3 ms·
I suggest amending the argument: "X is in a category whose archetypal member has certain features. Therefore, we should judge the past behaviors of X as if it
by 1123581321 14y ago
I suggest amending the argument:
"X is in a category whose archetypal member has certain features. Therefore, we should judge the past behaviors of X as if it also had those features, even though it doesn't; or assign future behaviors to X even though it cannot develop those features."
That said, I disagree this is a worse argument than its ideological opposite, A is not A.