6 ms·
Income Inequality Depresses Support for Higher Minimum Wages [pdf]
- almosthere 1y agoIf you force the federal minimum wage to be $15 for the entire country - we're only exporting more jobs to other countries - nearly instantly. I do believe that Tariffs should actually be determined by wage disparity. So if the US can make a paper plate for $0.01 each, but China can make it for $0.00001, then the Tariff for the paper plate should just be $0.01 - $0.00001. That way both plates are sell-able for the same price.
- notyourwork 1y agoWho can afford to live on $15/hr, let alone less?
- almosthere 1y agoPeople that need a job but can't get a $15 one or hold it steady enough. You end up with roommates or living with mom, but you can live off that.
- johnnyanmac 1y agoWho's getting approved for a house @ $15 an hour? And now you're hoping your parents can support you as if everyone has a healthy family life. As a not-so-fun fact, many homeless people were orphans aged out of the system. They end up straight on the streets.
- tptacek 1y agoThe paper doesn't appear to advocate for a federal minimum wage.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- lesuorac 1y agoWho determines the price that you can make a paper plate at?
- johnnyanmac 1y agoPeople always says this, but the impact in CA's minimum wage increases never happens. Turns out jobs woth minimum wage aren't ones you can easily outsource at this point.
- aerostable_slug 1y agoThat opinion is not universal: https://californiaglobe.com/fr/californias-20-fast-food-minimum-wage-job-losses-higher-food-prices-increased-automation/ https://californiaglobe.com/fr/californias-20-fast-food-mini...
- johnnyanmac 1y ago>outside of a recession Well that's already the first problem.
- glitchc 1y agoYou do realize you just advocated for a 100,000% tariff on paper plates, right? Here everyone is shitting the bed at 100% and 150% values.
- BurningFrog 1y agoThis system ends up with very high tariffs and prices on things like coffee and bananas, which can only be produced in the US at very high cost. This system optimizes for some kind of "fairness" between producers, rather than living standard for consumers. In reality, everyone is best of if things are produced where they can be made most effectively.
- int_19h 1y agoIn reality, "best if things are produced where they can be made most effectively" is usually a roundabout way to say "best if things are produced by the labor whom we can get away with paying as little as possible". Hence, outsourcing to countries where you can get away with smaller wages because the overall living standard is lower there and/or because the labor laws are non-existent or not enforced. But it's the same exact thing, just on a larger scale - you're still inherently relying on some people somewhere having a significantly lower quality of life than us to be able to exploit them like that.
- jdasdf 1y ago>The minimum wage can be an effective policy tool for mitigating economic inequality, but public demand for higher minimum wages has not kept up with rising levels of income disparities They could start the paper by not stating something obviously false.
- johnnyanmac 1y agoGiven some of the takes in this comment section so far, this community seems to be proving its point. I imagine almost no one in tech is making minimum wage, so I'm a bit perplexed why we seem to be so split on raising it. Some seem to have fallen for the "prices raise" narrative, as if they didn't raise regardless for the last 1t years.
- user____name 1y agoYou can find metastudies on historic minimum wage effects on prices or employment rates, spoiler alert: there is no correlation in sight. Same for rent control. Sadly that doesn't stop people from taking econ 101 and think they can use it to explain everything.
- const_cast 1y agoPeople ham-fisting free market economics is incredibly frustrating. Nobody actually bothers to do step 1: explain how a particular market is a free market. If they did that, they would be realize that all their conclusions they draw have zero foundation. The labor market is NOT a free market, and that's good. Everyone wants it to not be a free market. But that complicates things, and we can't make 1 million assumptions and draw basic conclusions. We actually have to, you know, analyze things.
- Sprotch 1y agoA better metric than income inequality would be the standard of living of the poorest. If everyone has access to medical care, housing, and education, does it really matter if some people have more on their bank account?
- loxodrome 1y agoBy that logic it’d be okay to have everyone making the minimum wage if it was high enough. Do you realize what a communist distopia that would be?
- lucyjojo 1y agoeveryone with a universal income? with no unnecessary suffering for housing, health, food or education? that's an utopia.
- jjice 1y agoI don't know enough about anything to intellectually comment on this kind of thing, but I do agree that the standard of living for the poorest is probably a good metric of a society. If the poorest people in a country get to live a happy, healthy life with people that love in not be stressed about food or housing, that sounds like a fantastic world. Do any countries current achieve this? Japan maybe? I have no clue.
- johnnyanmac 1y agoThese days, I believe every country is struggling with housing in some regard. But a good part of the EU and Japan and maybe South Korea might have had all those in the 2010's
- socalgal2 1y agoIt's hard to compare countries. Japan has a culture of lots of construction, and that housing is not an investment. They also have far less zoning rules and far less housing requirements (less of "must have 2 parking spaces, must have N meters of space in front of lot, must have X size bathroom", etc. The result is there are plenty of inexpensive and small places to rent. For example, I just did a search on suumo.jp on one train line 1 or 2 stops from Shibuya. 36 units came up under $275 a month. (would be several hundred units if I search all lines that go through Shibuya). The units are small (7.5 to 15 square meters), Many don't even have a shower (you'd walk to a public bath). But, you'll have shelter. So even on a minimum wage part time salary you can probably afford to have a roof over your head. And, that was in Shibuya. Go out 10-15 stops and it will get even cheaper or they'll get larger with more amenities for the same price. Food can also be affordable in Japan.
- loxodrome 1y agoThis paper seems based on the premise that inequality is bad, which is completely false. Inequality is absolutely necessary so that resources go to where they are used most effectively. This maximizes overall wealth/value creation, which is better for everyone, even if it is unequally shared. USA has highest median income in the world by a large margin for this very reason.
- pbhjpbhj 1y agoI mean, little could be clearly less true - people spend billions on advertising because they want to brainwash people into seeing their product as necessary/useful when it isn't. If you want to target resources, kill advertising is probably number 1. Second, you think we need more "CEO yachts"? That's where the resources are going more and more. IIRC billionaires in UK are 5 times richer since Covid. We have many little with poor housing and food situations. Western Capitalism directs resources to the wealthy, often those who gained wealth through past feudalism or [other?] crime.
- loxodrome 1y agoLook at this table https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Disposable_household_and_per_capita_income https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Disposable_household_and_per... The USA has the highest median disposable income (purchasing power) per household. How could you possibly believe that capitalism is making Americans and other capitalist countries worse off? There’s a reason practically everyone wants to move to those places!
- pbhjpbhj 1y agoWe're talking about wealth distribution within countries.
- loxodrome 1y agoMedian disposable income is a key statistic describing the distribution of wealth… half the population makes more and half makes less, so it tells you the central tendency, that is, how the middle class is doing.
- isapoor 1y ago[flagged]
- baggy_trough 1y agoI feel a deep sympathy for poor people, especially young people with minimal skills, which is why I think the minimum wage should be abolished. Making it much easier for them to get jobs is an important way for them to start gaining skills and becoming more productive, justifying a higher wage.
- johnnyanmac 1y agoI'll take "what is a dead end job" for $500, Alex. The kind of jobs offering sub-living wages are generally not ones that care about your growth. If they could get away with slave labor they would.
- baggy_trough 1y agoA so-called dead end job is much preferable to no job at all, which is the option on offer.
- johnnyanmac 1y agoNo job and studying for a career is preferable to not paying rent despite having a job. Of course I'm assuming you have a support network for that option. But that's the thing about poverty: you work twice as hard and progress nowhere.
- baggy_trough 1y agoEach person should be able to make that trade off for themselves. There’s no universal answer, and attempts to impose one are destructive.
- justanewuser27 1y ago[flagged]
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- comrade1234 1y agoIt feels like the USA is becoming like India (and others) where a middle class lifestyle depends more and more on the work of the extreme poor. I have friends in India with live-in Nannie's, live-in chef and a driver and they aren't extremely rich - they can get by paying these people a pittance. The USA similarly relies on low-paid, often illegal, workers being paid less than minimum wage to harvest their food, wash their cars, do their gardening, etc...
- msgodel 1y agoMost of the world looks that way and it's largely a consequence of their culture. We've spent decades saying that the US's culture was immoral for various reasons and did everything we could to import foreigners from places like that, now we're seeing the cultural shift and it turns out the ideas we had weren't as bad as we thought.
- mindslight 1y ago[flagged]
- cropcirclbureau 1y ago[flagged]
- msgodel 1y ago[flagged]
- cropcirclbureau 1y agoI'm referring to some of the rhetoric used to sell the current so called "decline" (authoritarian or economic). I believe they call them wedge issues? Every culture has nice words for it's bullshit. And yeah, that's whatabotism.
- msgodel 1y ago
- msgodel 1y ago[flagged]
- exabrial 1y ago[flagged]
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- talkingtab 1y agoI apologize in advance but this issue is a crucial one. The effects of this "inequality" for all people, rich and poor alike should not be underestimated. Accurately understanding cause and effect, having a diagnosis that actually affords an understanding and solution to the problem is of some importance then. In the US we see a severe and dramatic event: falling income and rising stock market. In simple terms, corporation profits are rising and those rising profits are going to those who are already wealthy. At the same time, the real income of common people is falling. The discussion often turns to "inflation" as though low inflation is good news. If you cannot afford reasonable health care, food, adequate housing, low inflation does not help. In the discussion of these increasingly common problems, the obvious solution - paying a living wage - does not come up. A key tool in understanding situations is "Cuo bono?" Who benefits? In the US and other countries it is corporations. An ancillary question is who does not benefit? The answer to that is question is given by the fact that the national minimum wage in the US is $7.25 per hour. Who benefits? Who does not? When the "too big to fail" banks had problems, the US instituted socialism for corporations. Who benefited? Who did not? And certainly there is less public opinion support for higher minimum wages. Why could this be? Public support is to some extent determined by public discussion - where people express their problems and issues. If there is no forum for this discussion, then perhaps that is the crucial factor. In which case measuring "public opinion" will not be predictive. A question then is whether there are forums where the experiences of common people are primary. Perhaps the Washington Post, owned by Jeff Bezos, is a such a forum? Really? Or perhaps other media, supported for the most part by corporate advertising is the answer. For example, the NYT with their articles about where to buy your two million dollar vacation home? Or here is a recent article for you: https://www.nytimes.com/2025/04/23/style/plant-sitter-nanny.html https://www.nytimes.com/2025/04/23/style/plant-sitter-nanny.... Our so called news media have dramatically failed. And somehow the NYT is surprised that there are people who will now choose any alternative over the status quo. And if you had the nerve to reject both candidates in the last election, the NYT deemed you a "double hater".
- johnnyanmac 1y ago>Our so called news media have dramatically failed. And somehow the NYT is surprised that there are people who will now choose any alternative over the status quo Our media is bought out by the very people who benefit, sadly. We've truly hit full oligarchy in 2025. Even manipulating the ones suffering to vote against their own best interests
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]