5 ms·
In what way is this piece saying something different than Zitron said on June 9 in his "Never Forget What They've Done" piece? https://www.wheresyoured.at/neve
by tptacek 1y ago
In what way is this piece saying something different than Zitron said on June 9 in his "Never Forget What They've Done" piece?
https://www.wheresyoured.at/never-forget-what-theyve-done/ https://www.wheresyoured.at/never-forget-what-theyve-done/
- yifanl 1y agoYou mean, besides how this one is targeted at journalists and that one is targeted at the tech industry? The difference, besides everything else is expectations: He expects the tech industry to overhype things because they're salespeople, he expects journalists to call them out when they're overhyping things.
- tptacek 1y agoCan you say more? I'm asking seriously; I'd like to have a better understand of "how to read" Zitron, because these pieces are long and emotive. Are they basically just responses to whatever the latest news is, the way David Gerard writes about blockchain stuff? Because I did see the utility in that kind of writing.
- yifanl 1y agoAre you asking because of the perceived poor reception to your recent blogpost? Because I'd say a lot of your questions are answered directly in this latest piece.
- tptacek 1y agoI've never written anything that got a better reception than that blog post, much to my chagrin, so I don't know where you're coming from with that. But put it aside: what parts of this Zitron piece are responsive to what I wrote? That would be super helpful to understand.
- altairprime 1y agoThe message, if stripped of emotion and audience, may not be wholly unique. The target audience of the two pieces is certainly different, and the emotional tone as well. Zitron doesn’t seem to direct his writing towards any single ‘audience’ week-to-week, as some others do; but each post does always appear to have a target in particular. So the way I would read Zitron, then, is to ask: ‘what is he trying to persuade who of, and how does his emotional intensity uniquely promote that outcome?’ (relative to less-intense others).
- rwmj 1y agoThe article is a long complaint about "churnalism". It's not exactly a new complaint. Nick Davies wrote a whole book about it in 2008 [1]. But it's getting worse and worse so it's worth reminding people of it. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flat_Earth_News_(book) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flat_Earth_News_(book)
- tptacek 1y agoThanks, that makes much more sense than my original read of the article.
- potatolicious 1y agoI think there's some overlap in the thrust of both pieces but they're pretty distinct topic-wise? The first piece strikes me as a paean against "enshittification" - the idea that the industry has done good things, but now subsists on a combination of hot air and making existing good things worse. It further makes the specific point that LLMs belong in the "hot air" category and that it shares little with other innovations of the past. It does touch on what he perceives as overly-friendly press coverage of the above, but I didn't read the piece as focusing on that point. FWIW, I find Zitron to be an... unreliable commentator on this subject, to put it mildly, but I am not entirely unsympathetic to the point. The second piece is more specifically focused on the overly-friendly press coverage, and the idea that journalists are either overly credulous, especially to fantastical claims about the tech, or openly corrupted by the parties they are meant to cover.
- tptacek 1y agoI feel like I pick up all that stuff but I don't really understand who the audience is for it. It would make more sense to me if these companies were public and taking investment (I mean, Google and Meta are, but they're not "AI plays", and this most recent piece focuses on Anthropic and OpenAI). Then the point of the piece would be, like David Gerard's blockchain pieces, "don't invest in this".
- potatolicious 1y agoThat's kinda my main beef with Ed's writing - it's pretty unfocused. Both pieces you linked demonstrate this - he careens from point to point. The lack of focus I feel like comes from the fact that his audience is an amalgamation of multiple groups, much of which is the "tech is over, it's all grifters now" cadre, so a lot of this isn't really meant to be a persuasive argument of anything but rather just a dumping ground of grievances. I alluded to finding him an unreliable narrator of this topic, and this is why. So much of this audience is so fully committed to "this is spicy autocomplete, a totally non-functional grift on par with NFTs" as a position that it compromises any of the other points he's trying to make. FWIW I do find some things of his sympathetic - particularly around how much structural risk we're taking on every time the VCs decide to line up the hype cannon behind something. That said, I think it's also fair to say that this is my projection of his argument, because his actual arguments are often too muddied to even draw that level of specificity. [edit] I continue to follow Ed's writing because a) I think there are glimmers or something in there and b) I treat it as a temperature read of a substantial minority of public opinion. The level of disillusionment and rising anger against our industry is concerning.