5 ms·
> There are plenty of dual citizens that would proudly admit that their first loyalty is to Israel This is legitimately debatable. If your allegiance is first
by JumpCrisscross 1y ago
> There are plenty of dual citizens that would proudly admit that their first loyalty is to Israel
This is legitimately debatable. If your allegiance is first to a foreign state, in my view, you should have to relinquish your American citizenship.
- peterlada 1y agoTotally disagree.
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago> Totally disagree Hence debatable. Let me escalate: I think such a bill would find bipartisan support. Right now might be a good time to attempt it. I hate the idea of revoking citizenship. But a question about swearing, on naturalisation, that your supreme allegiance is to America should be incredibly popular to secure.
- adastra22 1y agoYou are conflating naturalization with born citizens.
- birn559 1y agoThat would have the consequence that naturalized citizen would be second class. Because they have to watch out for what to say, otherwise somebody might denounce them and they have to fight against their live being destroyed.
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago> would have the consequence that naturalized citizen would be second class I know more born citizens with a second nationality than naturalised ones who gave up their first.
- exe34 1y agoCould you say a few words on why you think the words you have written justify the words you have quoted?
- JumpCrisscross 1y agoThe class of American citizens with two nationalities is populated more with the native born than naturalised citizens. If the class became second class, the latter would be—I suspect—underrepresented in it.
- birn559 1y agoThe same argument still applies.
- WastedCucumber 1y agoHate to break it to you, but you'd have to find support from the IRS / Ways and Means Committee first. For these institutions, the primary characteristic of US Citizenship is filing your taxes, no matter where to live or if you've ever even lived in the country. This puts the USA in the same odd category as Eritrea, Hungary, and I believe one other country. And despite the difficulty of revoking US citizenship, the rate of revocations has increased over the last decade or two. If there was such a simple way to toss out that old rag, I'm sure there would be many more (and a little less tax revenue). So I'm afraid* the USA is much more transactional than you think, at least regarding citizenship. *I must admit this is sarcasm. Thank god the US is transactional rather than so stubbornly patriotic about citizenship.
- simondotau 1y agoRevoking citizenship for any reason (other than for abject fraud) means that citizenship means nothing. Also, to be pedantic, you don’t have to have citizenship of a foreign country in order to have a greater allegiance to it.
- account42 1y agoLetting some people have dual citizenship while others only have one is already making a mockery of the concept.
- lipowitz 1y ago> Also, to be pedantic, you don’t have to have citizenship of a foreign country in order to have a greater allegiance to it. The behavior of the christian conservative cult is a bit more than a pedantic detail at this point. Why is trying to get Israel into a conflict to get Jesus to come and accelerate the end of all jews on Earth not antisemitism? I don't see wanting to use the Jew for cockfighting making it to the State Department's summary of antisemitism.
- victorbjorklund 1y agoYou know Trumps own wife and son are dual citizens right? Is he going to strip them of their citizenship and deport them?
- tdeck 1y agoI think it would take more than an act of Congress. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Afroyim_v._Rusk https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Afroyim_v._Rusk
- mathieuh 1y ago> How does one hate a country, or love one? Tibe talks about it; I lack the trick of it. I know people, I know towns, farms, hills and rivers and rocks, I know how the sun at sunset in autumn falls on the side of a certain plowland in the hills; but what is the sense of giving a boundary to all that, of giving it a name and ceasing to love where the name ceases to apply? What is love of one's country; is it hate of one's uncountry? Then it's not a good thing. Is it simply self-love? That's a good thing, but one mustn't make a virtue of it, or a profession... Insofar as I love life, I love the hills of the Domain of Estre, but that sort of love does not have a boundary-line of hate. And beyond that, I am ignorant, I hope. Ursula K. Le Guin, The Left Hand of Darkness
- jaoane 1y agoI love when people come here with quotes from books like this is the ultimate argument or something.
- pelagicAustral 1y agohttps://youtu.be/cHoVtHyqOu4?si=3SsGBo2ORB7eWWJV https://youtu.be/cHoVtHyqOu4?si=3SsGBo2ORB7eWWJV
- strogonoff 1y agoAllegiance is not love. Allegiance is recognising yourself as part of some whole. It’s not impossible to feel that and also dislike or even hate the whole, though it probably would not come without psychological issues unless you channel that into political activity to effect what you think is a positive change to the whole. It’s complicated. In terms of what dictates your action, true allegiance is more significant: it is possible to really love somebody and not do something for their sake, but if you really are a part of something then it’s not much of a choice. Some people, culturally or temperamentally, have an allegiance to their family and do not care beyond that. Some feel allegiance to a community (whether defined religiously or geographically or elsewise). Some people feel allegiance to nothing. In the US specifically feeling belonging to one’s state I presume could be more powerful than belonging to the country. It is not always or not everywhere that people feel a strong allegiance to a country, even if they always lived in one and never thought of moving. Among people who do feel country allegiance, I would imagine it is rare to feel belonging to two different countries with a similar force. Perhaps those people do exist (e.g., someone who mostly lived in country A but was born to immigrants from country B and also spent a lot of time in country B), and then it would be mighty unfair if they had to pick one, but people I know can usually classify one citizenship as “convenience” and another one as “true”. Comprehensively assessing true allegiances (or lack thereof) of a prospective citizen is fraught, but as phrased the question does not actually require that. For 99.9% of people, “do you feel allegiance first to a foreign state?” is pretty unobtrusive and has a clear answer. The main caveat is, of course, that those for whom the answer is positive will almost certainly just lie. In case using tangentially related quotes is considered smarter than original thought, I looked one up too and I raise you Orson Scott Card: “Every person is defined by the communities she belongs to and the ones she doesn’t belong to… a person who really believes she doesn’t belong to any community at all invariably kills herself, either by killing her body or by giving up her identity and going mad.”
- Mashimo 1y ago> If your allegiance is first to a foreign state, in my view, you should have to relinquish your American citizenship. I have one or two friends in that situations, and they want to do that. But it also cost a $2,350 fee to give up your US of A citizenship.
- ses1984 1y agoIf that's your view then the only logical conclusion is to not allow dual citizenship at all.
- FirmwareBurner 1y agoMany country don't allow dual citizenship precisely for these issues.
- victorbjorklund 1y agoDoes that mean all Americans should be stripped of their other citizenship since they have allegiance to a foreign state? For example Barron Trump is a dual citizen.
- spwa4 1y agoWow ... this will suck. Islam, the ideology, either is a state, or meant to be a state (just ask a few muslims, they'll explain. Also historically islam was a state until 1918/1923, and died in WW1, with the leader of islam, the caliph, abandoning islam) And, frankly, while this is most prominent with Islam, that religions describe their goal to be a single state and trying to be a single state is the norm, not the exception. Christianity is the exception here that does not want to have state power (even though that rule screams "compromise with the Roman emperor", and hasn't exactly been followed very well once Christians were well established) So no more muslims allowed in the US then? In fact no religion allowed except Christianity or revering the US directly somehow?
- Propelloni 1y agoYes, this will suck. No argument from me. However, I disagree with your conception of Islam as a state, even if it was explained to you by Muslims. The strongest argument I can build from your statements is that, according to the reference to the end of the Sunni Caliphate in 1923, p1) only Sunnis are Muslims, and p2) the Caliphate is unique, and p3) the Sunni Caliphate of 1923 is the original one, thus c) it was the state of Islam. We can disprove all of these premises. p1) is obvious, there are more Muslim religions than just Sunnis. The earliest schism was the Sunni-Shiites split, happening immediately after the first prophet's death. About p2), while I'm fuzzy on the details, I'm pretty sure that between the 900s and the 1900s there were at least 3 major, parallel Caliphates and also a bunch of smaller Caliphates. Geographically they were even sometimes overlapping. It might be interesting that the Caliphate of the Ottoman Empire (the one in question) was a Hanafist (a Sunni splinter group) Caliphate. On p3), the Sunni caliphate of 1923 was reestablished after a 300 year "hiatus" by the Ottoman Emperor to lay claim on Crimea. It had no representation besides a leader, the Sultan. Before the dissolution of the major Sunni Caliphate in the 1500s it relocated several times, from today's Syria to today's Iraq, to then and now Egypt. Thus we can say that the Caliphate had no continuous existence. We can furthermore say that the time the Sultan of the Ottoman Empire was the Caliph, it was because it was a diplomatic ploy of the secular power of the Ottoman Empire. Therefore, c) must be wrong. There are more Muslims than Sunnis, the Sunni Caliphate wasn't unique, and the Caliphate that ended in 1923 was not the original one. A less philosophical counter-argument could be the vigorous infighting between different Muslim groups we see today. I'm curious how the war on Iran changes that, if at all.
- GrantMoyer 1y agoAny law that allows a government to renounce people's citizenship for broad, vague reasons is a very, very bad law. Regardless of its intentions, it will be used as a tool to subvert the rights of citizens even outside the target group.
- larrled 1y agoAmazed to see such a take after what happened in LA. Obviously the median immigrant has strong feelings of loyalty to their mother soil as can be witnessed by the huge Mexican flags and the direct testimony of many individuals. Should we deport all those people who swear loyalty to “La Rasa”? If we want immigrants, and we should because we need them to lead us into the future, we need to be realistic about their loyalties. People are proud of their race/nationality, and immigrants often even moreso.
- alephnerd 1y agoThe Chicano movement made their own flag back in the Cesar Chavez era. 2nd, 3rd, and 4th Gen Los Angeleños of Mexican origin could have used (and plenty did) and a sign finger portion of protestors made sure to incorporate the US flag as well, but a significant portion simply did not realize that the Mexican flag is not viewed as an ethnic marker outside of CA.
- _pigpen__ 1y agoThe US State of California WAS Mexico in 1848. Much of California still is Mexico. The personal notion of "mother soil" may have nothing to do with current political boundaries.