6 ms·
Adobe Project Indigo is a new photo app from former Pixel camera engineers
- Brajeshwar 1y agoFor those interested in this, Leica LUX is the alternative iOS Camera. It also works for those who cannot afford to own a Leica. https://leica-camera.com/en-SG/photography/leica-apps/leica-lux https://leica-camera.com/en-SG/photography/leica-apps/leica-...
- raylad 1y agoI just tried it and the Leica Chrome setting looked better to me than anything the normal camera app or Project Indigo produced. But I hate subscription apps. And the rest of the UI seems quite clumsy.
- Melatonic 1y agoYou could probably shoot in apple raw with the built in app and then find a free Lightroom preset (I think Lightroom mobile can have custom presets uploaded to it) and get better results. Lightroom mobile also actually might require a subscription to edit raw files however (then again it can do a lot more for the price). It also has a free version and you might have good results shooting in a high quality .heif
- mrtksn 1y agoWow I love that. The processing looks like a Leica indeed, the UI has a Leica feel and put me in a mood for candid Leica style photos haha :) When using a DSLR I almost always shoot in (A)perture mode, it helps you control how much you separate the subject from the background and it's the thing I miss the most on phone. The portrait mode isn't quite the same. It's the first app that I came across to have an aperture mode, cool. PS: Apparently it lets you capture in all modes, but to edit the parameters after taking the picture it requires the pro mode.
- Melatonic 1y agoI don't think phones have adjustable apertures actually on their mobile cameras. That being said each camera will have a different aperture and you can exploit this to get real DSLR like bokeh (blurred backgrounds). Basically you want to make sure probably to use real focal lengths (disable digital zoom). This applies to all iPhones and androids. Usually the main (normal) focal length camera will have the largest sensor and best aperture. Have the phone focus on something close and find the closest distance the phone can manage. This will create the biggest background blur. On phones with longer length telephoto this will often also work if you find the closest focus point and do the same process. Depending on the actual focal length to sensor size ratio (and aperture) of the telephoto lens it may either have more or less blur than the main camera. The Ultrawide will usually never have much background blur ability but that is generally true for a real DSLR as well
- throwaway314155 1y agoCheaper than a Leica, but still really damn expensive for a camera app.
- al_borland 1y agoAnd if you want the shutter button accessory they advertise, that’s $395 (but sold out currently). That’s a lot of money for a MagSafe button. A person could get an entry level DSLR from Canon for about the same price.
- average_r_user 1y agoI really love this app, but I'm not a fan of the subscription model. While I understand the business reasoning, I'd much prefer having the option to purchase individual presets instead of committing to a full subscription. I recently used the B/W preset by Greg Williams during my trip to Iceland, and the results were fantastic. The grainy texture it added to my photos was exactly what I was looking for and really enhanced the dramatic Icelandic landscapes.
- stlava 1y agoI’m impressed they managed to make an app that makes me not want to use it or my phone to take photos! After I used it for about 5 mins I resolved to dust off my older DSLR and use it instead.
- Springtime 1y agoThe article's wording suggests this supports computational RAW which would be useful. That is, auto stacking multiple captures into a single RAW (a la Google Camera for Pixel phones), rather than the traditional single capture. Allowing for reduced noise and higher dynamic range. It's interesting as when I last looked a couple years ago only Fujifilm had a mirrorless digital camera (with cropped sensor) that supported this on-device.
- DidYaWipe 1y agoIt's just "raw."
- Springtime 1y agoEvery instance I've seen it referred to has used the RAW capitalization, including Google's PR, as it's an image format.
- DidYaWipe 1y agoR, A, and W don't stand for anything. It's raw data off the sensor, not an acronym. Therefore not capitalized. You can find millions of instances of any given literacy-impaired error. "Would of" and "your not going to find this" are wrong... but they're out there by the boatload. No need to propagate them further.
- Springtime 1y agoMy impression has been that the capitalization is to identify the word as an image format (a stand-in for whatever actual format is used), rather than being an initialism. Canon, Nikon and Sony among other hardware and software companies use it in this way. ZIP similarly doesn't stand for anything but is styled as such. So I suppose the pushback is more against being used as a stand-in for generic raw image formats. Edit: just noticed your comment was greyed but I didn't downvote it fwiw.
- 1y ago
- vr46 1y agoIndigo is excellent so far, a little bit buggy, but I am seriously impressed. (iPhone 12 Pro) And I have a Q2, a 5D4 and a 645Z, this little app is really great, and colour me surprised.
- bix6 1y agoIs this an actual SLR replacement / anyone know the RAW size and print size at 300dpi? Last time I sent iPhone photos into my print shop they kicked them back.
- tlhunter 1y ago> Is this an actual SLR replacement There's just no way to replace the massive 35mm sensor of a larger DSLR / mirrorless camera. The amount of light gathered can only be simulated by capturing many frames. True depth of field can only be emulated by imperfectly blurring estimated background area via software, leading to goofy blurred hairs. Even the reported megapixels of a smartphone contain a quarter or less the equivalent DSLR resolution detail (a 24MP smartphone photo is roughly equivalent to the detail of a 6MP DSLR photo).
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- josephg 1y agoYep this. I’ve been getting into photography over the last 9 months or so. I got a Sony a7iv and an increasing pile of lenses for it. It’s making me a huge camera snob. The truth is that nothing a phone can do can come close to the image quality of a proper modern camera. You can spot the difference a mile off. Photos from phones look like they’ve been passed through stable diffusion or something. They just look wrong in comparison to a real camera with real lenses and real lights. It shouldn’t be surprising. Real depth of field is physically impossible with a small lens. And cameras have teeny tiny lenses and sensors. It’s impressive how good the photos are given the hardware, but the hardware is very very bad in comparison to a dedicated camera with replaceable lenses.
- astrange 1y agoNobody cares about image quality, that's not a goal in itself. (There's an old camera influencer named Ken Rockwell who constantly pushes this; he has every possible opinion at once and is trolling most of the time, but he's right about this.) The smallness of a phone means it can take pictures larger cameras can't because you have it with you when the picture is happening. And that's what really matters. > They just look wrong in comparison to a real camera with real lenses and real lights. You can use real lights with a phone camera all you want!
- thedougd 1y agoThis is the first app I’ve ever downloaded for it to tell me my phone isn’t supported.
- yumraj 1y agoSame experience on SE3.
- jeroenhd 1y agoI'm surprised they did a hardware check within the app rather than just restrict the app on the iOS app store side. Surely they should've marked your phone incompatible before you wasted your time downloading the app? I do wonder what makes older phones incompatible, though. Others are complaining about the performance, so it could be that the low amounts of RAM Apple puts in their phones is starting to catch up, or it could be as simple as them not having trained their AI models for some older phones yet.
- jrgaston 1y agoIt's not a dslr replacement, what a weird claim. My Nikons and Fujis are so much nicer to hold, to adjust, to shoot. But for a phone camera the s.w is ok. More adjustable than the iPhone app. I like the controls, the current settings text, and built in help text. Only knock so far is it runs hot: never seen an overheating warning ever on my iPhone 14pro. Now i get one every ten or fifteen minutes when using Indigo.
- modeless 1y agoMarc Levoy is an "engineer"? Sure, but maybe more relevant is the fact that he's a well-known computer graphics researcher and professor emeritus at Stanford.
- danjl 1y agoAnd Florian is an ILM OG who wrote some of their most amazing tools.
- mrtksn 1y agoThis is the first time my iPhone 14 Pro felt inadequate. The app is so heavy that the phone is overheating after the first photo. it consumes so much resources that’s the music was playing in the background stopped because my AirPods connection dropped. For the very first time on this phone I felt like I need an upgrade, it felt like the last days of my iPhone 6s. I didn’t know you can do that to an iPhone. The photo quality is supperb though, obviously not DSLR replacement but it really gives you that feel. Apple’s own processing has become too boring, sometimes I use Halide just to have unprocessed raws.
- Aurornis 1y ago> The app is so heavy that the phone is overheating after the first photo. I have the same phone and no overheating errors here. Do you mean the phone got slightly warm? That’s not overheating, it’s just what happens when you use an app that leverage the CPU for anything non-trivial. It’s not overheating. EDIT: The screenshot below clarifies that the heat warning is a message in the app, not the actual iOS overheating protection as ( https://support.apple.com/en-us/118431 https://support.apple.com/en-us/118431 ). Regardless, I still can’t trigger the in-app temperature warning on my phone.
- mrtksn 1y agoIt's literally the app complaining about it: https://a.dropoverapp.com/cloud/download/b191e7b8-8dad-4fed-a86d-f6e15e4d2b08/8047326f-ed3d-4372-9f43-f7e336cfd66b https://a.dropoverapp.com/cloud/download/b191e7b8-8dad-4fed-... It will dim the screen soon, so much that it's unusable outdoors. I wasn't able to capture a photo outdoors yesterday using this app because of this. The first photo slowly finished processing but the app crashed, lost the photo. Then the device was overheating, the screen dimmed to unusable and the FPS dropped, the app become unresponsive and the music went away, the AirPods re-connected. Couldn't even try to capture a second one. It wasn't even that hot, just 28C.
- Aurornis 1y agoInteresting. I can get the app to crash if I spam the photo button and queue up the maximum number (8) of background processing tasks. Feels like an OOM error if I had to guess. Can’t get any of the other things you experienced to occur, though I haven’t tried Bluetooth audio.
- coolandsmartrr 1y agoStrange, they don't let you download this app from the App Store in Japan.
- preek 1y agoAfter the first shot on my iPhone 13 Pro in default settings, it immediately told me my phone was overheating and going to be unstable. Then it crashed. I tried once more, turned off raw mode, waited _minutes_ for one image to process and now my screen turns off and on again randomly while I type this comment.
- Jotalea 1y agoI expected worse from Adobe.
- neya 1y agoWho cares, it's Adobe. They'll eventually steal your work under some under-the-hood TOS update and even charge you for it. Don't believe me? Ask the existing CS customers. Fuck Adobe. They should be boycotted to oblivion.
- mesh 1y ago>4.2 Ownership >As between you and Adobe, you (as a Business User or a Personal User, as applicable) retain all rights and ownership of your Content. We do not claim any ownership rights to your Content. https://www.adobe.com/legal/terms.html https://www.adobe.com/legal/terms.html
- neya 1y agoI guess you missed the recent fiasco https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hxg5LzFw-_g&t=33s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hxg5LzFw-_g&t=33s https://blog.adobe.com/en/publish/2024/06/06/clarification-adobe-terms-of-use https://blog.adobe.com/en/publish/2024/06/06/clarification-a...
- jeroenhd 1y agoRuns on my iPhone 15, but not well. Phone heats up like crazy and processing photos takes a while. The end result is almost the same as the pictures the normal camera app takes. I think I must be missing something because this looks like a worse re-implementation of the normal camera app to me. Maybe I need to take the app out at dusk to take some pictures in more challenging conditions? I still prefer the photos from my Pixel over the photos from my work iPhone.
- dwayne_dibley 1y agoI know this is ranty, but I really miss internet sites that aren't 60% adverts, 30% padding and 10% actual thing. This isn't anything more than an announcement page.
- arresin 1y ago> Adobe Not interested.
- 0manrho 1y agoMy sentiment exactly. Unless it's FOSS for some reason, anything Adobe - especially if it's work/income related - is a hard pass.
- Jotalea 1y agoI see many users reporting overheating, incompatibility, and lag on 1 or 2 year old devices by using this app, which is ridiculous. If a flagship phone released this recently cannot handle an app like this, the problem might not be the phone, but rather the app itself. I simply cannot believe they (adobe) screwed up this bad, but I hope they will fix it before I get to try the app by myself. I do not want a broken expensive device.
- Melatonic 1y agoIf you want something lighter weight with manual controls and a much longer history I highly recommend the iOS app "Camera M". Unfortunately Apple restricts some control of the hardware only to the official iOS camera app so in some cases you are actually best off tweaking the built in app as much as possible. I believe Camera M actually has some details about this on their support page and FAQ. One time fee - often updated - no subscription. The UI isn't fancy but it does everything well and I've found their email support responds quickly and enthusiastically.