3 ms·
> I've been building software for the Mac since 2008 Ok, so they knew where Claude went wrong and could correct for it.
by amelius 1y ago
> I've been building software for the Mac since 2008
Ok, so they knew where Claude went wrong and could correct for it.
- simonw 1y agoRight: tools like Claude Code amplify existing skills and expertise, they don't replace it.
- risyachka 1y agoThe main issue here is you can’t acquire expertise by using llm to code for you. So unless you have 15+ yoe better add more reps. You can always switch to llm code assist in a blink, there is no barrier to entry at all.
- willsmith72 1y ago> The main issue here is you can’t acquire expertise by using llm to code for you. Agreed, but I wish I had it as a teacher while learning. The amount of help my interns need from me has reduced by at least 50%, and what remains is the non-trivial stuff which is completely worth my time to coach and mentor them
- nojito 1y ago>The main issue here is you can’t acquire expertise by using llm to code for you. You learn far far faster from reading code and writing tests than you do just writing code alone. I've long suspected for years that the bottleneck to software development is in code generation not keeping up with idea generation.
- risyachka 1y agoYou learn by trying to solve the problem by yourself. This is not about syntax but about learning how to create solutions. When you read solution you merely memorise existing ones. You don’t learn how to come up with your own.
- nojito 1y ago>When you read solution you merely memorise existing ones. You don’t learn how to come up with your own. You can't solve programming problems without reading code. Period. The more code you read the better you get at solving problems because your internal knowledgebase grows.
- AnotherGoodName 1y agoI tend to learn via code examples. 20+ years of experience and the llms have taught me about some features of libraries i was using but overlooked. I think they add to expertise honestly.
- freedomben 1y agoI wonder how common this is. Personally, looking at code examples can be helpful, but the vast majority of my learning comes from doing, failing, trying a different approach, succeeding, rinsing and repeating. I also haven't had much luck with getting llms to generate useful code. I'm sure part of that is the stack I am using is much less popular (elixir) than many others, but I have tried everything even the new phoenix.new , and it is only about an 80 to 90% solution, but that remaining percentage is full of bugs or terrible design patterns that will absolutely bite in the future. In nearly everything I've tried to do, it introduces bugs and bug hunting those down is worse to me than if I just did the work manually in the first place. I have spent hours trying to coach the AI through a particular task, only to have the end solution need to be thrown away and started from scratch. Speaking personally, My skills are atrophying the more I use the AI tools. It still feels like a worthwhile trade-off in many situations, but a trade-off it is
- cosmic_cheese 1y agoI also have not had much luck with LLMs when it comes to anything with substantial complexity. Where I’ve found them best is for generating highly focused examples of specific APIs or concepts. They’re much better at that, though hallucinations still show up from time to time.
- kiitos 1y agoIn my experience they very consistently diminish existing skills/expertise...
- simonw 1y agoHate to say it, but that means you're holding them wrong. If they diminish your skills, you're letting them do that. Learn to apply these tools in a way that helps you learn more things and do better work.
- Leave_OAI_Alone 1y agoThe ability to spin up a single page tool for converting timestamps or counting tokens or analyzing a few hardcoded weasel words is handy: nobody disputes that. But that is not the work most of us do. In the real world, away from those whose salary depends on marketing these agentic tools, an LLM is a context shredder. It provides plausible code snippets that are globally incoherent and don't fit style. CONVENTIONS and RULES files are a kludge, a sloppy hack. These tools flatten the deep, interconnected knowledge required to work on complex systems into a series of shallow, transactional loops that pretend to satisfy the user. The skill being diminished is not the ability to write a single-page utility or single-purpose script. It is the ability to build and maintain a mental model of a complex machine. The ability to churn out a hundred disparate toy tools is not evidence of a superior learning method, it is evidence of a tool that excels at tasks with no deep interconnected context.
- simonw 1y agoBuilding the stuff on https://tools.simonwillison.net https://tools.simonwillison.net only represents about 10% of the coding work I do with LLMs. I wrote about my process for non-vibe-coded projects here: https://simonwillison.net/2025/Mar/11/using-llms-for-code/ https://simonwillison.net/2025/Mar/11/using-llms-for-code/ > The skill being diminished is not the ability to write a single-page utility or single-purpose script. It is the ability to build and maintain a mental model of a complex machine. That's the thing that LLMs help me with 90% of the time. It's also why I don't think non-programmers armed with LLMs are a threat to my career.
- dangus 1y agoAnd at the bottom it’s revealed that this costs $200/month. I have trouble convincing myself to give Autodesk $50/month and I need that software for my primary hobby. And none of these AI companies are profitable. Imagine how much it will cost or how much it will be enshittified when the investors come looking for their returns. If everyone whose code illegally trained these models won a copyright lawsuit against Claude it would suddenly not be so good at writing swift code. Do we really want to bet on Disney losing their AI lawsuit? Honestly I realize my comment is not adding much to the discussion but the AI fatigue is real. At this point I think HN and other tech forums would do well to ban the topic for posts like this. Imagine if we were upvoting stories about how people are getting lots of coding done easier with Google and StackOverflow. It would be rightfully ridiculed as vapid content. Ultimately that’s what this blog post is. I really don’t care to hear how yet another dingus “programmer” is using AI to do their hobby/job for them.
- bwb 1y agoMaybe, but cost is going down fast on tokens, so this will likely be less of an issue.
- rvnx 1y agoOn Gemini it is actually going up
- nojito 1y agoOn average the change was a cost decrease because of the thinking token price decrease. For people who do not need thinking they can use flash lite which is cheaper as well.
- dangus 1y agoSounds like the product is stagnating and the only way to get the better thing is to pay more, which is kind of like saying you can get a faster server if you pay more. That isn’t moore’s law-style progress. If AI is truly progressing at the amazing rate that everyone is claiming then we should be continually getting better capability at the same price.