4 ms·
If AI can trade stocks and derivatives better than any humans, maybe we'll see wealth accumulation in a few large AI firms. And the stock market becomes effecti
by amelius 1y ago
If AI can trade stocks and derivatives better than any humans, maybe we'll see wealth accumulation in a few large AI firms. And the stock market becomes effectively useless to the rest of us.
- lofaszvanitt 1y agoYeah, but AI will be banned before that happens.
- dzink 1y agoNot if the lobbying budget of those making the AI money is larger than those that lose money to AI in the market.
- razemio 1y agoHow would you ban AI? It is unstoppable now.
- lofaszvanitt 1y agoWe'll see
- __MatrixMan__ 1y agoIt would be a reductio ad absurdum for the stock market which is long overdue.
- mu53 1y agoWhat AI? ML with gradient descent? Neural nets with deep learning? LLMs? Or the abstract concept of AGI that may or may not possible, but definitely isn't here yet? Hedge funds and investment banks are already using these tools to the max, and the markets are plenty profitable for everyone
- alephnerd 1y agoYou do realize that all the math used in AI/ML has been heavily used in Finance for decades right? Everything is Applied Math if you squint hard enough. All this AI/ML doomerism and boosterism is ridiculous. If you do not understand how gradient descent works or why as of today GPUs are better suited for model training compared to CPUs you should not have a say in this discussion. Most conversations around AI/ML appear to basically be pop-philosophy discussions that aren't even that grounded in philosophy fundamentals. If you have trash fundamentals, you will have a trash understanding of the world.
- mindwok 1y agoYou can make this point without needing to insult everyone’s intelligence and gate-keep discussions about AI.
- k-i-r-t-h-i 1y agotrading =/= investing
- amelius 1y agoinvesting == long term trading
- rickydroll 1y agoinvesting == (rent seeking || criminal activity) && regulatory failures
- kjkjadksj 1y agoThey already use models for trading better than any human and have probably done so since the 1950s. And what do you know, wealth accumulation has been significant over the last 70 years.
- amelius 1y agoYeah but wealth accumulation can only go so far, because at some point people will start to question the validity of the entire market.
- snoman 1y agoWith index funds effectively propping up the S&P etc. people are already questioning it. Consider that millions of people are parking billions of dollars in index funds that just track the ~500 biggest companies with the expectation they’ll all just get bigger.
- kjkjadksj 1y agoEvery paycheck people buy more into it via their 401k
- simantel 1y agoRenTec did this successfully, but their strategies didn't scale up beyond ~$30B AUM before they started moving their markets too much (with the Medallion Fund).
- im3w1l 1y agoI think what will happen is that ordinary people will invest in a mutual fund managed by AI and/or the funds people already invest in will start adopting AI-tooling. I think this scenario is plausible because the path to this scenario is so smooth so it will be the default outcome unless something strange happens to prevent it.
- SketchySeaBeast 1y agoI'm wondering what a market looks like where everyone is running an AI that makes the optimal purchases. The market needs bag holders. I also don't know that it would change my behaviour. If my goal is long term investment success what's the downside of my continuing to invest in broad market funds? I don't need an AI making split second decisions if my investment horizon is still 30 years.
- im3w1l 1y agoWild guess, but I think trading activity goes down. AI focuses instead on which equity issuances to participate in.