6 ms·
Don't hire a programmer if they don't code for fun
- stuntgoat 18y agoWhat if their idea of fun is taking slime samples from ancient damp caves in Northern California and graphing the mold contents compared with other similar caves in Oregon?I am just joking. I think any employee that you hire should be questioned regarding what project they have been inspired by. I would ask something like: "Talk about the last 2 or 3 projects you worked on ( personal or work-related ) where you felt 'extremely' to 'incredibly' inspired"
- LogicHoleFlaw 18y agoDr. Egon Spengler: I collect spores, molds, and fungus. From the classic Ghost Busters.
- TomOfTTB 18y agoHaving been responsible for a team of developers I can honestly say I don’t agree with this. At least, not entirely. Every team needs a few "Rock Star" programmers (to use the author’s terminology). When hiring those folks I think his advice is spot on. But the reality of programming a project is that there will be some tedious work that the "Rock Stars" will find boring. In my experience those types of developers actually do pretty mediocre work when forced to write no-brainer code. So I’ve found the best mix is to have a few of these rock star developers mixed in with folks who enjoy development and are hard workers but who are at a point in their life where they don’t have time for side projects. These are the guys who were probably rock stars in their younger years but now have spouses, kids and all the trappings of that (soccer practice, dance recitals, et al). Since they aren’t looking to work for the majority of their fulfillment they tend to be ok with the tedious stuff and since they are still decent developers they turn in solid code.
- ardit33 18y agoBut in a early stage startup you better off with few of the rockerstars types, then a lot of average coders. You can really do more, with less. In a early stage there is probably a lot of stuff to do, lots of features to keep the smart people engaged, and with fewer more productive people you have less overhead, less meetings, less political bs.
- mechanical_fish 18y agoin a early stage startup you better off with few of the rockerstars types Sure, but the article should make a point of including this qualifier. Because, of all the teams of programmers in the world -- even if you just count the competent ones! -- a very very small percentage are involved in early-stage startups, despite PG's best efforts. And a lot of those teams benefit from a mix of personalities, ranging from the energetic free electron to the dedicated day worker to the manager who actually kind of enjoys all those tedious meetings where (s)he evangelizes your work to upper management.
- dominik 18y agoRands in Repose has a useful take on "Rock Star" programmers; he calls them "Free Electrons." http://www.randsinrepose.com/archives/2005/03/20/free_electron.html http://www.randsinrepose.com/archives/2005/03/20/free_electr...
- sam_in_nyc 18y agoI agree with you completely. "Rock Star" programmers, or programmers who at least have that "Rock Star" mentality, are clever enough to realize that doing a shitty job on a project they openly dislike means in the future they won't have to work on projects they dislike. Due to their "Rock Star" mentality they can rationalize this poor work ethic because they truly believe they are benefiting everyone: "it's far better for me to kick ass with the XYZ project then to do this crappy ABC project" Trust me, I've been in that position (rock star). There's something more to "rock star" than just passion... they are aware of their rock star status. IMO, rock star programmers are good if you can handle them. You need to make them believe that what they are working on is of the utmost importance that they specifically were assigned it precisely because of it's importance and because of their capability. That's the best motivation for a rock star. Otherwise I agree with TomOfTTB: some rock stars, but more drones.
- bl00m 18y agoJust like photons, "Rock Stars" emit light but don't have substance. I'd rather have a look at a programmers code samples to see if it's elegant, clean and efficient.
- eru 18y agoYou should read up on photons. (I still upvoted, though.)
- ardit33 18y agoabsolutely not. The rockstars I know (3 on my life), do really produce a lot of code, and get done things quickly (and two of them had to leave early from work, as they family and children to take care off, yet they could produce almost twice the amount of quality code from other people and that's why they are so impressive. There are people that are all talk, and no game, but then they are people that can really produce code faster than you can think about a feature. Also, some of these people are able to do things that are too complex for any average programmer to even grasp. Things like implementing a very efficient interpreter, parser for a dynamic language, it top of something else, is only domain of people that really know their stuff. Sure, I worked on a interpreter, for a fictional language in CS class in college, but doing it for a production level language, is a totally different ballgame. As I said, management might be impressed by people that know how to talk, but a good programmer will only be impressed by people that really can code and get done things better then them. The only way to recognize one, is to work with one.
- Jem 18y agoI think it's the passion for what they do that differentiates a "rock star" from someone who just does it for the pay. You can have passion without being holed up in your bedroom programming 24/7.
- pclark 18y ago> The guy that takes a 10 minute set of verbal requirements, extrapolates, and builds a Web 4.0 Whooziwhatsit in a day, before you even know what Web 4.0 is. I can't think of anything worse in my team than someone that just constantly dives head first into code. Great coders stop and think, discuss, then code. IMHO.
- lbrandy 18y agoI can. The guy who is always listening for chances to jump in and prove how smart he is, instead of actually hearing what the other person is saying.
- pclark 18y agogood point
- msg 18y agoWe have both of those guys on our team. But hey, they do usually get stuff done. The guy who is not interested in good software design, can't learn or pick things up for their job, who requires constant repetition and babysitting, and finally breaks your software out of ignorance is worse than both of these.
- aswanson 18y agoWhy does he have this need to prove that so bad to other people that it trumps everything? Doesn't he know this himself already?
- barrkel 18y agoYou know, it really is possible to be working on something which is the "fun code" in your life. I try to avoid jobs where I don't have real passion for the thing I'm creating. Now, some of my "fun" might be in prototypes or similar concept testing or learning - lately it's been parser combinators - but ultimately it's all applicable to my day job, working on compilers.
- plinkplonk 18y ago"to my day job, working on compilers" This is the kind of day job one doesn't see here in Bangalore! Hereabouts everything is enterprisey this, soa that. :-(
- Xichekolas 18y agoFor what it's worth, you don't see many of those jobs in the midwest either... It's all SOA/six sigma/RUP madness here too. To top it off, I have to update three timesheets daily.
- plinkplonk 18y ago"To top it off, I have to update three timesheets daily" Ouch!
- gaius 18y agoYou should never hire a secretary who doesn't type for fun. You should never hire a caretaker who doesn't mop floors for fun. Doesn't actually work, does it? Why are programmers "special"?
- cracki 18y agobecause it's mental work, not physical. you can't force creativity. of course, not all programmers need to be creative, but some do have to be. i agree though, it's a bit foolish to expect all your programmers to be "rock stars".
- hc 18y agothe suggested heuristic obviously works only if a measurable segment of people of profession x practice their trade for fun. but, it seems credible to me in the case of writing software (and not so much for mopping floors).
- yummyfajitas 18y agoYou should never hire a musician who doesn't play for fun. You should never hire an artist who doesn't paint/draw/whatever for fun. Seems to work ok for creative professions.
- silentbicycle 18y agoYou should never hire a chef who doesn't cook for fun.
- Retric 18y agoTrying to lump all of programming into the types of things you have worked on is a narrow view of the field. Programmers produce everything from high art, to plumbing but it's much closer to engineering than a musician. While some parts of programming is creative as a profession you get the full range from creative work to simple trial and error. EX: There are a lot of programmers who spend a lot of time interfacing with buggy API's which is soul sucking work, because the bugs are random. PS: If you are building a boy band you probably don't are about artistic talent. It might be useful but it's far from the most important trait.
- iamdave 18y agoWe just call them rock stars. No we don't. We stopped doing that when other folks who were hiring "rock stars" failed to get a product off the ground, and proved their salaries couldn't live up to the livelihood of what a rock star expects to be compensated, thereby making the phrase "rock star" in any sense other than someone who does what Jimmy Buffet did overwhelmingly kitschy, and anyone using the phrase mind-numbingly foolish. Thanks for playing.
- thorax 18y agoI prefer "silly" to "mind-numbingly foolish", but I don't think he does himself any favors by using the term.
- Retric 18y agoYea, silly works. If we really want to give programmers silly names fine I am a "Professional". Aka the movie "the Professional" where you have a problem, you pay me money, I solve the problem. Rock Stars are just another silly name people give out so they don't have to pay you what your time is worth. Look up actual rock stars they tend to end up broke because while it might look like the are making a lot of money most of the time they are getting peanuts.
- jacquesm 18y agoif I correctly remember that movie it didn't end too well for the professional ;)
- aaronblohowiak 18y agoI respectfully disagree. He died protecting someone he loved, taking out an evil guy in the process. Thats as good a death as I could ask for.
- jadence 18y agoDude! Why do you have to post spoilers like that? Yeah it's far from a new release but still! I haven't seen it yet and it's on my Hulu queue. Thanks! Argh!
- known 18y agoAnd don't join companies that seeks references ( != back ground check ) for programmers.
- gcheong 18y agoDon't ever work for a place that doesn't have fun things to code?
- nihilocrat 18y agoThis is a good example of an article whose entire worth lies in the headline, and there is no real reason to actually read it.
- DaniFong 18y agoI think that fun is the wrong word. Fun would imply laughing and smiling, I think. Many works of creativity happen when there's ideas or feelings inside that are dying to get out.
- LostInTheWoods 18y agoIf a programmer codes for fun, he probably doesn't have a good idea of what real fun is. Secondly, not all things that need programming are "fun". Some are downright tedious, but nevertheless important.
- phil_collins 18y agoJust because a programmer codes something for fun on his own time doesn't mean he's going to have fun coding your app too.