4 ms·
You should never hire a secretary who doesn't type for fun. You should never hire a caretaker who doesn't mop floors for fun. Doesn't actually work, does it?
by gaius 18y ago
You should never hire a secretary who doesn't type for fun.
You should never hire a caretaker who doesn't mop floors for fun.
Doesn't actually work, does it? Why are programmers "special"?
- cracki 18y agobecause it's mental work, not physical. you can't force creativity. of course, not all programmers need to be creative, but some do have to be. i agree though, it's a bit foolish to expect all your programmers to be "rock stars".
- hc 18y agothe suggested heuristic obviously works only if a measurable segment of people of profession x practice their trade for fun. but, it seems credible to me in the case of writing software (and not so much for mopping floors).
- yummyfajitas 18y agoYou should never hire a musician who doesn't play for fun. You should never hire an artist who doesn't paint/draw/whatever for fun. Seems to work ok for creative professions.
- silentbicycle 18y agoYou should never hire a chef who doesn't cook for fun.
- Retric 18y agoTrying to lump all of programming into the types of things you have worked on is a narrow view of the field. Programmers produce everything from high art, to plumbing but it's much closer to engineering than a musician. While some parts of programming is creative as a profession you get the full range from creative work to simple trial and error. EX: There are a lot of programmers who spend a lot of time interfacing with buggy API's which is soul sucking work, because the bugs are random. PS: If you are building a boy band you probably don't are about artistic talent. It might be useful but it's far from the most important trait.
- bprater 18y agoAh, now we know that programming is an art! Nice discovery!
- moe 18y agoBecause you can learn typing without loving it and you can learn mopping without loving it. Not so with programming which is ultimately a creative task. I know plenty of people who went through university and learned the mechanics of programming without really liking it. These people will never be good programmers just like most people who wrote essays in college will never be good writers. Ironically a mediocre programmer really compares better to a secretary than to a great programmer. He may be able to churn out code when given detailed instructions, just like the secretary will type out your letter when you dictate it to her. But the great programmer on the other hand; he decides what letter to write...
- gaius 18y agoNot so with programming which is ultimately a creative task. 90% of programming - sometimes 99% - is forms or reports. Validate and store some data, or retrieve and format some data. No-one does that "for fun". You need professionals who can execute at a high level of competence true, but "creative" is a bit of an exaggeration.
- ObieJazz 18y agoIt depends what stage the project you're working on is at. Adding new forms to an enterprise-level CRM might be where a lot of (boring) programming jobs are at, but it doesn't preclude creative programmers: those who create a system from scratch that does something that has never been done before.
- gaius 18y agoAll Web 2.0 is is forms and reports. You think, back in the 60s when it was the latest thing, COBOL programmers called themselves "rockstars"?
- moe 18y agoThat's nonsense, web programming is not (at least not in the general case) about forms and reports. If forms and database queries eat up a large portion of your time then I'd suggest to look into proper frameworks. In fact, that's what web programming is about these days: Find ways to make the common tasks as easy as possible, without sacrifying performance or flexibility. You don't want to spend the lion's share of your time on creating forms and views. You want to spend it on making the creation of forms and views so easy that the friction for actual feature development approaches zero.
- rsheridan6 18y agoA secretary who typed for fun or a caretaker who mopped floors for fun would actually probably be more productive than one who didn't. More specifically, someone who IMs all night long is probably a faster typing than someone who avoids a keyboard after clocking out. What makes programmers special? 1) There are actually people who program for fun. If you looked for rockstar janitors who mopped floors for fun, you wouldn't find any. 2) There is an order of magnitude or two difference in the productivity of great programmers compared to average programmers, whereas a great janitor or secretary may be something like twice as productive as an average one. It's more important to find a good one. 3) Filtering good programmers is notoriously difficult - it's not like typing where you can give candidates a simple test and get a straightforward, quantitative answer, so every bit of information helps.
- mechanical_fish 18y agoIf you looked for rockstar janitors who mopped floors for fun, you wouldn't find any. In honor of my late grandmother, who devoted about twenty years' worth of Saturdays to cleaning the floors and bathrooms of her local church -- for free -- I must inform you that this isn't true. Whether or not she was maximally productive is quite a different question. A lot of ritual activity isn't especially intended to be productive.
- waldrews 18y agoDon't know about mops, but apparently there are people who broom for fun: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Curling http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Curling Canada. I don't understand it either.
- alrexx 18y agoThat is a killer national slogan, I'd go there just for the country with enough of a sense of humour to use it.
- brl 18y agoI guess because hiring a mediocre secretary or janitor will not jeopardize a software company in the same way as hiring a team of mediocre engineers.
- RobKohr 18y agoYou would be surprised. A kick ass secretary will make all the "sticky" points of running a company go smoothly. I have seen 2 great secretaries that if they replaced would have a significant impact to the efficiency of a company. Also an rock star secretary can work smart rather than hard finding ways to remove repetition. A janitor could be a rockstar if they used methods to clean an office space to extreme detail with utmost efficiency. Admittedly the more work moves into the physical world, the harder it is to scale with simple mental skill, but programmers are not the only ones that can become "rock stars." Also, WPM is not as relevant a way to measure a secretary's skills any more just as it isn't a way to measure a programmer's skills. @brl: I know you just wrote a sentence, and this really isn't a reply to directly to you, but more to the elitist us and them content of this forum.
- brl 18y agoI'm not putting down the contributions of secretaries or any other non-engineering roles in a company. My point is simply that the quality of developer talent at a software company will permanently influence the future of that company in a way that can't be compared by simple analogies. There are good reasons to be more concerned with hiring the best programmers you can find than hiring the best secretary or the best janitor.