6 ms·
> It's really sad to me how we have completely fucked a lot of youth with social media, smart phones, You have to be careful with Gen Z threads like this on Re
by Aurornis 1y ago
> It's really sad to me how we have completely fucked a lot of youth with social media, smart phones,
You have to be careful with Gen Z threads like this on Reddit and Twitter. They are inherently biased toward Gen Z people who are chronically online and deep into social media.
If you spend time with kids in the real world, you learn very rapidly that most of them aren't on platforms like Reddit and Twitter. Of those who use Reddit, few of them actually post anything or even have accounts.
The subset of Gen Z who actually post on Reddit is small and a lot of them fit the description of chronically online, so it's no wonder that Reddit Gen Z people speak as if their generation is not socially engaged at all.
- generalizations 1y agoThat should also be true of the Gen Xers replying though. So I think that effectively cancels out.
- Aurornis 1y agoNo, the legacy social media platforms are more popular with older generations. Facebook is the canonical example of a social media platform that arrived after Gen X was young, but it now heavily used by Gen X while nearly completely shunned by Gen Z, with millenials somewhere in the middle. Reddit and even Twitter are legacy social media platforms for Gen Z, especially younger Gen Z. The very oldest Gen Z people would have been too young to even use the internet when Reddit was launched.
- lapcat 1y agoNobody should take a Reddit thread as some kind of proof of a broad generalization. But some empirical data is given in the article, for example, Percentage of 12th graders going out with friends two or more times a week: https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!lQMo!,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F92ebf191-6ed2-4689-b5b2-bb36ba1b6ad9_1364x1064.png https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!lQMo!,f_auto,q_auto:... I think the Reddit thread is just a reflection of the reality rather than an argument for accepting that reality. You can attempt to discount the Reddit thread, but the submitted article wasn't even based on that.
- throwaway2037 1y agoIn highly developed countries, I think most people under 40 have moved away from Facebook towards Instagram, Twitter, and TikTok. I thought the main Facebook users are (1) those in developing countries (messenger especially) and (2) parents in highly developed countries who need to get updates for their kids' school/sports/clubs. Is this still broadly true?
- yubblegum 1y agoBasically, the kids who were socially marginalized in the prenetworks era also did not get to see the parties the socially active kids were having, and would have wondered at it all. It would have certainly been also 'a new experience' for them! Except back then they didn't have a place like reddit to go to and wonder out loud.
- snozolli 1y agoI never went to parties like this. I wasn't socially marginalized, I just wasn't one of the popular kids. Popularity at my school was closely tied with wealth and family status. A relatively tiny group of people lived this sort of life.
- anton-c 1y agoWe just had our own parties for our social group. Not as many pretty girls and alcohol stolen from parents but still a good time. Then when the popular kids were bored occasionally they'd end up at our shindigs
- grvdrm 1y agoPopularity is also so subjective. I look back at high school and see several popular groups. Did one rise above the others? Not in an obvious way. Like you said: some were from wealthier families, some were the athletes and their groupies (no surprise). But I went to parties of all shapes and sizes - some in those groups I just mentioned and some in other groups. Didn’t really matter that there was a premier group of socialites.
- throwaway2037 1y agoWere any of the popular girls physically unattractive? I doubt it. Popular boys can be popular without good looks, but it usually requires lots of money or great humour (class clown) or skill in a popular sport like American football or basketball. Look at a few "visually appealing" Instagram accounts. That will show you what basic popularity looks like, extended from high school.
- tlogan 1y ago
- esafak 1y agoAlso known as selection bias. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Selection_bias https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Selection_bias
- tines 1y agoWe know.
- afavour 1y ago> If you spend time with kids in the real world, you learn very rapidly that most of them aren't on platforms like Reddit and Twitter. Of those who use Reddit, few of them actually post anything or even have accounts. Certainly true. But it's also undeniable that a huge number of them are on TikTok, Instagram and the like. I think OP's point still stands that today's youth have been affected by that.
- rwyinuse 1y agoYep, I believe that at this point in rich countries people who are addicted to their smartphone and social media far outnumber those who aren't, at least in all age groups that aren't small children or retired.
- olyjohn 1y agoYep, and people get really offended when you bring it up, because so many people are addicted. I see it a lot in threads discussing auto accidents. Nobody wants to admit that a scary amount of drivers are on the roads using their phone constantly. I see it as a motorcyclist, because I can easily look down into most people's cars. My trucker friend also says that he sees a huge portion of drivers just on their phones constantly. Again, it's super easy to see into any car from a semi truck. The addiction is real, and such a huge portion of people have it and don't want to admit it. When you have to have your phone out while you're driving, you have a real problem.
- 98codes 1y agoI wonder how the levels of engagement compare between an extremely online GenX person, an average GenZ person, and an extremely online Gen Z person would look like.
- Auracle 1y agoThat's true. However, I worked as a photographer for about 10 years (quit about 2 years ago) and high school senior photos were one of my specialties, so I got to know a lot of teenagers. Overscheduling is, I think, the biggest issue. Most of the teens I worked with had something going on almost every night, to the point where rescheduling due to rain or heat was an absolute nightmare. Sports were the biggest offenders. They would often have gym/strength training in the morning and then practice in the evening, almost every evening. Keep in mind I'm mostly talking about summer, so the school year itself was worse. Those that had jobs would do them during the day. It's completely different from when I graduated high school in '06. Very few sports took over your life in the summer. Football had practice in the mornings for part of the summer, and that's the only one I'm aware of. I don't get the emphasis on sports. I played some in school but never took them seriously and if they required that much time from me I would have been out.
- AStonesThrow 1y ago[dead]
- ilikecakeandpie 1y agoI graduated in '05 and some of stuff my contemporaries were doing then wrt sports and trying to get to the next level was already crazy (playing for the school and doing travel ball as well, so many practices/camps/extra workout sessions) and don't get me started on the craziness wrestlers had to go through. I've heard it's even worse now as it has become more competitive to get to the next level, whether that's trying to get a good NIL deal or trying to play professionally
- germinalphrase 1y agoI was a HS teacher for about a decade. The demands on kids and families around youth sports (especially private/club leagues) is out of control. I had students, 14/15-years-old, going to their school team practice then club team practice, not getting home until past 9 pm every night. Families from three states away would enroll their kids in my school half of the year to play on the hockey team (staying with local sponsor family). Tournaments across the Midwest most weekends. These weren’t even future D1 athletes. I was a multi-sport athlete. My sibling played D1 soccer. It didn’t used to be like this.
- slg 1y agoThere is still a big difference between not being invited to/attending parties and not knowing if they even exist as a concept.
- torginus 1y agoI'm not quite sure if smartphones are still all that popular. With the rise of WFH, (and for Gen-Z, having a Covid lockdown college experience), most people are on actual computers and are sitting at home.
- fuzzy2 1y agoActual computers? People don't have those any more. Not even laptops. They have smartphones and they may have tablets. I'm over-generalizing of course, but that's the vibe I get. It's because many, both older and younger, entirely skipped the whole personal computing thing.
- lurk2 1y agoThe majority of web traffic has been mobile since the latter half of the 2010s.
- steve_adams_86 1y agoAnecdotal, but my 15 and 16 year olds, along with their friends, generally dislike computers and think they're inefficient, inconvenient, and too hard to use for most purposes they associate with devices. In other words, they have no idea what computers can do, and they just want the phone things that are easy to do on the phone. I've tried to teach my kids about computers, but they're extremely resistant. They just don't care. Their friends don't either, except for one who is notably interested in everything.
- throwaway2037 1y ago> generally dislike computers and think they're inefficient, inconvenient, and too hard to use for most purposes they associate with devices Hasn't this always been true for the masses for all eras of personal computing? I have been observing since the Apple ][ era!
- wil421 1y agoI get the same vibe from HN and other places on Reddit. Lots of folks are online in multiple places at all times. If I bring up a random internet topic in real like people give me weird looks.
- SubmarineClub 1y agoExcept the data repeatedly bears out that younger generations are spending more and more time online and in isolation. The idea that the internet remains the province solely of a few loner geeks is a total fantasy. Reddit is one of the most popular websites in the world. Also, I was a shy nerd in high school who used reddit, and I still partied. Fuck, I made my own booze to take to parties. Meanwhile my youngest brother - who is super social - graduated high school in the last few years and reports that partying is totally dead compared to my day.
- lapcat 1y ago> You have to be careful with Gen Z threads like this on Reddit and Twitter. They are inherently biased toward Gen Z people who are chronically online and deep into social media. Wouldn't Gen X responses on those threads also be inherently biased toward Gen X people who are chronically online and deep into social media?
- conductr 1y agoMaybe but they had a pre-internet life to reference and this topic is specifically discussing it
- lapcat 1y agoYes? That's the point. Even the Gen Xers with strong geeky/nerdy predilections had parties back in the day.
- conductr 1y agoPeople change. Just because a Gen X is nerdy/chronically online now, doesn't mean they didn't party in the pre-internet era. I'm one of them that fits that mold. I've probably withdrawn more from society specifically because I had the entertainment of being online, tons of knowledge to consume, a tool to build digital things, etc. I had none of that in most of the 90s, so I went to raves and keg parties every weekend and experimented with lots of drugs and even had sex.
- lapcat 1y ago> People change. Yes, and also society changes people. I think that's the point, and you allude to it: > I've probably withdrawn more from society specifically because I had the entertainment of being online, tons of knowledge to consume, a tool to build digital things, etc. I had none of that in most of the 90s The younger generations are suprised that we used to party all the time, because they never had a chance to live under the same circumstances.
- glxxyz 1y ago
- insane_dreamer 1y ago> inherently biased toward Gen Z people who are chronically online and deep into social media most of the Gen Z people I know fit this description is there really a significant Gen Z cohort that isn't "chronically online and deep into social media"?
- autoexec 1y agoIt's also true that it's "chronically online" GenX folks who are replying to the "chronically online" GenZ folks. Even if we assume that "chronically online" people and reddit users are nerdier, less social in the real world, tend to be more introverted, less likely to go to parties in general, etc. we're still left with teen parties being normal for the GenX nerds and alien to the GenZ nerds. As an old, chronically online, more introverted, nerd I can say that I absolutely attended parties in my teens and early 20s (only some of which were lan parties or BBS meetups)
- coldtea 1y ago>so it's no wonder that Reddit Gen Z people speak as if their generation is not socially engaged at all. Still one sees them even outside all glued to their screens.