4 ms·
I don't agree. Most LLMs have been trained on human data, so it is best to talk about these models in a human way.
by amelius 1y ago
I don't agree. Most LLMs have been trained on human data, so it is best to talk about these models in a human way.
- 4ndrewl 1y agoEven the verb 'trained' is contentious wrt anthropomorphism.
- amelius 1y agoSomewhat true but rodents can also be trained ...
- 4ndrewl 1y agoRodents aren't functions though?
- FeepingCreature 1y agoEvery computable system, even stateful systems, can be reformulated as a function. If IO can be functional, I don't see why mice can't.
- psychoslave 1y agoWell, that's a strong claim of equivalence between computationable models and realty. The consensual view is rather that no map is matching fully the territory, or said otherwise the territory includes ontological components that exceeds even the most sophisticated map that can be ever built.
- FeepingCreature 1y agoI believe the consensus view is that physics is computable.
- 4ndrewl 1y agoThanks. I think the original point about the word 'trained' being contentious still stands, as evidenced by this thread :)
- tempfile 1y agoSo you think a rodent is a function?
- FeepingCreature 1y agoI think that I am a function.
- tliltocatl 1y agoAnthropomorphising implicitly assumes motivation, goals and values. That's what the core of anthropomorphism is - attempting to explain behavior of a complex system in teleological terms. And prompt escapes make it clear LLMs doesn't have any teleological agency yet. Whenever their course of action is, it is to easy to steer them of. Try to do it with a sufficiently motivated human.
- psychoslave 1y ago>. Try to do it with a sufficiently motivated human. That's what they call marketing, propaganda or brain washing, acculturation , education depending on who you ask and at which scale you operate, apparently.
- tliltocatl 1y ago> sufficiently motivated None of these targets sufficiently motivated, rather those who are either ambivalent or yet unexposed.
- criddell 1y agoHow will you know when an AI has teleological agency?
- tliltocatl 1y agoPrompt escapes will be much harder, and some of them will end up in an equivalent of "sure here is… no, wait… You know what, I'm not doing that", i. e. slipping and then getting back on track.