4 ms·
Children in England growing up 'sedentary, scrolling and alone', say experts
- mensetmanusman 1y agoIt’s fascinating to track which cultures will be absolutely annihilated by the introduction of endless entertainment in a rectangle. (Annihilated in the demographic sense).
- infotainment 1y agoAll of them?
- vitro 1y agoSome maybe less.. [0] [0] https://washingtonmorning.com/2025/06/19/how-differently-tiktok-algorithm-displays-content-in-the-us-and-china/ https://washingtonmorning.com/2025/06/19/how-differently-tik...
- alephnerd 1y agoTikTok/Douyin isn't alone in impacting a mindset (though it does play a role). I see plenty of parents (even amongst Chinese families) handing a smartphone to their kids to essentially sedate them instead of engaging with them. Honor of Kings, Arena of Valor, and MLBB have similar dopamine rush cycles. Heck, even a bland, aggravating, obnoxious, and stick-up-their-butt social media site like HN can induce similar cycles.
- ericmay 1y agoIsn’t it basically all of them? I mean is there a culture as you say, which I interpret to mean a civilization or country, where iPhones* are affordable and isn’t facing this issue?
- alephnerd 1y agoI've seen similar issues in villages in developing countries like India and Vietnam as well. Parenting is hard, and smartphones reduce the amount of effort it takes anyone to get a dopamine rush, disincentivizing creativity. Smartphones are extremely powerful, but I strongly feel they shouldn't be in the hands of children at least until their adolescence - that way some amount of creativity is forced. Ironically, Steve Jobs was himself a major proponent of how boredom begets curiosity and creativity.
- mensetmanusman 1y agoThe US has many sub cultures, it’s too early to tell which survive since smartphones are so new…
- alephnerd 1y agoThey've been around for almost 20 years now, and 2.5 generations (later millenials, Z, Alpha) have all spent formative years using smartphones. The subcultures have already formed, died out, and formed into new subcultures multiple times already.
- FirmwareBurner 1y agoEntertainment is an effect, not the main cause. It's not the fault of availability of McDonalds that a person chooses to destroy their health eating only burgers, fries and Coke. Healthy options still exist, just that some people choose not to use them. So why do people choose endless entertainment instead of the "healthy options"?
- justjico 1y agoWell, isn’t this just the old paradox of free will. You are free to do whatever you desire. But you are not free to choose your desires.
- FirmwareBurner 1y ago>But you are not free to choose your desires. Couldn't be more false.
- em-bee 1y agohard disagree. this belief that we are not free to choose what we desire is a disease, and it's used to excuse bad behavior. it also takes away agency and hope from those who want to change. it takes willpower, but it is possible to change. what makes changing difficult is lack of experience. it is difficult to choose what we don't know, and negative experiences push you away from trying something that everyone says is good but that you only had bad experiences with. like if you had a bad experience making friends growing up then you will shy away from trying to make friends until you either push yourself to try anyways, or you make some friends by chance and realize that it is a good experience after all. the same goes for food, social media, and everything else.
- bloqs 1y agodopamine
- FirmwareBurner 1y agoIs dopamine a new thing in th human body?
- foobar1962 1y agoIt's been going on forever. "Stop looking at the cave art and take the garbage out."
- aspenmayer 1y agoI’m reminded of the intentional usage of whisky, rum, and other alcoholic spirits as an intentional policy of genocide against Native Americans. Also interesting is that during this same period of history, payment of taxes in whisky was common in some states in the western US, and these were federal taxes for debts left over from the Revolutionary War. These adjacent topics are reminiscent of modern national cryptocurrency stockpiles and stablecoin interest. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alcohol_and_Native_Americans https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alcohol_and_Native_Americans https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Forty-Three_Gallons_of_Whiskey https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Forty-Three_G... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Whiskey_Rebellion https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Whiskey_Rebellion
- theyknowitsxmas 1y agoKids don’t play Red Ass anymore?
- lanfeust6 1y agoWasn't that only in the schoolyard? Against the wall.
- mouse_ 1y agoWhat are urban kids supposed to do, play in traffic? There is no outside.
- topspin 1y ago> There is no outside. And if there were, whatever they might dream up to do with outside would be rapidly banned.
- II2II 1y agoIn traffic, no, but on the streets, why not? Things like street hockey and basketball are real. Kids ought to be able to be able to play in a field and fetch their ball from the street without ending up as roadkill. Of course, there are far too many drivers who view anything that impedes high speed travel as a nuisance, or worse. I regularly see drivers who run stop signs in front of a school, drivers passing unloading school busses with their stop signs extended, and impatient drivers try to push through crossing guards as children are crossing. I have also known crossing guards who were struck by motorists. Things like traffic calming measures don't work, since it typically ends up with drivers being more reckless. Very little seems to be done about it, aside from periodic campaigns (typically at the start of school years). And, of course, punishing children by limiting the spaces they can use and independence. People often claim that the cycling culture of the Netherlands was a product of trying to protect children from traffic. Most of the rest of the world, including England with it's "no ball game" signs took the opposite approach: rather than addressing the problem, they punished the victims.
- HPsquared 1y agoPeople used to do a whole lot of nothing. EDIT: But daily life provided enough social micronutrients to get by. Less so with the phones.
- Gigachad 1y agoThe "nothing" being wandering around outside, digging holes, and talking to people rather than sitting around watching paint dry.
- 1y ago
- markus_zhang 1y agoIt's PK. After a couple of generations everyone will get used to the new norm.
- hn_throwaway_99 1y agoWhat is PK? Also, obesity is apparently the new norm, and I guess we got used to that, but that doesn't mean it doesn't have huge negative impacts.
- markus_zhang 1y agoWas about to type “OK”.
- ryao 1y agoThe point of the article is to say that this is a bad thing, but to someone who was bullied as a child, the idea of being “sedentary, scrolling and alone” sounds like the ideal childhood. I remember adults saying socialization was a good thing when I was a child, and to me, that effectively claimed that my daily beating from 5 to 6 of my classmates was a good thing. It does not matter how much time passes; nothing will convince me that was a good thing.
- refulgentis 1y agoGetting beaten by a gang of classmates daily is genuinely awful & would leave some deep scars, I'm very sorry to hear that and wish you the best.
- ryao 1y agoThanks. 8 years of being bullied (with the first 3 years consisting of beatings and the latter 5 years consisting of psychological bullying) certainly did leave scars. The most obvious were regular nightmares. The less obvious was a coping mechanism where I would pretend that anything bad did not actually happen to avoid facing it. I do not think I ever fully grew out of that one. There are probably others, but I am not fully cognizant of them.
- jonnybgood 1y agoI don't follow. How does claiming socializing is good effectively claiming bullying is good?
- ryao 1y agoWhenever I complained that recess was unnecessary, I was told that it was good for me, sent outside and promptly beaten. Being sent outside and beaten happened regardless of whether I complained it was unnecessary. What I learned from that was that being beaten was considered good for me, since that is what happened when I was forced to “socialize”.
- bobxmax 1y ago
- OgsyedIE 1y agoIt's all well and good telling parents to do better, but this situation could only have arose in the first place because there is some kind of systemic reason for parents to not really care about the wellbeing of their offspring. Is this parental nihilism downstream of ideology, or the other way around?
- geerlingguy 1y agoI think it's because parenting is hard (always has been, some aspects like having to be a helicopter parent to not have CPS called on you in the US maybe make it harder). And screens are easy.
- mschuster91 1y ago> this situation could only have arose in the first place because there is some kind of systemic reason for parents to not really care about the wellbeing of their offspring. Yeah, guess what, like needing to work 2 full-time 40 hour jobs and having to deal with commute and chores on top of that, not to mention overtime or on-call. Modern capitalism is fundamentally incompatible with raising children, but by the time it crashes down it will be too late. But hey, the current generation of Boomers enjoys a stonks-go-up portfolio.
- aianus 1y agoMy parents and grandparents grew up in communism and they had to work full time jobs (and help bring in the harvest in the fall) with a side of hours standing in queues to buy meat. Meanwhile modern capitalism will allow me to work as little as I want after a decade or two of accumulating capital. Huge improvement all in all
- mschuster91 1y ago> Meanwhile modern capitalism will allow me to work as little as I want after a decade or two of accumulating capital. That's not an improvement at a societal scale, that's the thing. Without those in working age actually working and generating economic activity, the system becomes nothing more than a house of cards waiting to collapse. Capitalism, especially modern rabid capitalism, depends on the illusion of infinite growth - an illusion that can only fail, given modern demographic trends and resource scarcity. And it is completely unsuited for the coming era when a lot of work will be done outright by machines.
- mschuster91 1y agoOne thing to add I find missing in many such articles: the rise of helicopter parenting, correlating with the rise of families that can only afford to have one child. Basically, up until a few decades ago, it was the norm to have a lot of children - there was a lack of contraceptive options, access to abortions was highly questionable (and deadly on top of it, given the circumstances of back-alley "angel makers"), and most importantly it was the norm that quite a lot of these children would die from some sort of accident, pest or war. Nowadays, financial and housing insecurity plus the demands of modern capitalism (aka, have a full school education plus an academic degree, so you enter the workforce at 25, not 15, any more) drive people to start later and later with finding partners, much less having children, so the "room for errors" is much less than it used to be. And on top of that you got the horror stories of "child snatchers", pedophile gangs and knife-wielding immigrants that now make national headlines out of very individual crimes. It's hard to attempt to raise your child in the open when every newspaper shouts at you that THEY are out there to GET YOUR CHILD. The rabid fearmongering has gone completely out of control.
- HK-NC 1y agoSpent 3 years living as a minority among migrants in my country, 2 attempted murders and daily harassment fornmy partner, 1 sexual assault, several stalkers. I dont read the tabloids but there are definitely places I would monger the fuck out of fear.
- throw_lfnsooemd 1y agoThere is a big gap in outdoor activities for children between the ages of 12 and 18. That's when kids start to do things without their parents, but don't have the means to engage in most activities. There are plenty of parks and public spaces in the UK, but there is only so much football one can do before getting bored. Most of them can't afford activities, and they are unable to partake in the British national sport (going to the pub). The only thing left is to roam around and be up to no good. In the end, staying indoors and exploring the digital world is the only way for them to experience the world on an equal footing. It's a tough world for teens.
- martinald 1y agoI think we are romanticising what teens used to do (much more at least) to pass their boredom. Articles like this make it sound like pre smartphone everyone was doing endless sport, drama and other artistic and social endeavours. At least what I remember was a lot of underage drinking and antisocial behaviour. I can remember in the early 2000s children being made out as feral animals roaming the streets in the UK. Now they're being demonized for scrolling their phones.
- darepublic 1y agoIt's like the Simpsons episode from season 2 in which Marge crusades against violence in itchy and scratchy. And then, to Beethoven's ninth symphony, all the children start exploring nature and engaging in wholesome idyllic play.
- hn_throwaway_99 1y ago> Articles like this make it sound like pre smartphone everyone was doing endless sport, drama and other artistic and social endeavours. At least what I remember was a lot of underage drinking and antisocial behaviour. I would argue that that "antisocial behavior" is actually important for most people to be able to form and navigate authentic social relationships. I don't think all the kids in my generation (X) were involved in tons of "sport, drama or other artistic or social endeavors", but at the very least they were "hanging out at the mall". Sure, some of that was getting into trouble, but I'm astounded by how much adolescence has changed since I was a kid. Like I see a lot of kids that very rarely "hang out", and I'd argue that social media/text communication is a very poor substitute for in-person hanging out.
- martinald 1y agoI find it odd that this is has became such a pandamoniom now. As an elder millennial I can remember everyone being absolutely glued to MSN Messenger in secondary school. This was back in the dialup days so it was stopping your parents making phone calls! Regardless, I feel that it the debate needs to be about what children are doing. Probably like many here I spent a lot of my childhood devouring technical content on the internet, which I would say has given me the chance to work on incredibly interesting projects (and make friends with people across the world). If I had been time restricted on my computer (and a lot of my friends were) it would have significantly altered my career trajectory. If you are scrolling endless garbage tiktok or YouTube videos for hours a day, yes the utility is pretty low (though again, watching hours of trashy cable TV back in the day doesn't feel that different to me). That doesn't mean that many won't learn and find out about their passions in a way that was unthinkable a few decades ago.
- alephnerd 1y ago> As an elder millennial I can remember everyone being absolutely glued to MSN Messenger in secondary school. This was back in the dialup days so it was stopping your parents making phone calls! Computers were nowhere near as accessible (physically or UX wise) in the 1990s or 2000s compared to smartphones today. A $70 Android smartphone today would have been the equivalent of buying a top-of-the-line workstation in the 2000s for $40, so it is much easier to access a computer device at a much earlier age. On top of that, UX research has enhanced massively since the 2000s with an enhanced understanding into user reward mechanisms and psychology, and this kind of reward mechanism is being added in every kind of application (from enterprise B2B to social media) We shouldn't be Luddites, but limiting access to high sensitivity media (be it TV or smartphones) for those who are pre-adolescence should be an important part of parenting.
- martinald 1y agoMy point was more despite all the limitations people were spending 8+ hours a day on MSN messenger after school. I'd agree that (younger) children should have limits on social media - that's obvious for many reasons. But why smartphones in general? If they're reading a book or similar on it, what's the harm in that? My main point is it's not really the medium, it's the content.
- hackernoops 1y ago[flagged]
- arbitrary_name 1y agoHow pointless, biased and inflammatory. Generally, citizens commit crimes at rates higher than immigrants. Please keep that in mind while you read the Daily Mail or whatever tabloid you get your information from.
- eszed 1y agoJust to offer an alternate perspective: I read that comment ironically. I recognize that tone is ambiguous online.
- stephen_g 1y agoIt's not really valid English parsing to read it that way - if the poster meant it that way then they've accidentally formed the sentence in a way that's unambiguously not ironic. Putting the word refugees in quotes makes it biased and inflammatory, accusing people seeking asylum of being rapists and murders. If the whole phrase following the word probably was in quotes, only then could it be read ironically.
- eszed 1y agoFair. Reading more closely, I agree with you.
- tomhow 1y agoWe've banned this account.
- octo888 1y agoBan on "no ball games" signs is addressing the problem from the easiest and worst possible angle. More than 400 playgrounds closed in England from 2012 to 2022 and annual park budgets have fallen Why are they bouncing balls near/against a house? Probably because there aren't enough affordable, easy to access sports centres/playgrounds etc nearby. Plus helicopter parents afraid of letting kids out of their sight Bouncing balls are low frequency noises and can drive someone insane and completely ruin the quiet enjoyment of their home. Those signs are perfectly valid to prevent anti-social noise pollution and prevent damage to property Let's undo the austerity cuts instead of forcing people's property exteriors into make-do ball courts
- AlecSchueler 1y ago> Let's undo the austerity cuts Is that so easy to do? The economy that fed the investment governments isn't there anymore.
- octo888 1y agoYup ... it seems we can't afford anything except healthcare, defence, welfare and social care. That still doesn't make it ok to drive people crazy in their homes. We do still have plenty of playing fields etc where they can take their balls - it's on the parents
- _DeadFred_ 1y agoGen X was the latch key generation. We grew up watching Thundercats, Voltron, Price is Right,etc. And with per minute phone bills so we couldn't even call friends. If anything these kids might be MORE social.
- HK-NC 1y ago>One of the key arguments experts made is that the rise in time spent on smartphones and gaming devices is being driven not just by the ubiquity of screens themselves, but by the loss of alternative ways and places for children to play. Really? I grew up smashing rocks with hammers, throwing rocks, putting insects in boxes and watching them interact, digging holes, climbing anything climbable. Perhaps the screens are just killing imagination and offering too good an alternative.