4 ms·
Methylene Blue is fascinating because it has been present in alternative medicine, biohacking, and nootropics forums for decades. It seems everyone in those com
by Aurornis 1y ago
Methylene Blue is fascinating because it has been present in alternative medicine, biohacking, and nootropics forums for decades. It seems everyone in those communities discovers it eventually, thinks it must be a miracle substance, and then either feels nothing or has some initial positive effects that are either placebo or diminish quickly with tolerance.
From the anecdotes I’ve read over the years, very few people continue taking it. They either feel nothing, get some worrying side effects, or the initial effects they experienced (or placebo) disappear after a couple days or weeks. The most positive posts seem to be correlated with people taking a dozen medications and supplements at the same time, so it’s impossible to know what’s causing their experience.
Another ever-popular medication in these communities is Selegiline: Also an MAOI but selective for MAO-B at low doses (warning: it’s easier to reach MAO-A inhibition with repeated dosing, especially sublingual, than many internet sources claim). This one draws in people who are in their “dopamine explains everything” phase of learning neuroscience and think it must be a hack to get “more dopamine”. Again, few people continue it and many are confused about why they end up fatigued or tired while taking it instead of turning into the guy from Limitless. Neuropharmacology isn’t as simple as taking drugs to push neurotransmitter up.
Selegiline was repurposed as an anti-depressant recently, but it’s delivered transdermally and only showed efficacy at levels high enough to be a full MAOI.
- replwoacause 1y agoExcellent summary. As someone who has taken both and spent an inordinate amount of time on Longecity, this is pretty spot on.
- arresin 1y agoI remember there was a year on the imminst where everyone was trying methylene blue and reporting amazing effects.
- landl0rd 1y agoPretty much accurate, this is also my perception. I think the whole "nootropics" and "biohacking" community would benefit from mandatory introductory reading to understand that disrupting homeostasis in a durable and meaningful way is actually darn hard to do without serious side effects.
- spondylosaurus 1y agohttps://www.thecut.com/article/supplements-made-me-lose-my-mind.html https://www.thecut.com/article/supplements-made-me-lose-my-m... A recent cautionary tale about someone who took St. John's Wort because they didn't want to take antidepressants, then quit the SJW too quickly... which functionally put them into (prolonged, agonizing) SSRI withdrawal.
- Aurornis 1y agoSJW inhibits serotonin uptake and also has numerous other targets. It’s a fundamental misunderstanding of the alternative medicine world to consider it safer or more gentle than SSRIs.
- spondylosaurus 1y agoYeah, I thought it was ironic (and a little funny) that people promote it as an SSRI alternative even though it's just a less precise, less regulated SSRI. It's like telling someone to skip their quinine pills and chug a bunch of tonic water instead!
- girvo 1y agoTo be fair, tonic water (with some gin in it) tastes a lot better than quinine pills!
- Aurornis 1y ago> understand that disrupting homeostasis in a durable and meaningful way is actually darn hard to do This is a huge problem in online ADHD communities, too. The ADHD subreddits are a constant stream of people having “Wow I feel amazing” reactions after taking their first stimulant dosage, followed a week later by complaints that it “stopped working”. It’s a constant cycle of informing people that the euphoria they experienced was a side effect, not how they’re going to feel for the rest of their life taking a stimulant.
- 1y ago
- HighlandSpring 1y agoSelegiline is also known as Emsam, the patches reportedly Sam Bankman-Fried was on, alongside ADHD meds. I recall reading how this may have been a large driver of his compulsive risk it all decision making that eventually brought it all down.
- mickelsen 1y agoDelivery through transdermal patch (Emsam) is different than other presentations of Selegiline, and we don't know the doses he was on. I've heard a low dose of Emsam (6mg) gives a better, more stable dopamine baseline, without getting into MAO-A inhibition that happens at upper doses.
- Aurornis 1y ago> I've heard a low dose of Emsam (6mg) gives a better, more stable dopamine baseline, without getting into MAO-A inhibition that happens at upper doses. This is the broscience theory that you find on Internet forums, but it didn’t play out positively in the actual clinical trials. Getting into full MAOI inhibition was necessary for positive effects. The “more dopamine” theory appeals to people who treat the brain as a simple machine where you’re adjusting levels of different chemicals, but doesn’t really work out in practice. Dopamine is the neurotransmitter du jour in these circles, but mood and mental health are more than one chemical.
- mickelsen 1y agoThanks for the info, I was missing an update on this space. If there's no solid, reproducible evidence of cognitive or energy benefits at this level -and full MAO‑A engagement seems necessary for those effects, then that doesn't look good. About your second paragraph, I agree and I wasn't validating the bro part, just that I read about Emsam once. I guess it's mostly influenced by the popularity of performance enhancers in general, be it wakefulness enhancers, stimulants, etc. People are always trying to find "the edge", without the tradeoff, basically chasing a mirage. Maybe a neglected topic in this theme has been the acetylcholine pathway. Cobenfy, for example, has been approved for treating negative symptoms of schizophrenia and it's not a classical drug in that space.
- serbuvlad 1y agoIn my experience with hard drugs, the human body has an amazing ability to build tolerance, but in a way that biases against positive effects. So, for example, a first-time user may consume quantity X of a drug, and get the positive effect Y and negative side-effect Z. An experienced user may consume quantity X and only get a negative side-effect 1/3 or 1/4 Z. But also only get a positive effect of 1/10 Y. So even though the ratio of Z/X has decreased (less negative side-effect per unit of substance) so has the ratio of Y/X (less positive effect per unit of substance). Most importantly, the ratio of Z/Y has increased (more negative side-effect per "unit" of positive effect). I find no reason to disbelieve the existence of performance-enhancing chemicals (or mood-enhancing, or anything else). Perhaps Methylene Blue does do what it's fans think it does -- at first. If you want to get some work done, coffee can really help, Red Bull even more so, and speed even more so. The question is what happens on day 3, week 3, month 3, year 3 of continuous use.