5 ms·
Makes sense. You also don't give calculators to students of arithmetic.
by amelius 1y ago
Makes sense. You also don't give calculators to students of arithmetic.
- luqtas 1y ago[flagged]
- multjoy 1y agoYou can rely on the answer a calculator gives you. There's no danger that it will simply be confidently wrong.
- somanyphotons 1y agoSome calculators will confidently state incorrect answers to questions like: (10^15 + 7.2 − 10^15) * 100
- sfpotter 1y agoA calculator uses some type of finite precision arithmetic internally. If you run afoul of the limits of this arithmetic system, it may very confidently give you a wrong answer!
- mulmen 1y agoLLMs are notoriously bad at math but they’re not LMMs so that shouldn’t be surprising. If you want an LLM to do math you just ask it to write a program with tests.
- throwaway422432 1y agoHow about Pentium II floating point arithmetic?
- monero-xmr 1y agoWater? I didn’t realize that when you use water it disappears from the universe, or even from earth, or even from the local ecosystem
- rel_ic 1y agoEnergy doesn't disappear, but obviously it moves from useful forms to unuseful forms. Same with water. Your sarcasm just comes off as naive arrogance.
- monero-xmr 1y agoThe water is gone? Where did it go?
- mulmen 1y agoConverted to steam and carried out of the local ecosystem by wind. From the perspective of anyone downstream the water is gone.
- monero-xmr 1y agoReally? All water that goes into the air is gone forever? And then the wind blows it away? Incredible
- mulmen 1y agoWhy are you being so antagonistic? Are you ok? > Water? I didn’t realize that when you use water it disappears from the universe, or even from earth, or even from the local ecosystem Your own standard includes the local ecosystem.
- monero-xmr 1y ago[flagged]
- luqtas 1y agoyou should educate yourself both at the ecological impact of data centers and the economics of running a water facility. it's just too simplistic to skim down 'water' used into a thing that turns it into rain and then it's captured to be used again. good luck with your next naive comment saying something like: rain is almost distilled water and treatment isn't required, so it can go into data centers directly don't also forget people living nearby these facilities constantly facing drains due to the HIGH requirement of a server some read: https://thereader.mitpress.mit.edu/the-staggering-ecological-impacts-of-computation-and-the-cloud/ https://thereader.mitpress.mit.edu/the-staggering-ecological... https://aucgroup.net/water-treatment-plant-costs/ https://aucgroup.net/water-treatment-plant-costs/
- 123yawaworht456 1y ago[flagged]
- j-pb 1y ago1Kg of Beef takes as much Energy as 60.000 ChatGPT prompts, and as much water as 51.383.333 ChatGPT prompts. Stop eating meat, driving your car, and taking hot showers. Then we can talk about prompt resources.
- ath3nd 1y agoWhy not all of it?
- j-pb 1y agoCost of opportunity and diminishing returns. It's stupid to optimise a 0.01% case when you can spend that time on a 25% case.
- ath3nd 1y agoI don't eat meat for the last 10 years, don't own a car, and take cold showers. Can we talk about energy and resource efficiency of chatGPT now or you gonna gatekeep the conversation till I convince all of humanity to be vegan?
- j-pb 1y agoI'm gonna (mathematically speaking rightfully) consider the conversation an absolute waste of time and resources, until a significant portion of humanity does that, yes. Because you falling over dead and consuming 0 resources makes only reduce global resource consumption by 0.00000001%.
- luqtas 1y agoi'm vegan for a decade if that matters, i also opted for not having a driver license even lured to recieve a car when i turned 18. i'm also straight and i don't want children. the later (not having children) has a bigger impact than the first 2 together... should we be anti-natalists? anyway your also missing the copyright violation and the whole other plethora of problems coming from generative AI. like bias and misiformation. water and electricity is just a tiny point of this great pile of shit. also this low % still uses USA coal power most of the times and drains water from nearby houses. i'm not a rat to dry-bath on talc powder because some greed entrepreneur wants their 6 figures in-check
- DavidPiper 1y ago(Theses days) it's hard to know what you mean by this and whether you're being sarcastic. No you don't give arithmetic students calculators for their exams, and you expect them to know how to do it without one. Yes you probably give professionals who need to do arithmetic calculators so they can do it faster and with less errors. Giving calculators to people who don't know how, why and/or when to use them will still get you bad results. Giving calculators to someone who doesn't have any use for one is at best a waste of money and at worst a huge waste of time if the recipient becomes addicted to calculator games.
- izacus 1y agoThe person you're responding to has clearly used the word "student". What on earth are you on about?
- DavidPiper 1y agoI interpreted "students of arithmetic" as anyone that practices arithmetic - similar to "students of medicine", etc.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- mulmen 1y agoSeems like a reasonable expansion of the concept to me. Why the aggressive dismissal?
- mulmen 1y agoCan’t tell if you are serious but I will assume you are. Why not? Seems like a logical conclusion. 1. Introduce the concept. 2. Demonstrate an intuitive algorithm. 3. Assist students as they practice and internalize the algorithm. 4. Reinforce this learning by encouraging them to teach each other. 5. Show them how to use tools by repeating this process with the tool as the concept.
- darth_avocado 1y agoYou want to limit the use of AI in schools just the way you want to limit calculators: ensure the student can do the math without calculators, even when the computation is hard and then teach them to use the calculator as a tool to help them move faster. Restricting AI completely or introducing it too early, both would be harmful.
- mulmen 1y agoI'm not really convinced. This sounds reasonable but I can't formulate a good argument in favor.
- stephen_g 1y agoSarcasm? We actually weren't allowed to take any kind of calculator into any of our advanced maths exams in University (and I'm talking just 15 years ago, not when they were newfangled things).