14 ms·
> - if you give people the chance to place a label on themselves to give a name/form to a problem, they’ll take it. This one is widespread among the young peop
by Aurornis 1y ago
> - if you give people the chance to place a label on themselves to give a name/form to a problem, they’ll take it.
This one is widespread among the young people I’ve worked with recently. It’s remarkable how I can identify the current TikTok self diagnosis trends without ever watching TikTok.
There’s a widespread belief that once you put a label on a problem, other people are not allowed to criticize you for it. Many young people lean into this and label everything as a defensive tactic.
A while ago, one of the trends was “time blindness”. People who were chronically late, missed meetings, or failed to manage their time would see TikToks about “time blindness” as if it was a medical condition, and self-diagnose as having that.
It was bizarre to suddenly have people missing scheduled events and then casually informing me that they had time blindness, as if that made it okay. Once they had a label for a condition, they felt like they had a license to escape accountability.
The most frustrating part was that the people who self-diagnosed as having “time blindness” universally got worse at being on time. Once they had transformed the personal problem into a labeled condition, they didn’t feel as obligated to do anything about it.
- dataflow 1y agoCan't you just tell them to give you a doctor's note and then you'll figure out how to accommodate?
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- Brian_K_White 1y agoOh you have time blindness? How unfortunate! That's just like my check-writing blindness I just got.
- dsubburam 1y agoThis parallels the debate about free will and determinism. If you were in the determinist camp, believing that all that one does was predetermined by prior environmental causes, could you still hold people responsible for their actions? Hobart makes a convincing argument that you can: "Fatalism says that my morrow is determined no matter how I struggle. This is of course a superstition. Determinism says that my morrow is determined through my struggle. There is this significance in my mental effort, that it is deciding the event." [1] i.e., he is a "compatibilist", thinking that you can believe in free will and determinism too. If you find Hobart persuasive, time-blindness or no, it does make sense to reproach someone for being habitually unpunctual. [1] https://philarchive.org/archive/HOBFWA https://philarchive.org/archive/HOBFWA
- gsf_emergency_2 1y agoReposted to address: labels on clusters of belief such as "free will" and "determinism" tlb or pg has a pithy saying that I can't find now goes smth like "we should avoid labels [on people] not because they are useless (they aren't) but they are hard to get right. Adding the cost of being wrong to that makes them not worth it" There's some connection to the "build skill or taste?" dilemma threaded earlier https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44469163 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44469163 You can make proper use of labels-- that requires taste. To build skill, you try to find new labels that can go viral ;) E.g you combine them like Hobart :)
- ycombinete 1y agoWhy have you typed out the full word for everything in your cmmnt except for “something” and people’s names? I guess pg is Paul Graham. Who is tlb?
- gsf_emergency_2 1y agoA tik https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=pastYear&page=0&prefix=true&query=by%3Atlb&sort=byDate&type=comment https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=pastYear&page=0&prefix=tru... 'Trevor L. Blackwell', co-founder of YC Pls help
- zdragnar 1y agoThe problem is conflating one's identity with the label allows a person to project all of their problems onto the rest of the world. By "being" the label, one has little to no agency over it. Without agency, there is no responsibility, nor incentive to change. Without responsibility or incentive to change, there is no problem for the individual; rather the problem is everyone else. This isn't just something that a person can do to themselves- it's something society can do to people. The phrase "bigotry of low expectations" describes a behavior of assuming that a label identifies a person, and that they have no personal agency to overcome it. The behavioral shift of everyone around that person molds the image the person has of themselves to a limited, restricted version of what they're actually capable of.
- Walf 1y agoI'm sure there are those who self-diagnose without really suffering from a condition, but you do realise time blindness is a real issue, right? https://www.simplypsychology.org/adhd-time-blindness.html https://www.simplypsychology.org/adhd-time-blindness.html I don't watch TikTok videos, I don't use Instagram, but I have been plagued by these symptoms my entire life, and don't really care about others opinions on it. You probably don't have it if those symptoms don't resonate with you, but there are plenty of people who genuinely struggle, and there's likely some overlap with those who have undiagnosed ADHD.
- peab 1y ago“Time blindness” is not named anywhere in the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, Fifth Edition (DSM-5, 2013) nor in the DSM-5-TR (text-revision, 2022). It is not recognized as a stand-alone disorder or an official diagnostic criterion.
- rahimnathwani 1y agoEven if it were in DSM-5-*, would that mean it's a standalone disorder? I haven't read much psychology, but this article suggests a lot of psychological diagnoses are just labels for symptoms: https://slimemoldtimemold.com/2025/02/06/the-mind-in-the-wheel-prologue-everybody-wants-a-rock/ https://slimemoldtimemold.com/2025/02/06/the-mind-in-the-whe... Imagine that your car breaks down and you bring it to a mechanic and he tells you, “Oh, your car has a case of broken-downness.” You’d know right away: this guy has no idea what he’s talking about. “Broken-downness” is an abstraction; it doesn’t refer to anything, and it’s not going to help you fix a car.
- Aurornis 1y agoFYI: SlimeMoldTimeMold has been heavily debunked across multiple topics. It was popular for a while in rationalist communities for the multi-part series claiming lithium in the water supply caused obesity, until everyone realized the author has a serious habit of misrepresenting sources, claiming citations say things they don’t, and omitting contradictory evidence.
- imetatroll 1y agoThis is simultaneously funny and sad. I wonder when alcoholism will get a front row seat during zoom meetings (or even IRL meetings). "Can't help it hick I'm an alcoholic". I think a lot of societal change these days can be summarized by the idea that self-labeling is seen as transforming something into "everyone else's problem".
- kingkongjaffa 1y agoThis is interesting point. Western society has basically built a hyper capitalist system that creates individualistic consumers, but has failed to hold individuals accountable to minimum standards. The bar has never been lower and we just sort of amble on as a lonely, isolated society so long as the stock market grows quarter to quarter.
- wolvesechoes 1y agoIt was created because those hyperindividual consumers will not enact any political change as it requires numbers and solidarity, something that our society of snowflakes finds disgusting. Everything else is a byproduct.
- samdoesnothing 1y agoNo that is ridiculous. Stop blaming capitalism for every problem in the world, it just makes you look childish. Especially when it comes to alcoholism. As if the soviet union was a bastion of soberness with a high bar or something.
- const_cast 1y ago> Stop blaming capitalism for every problem in the world, it just makes you look childish. Economics is intertwined with every other study. We can't pretend socio-economics isn't real, social interactions fuel the economy and the economy influences our social interactions. Also, making connections to way capitalism might fuel addictive disorders, such as, say, talking about advertising of alcohol and tobacco, does NOT mean that we are saying communism is perfect. Communism fuels disorders in other ways. It's actually quiet childish to take any analysis of capitalism as a praise of communism. It's the sort of "team sport" mentality you see in politics among the most uneducated and reductive among us.
- BiteCode_dev 1y agoI think after a few expressions of time blindness, they'll discover that their contracts have continuity deficiency and their career vertical expression challenges. The feedback of reality will fix it, like for all young people.
- FirmwareBurner 1y ago>The feedback of reality will fix it, like for all young people. "A child who isn't disciplined at home, will be disciplined outside of the home" - old African proverb. The issue is kids growing up without being taught accountability, but instead that they're perpetual victims of "the system" created by evil old white men, and therefore nothing they do is ever their fault. This is the fault of the parents, school system and society as a whole who coddles kids giving them the false sense of security that they can always have their way, right until they hit the brick wall of adulthood featuring employment, bills, debt, responsibilities and self sufficiency.
- rightbyte 1y ago"Disciplined at home" is being a maybe not perpetual but victim of the system for something like 18 years though. I don't get where this idea that kids are coddled with comes from. They usually are not even allowed to wear the cloths they want or choose the food they want and get pushed around to silly extents. Kids almost never gets it their way.
- BlackFly 1y agoIn order to hold someone accountable for their actions you need to allow them a choice in the first place. Disallowing children from making choices is one way of protecting them from the consequences of a bad decision: by not allowing them to make it in the first place. That is what coddling is, protecting from the environment. Protecting them from the choice is just a more extreme version of shielding them from the consequences.
- rightbyte 1y ago
- zombot 1y agoSome young people in that phase of their lives where they grow into being responsible for themselves start missing the times when they were not responsible and try to extend those times with any pretext they can come up with. It's quite human but should of course not be encouraged.
- TheOtherHobbes 1y agoThis has been the worst thing about my experiences on Threads. A lot of people make what they - and the US mainstream, apparently - defines as a heterodox personality their entire sense of self. So almost everyone is some combination of queer, "neurospicy", a witch, "creative", and so on. This often seems to come with some assumption of moral superiority. But under the label many of them are absolutely mainstream people. Their posts aren't genuine spontaneous comments - they're calibrated and calculated as a marketing exercise for "engagement" and to promote a product, course, Insta lifestyle, and so on. I realise it's tough out there and everyone has to hustle. But there really aren't many who acknowledge the gulf between the vocabulary of rebellion from the reality of "Please buy my course on how to be anticapitalist." (Actual example - not made up.) If I looked I imagine I'd find a mirror image of hustle conformity and superiority culture on far right boards, only more so. It's all quite weirdly Social Media™. Edit: to add, I'm not criticising specific subgroups. I'm very aware the US is a dangerous place and being certain kinds of person significantly decreases your life expectancy. It's more how social media has somehow distorted the online experience of those subgroups away from straightforward human exchange into commercial opportunity without people being aware of it.
- debesyla 1y agoAnd long before the internet there was horoscope signs that, somehow, still manage to stick around.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- mystified5016 1y agoThis was a huge trend on Tumblr like ten years ago. The millennials got bit bad by this and I guess genz inherited it. Or maybe this is just how young people think when given access to this type of information.
- Treehouse16 1y agoTime blindness is a real thing. However, I know it triggers peope snd it allows them to complain about people being late. "Time blindness" is about temporal processing, and I have it. I only mention the condition when people ask me questions about when something happened, because people think everyone is the same, I have to explain that I can't perceive time. It's real, etc. So exhausting, but they keep complaining about something they don't have. https://psychiatryonline.org/doi/10.1176/appi.neuropsych.19120342 https://psychiatryonline.org/doi/10.1176/appi.neuropsych.191...
- mapt 1y agoThere is a pervasive feeling in our complex postindustrial society that one thing we are lacking is a little fucking slack, the sort of thing that might be unavoidably extended on a very regular basis in the primeval human tribe/clan. We get it where we can. Turning employment and education into an up-or-out pressure cooker that thinks nothing of, for example, firing the bottom performing 10% of people every year, or failing a student who's fifteen minutes late to a final exam, is not what we are built, cognitively/socially/culturally, to tolerate. These people are taking a norm that we DO make a formal attempt to force tolerance on, disability, and trying to extend it to get the system to treat them more like a human being and less like a competitor. Let's take a more consensus trend: ADHD. ADHD barely existed as a recognized social phenomenon until the 1990's. > I didn’t realize how much of a psychiatrist’s time was spent gatekeeping Adderall. > The human brain wasn’t built for accounting or software engineering. A few lucky people can do these things ten hours a day, every day, with a smile. The rest of us start fidgeting and checking our cell phone somewhere around the thirty minute mark. I work near the financial district of a big city, so every day a new Senior Regional Manipulator Of Tiny Numbers comes in and tells me that his brain must be broken because he can’t sit still and manipulate tiny numbers as much as he wants. How come this is so hard for him, when all of his colleagues can work so diligently? > (it’s because his colleagues are all on Adderall already – but telling him that will just make things worse) > He goes on to give me his story about how he’s at risk of getting fired from his Senior Regional Manipulator Of Tiny Numbers position, and at this rate he’s never going to get the promotion to Vice President Of Staring At Giant Spreadsheets, so do I think I can give him some Adderall to help him through? > Psychiatric guidelines are very clear on this point: only give Adderall to people who “genuinely” “have” “ADHD”. https://slatestarcodex.com/2017/12/28/adderall-risks-much-more-than-you-wanted-to-know/ https://slatestarcodex.com/2017/12/28/adderall-risks-much-mo... https://youtu.be/xErFsi5AdQ0?si=x0OWNLy07fUr3Cry&t=702 https://youtu.be/xErFsi5AdQ0?si=x0OWNLy07fUr3Cry&t=702