6 ms·
This reminds me of the observation that you shouldn't buy a car from a dealer who calls himself Honest Ed. Because honest people just go around being honest, t
by mjd 1y ago
This reminds me of the observation that you shouldn't buy a car from a dealer who calls himself Honest Ed.
Because honest people just go around being honest, they don't go around broadcasting honesty.
- robomc 1y agoThe tennis example is weird though. I don't think people who are bad at tennis go around claiming they're great at tennis, do they?
- alemanek 1y agoThey do, seriously it is very common with male interactions. I have seen it first hand with tennis, golf, chess, and bowling. With golf easily being the most common
- kriro 1y agoChess? Can't you just ask for their ELO? Or some proxy like chess.com rating? If you're good you must have played a lot of games. If you did, you got some number to back it up.
- weitendorf 1y agoI find it helpful to tell people who I know only dabble in eg chess that I am "pretty good at chess" when they do not have enough context on things like Elo and FIDE ratings to be able to understand comparisons like that. Of course, if someone knows what Elo is or is an active chess player then I will more humbly just tell them I am only like 1600 on lichess. I don't think this is necessarily bad. Compared to people who only dabble in things, someone who spends a decent amount of time on something actually is "pretty good" at it even though they might not be top tier to people within that same culture. I think there is some popular (dan luu?) blog about this. You can actually pretty easily be in the top 1% of skill or knowledge on something, and while that doesn't make you a world expert by any means, it does kinda make you an expert to an average person. My 1600 rating is very good within the pool of people who know what chess is and can play it, even though it's not impressive at all for people who actively play chess.
- readthenotes1 1y agoDunning Kruger would have us think so. Also, most people who are good at something let their actions speak.
- hluska 1y agoTennis is competitive though and unlike golf there’s no form of handicap. When it comes to pick up tennis, it’s not fun playing against someone way below or way above your level. I refer to myself as mediocre at tennis so I can play against people who are around my level. People who are good refer to themselves as being good so that everyone enjoys themselves (and improves) on a court. The difference between good and mediocre is significant. To the point that I cannot return a good tennis player’s serves. The difference between mediocre and post beginner is just as significant.
- bruce511 1y agoHaving played both tennis and golf, I agree. It's a lot harder to play social tennis than social golf. Two nice things about golf - the handicap system let's two players of different level engage in fun competition. (Yes, handicaps can be manipulated, but for the most part aren't. ) Second a very good player can play with a bad player, and both can have fun. The social factor is more important to the fun, and I've enjoyed tight games with people with hugely disparate handicaps. With tennis I always want to play either someone just a little bit better than me. Someone who can help me get a bit better all the time. My enjoyment of the game depends a lot on their performance. Both are enjoyable in their own right.
- wink 1y agoHow do you overcome a wrong observation of a local maximum though (e.g. in your club maybe)? I only experienced something like this once, late 90s. We thought of ourselves as pretty ok StarCraft players until we got some visitor to a lan party who basically demolished everyone. This was pre-ladder iirc so you only played a handful of games online.
- 1y ago
- xyzzy123 1y agoOr how countries with "democratic" in the name invariably are not.
- riehwvfbk 1y agoAnd few countries are as split into two warring camps as the United States of America.
- theoreticalmal 1y agoWhere’s the war? I must not be in a conflict zone
- t-3 1y agoTry going outside and attempt to honestly express your opinion of the current President or Israel or immigrants or ${current_political_thing}. Maybe you live in a political monoculture, but most places are not.
- wredcoll 1y agoMate, people yelling insults at you in public in regards to your political opinions is practically the definition of a functioning democracy.
- DougN7 1y agoNot if it uses fear and intimidation as a tactic.
- wredcoll 1y agoAre you technically correct? Yes. Are the majority of people who make these types of complaints thin-skinned right-wingers? Also yes. In my experience, people who actually experience intimidation for their views, like you know, the view that being gay is fine actually, don't go around making these types of complaints. They're out protesting and fighting.
- ldjkfkdsjnv 1y agoYup. Anytime someone keeps advertising some trait, its probably a cover up. They might not even be aware of it.
- GianFabien 1y agoPerhaps they are subconsciously aware of it. That is why they have to go around muttering affirmations to the contrary.
- ldjkfkdsjnv 1y agoSome of the worst behavior ive seen in my life has been done by devout catholics. who themselves cant see the consequences of their actions. and im not knocking religion, i just had to live alot of life to start being alarmed by outspoken moralists.
- ryandv 1y ago> Some of the worst behavior ive seen in my life has been done by devout catholics. Those same "devout Catholics" can also be found identifying as secular "progressives" or whatever other word is trendy and evokes implications of moral superiority and righteousness. The religions and pantheons may differ but the core psychological mechanisms are the same. The devout Catholic knows all the canned responses and hymns by rote, but only when the priest is there to prompt him; he forgets his moral code the second he has stood up from the pews. Analogously the secular progressive will eagerly output all the tokens expected of a "good person" when adequately prompted with contemporary inclusive language; yet they don't appear to be able to keep to their principles in other environments when they aren't being supplied with the exact same context and tokens.
- wredcoll 1y agoWhat a wildly random series of sentences that never bother making an actual point. Personally, while I'd rather people be good, I'll settle for them pretending really hard.
- ryandv 1y ago> I’m suspicious whenever someone says, “I’m an (adjective) (noun).” Why did you need to say, “I’m a great tennis player,” “I’m a deep thinker,” or “I’m a generous person”? Instead, why not simply play tennis, regardless of how great you are? Or think as deeply as you want? Or be generous? Which is why the whole "identification" fad is bullshit. Why bother identifying as a singer if you cannot sing? Just a continuation of this postmodern delusion that puts the cart before the horse and elevates language and symbols about reality over reality itself.
- dylan604 1y agoMost of the time, you don't have to walk the walk though. With the sports example, you can drop being great at it while talking to people at a bar or dinner party or online as you can't be asked to prove it right then and there. If you claim to be a good singer, you can pretty much do that at any time so that's a bit harder.
- wredcoll 1y agoWhen people talk about their own identity, they very rarely mean something like "great at singing". I admire your confidence that reality is so easily measured and categorized though. Personally, as I grow older, I find more and more exceptions to things I once thought of as immutable truth.
- ryandv 1y agoNo, my point is that the concept of identity is nonsense. Show me a proof of the existence of an "identity" and I will furnish you proof of the soul and god.
- wredcoll 1y agoSure, just as soon as you show me the proof of existence of "thoughts" and that you exist as something other than an illusion in my mind. How about the existence of numbers? The proof of 1+1=2? We humans have words for lots of things that only exist as abstract concepts without a physical embodiment. Identity is one more of those and it's trivial to understand its application to real people.
- alwa 1y agoHonest Achmed, on the other hand—I hear he issues only the most legitimate of certificates from his Used Cars and Certificates Emporium! https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=647959 https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=647959
- MichaelZuo 1y agoYeah discussing honesty seems pointless in real life considering a much lower bar… avoiding writing provable factual lies on the record… is often not even satisfied by large swathes on the population. Who often get away without any noticeable punishment too. In comparison even a deceiver that says a dozen half truths an hour, without any outright factual lies, seems like a paragon of virtue.
- kirubakaran 1y ago"Open" AI
- garbanz0 1y agoI just say "To be honest" when I want to signal I'm about to say something that someone doesn't want to hear or that is slightly inappropriate
- nine_k 1y agoIn general, one's own words are the cheapest, and thus least reliable, form of signaling. If you call yourself "Honest Ed", it's pretty suspicious; if others unironically give you a moniker "Honest Ed", it's high praise. Understatement is something only the renowned can afford; those who suck (or swindle) have to resort to overstatement and seek gullible audience.
- dylan604 1y agoSometimes people give the names ironically like calling the NFL lineman Tiny
- brikym 1y agoI think that's true of most marketing. The bigger the lie the more shouting has to be done. Peter Thiel mentions that monopoly companies often have the most 'sales' in order to seem competitive. And conversely small competitive companies want to seem large and stable. A bag of lettuce won't have 'healthy' all over the packaging because that's self evident but a bottle or can sugary drink will have all sorts of claims about vitamins there is even a brand called Vitamin Water. Honey Nut Cheerios Heart Healthy Breakfast Cereal. Vitamin Water. Green Hydrogen. Clean Diesel. Patriot Act.
- pers0n 1y agoSounds like people that claim to be religious or mention they are Christian to gain trust, I lived in the Bible Belt and saw that a lot
- jjtheblunt 1y agothat's everywhere
- yencabulator 1y agoActually, no. It's incredibly rare in the Nordics, which are way more secular. Claiming to be religious there gains you practically nothing, and might lose you some.
- jjtheblunt 1y agothat is also true in wide, but unpredictably located, swaths of America, i can attest. I grew up in a very famously religious suburb of Chicago, and the proudly super church-y family nearby ended up with the father convicted of embezzling from the church. consistent with your nordic point, it seemed to surprise no one (perhaps because most of the area was northwest european recently derived families).
- tptacek 1y agoI'm trying to think of a famously religious suburb of Chicago besides Skokie, which I would not describe as "church-y". Wheaton? I had to look that up.
- jjtheblunt 1y agowheaton it is. evanston before that as a toddler. you're in oak park? (hi!)
- tptacek 1y ago
- mbreese 1y agoThat reminds me of the Guarantee scene from the movie Tommy Boy: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mEB7WbTTlu4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mEB7WbTTlu4 To briefly summarize (and sanitize), just because someone puts a guarantee on the box doesn't mean they'll stand by it. The guarantee on the box makes you feel warm and toasty, and that's what you bought -- the warm feelings. But if you have a quality product, you don't need to advertise the guarantee... the product is good enough on it's own. (or something like that...)
- tough 1y agoSimilarly the -refund, no questions asked- even if its honored by merchants plays on a psychological effect where most people wont ask for a refund (even if they dont use the product) unless its really broken/whatever marketing is the art of manipulation
- beAbU 1y agoMy father has been a Leatherman guy for as long as I can remember. We were at a gun show or trade fair many years ago, and leatherman had a stall there. They had a guy manning a service station, and the idea was you bring you multitool and they'll oil it, sharpen the blades, tighten screws etc. All free of course. So my dad sends me with his leatherman to stand in the queue at this stall, while he goes to enjoy the rest of the expo. Eventually my turn comes up, I hand over my dad's multitool and the gentleman gets to work servicing it. He beckons to the person behind me, to find out what he wants. This guy walks up and dumps a heap of parts on the bench. His multitool was in literal pieces. It fell off his belt while at speed on a motorcycle or something. The Leatherman Man put down my dad's tool, scraped the heap of scrap off the bench into a bin, reached for a shelf behind him and pulled off a brand new multitool and gave it to this guy, and waved him off. This to me was the most powerful expression of "we got u" I've ever seen from a company, and they don't even put "no questions asked" on the box! Needless to say I'm now also a Leatherman guy.
- tough 1y agothere was a time when apple wasnt a big shot where going to a genius bar felt like this, like your mac could be out of warranty technically but some guy could go above and beyond to try and fix it. great customer service is a great hack for retention
- bloomingeek 1y agoI think most people get taken advantage of at a car dealership because they don't understand that they must do their homework on what the value is of the vehicle they're interested in, understand the financing, knowing what the extended warranty is worth and always walk away from pressure salesmanship. If something is confusing, have them print out an offer on the vehicle and take it to someone for help. If they don't want to do that, walk! If the buyer remembers the dealership wants to make as much money as they can, then it's you against them. Since this is a given, what's on paper counts.
- tough 1y agoor just call every dealership on the country looking for the ones that randomly need to fill their sales quota that month
- majormajor 1y agoThe more expensive a transaction, the more crap. Houses are worse than cars! But then if you spend enough more you get into super fancy squads of lawyers territory and a lot more due diligence and contracts. The sweet spot for scams it: * rare enough for the average person that they won't do too many in their life, and so it would be high effort to become an expert * not quite expensive enough that all your potential buyers can lawyer up Kinda funny that we put up with it. It's not adding value to the economy.
- yencabulator 1y agoI'm very much ok with having a used car, and in case that's true for you too, here's my thinking: A private seller may be scamming you, but a professional car salesman is guaranteed to be.
- infamousclyde 1y agoSimilarly, there’s a special military unit whose motto is “Facta Non Verba”— deeds, not words. Talk is cheap!