6 ms·
Therapy dogs: stop crafting loopholes to fair, reasonable laws
- tiahura 1y ago[flagged]
- hollywood_court 1y agoAgreed. People are pushing the boundaries a bit too far and it's going to end up harming the people who truly do need animals like this with them in public.
- kennywinker 1y ago99.99% of the time it’s a way to bring your dog in the cabin instead of sedated in a crate (not something I want to do to my dog, so i get it). But for the other 0.01% of the time - your statement is quite prejudiced. Barring people with a disability from the main way travel distance is not the world i want to live in. Everyone is entitled to reasonable accommodations for their differences. Might as well say children can’t fly - they’re “emotionally unstable”. I’ve sat next to people who’re afraid of flying. It looks awful. If a dog on your lap helps you avoid a panic attack it seems like we can find a way to make that work without too much trouble.
- ameliaquining 1y agoNote that airlines aren't in fact required to allow emotional support animals in the U.S. I suppose I wouldn't be against loosening the "animal must perform a task" requirement as long as the "animal must be under control" requirement remains intact.
- devilbunny 1y ago> bring your dog in the cabin instead of sedated in a crate Bring your dog in the cabin without paying the fee, also. My wife flies with our (her, really) dog in the cabin all the time. She pays the fee, and the dog does have to be small (IIRC 10 kg is the cutoff, but I could be wrong). But small dogs in a proper carrier are acceptable.
- ameliaquining 1y agoThe fee seems like rent-seeking on the part of the airlines, so while I'm not going to agitate for prohibiting it or anything, I'm also not going to shed any tears if people skirt it in a way that doesn't inconvenience anyone.
- kennywinker 1y ago10kg means for a huge swath of breeds that option’s not available. For context a large Boston terrier would be excluded. So for some it might be about the fee, but for anybody with a dog bigger than 10kg (i’d guess that’s more than 50% but idk) that’s probably not it.
- devilbunny 1y agoIf your dog is over 10 kg, it’s probably not going to fit in a carrier small enough to go under the seat in front of you. So you should be buying a seat for it anyway.
- taeric 1y agoI assume this is largely a US thing? Do other places have similar behaviors? I seem to recall many people from over seas were surprised that we let dogs in the house. That last is always amusing to contrast with how hard of a line some people take on not doing shoes in the house, but then seemingly fine with pets.
- TulliusCicero 1y agoUS rules around service animals (typically dogs) are a bit odd. You're allowed to take a service dog nearly anywhere, which itself is fine, but the problem is that there's no official licensing system that a business could somehow check to make sure your animal is legit. Legally, they're only allowed to ask what service the animal provides and they can kick it out if it's disruptive. So the inevitable result is people taking advantage of this legal gray area by bringing in dogs that they pretend are sorta-service dogs (emotional support/therapy dogs) and getting away with it for the reasons explained in the article. And once those dogs are normalized, then it seems like dogs in general are okay and so just about anyone might decide to bring in their dog. A common point of comparison here is handicapped parking spots, since it's also a situation where the handicapped are granted a special privilege to mitigate the handicap, but obviously for parking spots there's a whole legal system for being allowed to park in those special spots. You can't just "self certify" that you can park in a handicapped spot, you have to get a placard from the government that you put on display on your car.
- baggy_trough 1y agoClearly we need such a licensing system, and such license would need to be displayed on the service animal. The lack thereof seems like yet another indicator that our government cannot legislate itself out of a paper bag.
- TulliusCicero 1y agoI completely agree, though unlike the author I don't really have an issue with people bringing dogs into some kinds of businesses. Restaurants and grocery stores no, but something like a hardware store I'm fine with.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- flufluflufluffy 1y ago[flagged]
- Boogie_Man 1y agoI am personally extremely tired of seeing random misbehaved non service breeds in red amazon.com vests which say "service dog". It's entitled, disrespectful to the public, disrespectful to the rule of law, and disrespectful to individuals who legitimately require a service animal. I will loudly state "oh nice it's one of those fake service dogs" at the aquarium, you cannot stop me. I also loudly announce "No dogs on the walking path, thank you citizen" at the public park when people ignore posted signs. Every single square foot of our world is not a playground for the invasive species you keep exclusively for emotional and social benefits. My productive milk cow, on the other hand...
- RajT88 1y agoAre you Robocop?
- absurdo 1y ago[flagged]
- Boogie_Man 1y ago[flagged]
- Analemma_ 1y agoThe idea that only uniformed officers are allowed to enforce social norms is a major part of what got us into this mess to begin with.
- TulliusCicero 1y agoMajor whoosh moment here. The RoboCop reference is clearly because of the phrasing: > "No dogs on the walking path, thank you citizen"
- TeMPOraL 1y agoThat has more of a Half Life 2 vibe.
- _myrk 1y ago[flagged]
- vinceguidry 1y ago[flagged]
- jahsome 1y agoThey did say they go to the mall every week. As far as I'm concerned, in 2025, that's akin to announcing "I'm a psychopath!"
- aspenmayer 1y ago[flagged]
- arp242 1y ago[flagged]
- aspenmayer 1y agoI think it’s a troll, but it could be a special kind of activist that is posing as a troll or otherwise indistinguishable from a troll. A lot of trolls lean in to hyperbole. Part of me wonders if it is some kind of false flag to make right wing people look bad, but I know enough unhinged folks of all political stripes to safely assume it could go either way, earnest or engaging.
- vinceguidry 1y ago[flagged]
- aspenmayer 1y ago> If maga were both sincere and intelligent then they'd be actual nazis. They lack the second quality so they just spout ineffectually in public spaces thinking they'll get support. If they knew history they'd understand that's not a viable strategy. Ya need a lot more than that to build authoritarianism bro. Their egos won’t let them go full nazi. Cognitive dissonance is overcome via suspension of disbelief through self-hypnosis at home and collectively online and at rallies. Their need to appear respectable prevents how deep down the rabbit hole that most are willing to go, which is why they lean in to extremism, because it alienates followers from moderating influences of family and friends who are not already indoctrinated. It’s a cult of personality. The liberals are baited for clicks and impressions, and the left are again sidelined until the next time they need to be chided for being insufficiently centrist by liberals. Non-extremists on both sides become the controlled opposition relative to each other vis-à-vis the political parties proper. We’re tilting at windmills while digital sharecroppers toil on company plantations, their blood from stones mere grist for the blood money paper mill. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HyperNormalisation#A_World_Without_Power https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HyperNormalisation#A_World_Wit... https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=to72IJzQT5k https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=to72IJzQT5k HyperNormalisation (2016) > In Russia, Vladimir Putin and his cabinet of political technologists create mass confusion. Vladislav Surkov uses ideas from art to turn Russian politics into a bewildering piece of theatre. Donald Trump employs the same techniques in his presidential campaign by using language from Occupy Wall Street. Curtis asserts that Trump "defeated journalism" by rendering its fact-checking abilities irrelevant. > The American Left's attempt to resist Trump on the internet had no effect. In fact, they were just feeding the social media corporations who valued their many additional clicks. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MIHC4NNScEI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MIHC4NNScEI HyperNormalisation explained by Adam Curtis > I'd be more than happy to discuss further. Over email, telegram or zoom. If you check my profile, you can find many available resources, including contact details.
- ipsum2 1y agoThis topic is ragebait. I predict the comment section will be pointless name calling than genuine discussion.
- chrisan 1y agoWell you weren't too far off. Already calls for execution on the spot for barking and role playing robocop or something. Some very stable minds or russian bots, I dunno. Not sure why this is on HN at all tbh
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- impoppy 1y agoWhy would therapy dogs craft legal loopholes in the first place
- ameliaquining 1y agoBecause people broadly understand that service dogs are a legally protected thing but not the exact details of the relevant laws, and this leads to interesting consequences when combined with increasing awareness of mental health in recent years. Probably in another decade the controversy will have settled somewhat.
- impoppy 1y agoCrazy to have lawyer dogs before flying cars
- neilv 1y agoShih-tzus are some of the most persuasive negotiators.
- gwbas1c 1y agoWhen I lived in California, it was common for restaurants to allow dogs in outdoor seating, especially sidewalk seating. My wife and I took full advantage of this; with full permission of the restaurant staff. I was rather surprised about 12 years ago when we were looking to move in together, and someone told us, "oh, you can get around this building's no dogs policy with a doctor's note." That really bothered us. We ended up moving to a place that was within walking distance of a great dog-friendly (on the patio) bar. I walked our dog there nearly every weekend! There's now a restaurant in town (Massachusetts) that proudly claims their patio is dog friendly. I might take advantage of it when my puppy is a little calmer.
- TulliusCicero 1y ago> I was rather surprised about 12 years ago when we were looking to move in together, and someone told us, "oh, you can get around this building's no dogs policy with a doctor's note." That really bothered us. That's a federal rule around emotional support dogs I think? Honestly I think landlords should just be banned for having those kinds of rules against common pets like some saner countries, so I don't have a problem with people getting around it. Landlords in the US have too much power over tenants.
- mvdtnz 1y agoSome of us want to live in no-dog buildings and we should have that option.
- TulliusCicero 1y agoIn practice it just becomes landlords suppressing what people can do in their homes to make things easier for themselves. Landlords would also happily ban parties or children if they could somehow get away with it. That some people would be happy with a no-child or no-party building wouldn't make that okay either. That said, if it was a matter of a small number of buildings being allowed to designate themselves as no-pet/no-dog, I'd probably be okay with that. Things like this only tend to become a problem if you let anyone do it.
- rsingel 1y agoI'll stop ignoring no dogs in parks signs when drivers stop ignoring speed limit signs
- pakitan 1y agoDemand free Palestine, while you're there, just to make sure you don't suddenly run out of reasons to continue being obnoxious.
- hollywood_court 1y agoI wouldn’t recommend that kind of behavior around Auburn. My son attended a forest school for three years, located in the middle of a protected nature preserve. The preserve has clear signage posted throughout stating that dogs are not allowed on the trails. Despite that, there were many mornings when I’d be walking back to my car after drop-off and would see someone heading toward the trails with a dog. I always made a point to politely let them know about the rule and that a staff member would likely ask them to leave once spotted. This happened at least 70 times over the three years my son was enrolled. Out of all those instances, only one person actually turned around and left with their dog. The issue became so frequent that preserve staff had to involve law enforcement and began issuing trespass notices. While I only personally witnessed this once, the director told me it became a regular occurrence. The one time I did see it unfold was honestly kind of entertaining. I gave my usual friendly heads-up to a couple with a small dog. The woman scoffed and said something like, “It’s just a small dog,” and continue into the forest. I went back to my car to send some work emails and Slack messages — and a few minutes later, watched as she was led out of the preserve in handcuffs. Apparently, she gave the same attitude to the responding officer.
- BeetleB 1y agoI believe you're missing the GP's point. Just as some people are enraged by folks violating "no dogs" signs, there are people enraged by folks not following traffic regulations (including the speed limit). Just as someone may think it's weird that someone goes on a very, very angry rant about people driving 63 mph on a 60 mph zone, lots of people find it weird when people go on a rant about dogs. This is exacerbated by the fact that one of these is much deadlier than the other. So when you go on a rant about dogs, just keep in mind a lot of people are viewing you in a way people view those who complain about people going above the speed limit (regardless of the lane you're in). Anti-disclaimer: I hate dogs. Would never date someone who had one because I don't want to be around one, and also because I wouldn't want to deprive someone of one.
- rahimnathwani 1y agoRelated: https://youtube.com/shorts/QsrxRmlatPI https://youtube.com/shorts/QsrxRmlatPI
- teeray 1y ago> unless they are a licensed service animal The problem in the US is that there is no such thing. You can ask “whether the animal is required due to a disability?” and “what tasks has the animal been trained to assist with?” The trouble with this is that you can construct any animal to pass those tests with some creativity. For example, trying to bring the family dog to an AirBnB: 1) “yes” 2) “The dog alerts me by barking when someone comes to the door” (i.e. most dogs). Access Granted. The second answer is reasonable for hard-of-hearing individuals, but you cannot actually ask if the person is hard of hearing, so you simply have to accept that the dog is a service dog. Society wants a licensure system, but for some reason we’re not being provided with one in the US.
- ameliaquining 1y agoDoes that loophole actually come up in practice very often? The impression I get is that it's much more common for people to either not know which questions they're legally entitled to ask, or not want to.
- lotsofpulp 1y agoYes, if you run a business, especially one that charges for pets like a hotel, almost every dog that comes through will be a service dog. There’s zero consequence for lying about it, and potential to save $50 or $100 or just being able to enjoy taking your dog wherever you want.
- SSchick 1y agoHaving moved from the EU (Germany) to the US there seems to be a LOT of these bad-faith skirtings of reasonable laws, especially in automotive (eg. license plate screens, window tint etc.) where lack of enforcement is abused and will eventually lead to the penaltization of the general public.
- yencabulator 1y agoUSA is not a high-trust society, and has low-key corruption everywhere. EU, or at least big chunks of it, are much more high-trust and "spirit not letter of law" minded. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High-trust_and_low-trust_societies https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High-trust_and_low-trust_socie...
- thepaulmcbride 1y agoI moved from Ireland to the US and noticed the same. So many people in the US treat others as if they are NPCs. Rules only exist so that they can’t bother you, but the rules don’t apply to you. It is extremely frustrating!
- _DeadFred_ 1y agoWe're a nation of persecuted immigrants. Some of our ancestors were deeply religious, but others were just stubborn contrarians who resisted authority to spite their neighbors. Europe exported those difficult people to the States.
- cromulent 1y agoThe wonderful New Yorker article "Pets Allowed" comes to mind. Turtles, turkeys, and so on. https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2014/10/20/pets-allowed https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2014/10/20/pets-allowed
- socalgal2 1y agoIs this a question of the people following the law or not liking dogs? I ask because people breaking the law bugs the crap out of me and it's specifically "breaking the law", not the behavior itself. Meaning, if the law changed the behavior would no longer bother me. For me it's about (1) being law abiding and therefore a sucker to all those who get away with more than they're supposed to (2) being afraid of selective enforcement - for example if it's traffic violation and it's enforced on me then my "points" go up which means my car insurance goes up. It's already at $4k a year with no points. One additional point is average ~$4680. So i don't want break at and fume at those who do but don't get caught. So yea, seeing people take dogs where they are not supposed to, run red lights (bikes or cars), make right turns on red on "no right turn on red" places, make illegal left turns, speeding, walking un "bikes only lanes", etc all piss me off. I go to local farmer's markets. There are signs everywhere, "No Pets". No one is obeying this law. Literally no one. WTF do they have the signs? All non-enforcement does is bread contempt for laws in general. Either enforce it or remove the signs. Same with other laws. In other words, if the law was changed, these things suddenly wouldn't bug me. I recognise this as strange but I also feel laws and their enforcement is how we as a society enforce cooperation living together. Non enforcement = people taking advantage = worse society.
- TulliusCicero 1y ago> I go to local farmer's markets. There are signs everywhere, "No Pets". No one is obeying this law. Literally no one. WTF do they have the signs? All non-enforcement does is bread contempt for laws in general. Either enforce it or remove the signs. Is that a law, or just a rule from the farmer's market?
- socalgal2 1y agoThe signs says they are from the health department. I'm sure the farmer's market would prefer to remove them given 30% of customers bring their dog.
- colechristensen 1y ago>I go to local farmer's markets. There are signs everywhere, "No Pets". No one is obeying this law. Literally no one. WTF do they have the signs? All non-enforcement does is bread contempt for laws in general. Either enforce it or remove the signs. I think this is just health code where the law is forcing them to put up these signs but nobody actually cares if there's dogs there, it's not really needed to ban dogs there, and the only people who want to enforce that rule are people who really like rules.
- abeppu 1y agoWhile I agree with the broader point that people should not abuse rules that are meant to accommodate for real needs ... this seems like the smallest-scale example of our society falling away from having meaningful rules right now. If you have the energy to be a Karen about rule-breaking and bad-faith behavior, please take a look at your elected officials, their actions, and their business dealings.
- IshKebab 1y agoWhatabout...
- abeppu 1y agoFrom https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Whataboutism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Whataboutism > Whataboutism or whataboutery (as in "but what about X?")[1] is a pejorative for the strategy of responding to an accusation with a counter-accusation instead of a defense against the original accusation. I'm not accused of anything or deflecting with a counter-accusation. I don't have a dog nor have I ever claimed an animal is a therapy animal. I actually think the post could be a bad-faith bait article which is itself an attempt to be a distraction.
- IAmBroom 1y agoYou almost literally what-about'ed "your elected officials".
- abeppu 1y ago1. I explicitly said I agree with the broader point 2. The fallacious form of "what about ..." is trying to dismiss problem X without addressing it by raising problem Y. I identified the article's concern as being part of a larger erosion of rule-based good-faith behavior, which I agree should be addressed. But I think the more effective way is from the top down. I'm _not_ saying that people should bring their dogs into restaurants until the government is no longer corrupt. I _am_ saying that this is the most pedantic, narrow way to go about improving anything (and possibly virtue signalling about disabilities without input from those people, and from policing other people's behavior in a way that comes off as self-righteous without achieving anything.) 3. Merely pointing at people and labeling them as what-abouting is itself a fallacious way of avoiding confronting that person's argument. Again returning to that wikipedia article: > Christian Christensen, Professor of Journalism in Stockholm, argues that the accusation of whataboutism is itself a form of the tu quoque fallacy, as it dismisses criticisms of one's own behavior to focus instead on the actions of another, thus creating a double standard. Those who use whataboutism are not necessarily engaging in an empty or cynical deflection of responsibility: whataboutism can be a useful tool to expose contradictions, double standards, and hypocrisy. > Abe Greenwald pointed out that even the first accusation leading to the counteraccusation is an arbitrary setting, which can be just as one-sided and biased, or even more one-sided than the counter-question "what about?" Thus, whataboutism could also be enlightening and put the first accusation in perspective. I.e. while I maintain that I am literally not using it in this instance, I nevertheless I find the impulse to loudly label something "whataboutism!" as a way to avoid engaging with a critique to also be a lazy fallacy.
- JimBlackwood 1y agoI really disagree with the owners statement that therapy dogs should never be able to get licensed. If they go through the same training as current disability dogs, then what’s the problem exactly? There are enough non-visible disabilities where dogs can be useful, for instance in panic disorders where they can recognise it before the owner. In regards to dogs in coffee shops, etc. Aslong as there are enough spaces that allow dogs, it shouldn’t be a problem when most other places don’t allow them. I think there are enough people that enjoy dogs to make that work.
- IshKebab 1y ago> If they go through the same training as current disability dogs, then what’s the problem exactly? With guide dogs the benefit is huge - someone can get around without human assistance. With "emotional support" animals it just means someone gets to take their pet with them to have coffee. Not a big enough benefit to outweigh the downsides.
- JimBlackwood 1y agoI think you underestimate how debilitating some disorders can be and the assistance a dog can give. If a person is unable to get a coffee without an assistance dog, and the dog is properly trained, why would you want to rob them of participating in a normal life? Something being "just" for you, does not mean this holds for everyone.
- KeepFlying 1y agoUnder the ADA, the kind of dog youre describing would be a service dog, same as any other. "Therapy dog" isn't a term that the ADA uses. You can totally have a legitimate service dog for invisible disabilities. Licenses don't mean anything in the US btw. The law does not require it and having a "license" is meaningless. Sometimes a training organization might vouch for the dogs skills, but that isn't a license and doesn't legally mean anything.
- tmaly 1y agoI met a couple that had paid $100 to get a fake service dog certification. I guess the training is extremely hard and many people don't want to do it. I have a miniature golden doodle that I try to take to as many places as possible. But if there is a place that is strict, I end up just having to crate her.
- diddid 1y agoI feel too, at least in the US, people have backed themselves into a corner where they are unable to dole out punishment. Not just for violating or abusing taking their dogs everywhere, but literally everything. Should someone be punished for a prank gone wrong? Of course not, they didn’t mean it, it was just a prank! Should someone be punished for faking a therapy dog? Of course not, it’s just a dog! Should someone be punished for speeding? Of course not, it’s just speeding and all cops are bad! Should someone get in trouble for minor theft? Of course not, it’s just minor theft, capitalism is bad! Eventually though they end up on the side being taken advantage of and now they have no recourse because they are all in on the no consequences society. If they speak up, their peers who are also part of the no consequences society disown them, until it then also happens to them. I guess that’s an oversimplified version of it. If nothing is a crime then you can have no criminals, society is better already, and you all get A+, yeah for us!
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- ValveFan6969 1y ago[dead]
- anotherevan 1y agoPersonally I want more miniature guide horses in the world. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guide_horse https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guide_horse