8 ms·
Defiant loyalists paid dearly for choosing wrong side in the American Revolution
- komali2 1y ago[flagged]
- inquirerGeneral 1y ago[dead]
- CivBase 1y agoI don't think it died over the last few years. I think it's been dead for decades. Most Americans only seem to be anti-authoritarian when the authority is part of the opposing political party. This is nothing new. What is new is how much presidential power has expanded - allowing for increasingly authoritarian policies.
- Benanov 1y agoI would say that it's not "new" that presidential power has expanded. That's very new, and every president over my lifetime has expanded it bit by bit. 4547 is just doing so at a much more rapid pace and using obscure laws that no one wanted to take the time to clean up. I expect that if we get out of this the American populace will insist Congress tighten up its books and repeal and clarify some of its more obscure laws.
- baggy_trough 1y ago> I expect that if we get out of this the American populace will insist Congress tighten up its books and repeal and clarify some of its more obscure laws. Thanks for the chuckle!
- ericmay 1y agoWhen Americans were “resisting authority” by not wearing masks and keeping their businesses opened despite lockdown orders did you feel the same pride in anti-authority behavior then? One person’s freedom fighter is another person’s terrorist. Always has been and always will be that way. The winning side when there is one usually gets to write the history of who was what. Do you still feel pride in American anti-authoritarianism today or do you think the US may have turned out to be governed more like the UK, Canada, Australia, or New Zealand complete with trust in government run healthcare had it not succeeded in rebellion? Important to remember all of these things when you are being introspective of an issue like the protests ongoing in Los Angelas and elsewhere. Anyway it’s hard to resist authority when you can’t find parking for the local protest.
- jeffbee 1y agoAnybody get tear-gassed for not wearing a mask?
- alex43578 1y agoEquating not wearing a mask with assaulting federal agents, damaging federal property, or being part of an unlawful assembly doing the former is quite a stretch. Be realistic about why the groups in LA are getting tear-gassed or pepperball’d.
- roenxi 1y agoYes. That is part of why the various COVID measures proved quite unpopular. In Australia for example we saw the standard crowd-control treatments [0] being used to break up protests of people who objected to the sudden spike in authoritarianism. There was also the internationally eyebrow-raising financial abuse that the Canadians were doling out that was a new low for anti-protest tactics and political repression. [0] https://www.skynews.com.au/australia-news/coronavirus/victoria-police-fire-rubber-bullets-as-part-of-new-tactics-to-disperse-crowds-protesting-in-melbourne/news-story/0c7743f78ac17ffc569a75aa1e6c9fcc?nk=f03ea4252b7a9615ba49b3cd1adeb884-1749475700 https://www.skynews.com.au/australia-news/coronavirus/victor...
- ap99 1y ago[flagged]
- ceejayoz 1y agoThe “laws must be enforced, back the blue” folks voted in a convicted felon - exempting him from sentencing! - who then pardoned hundreds of people who assaulted cops on his behalf. Spare me.
- pjc50 1y agoI think a lot of people believe that there ought to be a statute of limitations on immigration; if you've been peacefully living and working in the country for many years, what's the actual public purpose of deporting someone? Including breaking up a family?
- alex43578 1y agoSurely you recognize the same “representative government forms the core American value” you laud is both the mechanism by which the current administration was elected, as well as the same mechanism that passed the immigration laws that are being enforced, right?
- hiddencost 1y agoICE's actions are wildly illegal. None of this false equivalence nonsense.
- anonfordays 1y ago>ICE's actions are wildly illegal. No they're not. Deporting illegal aliens is not "wildly" illegal.
- Supermancho 1y agoCherry picking isn't compelling. The parallels between the philosophies of ICE and Israel are noticeable. ie Extraneous damage and laws broken along the way are justified collateral damage by sympathizers. A dark period for the US, indeed.
- anonfordays 1y ago[dead]
- Supermancho 1y ago>>>> ICE's actions are wildly illegal. >>> No they're not. Deporting illegal aliens is not "wildly" illegal. - anonfordays >> Cherry picking isn't compelling. > Glad that's not what I'm doing. - anonfordays Yes it is. "Actions" is broader than your cherry picked singular action - "deporting illegals". Rephrasing, graciously, something like "the deporting of illegals is the goal and that's lawful" would be more correct. Unfortunately, I don't think you have anything to add to a good faith discussion. Good luck with whatever.
- ty6853 1y agoWe're constantly pitted against one another. Ammon Bundy used actual armed militias to check the power of unelected bureaucrats who were constantly changing up the regulations against ranchers, and it actually worked. Anytime something actually works, the first thing the establishment does is tell you they are on the right, or the left, or they're your enemy. No matter that Bundy actually was on the side of immigrants rights, and stood against Trump, nah all the people that have employed effective strategies are right wing or left wing loons who should be discarded. The establishment has us all divided. The true enemy of the people is the unelected bureaucrats that snatch people off the street and impose ever changing demands with the power of law, all while bypassing constitutional rights. Unfortunately this divide and conquer strategy is highly effective. Most 'sides' seem to think their guy will do better the next time and they are just protesting until the power can be used appropriately. The problem is that anybody's guy had the ability to do so in the first place.
- pjc50 1y agoThe hypocrisy is, as you spotted, all the way back to the original founders. The original agreement was freedom for whites only, and too many people want to go back there.
- sQL_inject 1y ago"critical of people for defending the city from ICE stormtroopers. I see people justifying paper-checking, something I'm sure we roundly mocked the Soviets for doing - I thought gestapo agents checking the papers of people in the streets was commie shit?" Truly curious, what methods are you suggesting we use to keep our immigrant population tracked and controlled? If the immigrants aren't leaving after being asked nicely, what steps can we use other than force to remove them? Surely you don't believe unchecked immigration in our modern Nation is good? If you do, then how much is too much, at what number, and what if those immigrants still collected benefits of your tax dollars while not themselves paying into the system? What if they voted for someone you don't like?
- pjc50 1y ago> what methods are you suggesting we use to keep our immigrant population tracked and controlled? You can't track and control only immigrants. Any such system would include tracking and controls of citizens, simply in order to sort them into the "not immigrant" category. Hence all the "papers please". (Not to mention the false positive problem!)
- alex43578 1y agoSurprise, you’re already tracked in a dozen harmless ways that enable modern life: drivers license, Social Security number, birth certificate, etc; even before you get into quasi-public records like credit reporting, bank accounts, and insurance. Acting like showing ID to an immigration official is some unprecedented intrusion is absurd. Fly domestically, shop at Costco, or buy a 6 pack of beer and you’ll end up showing more “papers” than a typical interaction with Customs/ICE, assuming you’re not illegal.
- ceejayoz 1y agoI can not shop at Costco, not buy beer, and not fly. I can't not interact with law enforcement, which is why we have things like the Fourth Amendment to protect us in those non-consensual scenarios.
- ExoticPearTree 1y agoTwo things: - the US has a history dealing very harshly with whoever goes (or is perceived to be) against the federal government - I do not understand why would anyone be pro illegals and go against their country to support them The world is going bonkers.
- ap99 1y agoThe people who are pro illegals either 1) face zero consequences for not enforcing the border laws, 2) illegals themselves, or 3) people who are anti-anything-Trump/Republican. America isn't a town square that the world is somehow entitled to inhabit. It's a country with borders and laws.
- jeffbee 1y agoIn literally every jurisdiction in America, failure to enforce a law is not itself unlawful. It is protected by sovereign immunity at the federal, state, and lower levels as well. Discretionary acts of government regarding how to enforce the law are not subject to judicial interference.
- AnimalMuppet 1y agoOK, but in the current situation, the laws are federal, and the feds are choosing to enforce them. A state or city preventing the feds from enforcing them is not protected by sovereign immunity. It seems to me that the most that can legally be done is to require the feds to actually follow due process. (But I thought different yesterday, and I may think different tomorrow...)
- jeffbee 1y agoI think you're misrepresenting the situation and the relationship between the federal and state and local governments. There certainly is not anything in the Constitution that compels a local government to allow a federal agency to house their prisoners in the local jail, or to have offices in the local police station, or to have keys to the coffee room in the local courthouse. For that matter, if the feds happen to have their own offices there's absolutely nothing that dictates that there has to be a local road to that place, that anyone is allowed to drive on. If a state or local government reckons that their material support for federal activities is limited to a certain extent, that is well within that state's purview.
- parpfish 1y agoI think early American settlers had a little extra moxie because there was excitement about how they were in a new world (to them, literally) and they were thinking big and creating something new. It used to be that every American was basically frontiersman or explorer that was pushing boundaries, but things settled down and now people are largely content and nestled in place.
- malfist 1y agoModern conservatism grew out of authoritarian monarchist philosophers of the French revolution. It's inherently tied to supporting an unquestionable social hierarchy with rulers at the top, be they kings, presidents or billionaires. It's not so much as the philosophy is dead, but more that it's finally achieving it's goals. Anti authoritarianism is just a rhetoric device. Just like saying trans people shouldn't be allowed to use the bathroom is a rhetoric device for achieving the goal is forcing trans people out of existence, either by making their lives such hell that they take their own lives, or that they go back to the closet.
- anonfordays 1y ago>Modern conservatism grew out of authoritarian monarchist philosophers Not in the US. Modern conservatism in the US is tied to the individualistic self-reliance movement that rejects the concept of rulers at the top in favor of States' rights and local governance. It is classically liberal with special emphasis on individual autonomy, limited government, economic freedom, political freedom and freedom of speech. You may be confusing it with conservativism in the UK/EU.
- ty6853 1y agoYou're thinking of classical liberalism, which is something the dominating political factions are highly against. The contemporary meaning of conservatism has been hijacked by the Republican party which does not employ any of those goals.
- anonfordays 1y ago>You're thinking of classical liberalism Yes, that is what I typed in my comment above. >which is something the dominating political factions are highly against. The current Republican party's platform follows classical liberalism: "Classical liberalism is a political tradition and a branch of liberalism that advocates free market and laissez-faire economics and civil liberties under the rule of law, with special emphasis on individual autonomy, limited government, economic freedom, political freedom and freedom of speech."[0] You can argue that Trump isn't following that, but it is what the Republican party has incorporated into it's platform for decades. [0] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Classical_liberalism https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Classical_liberalism
- dfxm12 1y agoI don't know what happened to our values Concentration of media has allowed conservative think tanks to shape people's values. Ten years ago [0], this meant all conservatives were getting marching orders from Fox News. Today, there is the illusion of choice among conservative media outlets (Fox News, X, Newsmax, etc.), but they all send the same message. Even traditionally more moderate outlets, like the WSJ, are being bought by the corporate class and shifting their message to the right. 0 - https://www.pewresearch.org/journalism/2014/10/21/political-polarization-media-habits/ https://www.pewresearch.org/journalism/2014/10/21/political-...
- ecshafer 1y agoAnd where do liberals get their marching orders? Or did this effect not happen there?
- dfxm12 1y agoThe polling data suggests they get their news from varied sources and tend to focus on issues moreso than parties or candidates.
- bigfishrunning 1y agoCNN, MSNBC, HuffPo, NYT
- ceejayoz 1y agoThere's a reason "Dems in disarray" is a meme. It's very much based on reality.
- stefantalpalaru 1y ago[dead]
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- saysjonathan 1y agoNow I want to see 'Tories' used derisively in modern American politics.
- dontlaugh 1y agoGo ahead. In the UK there’s regular Tories (Conservative Party), red Tories (Labour Party under Blair or Starmer), tartan Tories (SNP), etc. In the US it seems like you only have red and blue Tories.
- shortrounddev2 1y agoActually there's a massive difference between Democrats and Republicans in the US, and that difference matters a lot
- bix6 1y ago[flagged]
- moogleii 1y agoRecently learned that one of Ben Franklin's sons was a loyalist. He fled to England after the war.
- jplrssn 1y agoAs did everyone else who read the article :-)
- chasil 1y agoThe recent series with Michael Douglas makes repeated mention of William Franklin. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Franklin_(miniseries) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Franklin_(miniseries)
- Balgair 1y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/William_Franklin https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/William_Franklin Not only was William a loyalist, he was the last colonial governor of New Jersey and was one of the chief leaders of the loyalists. His early years and heritage are just crazy stuff, even for our times. There is a good reason you've not heard about ol William before, because his story and relationships are totally nuts. My lord, the conflicts of interest are at actual war. Imagine if Putin's bastard son was one of Zelensky's most important generals.
- FridayoLeary 1y ago>What’s more, much of the population, “probably a statistical majority, [just] wanted to get on with their own lives without worrying about declaring their allegiance to one side or the other,” Still the same today.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- morkalork 1y agoThe absolute truth right here. Just go on reddit to see it any time a roadway gets blocked on protest.
- aaomidi 1y agoReddit is one of the most as astroturfed platforms out there.
- stormfather 1y agoGhislaine Maxwell, for instance, was a mod on /r/worldnews and one of the most prolific posters.
- whytaka 1y agoWhat's a general news forum with high quality commentators you think is relatively devoid of astroturfing?
- aaomidi 1y agoHonestly, I think it doesn’t exist. But Reddit in particular is nasty about this. I think HN does a bit of a better job but the issue here is that the majority of users are generally well off. This skews the discussions.
- pjc50 1y ago[flagged]
- disposition2 1y agoThanks for sharing, I’ve always enjoyed the Smithsonian magazine and its articles, hope to visit some day. I’m hoping all the RIFs, reductions / eradication of IMLS, etc. don’t reduce the gains in & sharing of knowledge from these institutions, but if I am being honest it kind of feels like it’s purposeful destruction. So I’ll enjoy it while we have it.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- mcphage 1y agoI’m planning to take my kids to Washington this summer to see the Smithsonian museums. It doesn’t seem like a great time to go to Washington, but I don’t know if they’ll be there, or in what state, next summer or the summer after.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- ben7799 1y agoI have always thought the fact Boston was a hotbed of revolution and New York city was a loyalist stronghold (as the article mentions) has had some small subconscious effect on the ongoing rivalry between the two cities all the way to the present day. We joke about the Red Sox and the Yankees but deep down there is this smidgen of it that goes all the way back. Also from the article, amazing how William Franklin has been almost erased by history even though Benjamin Franklin is endlessly discussed in elementary history in the US. A fascinating addition to the story. I'm sure historians are familiar with this, but it's likely something every day Americans should all know about. I know it was not mentioned in my education through high school, including AP history. There was scant discussion of loyalists, the Tories were definitely mentioned but it was not covered in the same way the community & family divisions of the Civil War were.
- taeric 1y agoThis feels odd. Many people paid dearly for being involved, period? It isn't like we have any dynasties that survived through the era, did we? Specifically, 46 people signed the declaration of independence. How many of those are remembered today? Do I expect that people on the "other side" had it worse? Yeah, but this framing implies a spoils system. This always makes it odd to read about narratives that go about people's connection to family land. It is almost anti American in how we were founded and grew. I know we have a few estates that are named and known. Is that a larger number than I realize?
- runako 1y agoSharp contrast here with the aftermath of our bloodiest war.
- sys32768 1y agoAmerican descendants of loyalists often hide their roots. I know this because my grandmother told me a few years before she passed that her father, a mason and devoted patriot, once confided a scandalous family secret: there are loyalists in our family tree. Sadly, grandma's research never got her to the root of this claim despite much research, but thanks to online resources and some helpful Canadians, I discovered the truth. Grandma's grandfather had emigrated from New Brunswick, Canada, during the Civil War, in which he served the Union. It turns out his great-grandfather was a captain in the Queen's Guard during the American revolution, born in Connecticut. He and his wife and children had fled after the war with other loyalists to New Brunswick, Canada. They suffered many deprivations, although the loyalist commission board compensated them about half their worldly goods they lost in America. This captain had married a woman whose brother fought for the Americans at Bunker Hill. While researching my grandmother's grandfather from Canada, I discovered a telling white lie: he would tell the local busybody newspaper that he was visiting his sister in New York. Thing is, he had no sister in New York. Instead, I discovered the Canadian newspapers not long after were reporting he had arrived from America to visit his sister in New Brunswick. I was blown away by all this rich history, but when I shared my discoveries with all the remaining family on that side, nobody expressed excitement. In fact, the one person who used to call me up to discuss family history, stopped calling me.
- sa46 1y agoOther fun fact, Army Rangers trace their lineage to Rogers’ Rangers. Rogers fought for the crown in the Revolutionary War. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rogers'_Rangers https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rogers'_Rangers