9 ms·
So, is this an app that bundles it's own X11, or is it using a Quartz/Cocoa backend for GTK? EDIT: I downloaded it, and the app bundle doesn't seem to have an
by wtallis 14y ago
So, is this an app that bundles it's own X11, or is it using a Quartz/Cocoa backend for GTK?
EDIT: I downloaded it, and the app bundle doesn't seem to have an X11, so that's nice. However, upon firing it up, it throws up a splash screen in front of all other applications. Who still thinks that's acceptable behavior on a multitasking operating system? Also, the app quits when the last window is closed, which isn't how OS X apps are supposed to behave.
- bonch 14y ago> Also, the app quits when the last window is closed, which isn't how OS X apps are supposed to behave. Close the last document in TextEdit on Mountain Lion and see what happens to TextEdit.
- sliverstorm 14y agoWho still thinks that's acceptable behavior Adobe still does, and of all apps, GIMP is going to be one of the most likely to emulate them.
- MikeCapone 14y agoPhotoshop's splash screen doesn't stay on top of all other windows and steal focus, at least not in the version that I have. If anyone from GIMP is reading this, I strongly recommend that you fix that or at least allow us to disable the splash screen. Thank you.
- w1ntermute 14y agoHave you tried this: http://kuoi.com/~kamikaze/read.php?id=129 http://kuoi.com/~kamikaze/read.php?id=129 Looks kind of old, but it might still work.
- graue 14y agoOff-topic rant: "Someone with spare time on their hands feel like adding a 'Disable splash screen' checkbox to the preferences panel?" That suggestion illustrates a common anti-pattern in open source software. Broken behavior should simply be fixed, not receive an extra option to turn it off. No one wants to have to check an "unbreak my software" checkbox.
- w1ntermute 14y agoI don't think this is necessarily broken behavior. Photoshop has a splash screen too, and from what I understand, it's there because of the long loading time.
- wtallis 14y agoA splash screen that can't be minimized, hidden, or covered up with a useful window is definitely broken behavior. I think it can only be implemented by abusing APIs meant for screensavers and full-screen games.
- sliverstorm 14y agoAre you kidding? All you need is always-on-top behavior, which is usually offered in some form by most window managers.
- wtallis 14y agoI was referring to implementing this behavior on OS X specifically. To get this behavior, you have to deliberately avoid the usual way of throwing up a modal window in order to have that modal window stay visible and on top when the application is deactivated. I don't even have to dig up the source code to know that it reads like an ugly hack that messes with the raw values of an enumerated constant. Most likely, it's in the Quartz backend for GTK, and somebody only implemented half the abstraction for window management.
- tincholio 14y agoThank you kindly, sir, that worked! The current wrapper script is a bit different, but the same switch does the trick.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- atopuzov 14y agoIt uses GTK with Quartz support, which has it's quirks :(, and the GTK engine they are using looks nice (murrine + theme zukitwo). I been using Wireshark with GTK-Quartz in that mode for a few years (compiling on my own) but they have managed to integrate GTK menus to the Mac menubar.
- forgotusername 14y agoI'm confused. You double clicked an application icon, and the application opened? You seem to be conflating the popular hate for focus being stolen due to some non-consensual event, and the consensual starting of an app. If GIMP didn't have a splash screen, there'd be no indication it was loading at all (and it's one big fat app.. several generations of code including a huge chunk of Python loaded at boot).
- reitzensteinm 14y agoSplash screens are fine, splash screens that are set to always on top are not. Important distinction.
- protolif 14y agoThe toolbox window is also set to 'always on top'. It's not a huge deal, compared to the x11 version though. I just open another virtual desktop for it in Lion.
- DigitalJack 14y agoThe icon bounces when an app is starting in osx. I am sure there are probably a couple, but normally Mac apps do not do splash screens.
- wtallis 14y agoOS X app icons bounce in the dock while the app is loading. If it takes a really long time, a splash screen is ok, but a splash screen that sticks around for a full minute and thwarts every attempt to raise a window above it is just insulting.
- protolif 14y agoI agree that they should change this, but I don't find it offensive, because I know that the GIMP project has been around since it was acceptable to get a cup of coffee while your app loads. I'm just saying, that they've got a lot of legacy code. I'm just happy that it works, for now.
- naz 14y ago> Also, the app quits when the last window is closed, which isn't how OS X apps are supposed to behave. If anything, they're ahead of the curve. Most Apple apps are beginning to follow this behavior: App Store, Calculator, Contacts, Dictionary, DVD Player, FaceTime, Font Book, Game Center, Garage Band, Image Capture, iPhoto, and so on.
- cmelbye 14y agoNotice how most (all?) of those are single window applications.
- buu700 14y agoSo is Gimp, with the release of 2.8 (well, the option's there anyway).
- _1 14y agoBut it's still a document-based application. Those, in general, stay active even if all the documents are closed.
- timdiggerm 14y agoNot in the new Apple way. I believe the idea is that they'll save their state but close.
- agscala 14y agoRight, but does opening more than one window for a single application count? Two chrome windows for instance.
- ken 14y agoApple's OS X Human Interface Guidelines[1]: "In general, quit when users close the last open window in your app." [1]: http://developer.apple.com/library/mac/documentation/UserExperience/Conceptual/AppleHIGuidelines/Windows/Windows.html#//apple_ref/doc/uid/20000961-TPXREF56 http://developer.apple.com/library/mac/documentation/UserExp...
- poblano 14y agoLike iTunes.
- btn 14y agoKeep reading... "If an app continues to perform some function when the main window is closed, it might be appropriate to leave it running after the user closes the main window. For example, iTunes continues to play after the user closes the main window."
- flatline3 14y ago"In apps that are not document-based ..." GIMP is document-based.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- mbell 14y agoWhat i find annoying in OS X is flipping over to a desktop, telling an app to start (with the hope that it starts in that desktop), then flipping over to another desktop to keep doing stuff while it loads, only to find that the app has decided to start on your current desktop, not the one you launched it in.
- gosub 14y agoThis also happens to me in GNOME (v 2.30.11, Debian 6.0.5).
- btn 14y ago> Also, the app quits when the last window is closed, which isn't how OS X apps are supposed to behave. This is almost consistent with Apple's HIG: "In general, quit when users close the last open window in your app. [...] If users close the last remaining document window in a document-based app and switch to another app, it’s appropriate to quit the app" (emphasis added). [1] [1]: https://developer.apple.com/library/mac/documentation/UserExperience/Conceptual/AppleHIGuidelines/Windows/Windows.html#//apple_ref/doc/uid/20000961-TPXREF56 https://developer.apple.com/library/mac/documentation/UserEx...
- nsxwolf 14y agoThat's odd. I don't think I've ever seen this behavior. I just tried it with Pages and the application remained open.
- jarcoal 14y agoGive it a try with TextEdit and you'll see the expected response.
- tuananh 14y agoCmd W closes the document without quitting TextEdit. just tested on lion. Mac is document-based instead of application-based so closing document doesn't quit the app. it only does if multiple documents doesn't make sense to the application like System Preferences.
- nspragmatic 14y agoYou're doing it wrong. This is the HIG quote from above: > "In general, quit when users close the last open window in your app. [...] If users close the last remaining document window in a document-based app and switch to another app, it’s appropriate to quit the app" (emphasis added). In TextEdit, close the last document and then _switch to another app_. You're missing the last step.
- grannyg00se 14y agoDoesn't behave typically on Windows 7 either. Clicking the window close button doesn't close the app, it closes the currently open document. Also, ALT+F4 doesn't close the app either, just the current document. This is in single-window mode where closing the window should close the app. Fortunately CTRL-Q does what it's supposed to. Oh, and great job GIMP folks. I love GIMP and recommend it often. I've even tried to convince some folks to stop using illegal Photoshop copies and switch to GIMP instead (so far I have a 0% conversion rate).
- hnriot 14y agoso far I have a 0% conversion rate that's not surprising given that the GIMP pales by comparison to photoshop. There's just no comparison. I think the high price of Adobe Creative suite has always been there because any professional uses it and buys it, but Adobe knows there are many illegal copies used by students and they just assume they one day will get jobs and then they will be paid users, meanwhile the illegal use is subsidized by the industry who doesn't care how much it costs because it gets the job done. By comparison GIMP is a toy. I know its a pet of the open source community, but commercial software with real designers and focus groups and product managers sometimes get it right.
- sbuk 14y agoPhotoshop is hardly a beacon of software done right. In my experience (been using Photoshop pretty much everyday since 1991) it has got considerably more bloated and unstable with each release, the exception perhaps being 5.5. The benefit that Photoshop has is familiarity and Adobe's pricing structure is that of an abusive monopoly - they know they can charge as much as they do because they have a monopoly. This monopoly was earned in large part because early on, Photoshop was the most accessible app.round about 5.0 Adobe started to get sloppy. I've started using Pixelmator for about half the image work I do on the Mac and IMHO it represents excellent value for money. It works like Photoshop used to do. It's lacking some feature, mainly the ability to work in colour channels, but for the price, it's hard to beat.
- 14y ago