6 ms·
A Review of Aerospike Nozzles: Current Trends in Aerospace Applications
- ge96 1y agovideo on the rectangular one https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FcW9kUUTfxY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FcW9kUUTfxY I'm not sure if this one counts but recent https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UShD03eG9IU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UShD03eG9IU
- hinkley 1y agoI have some hope that rotating detonation engines will make aerospikes viable. But I don’t even see them mentioned in this paper. The idea with the constantly moving flame front is that it spreads the heat out. The limitation with aerospikes is getting enough coolant through the spike. Bells are simpler to cool, which as I understand more than makes up for them needing more cooling.
- ambicapter 1y agoDoesn't seem like a front rotating around the spike would gain that much "spreading out" over a continuous front. At the end of the day, its a spike that narrows to a very small point.
- JumpCrisscross 1y agoRDEs are far less tested than aerospikes. (In part because you can build a dipshit aerospike in your garage. I don’t know anyone who has made an RDE at home.)
- hinkley 1y agoI know one idiot on YouTube who has made an RDE at home. He was smart enough to leave the room while it fired. Tomatoes are disgusting.
- ben_w 1y agoI know Integza tried, but did he ever confirm his engine was doing a rotating detonation? He said near the end of the video 2 years ago, "I'm not sure if I got a rotating detonation wave": https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fRMMSyCcTDI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fRMMSyCcTDI
- fogh1 1y agoI think they were mentioned briefly. Aerospikes can work with rdes potentially if the certain versions catch on, but at the end of the day the heat fluxes are even worse for the detonation based engines. The main reason aerospikes don’t make sense is that you adding more area that gets the highest amount of heat flux and your plumbing and cooling jackets becomes a nightmare.
- Gravityloss 1y agoI wonder if aerospikes were popular as an idea in the J-2 engine ~Apollo era since USA only had gas generator engines (and expander RL-10). You can't get to very high chamber pressures with those, and then maybe aerospike was a way to work around the limitations. Then XLR-129 and SSME came along with staged combustion cycle and you can just have higher pressure engines. They can both run at sea level and still have a decent efficiency in vacuum. The linear aerospike for X-33 was kind of a neat tech demo and fit in with the whole shape of the vehicle and composites, non-tubular tanks and large base area. Maybe too many new things at once in retrospect.
- hinkley 1y agoThe estimates are that a fully functional RDE will be up to 25% more efficient than a standard bell/deflagration design. Efficiency means less heat per kg of mass to orbit. And with the rocket equation, that’s a lot less engine per kg of payload. Efficiency means either less heat, or intensely more incentive to solve the heat problem even with unobtanium. You could make the damned things out of molybdenum, which has 8 times the thermal conductivity of titanium, and a higher melting point.
- psunavy03 1y agoThe abstract brings up SSTOs, but has there been anything in recent invention that will make them anything other than the white whale people have been chasing since forever?
- PaulHoule 1y agoThe 1990s were a lost decade for reusable space flight because instead of chasing incremental improvements to the Space Shuttle (an orbiter with reusable tiles that could be turned around in days, not months) or something like the Falcoln 9 or the fly-back version of Saturn V that O'Neill's students drew in 1979, it was all about SSTO. SSTO is just marginally possible, if it is possible you need exotic materials and engines and you're never going to get a good payload fraction and adding wings, horizontal takeoff, horizontal landing and such just makes it worse. The one good thing about it is that you get closer to "aircraft-like operations" because in principle you can inspect it, refill it, and relaunch it -- whereas something like the STS or Falcoln 9 or Starship will require stacking up multiple parts for each launch. My guess is aerospikes are making a comeback though because of interest in hypersonic weapons system. I could also see them being useful for the second stage of something like Starship which mostly operates at high altitudes but has to land at low altitudes. There are a lot of other technical problems, like the thermal management system, which really have to be solved before worrying about that optimization.
- cubefox 1y agoCurrently the Starship upper stage simply has two different sets of bell nozzles: Three engines with nozzles for atmospheric pressure, and three for vacuum. I wonder how inefficient this really is compared to having just aerospike nozzles.
- psunavy03 1y agoThat's the same as the genesis of the question I asked above. SSTOs are a concept, but given their complete lack of market share, I assume as a non-aerospace engineer that there are valid reasons smart people have not been able to design a competitive one yet. Similarly, I assume there are valid reasons SpaceX has chosen not to use aerospike Raptors, especially given their well-earned reputation for innovating things everyone else swore couldn't be done. If even they haven't been able to make it work, that's a strong data point as to the state of the art.
- gatkinso 1y agoIs that an AI generated image of the Venture Star? It's missing portside wings..
- whalesalad 1y agoGotta be, the skunk logo is an approximation of the real one.
- PaulHoule 1y agoThe article has a link (citation 17) to a site selling toy models of that vehicle as an image source, I can find one (fourth image in the gallery) there where it sorta looks like the wing is missing because the wing is black against a black background but it's not the same image shown in the paper: https://fantastic-plastic.com/lockheed-martin-x-33-venturestar---retired.html https://fantastic-plastic.com/lockheed-martin-x-33-venturest... The name "Venturestar" is properly rendered in that image but "NASA" and "Lockheed Martin" are thoroughly mangled the way I'd expect text to be mangled in an AI image. The image from the toy site could have been used as as reference image to create the image in the paper one way or another.
- Ginger-Pickles 1y agoYes, if you look close, the paper is replete with error-filled generative reproductions of existing illustrations in the citations; including Fig. 6 (MC Escher struts), Fig. 7 (sprouting greeble tubes), and Fig. 8 (actuators replaced by tubes connected to mystery manifolds). Even Fig. 2 shows the spike geometry magically changing, which is not addressed in the text and seems like an error carried over from the original illustration in the cited source. Casts serious doubt on the credibility of the rest of the work.
- whalesalad 1y agoPretty neat, my dad worked on that X-33 program at Lockheed.
- jamesblonde 1y agoI thought this would be about the key-value store, Aerospike.
- itsthecourier 1y agocool contribution from a top Colombian university researchers