5 ms·
Dreams of improving the human race are no longer science fiction
- 01HNNWZ0MV43FF 1y agoParaphrasing Slate Star Codex from memory: I don't want it because then everyone will be pressured to take the most invasive "improvements" they can get, or risk being outcompeted, and then after the whale fall we'll still be miserable, but also with brain bugs.
- rbanffy 1y agoFor that to work, we need to evolve past competition and remove the fear of being outcompeted.
- lazide 1y agowhich makes no sense on it’s face, as as evolution (and nature itself) is fundamentally competitive. you might as well say we should ‘compile ourselves past compilers’.
- bananaflag 1y agoLaughed out loud at that, thanks.
- n4r9 1y agoArtificial selection need not be competitive in the same way that natural selection is. And even if it were, competition between genes doesn't necessarily equate to competition between individuals.
- lazide 1y agoAnd certainly there is no competitive or evolutionary advantage for one person (or geneset) to convince a naive group of individuals that is what is going on while they pull the strings in the background. Or a person or set of individuals to pretend to be going along with said program (if said program is honest) while actually abusing/manipulating the program to benefit them eh? [https://www.irishtimes.com/life-and-style/health-family/latest-dutch-fertility-clinic-scandal-may-only-be-the-tip-of-the-iceberg-1.4793642 https://www.irishtimes.com/life-and-style/health-family/late...] among dozens (hundreds?) of others. Ignore the incentives of reality at your peril.
- rbanffy 1y agoCompetitive societies have more and more serious mental health issues. What program are you referring to? When I mentioned evolving past competition, I didn't say anything about gene-based evolution, but social evolution, where we consciously place a higher value on cooperation over competition.
- lazide 1y agoGene based evolution is constant. There is no way to avoid it; any more than it’s possible to avoid a compiler (somewhere) for any decent sized computer program, even if you’re writing in Python. So what you’re describing is not what you think you’re describing at all. Those ‘non-competitive’ societies are actually just those where the competition has been decided through structural elements which are not currently being contested to the same extent. Because someone either ‘won’ the war already, or the ‘war’ is more subtle and manipulative rather than being out in the open. If you happen to be on the ‘winning’ side of that war, then that looks great. If you’re on the losing side, you won’t get much of a chance to notice or fight about it. And what cannot be ‘seen’, ‘doesn’t exist’. War, after all, only can occur when someone is able to actually fight - and can see a reason to want to. Because in either one, someone is making the choices (explicitly, or implicitly!) which decide whose genes actually end up spreading. Complaining about mental health issues in competitive societies is like complaining about people getting maimed in war. And if people just stopped trying to fight back, then hey, world peace! (Once whatever Emperor conquered first won, of course) Society is the increasingly abstract and confusing game we build on top of all this so we’re not all writing the equivalent of assembly - aka Ghenghis Khan’ng each other. But it’s all the same at the end of the day - the computer (aka reality) runs whatever instructions gets spit out (aka genes). And whoever decides that, ‘wins’.
- n4r9 1y agoOkay. But if social norms lead to almost everyone mating randomly and couples having the same number of kids on average, then what happens to genetic evolution?
- imtringued 1y agoIf there was a free lunch, biology would have taken it.
- gruez 1y agoThat's unconvincing given how the modern environment is so different than the environment that we evolved in.
- fincycaden 1y agoInterestingly this is Ted Kaczysnki's argument for what will inevitably happen with genetic engineering of humans
- mitchbob 1y agohttps://archive.ph/uFfuK https://archive.ph/uFfuK
- metalman 1y agomodify, not "improve", perhaps speciate, perhaps become like insects with physicly different specialised castes, perhaps fail to understand the complecity and end up unable to outperform natural selection, but most definitly the game is on and the game is open ended, and the technology is fairly strait forward ,useing tools that do not require the ulra high precision and refinement of elecro/mechanical technologys, so containment and control of bio/genetic technology will be impossible. the main constraint on unhinged out of control developments is that iterating will remain slow, and require carefull planing and methodical implimentation over generational time spans, but costs will be low, and any sufficiently motivated small group/company/country can join the"fun", which is another point, this will be more "art" that science, as there is no equivalent to other types of engineering, so cloning will be atractive, but will present serious problems if large numbers of cloned indivuals are attempted. I leave out ethics and morality and refer anyone to the blank stare response that will be given by the types of people who are, right now, giving, while they go about realising there ideal society.
- rixed 1y agoDid we invent public education? Ha, no, just a rant against outdated regulations that are annoying to tech bro billionaire on a mission from God that he met during an acid trip (or was it burning man?) Not sure if from 1998, or satyre?
- leukimia 1y agoWhile life extension with exercise, supplements, and what have you can just be a wasted effort because these people die anyway with variable lifespans in the normal range like the rest of us, someone needs to maintain a list of sane things we should try just because they make our lives better, so that people don’t waste their lives with bad info, e.g. people eating mostly carbs in a blue zone living longer, which has been proven to be B.S. For example: - Walk a lot if possible, or do some sort of low impact sustained activity that involves as much of the body as you can. - Reduce carbs- higher ketone levels can reduce Alzheimer’s. - Reduce processed food- MTHFR mutations and too much folic acid enriched flour can cause ADD symptoms. - Eat salmon/sardines, broccoli, carrots, blueberries, spinach, with squeeze of lemon or lime- get omegas, vitamins, nutrients, healthy carbs. - Some meds, multi-vitamins, and supplements can screw you up depending on the person- they might be causing or multiplying aggression, flight of ideas, paranoia, etc. and it can take years to undo some damage even partially. - Supplements may be needed especially as you get older- like calcium and potassium. - Always keep a watch out for answers- e.g. one day this popped up on HN about a possible cure for Crohn’s disease: https://www.crick.ac.uk/news-and-reports/2024-06-05_major-cause-of-inflammatory-bowel-disease-discovered https://www.crick.ac.uk/news-and-reports/2024-06-05_major-ca... - Do your best to get sufficient sleep but just get up if you can’t sleep for a long time rather than stressing about it. - Brush and floss your teeth. - Be social, but don’t force it, and reduce dysfunction. - Go for it, but don’t worry about it.
- joelthelion 1y agoThere are a lot of people working in this area. One of the most prominent is Peter Attia.
- stefantalpalaru 1y ago[dead]
- localghost3000 1y ago> Having passed through the “gateway to God” opened by psychedelic drugs, the German tech billionaire wanted to I closed the article right about there.
- more_corn 1y agoThank you for braving the undiscovered country and reporting back as a warning to future travelers. I too shall journey elsewhere.
- amai 1y agoWhy science fiction? The Nazi plans to clean the race by killing handicapped childs were real, see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Racial_hygiene https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Racial_hygiene and https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aktion_T4 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aktion_T4 . These dreams of improving the race can get nightmares very quickly. Lets not repeat that.
- gruez 1y agoNowhere in the article did it advocate for forcibly killing or sterilizing people. If your objections are over selecting for desirable traits, what are your thoughts on screening for down syndrome and other genetic diseases? Are those also bad because "These dreams of improving the race can get nightmares very quickly. Lets not repeat that"? Is it better to ban such genetic screening lest we turn into nazis?