5 ms·
Harry Brearley, the creator of stainless steel (2016)
- kissiel 1y ago[flagged]
- throw310822 1y ago[flagged]
- perihelions 1y ago> "algebra (Taylor bought him the book, a gift Harry brought home to show off, and never forgot)" If anyone was hooked by this tangent, this was[0] "Todhunter’s[1] Algebra" [2] (1858? 1870? 1871? 1889?) you can peruse for free at [2]. [0] https://www.readingsheffield.co.uk/harry-brearleys-reading-journey/ https://www.readingsheffield.co.uk/harry-brearleys-reading-j... [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Isaac_Todhunter https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Isaac_Todhunter [2] https://archive.org/details/algebraforuseofc00todhuoft https://archive.org/details/algebraforuseofc00todhuoft
- readthenotes1 1y agoIf you really want a tangent, Todhunter is the middle name of one of the best detective authors in the history of detective fiction: Rex Stout. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rex_Stout https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rex_Stout The Timothy Hutton shows available on YouTube are a good introduction if you can get over the poor transcription to youtube.
- LgWoodenBadger 1y agoIMO, Stick with the books please. The tv series you mention mischaracterizes everyone.
- superfunny 1y ago[flagged]
- ReptileMan 1y agoFirst was Bach, then came Wagner, then Yngwie Malmsteen (yeah I know he is boring, but he was probably the one that showed the public this part of the metal lineage the clearest)
- CuriouslyC 1y agoIt would have been more interesting for sure. What is steel before death?
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- vanderZwan 1y ago> The range of the mind’s eye is restricted by the skill of the hand. The castles in the air must conform to the possibilities of material things—border-line possibilities perhaps; or, if something beyond the known border is required, the plan must wait until other dreams come true. That's a quote that surely appeals to many here.
- anton-c 1y agoAs a jewelry maker and guitar player I am gonna enjoy this either way
- datameta 1y agoAnd the strings of the guitar are an intersection of both interpretations! There are several core wire alloys used and many different kinds of winding wire to achieve different tone and magnetic response. Fun fact, a common older winding alloy for acoustic guitars was called 80/20 Bronze despite actually being copper/zinc alloy and therefore Brass!
- convolvatron 1y agobronze is a word used for all alloys of copper. brasses are a subset of bronzes.
- bookofjoe 1y agohttps://archive.ph/adMbF https://archive.ph/adMbF
- adrian_b 1y agoWhile the invention of stainless steel is one of the most important in history, it should be noted that almost never an invention appears really independently, but almost always it appears as a consequence of a chain of prior inventions, which have been necessary to make it possible. Leading to stainless steel, a first step was the discovery of the method to produce aluminum cheaply, by electrolysis. With cheap aluminum available, a method for producing chromium was discovered, by reducing chromium compounds with metallic aluminum. With metallic chromium easily available, after a century from its discovery, during which making metallic chromium had been impossible in great quantities, it has become possible to investigate the properties of the chromium alloys with the other available metals. Soon, it has been discovered that chromium can produce interesting alloys with cobalt ("stellite") and with nickel, and that these alloys are the first metals that can rival the platinum-group metals in chemical resistance. It has been suggested that these chromium alloys could be used for stainless cutlery, but the high prices of cobalt and nickel have prevented the use of such alloys, except for special applications where the cost was unimportant. More than a decade later, the next logical step has been the discovery that the expensive cobalt and nickel can be substituted with cheap iron, without diminishing much the chemical resistance of the alloys. It should also be noted that while Brearley has invented the ferritic stainless steel, which has only small amounts of any other elements besides iron and chromium, almost simultaneously a different kind of stainless steel has been invented in Germany, austenitic stainless steel, which also has significant amounts of nickel, besides iron and chromium, with enough nickel to change the crystal structure of the steel. Austenitic stainless steels have various advantages, especially that they are much more suitable to cheap processing by plastic deformation, so nowadays they are much more widely used than the kind of stainless steel invented by Brearley.
- pfdietz 1y ago> Leading to stainless steel, a first step was the discovery of the method to produce aluminum cheaply, by electrolysis. With cheap aluminum available, a method for producing chromium was discovered, by reducing chromium compounds with metallic aluminum. Are you sure about that? Chromium is produced (as ferrochrome, a FeCr alloy) by carbothermic reduction of chromite. This is done in an arc furnace, so electrical energy is needed, but no aluminum. Pure chromium (without the iron) is not needed for production of stainless steel.
- datameta 1y agoThe full read particularly resonated with me from the perspective of a metaphor to today's rapidly changing engineering practices. > “Time was,” he lamented later, “when a man made steel, decided what it was good for and told the customer how to make the best of it. Then, with time’s quickening step, he just made the steel; he engaged another man, who knew nothing about steelmaking, to analyse it, and say what it was good for. Then he engaged a second man, who knew all about hardening and tempering steel; then a third man who could neither make steel, nor analyse it, nor harden and temper it—but this last tested it, put his OK mark on it and passed it into service.” In a way it warms my heart that obfuscation in such a manner, perhaps even enshittification, is not a new experience for those watching a trade modernise. Several things come to mind: npm and python library dependency hell and LLM as a catalyst of skill atrophy in experts simultaneously with the enablement of a whole new middle layer of proprietors. Also the article led me to think more about the idea of simultaneous invention - I used to believe it to be redundant and wasted work. But this still can lead to different outcomes even with identical formulations or methods. Getting an invention into use in the world is perhaps as great a feat as the invention itself. I now believe any worthwhile invention deserves more than one champion. In today's hyperconnected world it is easy to discover that someone else has beaten you to the full flourishing of idea into invention, but I find that doing the novel work oneself with one's own mind and hands still provides the unique learning opportunity which can allow one to invent yet again, albeit now with a widened skill and knowledge horizon.
- pfdietz 1y ago> perhaps even enshittification This is rather silly, since steel today is far superior to the steel of his day. The complexity he bemoans is part of that process of improvement.
- datameta 1y agoI did not mean to imply that steel quality has in any way continued to suffer. He was talking about the process of the early 20st century in comparison to the late 19th when steelmaking was handled more end-to-end from maker to user. I am talking about enshittification of digital applications and services compared to the earlier years of the information age.
- gsf_emergency_2 1y agoFrom time to time, I see articles implying the medieval use of chromium, however sparingly, in forging weapons (near east or central Asia) Eg. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S030544032030145X https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S03054...
- adrian_b 1y agoThose who made such early examples of chromium-containing steel had no idea that chromium existed. What happened is that they have found a place with chromite and they have believed that they have found magnetite, because both are heavy blackish stones. Most likely the chromite was actually mixed with true magnetite, which is always much more abundant (chromite is a mixed iron-chromium oxide, while magnetite, which has an identical crystal structure, is a mixed Fe(II)/Fe(III) oxide). Then they have used the magnetite mixed with chromite exactly like they knew to use magnetite, for making steel. The steel happened to be better than what they had made before, and they were happy that they had found a source of particularly good magnetite for making steel. After gathering experience, they have probably adjusted their techniques for smelting and forging to work better with steel made with the natural magnetite-chromite mixture, but that is all the extent of their knowledge. Because the ancient smiths did not know how to do chemical analyses, they had no idea why using similarly looking minerals mined from different places results in metals with different properties. In the ancient world it was well known that certain steels or bronzes made in certain places are much better than the steels or bronzes made in other places, so the price of steel or bronze varied a lot based on its provenience. These quality differences were frequently caused by impurities in the source minerals used for metal production, whose presence was unknown for the ancients, but they were aware of the qualities of the metals produced there. No knowledge whatsoever about the existence of chromium has existed anywhere, before the creation of the modern chemistry, based on the concept of chemical element, slightly before the French Revolution, towards the end of the 18th century, which triggered an intense search for the discovery of new chemical elements.
- gsf_emergency_2 1y agoWhat you say sounds reasonable, but the university PR claimed that they knew chromite was special >Crucially, analyses using Scanning Electron Microscopy enabled them to identify remains of the ore mineral chromite [rusakhtaj], which was described in Biruni’s manuscript as an essential additive to the process. https://www.ucl.ac.uk/news/2020/sep/chromium-steel-was-first-made-ancient-persia https://www.ucl.ac.uk/news/2020/sep/chromium-steel-was-first... This still doesn't say they knew about chromium ofc just that it was not just magnetite. Ofc one has to read farsi to make sure rusakhtaj wasn't a common alias for magnetite. Who knows, rudimentary awareness of the concept of "alloy" might have existed there..
- legitster 1y ago> That Brearley is credited with discovering stainless steel is due mostly to luck; that he is credited with fathering it is due mostly to his resolve. It's interesting that most times I have heard these stories growing up the "discovery" aspect was always emphasized - some retelling even framed them as "accidents". Forgetting the parts where the person in question had dedicated a lifetime of study in pursuit of the finding.
- unixhero 1y agoBut it isn't always stainless!