms·
> But some experts stress there is still a difference. > Graham Pearson, professor with the University of Alberta's department of earth and atmospheric science
by zahlman 1y ago
> But some experts stress there is still a difference.
> Graham Pearson, professor with the University of Alberta's department of earth and atmospheric sciences, says that the natural formation of diamonds deep underground results in a "complexity" you can't get with the lab-grown variety.
Okay; but why should I aesthetically prefer this?
- kstrauser 1y agoYep. In the context of what should be a very simple crystal structure, "complexity" is another word for "defect".
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- OJFord 1y agoExactly, at the same price yes the natural stone will have more 'complexity' and be lower-graded than the lab one as a result.
- chihuahua 1y agoFor decades, the marketing message was that less defects = better = more expensive. Apparently, when lab-grown diamonds came along, that had to be inverted: now, lab-grown = less defects = "less character" The whole thing is such an obvious marketing exercise with very little to back it up (as evidenced by the extremely low resale value of diamonds)
- cubefox 1y agoBetter question: Why should you aesthetically prefer a diamond to cheap glass?
- masfuerte 1y agoBecause they don't look the same. Not even a little bit. Glass doesn't sparkle.
- throwmeaway222 1y agoIf that's what makes real diamonds special, these shoes should we worth at least $100M https://www.walmart.com/ip/Miluxas-Women-s-Glitter-Tennis-Sneakers-Neon-Dressy-Sparkly-Sneakers-Rhinestone-Bling-Wedding-Bridal-Shoes-Shiny-Sequin-Shoes-Clearance-Silver-9-42/5171081799 https://www.walmart.com/ip/Miluxas-Women-s-Glitter-Tennis-Sn...
- kstrauser 1y agoOK, but there's a real difference. My wedding band has small diamonds in it, and occasionally I'll be sitting inside where the sun falls on my hand and casts a million pretty blue and white and red sparkles on the walls and ceiling of the room I'm in. Diamonds (and other gems) really are beautifula to look at in ways that glass just isn't. And manmade ones, sparklier still out of the forge of our own cleverness, are much nicer in my opinion.
- function_seven 1y agoDiamonds sparkle a lot more brilliantly due to their high refractive index. (Moissanite is even better, so it should be preferred over diamonds unless I’m overlooking some other difference in their attributes?) But plain glass gems look comparatively bland when used as jewelry.
- mensetmanusman 1y agoMoissanite scratchers much easier.
- function_seven 1y agoOh duh. I was so focused on optical qualities I didn’t even think about material ones.
- 0cf8612b2e1e 1y agoI need a geologist to explain this one. Moissanite has a Mohs hardness of 9.5. I guess it is easier to scratch than a diamond, but the scratability should be indistinguishable between the two for all practical purposes.
- jjmarr 1y agoNot a geologist but Mohs hardness is an ordinal scale so the distance between 10 and 9 isn't well-defined. The numbers are defined as being specific minerals. Diamond (10) is 4x as hard as corundum (9) which is 2x as hard as topaz (8). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mohs_scale#Reference_minerals https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mohs_scale#Reference_minerals
- cubefox 1y agoEverything scratches easier than diamond. Moissanite is still very hard to scratch.
- recipe19 1y agoYou can make some plausible arguments against glass. It scratches more easily and doesn't shimmer as much. But synthetic sapphire is the same league and costs a lot less. The modern-day aesthetic of diamonds is just that they are expensive. They're not distinguished by utility, quality, or appearance from cheaper products. The ultimate status symbol, but also obviously a bit of an issue...
- philjohn 1y agoBecause the refractive index of diamond is higher than that of glass, which makes it look prettier and "sparkle".
- grues-dinner 1y agoA chip of concrete has more "complexity" than any diamond. But somehow I bet Graham's wife isn't wearing a piece of Blue Circle's finest.
- thfuran 1y agoThough it can look pretty neat of you polish it up and acid stain it.
- mensetmanusman 1y agoIt can result in interesting color centers.
- margalabargala 1y agoWhich can be replicated cheaply in a lab, and will be the moment they become desirable.
- mensetmanusman 1y agoFor uniform color, yes, for spatial color gradients (eg 3D swirls), no. (I don’t know if color gradients are even desirable in the market.)
- gitremote 1y agoHe's an earth sciences geek, so he prefers natural diamonds' relationship with the earth. This aesthetic is irrelevant for most people.
- ghushn3 1y agoI have an outdoor fireplace filled with shattered tempered glass. It's like, rough, chunky glass pebbles. It's much much more complex that a solid sheet of tempered glass, and it catches the light and reflects it in sparkling ways. Maybe these so called "complex" diamonds create more interesting light interfaces?
- monster_truck 1y agoThey don't. If they did, it would be possible to detect the difference with perfect accuracy. Instead, the detectors made by those interested in pushing the concept of "real, natural" diamonds have a false positive rate of 5% looking for the inclusion of things labs could easily add if they cared to
- jajko 1y agoIf that's what you are after there are more interesting stones than diamonds for that, ie moissanite.
- DonsDiscountGas 1y agoNo reason, which is why he didn't offer one. But of course they have to have some pro mined diamond quote for "balance".