13 ms·
English doesn't use accents because the speakers don't give a __ about the correspondence between the written form and the pronunciation. https://en.wikipedia.
by amelius 1y ago
English doesn't use accents because the speakers don't give a __ about the correspondence between the written form and the pronunciation.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ghoti https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ghoti
- knome 1y agoghoti is a ridiculous example. it takes its components entirely out of context. 'gh' as 'f' only occurs at the end of a syllable, 'ti' as 'sh' only exists as part of '-tion' where the pronunciation slurred over time. Pretending it says anything about the nature of the English language outside of English being a complex merging of various other languages that has evolved with time is silly.
- salomonk_mur 1y agoRead and read are the same exact fucking letters and are pronounced differently. You really don't need to go very far to find many examples. English is fucked up. The only way to learn how to speak it properly is by memorization. Other languages like Spanish or Korean keep a near-perfect one to one correspondence between written form and expected pronunciation.
- efilife 1y ago[flagged]
- selectodude 1y agoEnglish lacking a language regulator makes it hard to be a bootlicker for that particular language. Whose boot are they licking?
- eviks 1y agoThe blob's
- JKCalhoun 1y agoWhat was the poem (song?) that captured many more of these? (Anyone?)
- defrost 1y agoThe Chaos (1922) by Gerard Nolst Trenité ? https://people.cs.georgetown.edu/nschneid/cosc272/f17/a1/chaos.html https://people.cs.georgetown.edu/nschneid/cosc272/f17/a1/cha... https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1edPxKqiptw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1edPxKqiptw (and others similar)
- JKCalhoun 1y agoBingo!
- toast0 1y ago> wind, rewind Wind and rewind are fine. It's just wind and wind are a problem, like read and read. For example, wind and rewind sound the same in: Rewind that, so I can see him wind up.
- yread 1y agoalso wound and wound
- jcranmer 1y agoThe best 'defense' of English spelling I'm aware of is https://www.zompist.com/spell.html https://www.zompist.com/spell.html, which at the end admits: > I doubt that this page will convince anyone that English spelling is a good system. There's too many oddities. [...] What I hope to have shown, however, is that beneath all the pitfalls, there's a rather clever and fairly regular mechanism at work, and one which still gets the vast majority of words pretty much correct. It's not to modern tastes, but by no means as broken as people think. Which is to say, English spelling is definitely messed up. But it's not some insane thing that lacks any hint of sanity that some people try to portray it as.
- ragazzina 1y agoThis article feels to me as it was written in bad faith, trying and failing to prove a point, but then positing the point was proved. The author happily start the article by submitting: >The purpose of this page is to describe [...] the rules that tell you how to pronounce a written word correctly over 85% of the time. but then they quietly show that with their whole page of rules, the reader will not actually pronounce 85% of the words correctly as they just claimed, but actually less than 60%. By arbitrarily deciding that a number of errors can be considered small, the author bumps the number of "correctly pronounced words" to 85%. Are we talking about 85% of the whole language? No, just 5000 words. Even if they are the most frequent in the written language, they would still only account for around 95% of all the words. The author position is: - people complain about the English spelling all the time, saying it's horrible - the English spelling is actually pretty systematic and this page will explain the rules to understand it - when you will have mastered these rules, you will pronounce half of the words perfectly - for extremely common words such as "give", "get", "real", "very", "put", "half" you are still SOL - the english spelling is not so horrible after all: as a perfect student you will only butcher more than 1 word every 10 spoken To me, the author has proved the point he was trying to disprove. (and in which rule do /ˈsɪŋɚ/ and /ˈfɪŋɡəɹ/ end up?)
- Pooge 1y agoCould you please share your list? I have this discussion a few times per year and I'd love to hand that list to people that think written English makes sense. I was thinking of writing a blog article on it but I don't think I'd need to anymore!
- efilife 1y agoI'll organize it a bit and I can (if I don't forget) share it tomorrow
- Pooge 1y agoPing!
- efilife 1y agoBelieve me or not, I kept the list in a chat with my girlfriend on a certain social platform and got my account banned (just yesterday). I'll bother her to find it, check this thread in a week if I don't get it in the next hour. Although the list is not as extensive as you may think
- Pooge 1y agoAppreciated nevertheless! Cheers
- efilife 1y agocompiling the list together tomorrow. sorry for the wait
- efilife 1y agoHere's the list. You probably expected something larger due to me saying I maintain it since 2022, but I wanted to keep the best examples here https://pastebin.com/JhFdEY5Y https://pastebin.com/JhFdEY5Y Pasting it here as HN doesn't like my formatting
- marci 1y ago> In my native language these kinds of errors are impossible as how you pronounce letters doesn't change depending on the word they are in Don't forget when the pronunciation depends solely on the meaning. Live or Live?
- brainwad 1y agoYour examples are more or less regular though. English is a stress-based language, so it's expected that pronunciation might change when you add an extra syllable, if the stress moves (syllable -> syllabic is another example, btw). > wind, rewind This one is trivial, no? the "wind" in "rewind" is pronounced the same, with /aj/. The "wind" with /ɪ/ is unrelated.
- huimang 1y agoAll languages have inconsistencies, but it seems in vogue these days to single out english and use it as a punching bag. Furthermore, no natural human languages (i.e. not artificially constructed ones like esperanto) are logical. They all have irregularities and illogical aspects. It is not "beyond fucked" that things have different pronunciations sometimes. Other languages have problems for people who solely learn by speaking. It's not unique to english.
- int_19h 1y agoEnglish is singled out because its orthography really is atrociously bad even when compared with other languages. https://arxiv.org/pdf/1912.13321 https://arxiv.org/pdf/1912.13321
- huimang 1y agoAmongst niche circles of linguists, maybe. It's easy to single out for the average person because it's popular- english is a language learned around the entire world. Besides, I'd rather have some more word pronunications than memorizing a table of der/das/die,dem/dem/der and a word's gender on top of learning the word itself. Or changing the position of a verb depending on if I used a modal verb or not.
- int_19h 1y agoWe were talking about the orthography specifically. There are certainly areas in which English is much simpler than other languages, including those that you mention. But its orthography is objectively very bad.
- coffeeling 1y agoA Dutch man wrote an amazing poem highlighting the absurdity of English orthography: https://people.cs.georgetown.edu/nschneid/cosc272/f17/a1/chaos.html https://people.cs.georgetown.edu/nschneid/cosc272/f17/a1/cha...
- pookha 1y agoAs someone that enjoys reading I can't think of a more descriptive language than the English language...It's easily one of the most powerful languages on earth and has twice (!) the number of words in its vocabulary compared to something like French, which is heavily centralized by some managerial class. You just have to appreciate the language for what its strengths are (unbounded capability to communicate using just words) vs what you as a novice need to do to master it. Which, to be frank, is easier than mastering something like the Korean language that has all this drama and ceremony around politeness and speech levels.
- jcranmer 1y agoThat is a really bad example, because English does have fairly productive pronunciation rules [1], and trying to make 'fish' come out of ghoti requires breaking them. 'gh' only occurs as an /f/ sound when it occurs at the end of a syllable; as an initial consonant cluster, it's invariably /g/. Turning 'ti' to /ʃ/ is a fairly normal affricatization, which requires a subsequent vowel, which is lacking here (consider words like 'ratio', 'gracious', or 'nation'). Even turning the 'o' into /ɪ/ relies on fairly regular vowel destressing, which there's no reason to expect in 'ghoti'--which should be pronounced per English rules, pretty unambiguously, like goatee. There are some real issues with English spelling, like the inconsistency of pronouncing 'ea' as /i/ or /ɛ/ (consider, uh, read and read). But 'ghoti' isn't one of them, because that's a case where there's not a lot of ambiguity in English pronunciation. [1] The worst offenders in English pronunciation are when English borrows foreign words both with foreign pronunciations and foreign spellings.
- degun 1y agoThe explanation you gave is already contained in the cited Wikipedia article. I think this "ghoti" example is more of a tongue-in-cheek mocking of pronunciation inconsistencies. If you want a jarring example, consider laughter and slaughter. I know, i know, they have different origins, but still, it confuses foreigners like me while learning the language.
- mousethatroared 1y agoBut English orthography isn't meant to serve foreigners. Im ESL, I struggled with English spelling as much as the next latin speaker who's already learned to read and write in foreigner. But now that I get the reason behind it, I love it. I consider English orthography worthy of UNESCO protection, even. In fact, I am annoyed at the regular spelling of my two latin languages that have left so much history behind.
- hyperpape 1y ago> But English orthography isn't meant to serve foreigners. Or natives. It is slower for children to learn to read English than other languages.
- eesmith 1y agoI thought the article did a good job of explaining how English uses additional letters where French use accents, like the "h" in "ship" to indicate how the s is pronounced.
- 6P58r3MXJSLi 1y agothat's how "sh" is pronounced, not how "s" is pronounced same pronunciation of sh in ship is found in - sugar - sure - machine - Chicago - mustache - sheikh - nation (!!!!) Can you notice that some of those words do not have any "s" in them? English doesn't make any sense.
- eesmith 1y agoYes, and how do those entirely true observations connect to the non-use of diacritics in English? I pointed out the ship example from the text, which was used to demonstrate how "this early French influence over English, which arose from the Norman Conquest, is the beginning of the reason why English is written without accent marks. ... This was the French habit that the Normans brought to England: the use of extra letters to spell sounds that the alphabet didn’t have special letters for. This is why English has combinations like sh, th, ee, oo, ou that each make only a single sound." That's an extra letter being used to indicate a different sound than the base sound, similar to how diacritics are used to indicate a different sound than the base sound ("the cedilla has the function of ensuring that a c can be pronounced like an s, despite coming before an a, o, or, u").
- 6P58r3MXJSLi 1y ago> "is the beginning of the reason why English is written without accent marks" > sh, th, ee, oo, ou That's cool 'n all, but I believe that only applies to French writing in English for English people. Many languages have combinations of letters that have a single sound, it's no excuse for not having accents. In German one can write strasse and straße or müller and mueller (different writing, same sound). They too don't have accents, but words written differently also sound different: schon = "already" and schön = "beautiful". But German, on one hand retained diacritic marks, on the other it's also almost deterministic about pronunciation. a it's always /a/ ä it's always /ɛ/ or /ə/ like e sch it's always /ʃ/ as in schule ch it's always /x/ after a, o, u and /ç/ after e, i and so on English doesn't use diacritics, IMO, because English doesn't make sense, it's a pastiche of lowest common denominators, so fck diacritics, they are too hard, let's write words as we like and pronounce them the way we feel they should sound, regardless of how they are written. But it could use accents, for example rècord and recòrd, present and presènt, pérmit and permìt it's just they never thought it could be useful...
- KurSix 1y agoTo be honest, English orthography is such a Frankenstein's monster of historical layers that even if we did care, untangling it would be a nightmare
- beeforpork 1y agoLike others, I don't find that nonsense word particularly enlightening. But maybe compare '-ough' in: cough, tough, dough, through, plough.
- jameshart 1y agoYou missed enough and borough
- tanjtanjtanj 1y agoThe -Ough in enough and tough and in borough and dough are pronounced the same, at least in any accent I can think of.
- jameshart 1y agoOkay, enough=tough, they did have that one - not sure why I missed it. But ‘borough’ in British English doesn’t rhyme with dough. The ‘-ough’ is a schwa.
- wizardforhire 1y agoYep! Not only that but people will actively mispronounce words as a form of vetting. Mispronunciations also becoming a form of tribal identity. Speaking of American vs proper English. America is the most diverse cultural landscape in human history. If you stay put, you won’t see it. Start traveling around the country and its the only thing you see. this is not hyperbole. Sure other places are diverse, however because of the unique nature of the US and its size it just ends up attracting and subsequently absorbing.
- DiogenesKynikos 1y agoAmerica is diverse in some ways, but in terms of language and dialects (which is what we're discussing here), America is remarkably homogeneous. There are many tiny countries with more linguistic diversity than the US.
- wizardforhire 1y agoSpecifically to english and dialects, you are correct. England proper has a different dialect and accent for every nook! London for literal neighborhoods! It also has several hundred if not thousand of years on the US for language to develop. Africa has everyone beat on this front. Bantu alone has who knows how many sublanguages! America has done a pretty remarkable thing in keeping its language internally consistent despite it’s overwhelming cultural diversity and influences! That it sucks to learn for the uninitiated is exactly for this reason.
- tempodox 1y agoIndeed, you could never tell how an English word is pronounced unless you “just know”. And then it's still inconsistent (e.g. finite / infinite).
- brainwad 1y agoMost English words are regular, and most commonly used ones too. "the", "be", "are", "why", "can", "might", "life", etc. are all perfectly regular if you understand how to read english orthography (which uses character clusters and can't be read a letter at a time). Infinite/finite regularly related, too - the reason the pronunciation of the finite cluster changes is due to stress differences (initial in- always takes the stress, and then the following syllable must be destressed). Note that the long vowel at the end comes back in the 4 syllable "infinitum", again due to regular stress rules.