6 ms·
Minimum wage is a silly thing to look at. In 1980, 10% of men and 22% of women earned min wage. In 2010, this fell to 5% and 7%. http://www.statista.com/statis
by yummyfajitas 14y ago
Minimum wage is a silly thing to look at. In 1980, 10% of men and 22% of women earned min wage. In 2010, this fell to 5% and 7%.
http://www.statista.com/statistics/185536/share-of-workers-paid-at-the-minimum-wage-by-gender/ http://www.statista.com/statistics/185536/share-of-workers-p...
Further, a look at hard data (for both the bottom 20% and the middle 20%) shows that people today are more likely to own a car than in 1981, and have more house per person than in 1989 (no data on square footage exists in 1981).
http://www.aei.org/files/2011/10/25/Material-Well-Being-Poor-Middle-Class.pdf http://www.aei.org/files/2011/10/25/Material-Well-Being-Poor...
So no, it's not the economy.
- api 14y agoEarth to Planet Trust Fund: it is the economy. http://livingwage.mit.edu http://livingwage.mit.edu Also look at the ratio of median income to real estate value. We are still in a housing bubble. My household earns about 40% more than the national average, we do not live extravagantly, we budget well, and we feel barely middle class. This is ridiculous. I'm surprised there aren't riots.
- yummyfajitas 14y agoI'm sorry that stats about what people actually consume disagree with your vague speculation about what stuff should cost. If we "feel barely middle class", it's because our expectations and desires have grown faster than our means. It's not because we have less than some historical cohort.
- api 14y agoThis is exactly what both the left and the right are propagandizing the middle class to do: lower expectations. In some cases, it means lowering our expectations to below those of our parents. Think about that for a minute. Find me a corporation or an entrepreneur who thinks like this. Imagine a CEO saying this to shareholders and the board: "We didn't make our goals this quarter, and many in our industry also showed reduced sales numbers. It is clear that we need to reduce our expectations. Next quarter's numbers will be lower, and shareholders are just going to have to take a loss." He'd be out on his ass the next day. Related to this is the idiotic garbage that the working class are fed by the media: that they should hate people who make good wages and agitate to cut those other peoples' wages down to be in line with their own. Again, find me a corporation that thinks like this. Apple is currently worth more than Microsoft. Is Microsoft thinking "how can we make them make less money?!?" No. They're thinking "How can we grow? How can we make as much money as Apple is making?" Unbelievable. You realize that you're being sold into fiefdom on the feudal "lands" owned by the financial industry, right? Edit: I'm not a socialist. I'm a capitalist. Part of capitalism is negotiation. The American middle and working classes have been fed this ridiculous line of baloney that capitalism is a magical hands-free machine that will elevate their standard of living if they do nothing. It doesn't work that way, as every businessman and entrepreneur understands. You have to negotiate. You have to push. They push, and you push. Studies have shown that the ideal point in negotiation is often precisely where both parties feel a bit, but not too, unhappy. Right now the rich and corporate interests are rolling in it, happy as clams, and everyone else is suffering. That's because one side is pushing and the other side is not. So how do workers and professionals (whom I count as workers... the white/blue collar distinction is increasingly meaningless) push? The old way was unions, but that's definitely shown its age. We need some new ideas. Lowering our expectations is not a particularly productive idea. Edit 2: I also think using government to push is fair game. Why? Because the rich and corporations do it. They take corporate welfare, bailouts, special infrastructure investments, government contracts, and benefit hugely from publicly funded R&D. But they want you to refuse to use the government as a lever because... it works! So capitalists really ought to be socialists, at least for now. Only give up a lever in a negotiation if the other party on the other side of the table also gives up that lever. The rich want you to be principled libertarians while they munch at the government trough.
- tacogordito 14y agoI can't help but nitpick. Companies lower guidance and expectations all the time. Share price almost always falls when this happen, but it's not uncommon and not cause for the CEO being ousted. https://www.google.com/search?hl=en&gl=us&tbm=nws&q=lowers+guidance&oq=lowers+guidance https://www.google.com/search?hl=en&gl=us&tbm=nws...
- tatsuke95 14y ago>"We didn't make our goals this quarter, and many in our industry also showed reduced sales numbers. It is clear that we need to reduce our expectations. Next quarter's numbers will be lower, and shareholders are just going to have to take a loss." Uh, they do say that all the time. I tend to agree with the other poster: our expectations are too high. It's a product of having witnessed one of the greatest runups in wealth (and debt) we've ever seen in history. A 2500 sqft house, two (or three) cars, regular vacations to Europe or the warm south, maybe a summer house, boats, motorcycles and other toys...these things are now expected by the "middle class". It's completely out of whack with history and the rest of the planet. So whether you choose to lower your expectations or not has no bearing on what will actually happen. We're going to have a deleveraging run where the average Westerner is, as a whole, poorer than the generation before us.
- JonnieCache 14y agoWhat incentive do we have then, to not forcibly extract that wealth from the previous generation? To me it seems that if we need to de-leverage, why on earth should we pay these people their pensions? All the intergenerational trust and good faith is already gone anyway. Note: the views casually related above may or may not represent the actual considered opinions of the management.
- tatsuke95 14y ago>"What incentive do we have then, to not forcibly extract that wealth from the previous generation?" We do have the incentive. And we will extract that wealth. But it takes time, since "they" currently have the political power. What you describe is what is happening in the real world. Reform everywhere so they get the pensions and benefits, but nobody after them will. This is happening both publicly and privately. Even unions are stiffing new members. We'll have the last laugh, though. Eventually the boomers will need to divest. At that point they'll find out we don't have the money to buy their assets.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- specialist 14y agoReally? AEI? Minimum wage hasn't kept up with inflation. Debt financed consumption. You're trying too hard. This stuff isn't that complicated.
- yummyfajitas 14y agoThe numbers all come from the American Housing Survey and Consumer Expenditure Survey. Are you claiming they are incorrect? Or are you merely stating your dislike for AEI?
- specialist 14y agoLies, damned lies, and statistics. I rather like the AEI. It serves a purpose. Kind of like a honeypot.
- liber8 14y ago"Minimum wage hasn't kept up with inflation. Debt financed consumption." You're right that minimum wage hasn't kept up with inflation. You're also right that debt financed (a lot of) consumption. But it doesn't follow that those earning minimum wage drove consumption by acquiring debt. As yummyfajitas links above show, those earning minimum wage are a tiny percentage of overall wage earners. In other words, minimum wage earners aren't going to move the needle much. Double minimum wage (and magically don't have that affect employment levels) and consumption isn't going to go up all that much, simply because there aren't that many people earning minimum wage. For that reason, it is a bit of a silly metric to base an argument on.
- specialist 14y agoOP is about why Millennials aren't buying cars and houses. Whereas OP includes values (eg smartphones vs cars), thaumaturgy also says they don't have the cash. No reasonable person can deny wage stagnation, rising unemployment, increasing costs (education, food, housing, and transportation). yummyfajitas gets argumentative, citing some libertarian fallacies. specialist refutes yummy. liber8 gets pedantic, forgetting original point.
- thaumaturgy 14y agoUpvoted you for being the only response with numbers so far, even though I disagree with your conclusion. The average price of a new car in 1980 was $7,200 [1]. In 2010, it's $28,400 [2]. That's an almost 300% increase. Federal minimum wage in 1980 was $3.10 [3]. In 2010, it's $7.25, a 130% increase. That's lagging pretty far behind new car prices. You point out that fewer people are earning minimum wage now than in 1980, but I would counterpoint that more people are unemployed now than in 1980 -- by almost double in terms of the real numbers of unemployed people (but "only" a rate increase from 7.1% to 8.4%) [4]. Although car ownership did increase from 1980 to 2010 [5], total new passenger car sales actually fell from 1980 to 2010 [6], which is closer to what the original article was actually discussing, and would support the conjecture that there are simply more cars on the road now than in 1980. Further, the inflation-adjusted income of people aged 25 to 34 has stayed roughly level from 1980 to 2010 [7], which pretty well jives with so much of what I've read everywhere else that shows a tremendously overall weakened buying power amongst the youth demographics -- which, again, was what the article was trying to be about. So, in summary: the price of a new car has gone up a lot but wages have not, especially if you're young. I'm pretty confident that this might be a factor in why young people aren't buying new cars. [1]: http://www.thepeoplehistory.com/1980.html http://www.thepeoplehistory.com/1980.html -- might not be a good source, I'm open to suggestions for something better. [2]: http://www.ehow.com/facts_5977729_average-cost-new-car.html http://www.ehow.com/facts_5977729_average-cost-new-car.html; this number seemed high to me, but http://www.usatoday.com/money/autos/2010-07-12-carprices12_ST_N.htm http://www.usatoday.com/money/autos/2010-07-12-carprices12_S... corroborates it. [3]: http://www.infoplease.com/ipa/A0774473.html http://www.infoplease.com/ipa/A0774473.html [4]: http://www.nidataplus.com/lfeus1.htm http://www.nidataplus.com/lfeus1.htm [5]: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Motor_vehicle#United_States http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Motor_vehicle#United_States -- because I questioned the partisanship of your source. [6]: http://www.bts.gov/publications/national_transportation_statistics/html/table_01_16.html http://www.bts.gov/publications/national_transportation_stat... [7]: http://nces.ed.gov/fastfacts/display.asp?id=77 http://nces.ed.gov/fastfacts/display.asp?id=77
- yummyfajitas 14y agoIf car ownership increased, but sales of new cars fell, it implies people are keeping the same car for more time. The employment to population ratio is the same as it was during the 80's, and was considerably higher until the recent recession. In contrast, the fraction of people earning min wage has fallen. http://research.stlouisfed.org/fred2/series/EMRATIO http://research.stlouisfed.org/fred2/series/EMRATIO Further, adjusting wages (rather than total comp) for inflation is a gratuitous statistical fallacy. One of the biggest drivers in "inflation" is an average of the price of the expanding basket of goods called "health care" [1]. For most people, this is paid for out of non-wage compensation. [1] I.e., an MRI + laparoscopic spine surgery today costs more than back pain in 1980.