15 ms·
Apple Rejects App That Tracks U.S. Drone Strikes
- RexRollman 14y agoOffending people's tender sensibilities should not be a reason to reject an app.
- Steko 14y agoYou build your billion dollar app store and you can run it the way you want.
- ucee054 14y agoEvery comment you have made on this page has been in reply to someone's criticism of the App store's horrid policy. Every riposte you have given has been that Apple have the right to choose their policy. Yes, Apple may have a right to have a horrid policy. But that doesn't make the policy any less horrid. The horridness of the policy is the whole point. You have therefore missed the point every time, with every answer.
- Steko 14y agoI'm not missing the point, I'm contesting it. You're assuming the conclusion that the policy is horrid. No, that's what is under debate. I'm fine with the policy of not approving this app. I'm sorry you came here to here a dittohead fest where everyone echo'd your views and didn't get it.
- retrogradeorbit 14y agoI've heard developers echo your sentiment right up until it was their app that was rejected. Pride cometh before a fall.
- ucee054 14y agoContesting the point would be to explain why the policy is not horrid, to the people who regard it as censorship and therefore horrid, by addressing the point. You did not do that, you said "Build your own Apple then!". This comment is the closest you ever came to defending the policy, by saying "I'm fine with it". But you're not trying to convince anyone else by providing any information or reasons. Rather, you're asserting that they can't possibly convince you. And you have resorted to a low by attacking me personally as a "dittohead".
- Steko 14y agoI've addressed why it's not horrid all over the place in this thread. The goods that store X sells are not chosen by the public or by committee or by anything else. They are chosen by whoever owns store X. That's how every store works and if store X doesn't want to sell pornography or political merchandise or whatever that's up to them. And if you think Apple is horrid for having the same policy as virtually every other store in history then by equivalence they are all horrid. That's obviously absurd so your claim is false. QED.
- ucee054 14y agoNo, if Apple's policy is not to sell the drone app, and (let's assume) Google's policy is to sell the drone app, these are not the same policy by definition. (Therefore you cannot claim that all stores have the same policy. This stuff is high-school level logic and I don't understand why you have difficulty with it.) In which case I am perfectly free to find Apple's policy horrid, and find the hypothetical Android store policy commendable.
- mike-cardwell 14y agoI can understand Apple wanting to keep its market place "clean", but at the very least, iDevice owners should be able to opt-in to seeing apps like this. Why can't it just be flagged "adult" or something, and you can then opt-in on your device to seeing apps flagged as such? Why does Apple think it is suitable to make these decisions on your behalf, iDevice users? Are you happy with this? Personally, I'll be sticking with my HTC device running Cyanogenmod.
- DrJokepu 14y agoI believe the following parts of the iOS App Store Review Guidelines answer your question: * We have lots of kids downloading lots of apps, and parental controls don't work unless the parents set them up (many don't). So know that we're keeping an eye out for the kids. * We will reject Apps for any content or behavior that we believe is over the line. What line, you ask? Well, as a Supreme Court Justice once said, "I'll know it when I see it". And we think that you will also know it when you cross it. * This is a living document, and new apps presenting new questions may result in new rules at any time. Perhaps your app will trigger this. * Lastly, we love this stuff too, and honor what you do. We're really trying our best to create the best platform in the world for you to express your talents and make a living too. If it sounds like we're control freaks, well, maybe it's because we're so committed to our users and making sure they have a quality experience with our products. Just like almost all of you are too.
- roc 14y agoIf they have a parental control feature, recognize that it's not usually turned on, so set app store policy assuming parental control isn't on, but that style of protection is desirable ... why don't they just default parental control to "on"? Or at least make it a device-setup-time prompt? Of the "iOS' walled garden is anticonsumer" concerns - the one that's in regular demonstration is Apple's refusal to allow adults to indicate that they really are grown up enough to be exposed to content regarding politics, religion, war and, yeah, even sex.
- delinka 14y ago
- sageikosa 14y agoBig Apple is watching [out for] you.
- Rudism 14y agoThank you, Apple, for protecting me from a news aggregation/notification and mapping app like this one. I'll stick to my fart sound boards and purchasing currency for manipulative "games" with zero actual entertainment value any day!
- myared 14y agoThe irony is that this news aggregator is being denied, yet someone could make a game called "Drone Wars" where you operate a drone on missions and Apple would have no problem with it.
- gaunab 14y agoVery true words, and this irony is what should really be the matter here. It's "objectionable content" to receive reports on death penalties issued by the US government, carried out by unmanned planes at some part of the world no one in the US really cares about? Well, yeah. Thanks, Apple, for keeping your sweet and "entertaining" app store clean of this ugly and objectionable thing called reality.
- Tichy 14y agoIt's called freedom - freedom from objectionable things.
- ktizo 14y agoPerhaps the coder could make a game, which invites you to play at flying each drone attack as each one gets reported in, with lots of american flags and funny voiced terrorists to kill. Call it "Patriot Death Force" and have a heavy metal sound track and stuff. That would probably get through fine.
- genwin 14y agoLove it. I suspect if the app was based on real data it'd be blocked. Apple would let you attack the same spots though.
- eevilspock 14y agoI think iOS is better than Android. I support the idea of a walled garden in principle (as long as it isn't a monopoly, and in this case it isn't. People can choose Android or others). But the free flow of honest information is fundamental to democracy. This is stupid and gutless editorial censorship on Apple's part (unless there's some detail about this story that I'm missing). I hope someone higher up sees this, reverses the decision, and clarifies their internal standards on this. Fucking lame Apple! Shape the fuck up! @Rudism: ditto.
- AndrewDucker 14y agoYou support a walled garden, but not if it blocks information? I'm sorry, but that's completely contradictory. The point of the wall is that it blocks things Apple don't approve of.
- eevilspock 14y agoYou can support an approach and also believe someone is doing it stupidly, or even unethically, all without being contradictory. For example, do you support the right of a newspaper editor to pick and choose which letters to the editor get published? How about a restaurant's reserved "right to refuse service to anyone"? If you do, you still reserve the right in each of these cases to object to individual decisions, and to refuse patronage if an individual decision or a pattern of decisions offends you. All without contradicting yourself.
- cageface 14y agoBut that's exactly the problem with the benevolent dictatorship model. Sooner or later this kind of absolute power is used unwisely or outright abused and you have no recourse. This is why almost every country in the world has abandoned monarchy. It's ultimately too error-prone and inefficient.
- eevilspock 14y agoWhat you seem to propose as an alternative to monarchy is not democracy, but anarchy. No rules sounds great in principle... Even Linux has King Linus. And Android has King Page, Queen Rubin and a host of Lords (Verizon, AT&T, Samsung, etc). Don't kid yourself. Furthermore, we're talking about a product, a phone, not national governments or the sovereignty of citizens over them. Poor strawman.
- Shivetya 14y agoif you want the conspiracy side of this, wrong guy is in office.
- Craiggybear 14y agoThis is actually quite interesting but sadly not entirely surprising.
- thechut 14y agoBuild an Android version, I doubt that the Play Store will block the app. And if it does you can have it one of the 1- other available stores.
- chmod775 14y agoThey don't block any apps. They just remove the ones that do not abide by the rules. Also Google is pretty liberal itself and likes free information (Well, they are a search engine. of course they do) and I do not think they would remove it even if it would say "And this is why democrats suck" in big-red letters on every report. You are free to use the app or to not use it. It's your decision in the end.
- joeycfan 14y agoApple's attitude has always been 'we know better'. Thing is, with Jobs, they were right...
- nachteilig 14y agoI typically support Apple's app store limitations, but come _on_ guys. This is almost as silly as the Mark Fiore situation.
- nuje 14y agoNice to know no iOS app can help out if some day drones start strafing my country (cue arab spring etc.)
- lutusp 14y agoThis is a tempest in a teapot. Obviously the same content could be placed on a Web page containing an incarnation of Google Maps, with an updated overlay containing publicly available data about air strikes. Then iPod/iDevice owners could simply launch a browser and visit the site for the latest data. It's obvious from the article graphic that the app is using Google Maps to display its data, so hosting it in a Web page would produce the same outcome, even the same appearance. Indeed, given the move to so-called cloud computing and the public nature of the data being displayed, that's a more obvious way to accomplish the program's role -- put it on the Web and publish the page's address.
- scott_s 14y agoThe creator stated push notifications as one of the main points of the application. Rather than being about getting raw information, this app is more about general awareness.
- lutusp 14y agoAn issue easily solved by the user pressing "Refresh" on a Web page, or the provider designing a page that refreshes itself at 30-second intervals, and avoiding this entire brouhaha. If the app was something other than an obvious and trivial Google Maps incarnation, this might be different, and I am in no way excusing Apple's paternalistic behavior, but it isn't as though the content is being suppressed by their decision. It's better overall if this is a Web page -- it lifts the restriction of being an iOS app, it opens the source to anyone with a working browser. It's a more robust solution to what seems to be a non-problem.
- scott_s 14y agoI still think you're missing the point. The point was someone would be going about their normal day, and intermittently receive notifications of a disturbing event from the phone in their pocket. A webpage breaks this, as users have to seek out the information. Again, this app is more a creative endeavor than a tool. The author is thinking of ways to make people more aware of something, forcing them to think about it during their day, not trying to give them raw information. (Granted, one must still decide they want to be forced to think about this during their day, as they have to install the app and allow push notifications.) I'm also not making any judgements on Apple or the app itself. I'm just trying to explain what I think the creators' intentions are, and why a webpage is not suited for those intentions.
- rickmb 14y agoAs an Apple fanboy, I've been able to rationalize everything Apple has done concerning the app-store up to now, even if I personally would have like to have seen a way more open and liberal approach. And the overblown anti-Apple FUD, using misplaced terms like "censorship" and "monopoly" whenever an app was thwarted by Apples opaque policies has made it easy to ignore the objections of detractors. But I find it impossible to justify what is quite obviously a politically motivated rejection. I still believe this is Apple's store, and they can admit and reject what they like. But if politics comes into it, than that changes my personal perspective on buying Apple products. Just imagine if the subject would be "places that legalize gay marriage" instead of drone strikes. The only "objectionable" part of the drone strike app is that it may have a political agenda. That should never be grounds for rejection.
- dlikhten 14y agoAndroid FTW. I know this pops up constantly, but this is EXACTLY the reason I advocate for android. This sort of shit does not fly there. Apple has the ability to censor which even the government can't and worse is that it's fully legal. I really wish people would take these stories as a sign that we need to focus on the android market. FWIW: I am not advocating for the baby & bathwater argument. I think we must focus on android because it will put market pressure on apple to have a more fair/just approval process.
- stephengillie 14y agoEven if both Google's and Amazon's app stores reject an app, there are still other markets. And you can just download APKs from websites/ftp/etc and install them to your android, no market required.
- nivla 14y agoThat is until all the three (Apple, Google and Microsoft) decides to only allow installs from the maketplace, you know for "security" reasons. The problem is if one company gets away with it, others follow suit.
- grandalf 14y agoI think it's important to be reasonable in cases like this and realize that companies willing to undertake censorship like this on behalf of government will surely (and happily) do things like install payloads on your device without permission. It's really a very small leap to expect this.
- fleitz 14y agoHelping nations keep track of progress through their crimes against humanity is more IBM's business. Apple is merely interested in the fall from grace, not the accounting.
- sageikosa 14y agoAny user base who would give up a little freedom for a little security, will end up with a platform-specific app store.
- oofabz 14y agoActually killing people is "objectionable and crude". Telling people about it, in an attempt to stop further killings, is anything but.
- nextstep 14y ago"About two weeks later, on July 23, Apple told him was just too blah." What is this supposed to say?
- chimeracoder 14y agoI came here to see if anybody else noticed this too. The only thing I can think of is an oversight by a lazy copy editor, just like the occasional [TK] that slips into print. Though this is becoming increasingly rare, both because the [TK] notation is losing popularity, and because having copy editors at all is also losing popularity....
- prodigal_erik 14y agoApple's dystopian system is working as designed. If you're going to take offense, let it be that they granted themselves the power to do this at all, not whether they got around to using it or for what. I just worry how many customers may not care what they opted into even if they knew.
- wprater 14y agoWhoa. Now Apple is providing censorship for our [corrupt] government. Sigh.
- genwin 14y agoThey go hand in hand, I'd say.
- frusciante29 14y agoI know people are getting killed in Afghanistan. Why would I want to know how many and when?
- toomuchcoffee 14y agoThe Cupertino company says the content is “objectionable and crude,” according to Apple’s latest rejection letter. "We train young men to drop fire on people. But their commanders won't allow them to write F-U-C-K on their airplanes... because...? it's obscene!" -- Colonel Walter E. Kurtz
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- spinchange 14y agoClearly not as desirable as just having the finished app approved, but a drones twitter account that posts every time the strike database is updated sounds like an itch worth scratching to me.
- hcarvalhoalves 14y agoEverything now is an app, distributed inside walled gardens. Censorship! Yay! In other news: just make stuff like this as a mobile site.
- thisischris 14y agoThis is a mobile site with a native wrapper- that's why it isn't allowed.
- lukifer 14y agoMobile-wrapper apps are indeed allowed. This one was rejected specifically for "crude" content.
- blazingfrog2 14y agoInstead of calling this a political move, I'm wondering if they would allow an app that tracks murder victims across the US as they happen. My guess is that it would be rejected too for the same reasons, which are probably not political. This would simply be, as they said, crude. And IMHO, inappropriate.
- lancewiggs 14y agoOr an app that tracks crime, classifiable by type? That would be useful. As would thus app be to many journalists. This is a slippery slope.
- ars 14y agoWould either side of the "national drone debate" (if there is such a thing) object to this app? Those opposed to it would like to know what's happening. Those in favor would like to see how effective it is. I can't see either side objecting, so I agree with you that it's probably the fact that it's about death that is the reason they were rejected.
- Tycho 14y agoI can just imagine some bored senator turning an app like this into an indictment of how Apple supports anti-Americanism and dodges taxes.
- Kerrick 14y agoFrom the reddit comments -- I'm surprised nobody on Hacker News brought this up before reddit! > Mobile app developer here... It was probably rejected because all it is is a web page wrapped in an app. > > 2.12 Apps that are not very useful, are simply web sites bundled as apps, or do not provide any lasting entertainment value may be rejected > Which this app clearly is. It's not even using the mapkit API. It's just a link to a web page.
- cageface 14y agoNope. As quoted directly in the article: The Cupertino company says the content is “objectionable and crude,” according to Apple’s latest rejection letter.
- enraged_camel 14y agoUnlike most of the posters in this thread, I don't think Apple's rejection of the app is political. Most likely, they want to protect themselves against future legal liability, since there is a risk that the US government (specifically the Department of Defense, or Department of Homeland Security) will question the legality of drone tracking programs if they haven't already.
- tiglionabbit 14y agoIs this information available on a web page somewhere?
- antihero 14y agoI think drone strikes are pretty fucking objectionable. Showing them on a map? Not so much.
- nell 14y agoWhat if this request was from the govt?
- JohnnyBrown 14y agoApple is literally preventing lifesaving technology from being deployed into the world. Due to this politically-motivated decision, actual real live human beings are being denied a simple tool that could allow them to literally avoid death. If we aren't civilized enough to distinguish between combatants and foreigners (is has been clearly shown that we are not), we could at least have the decency to give the spectators to our fireworks shows a warning.
- greedo 14y agoHyperbole much? This isn't a realtime tracking app that shows a drone in flight as it launches a Hellfire missile towards someone on President Obama's hit list...
- jrockway 14y agoMeh, it should be a web app anyway.
- nathan_long 14y agoOne more reason to develop for the open web instead of someone else's platform.
- Create 14y agoiOS privacy app returns as a web app Bitdefender says that Apple removed the application, which previously was a paid product, from the iOS App Store in June, but hasn't given it a reason for doing so. A potential cause could have been that Clueful tried to auto-detect a user's installed iOS apps so it could then display information about them. http://www.h-online.com/security/news/item/iOS-privacy-app-returns-as-a-web-app-1695483.html http://www.h-online.com/security/news/item/iOS-privacy-app-r...